Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To hate bloody book bags?

105 replies

Rainallnight · 27/10/2021 19:40

Why are book bags a thing? They are annoying, uncomfortable to carry and can’t sensibly hold anything else. Which means I end up carrying them plus whatever other bag is needed for DCs’ bits and pieces.

Why can’t reading books be put in an ordinary backpack? Is there something I’m missing?

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
IdLoveToButCantBeArsed · 28/10/2021 15:43

@Heyiam

Genuine question.. those that are claiming there’s not enough space for backpacks if yr 4 or younger, surely there is a chair for each child that the backpack could be hung on? Also if a school has the room the host a p.e bag all the time bar half term when they are sent home to be washed it would be a fair presumption going by responses on this thread that parents would rather go in with a rucksack everyday and use the p.e hook than negotiate the school run with book bag lunch bag water bottle plus w.e else separately. For all the teachers / ta’s saying book bags are easier, there’s plenty of things that would make my job easier unfortunately I still have to do it the hard way. Suck it up. Putting 30 books in 30 rucksacks isn’t worth getting worked up about surely?
@Heyiam, I work in reception, the children don't have a chair each, it's very much free flow.

As for making my job easier, that's really not the point.

I have 60 children in my year, if I take just 3 minutes changing each child's reading book (yes, it does take that long, fetching bag, checking which books have been read, what level do they need, finding suitable replacement, marking off in folder to keep track, writing in reading record, putting back) that's 3 hours just to change books, and that's with book bags.

Would people prefer teachers and TAs to spend even more time on this, or would they rather that time was spent actually listening to children read?

Same goes for all the other stuff we need to put in and out of bags on a daily basis, more so in reception as 4 year olds can't be relied upon to do it properly themselves yet. It's in everyone's interest to get these jobs done as quickly as possible so we can actually spend our time helping the children, maybe even teaching them to learn how to do this stuff independently!

Etonmessisyum · 28/10/2021 10:20

None of my 4 have ever had them. All items went in school bags and remained flat and came out in one piece - my youngest just has a change of clothes, lunch and water bottle in his bag all homework is done over Google classroom. He’s not had a reading book since they went back after covid.

RedHelenB · 28/10/2021 10:16

Yabu. They take up less space in the classroom and keep books and letters flat.

Georgieporgie29 · 28/10/2021 10:14

It’s interesting reading all of this because we have been asking our school for years to have reading book bags and they say no due to space. We have the pe type bags and they are a nightmare. The get tangled, kids trip on the drawstring bits, any bits of paper put in there get crushed.

IloveJudgeJudy · 28/10/2021 09:33

Admittedly my 3 DC are now in their 20s but I couldn't understand why the flap didn't go over the handle like a music bag. The Velcro always seemed to come undone if there was anything more than one book and a letter in there. We walked over a mile to school daily. I couldn't carry 3x bookbags and all the other junk. I had to fight for DC to be allowed a backpack. My argument was that the school/society promoted walking to school yet didn't want to facilitate it by allowing backpacks. I was also in a group of mothers who kind of shepherded their DC all together, to and from school and took others' DC on various days (but like an informal walking bus) so couldn't possibly have carried all the bookbags.

I'm of the opinion that it's a faulty design.

CaptainMyCaptain · 28/10/2021 09:14

@Iloveallofthem

I loathe book bags.

In our class ( I'm a TA) the trays get completely stuck as there is so much stuffed inside the book bags, that are then forced inside the trays.

If I had a pound each day for every child
who has asked me to help them
to open their tray I would be a very rich lady!

That's why I kept them all in a box, the TA put them in register order while I did the register. By the time I retired we had dispensed with individual drawers anyway as they only accumulated crap.

The only downside with book bags for me was the velcro flaps which were death to tights. When they introduced flaps over the names that added another time waster undoing them all to find the name.

ThanksItHasPockets · 28/10/2021 09:12

www.irishtimes.com/news/world/europe/phased-reopening-in-german-schools-as-classes-judged-unlikely-covid-19-hotspots-1.4320983

If we’re talking about German classrooms, admittedly I am quite clumsy but I look at this photo and wince at the trip hazards. The aisles between the desks aren’t clear and the teacher can’t circulate freely without picking her way across (Covid limiting movement aside). Is every child going to pick up their bag and take it with them in the event of a fire drill or are those pathways going to remain blocked?

Iloveallofthem · 28/10/2021 09:02

I loathe book bags.

In our class ( I'm a TA) the trays get completely stuck as there is so much stuffed inside the book bags, that are then forced inside the trays.

If I had a pound each day for every child
who has asked me to help them
to open their tray I would be a very rich lady!

Igneo · 28/10/2021 08:53

Plus those kids in bavaria are clearly juniors. book bags are largely for infants.
Protecting books is important.

CaptainMyCaptain · 28/10/2021 08:42

@UntilYourNextHairBrainedScheme

www.alamy.com/stock-photo-school-children-unpacking-their-bags-in-a-classroom-munich-bavaria-87483438.html

I wonder why English (or British? Or Uk? Is this a problem in Scotland, Wales and Northern Ireland or just England?) primary school classrooms are so overcrowded that there's no room for children to carry a practical backpack properly packed with an A4 folder for letters and worksheets and keep this by their desk, as they do in other countries...

Not being permanently at the desk is a complete red herring - they're not permanently by their tray either!

There's space at the front of German classrooms for every child and the teacher to put their chair in a circle to sit, whilst still having the desks set up with room for proper backpacks by each desk. As children walk to school without parents nobody carries multiple different awkward bags and seperate items for them, everything fits in their school backpack. Nothing gets crumpled because German primary school teachers value neatness and order above all else (not that that last part is actually a good thing imo).

Great! We'll rebuild all the Primary schools then because I've never been in one that has this much room.
FateHasRedesignedMost · 28/10/2021 07:44

I don’t mind them. My son’s has a plastic zip folder within it to store all books, paperwork, reading diaries etc. There’s space for his gloves, hat, jumper. The only thing I have to carry is his water bottle provided he’s wearing his coat!

BeStillNowColin · 28/10/2021 07:41

In the school I volunteer in all classrooms have trays, in KS1 they all have book bags and put their bag into their trays and letters or books go into the tray. The tray should be empty at the end of the day. Very easy visual check to make sure they have everything they should have.

In KS2 they have lockers, there is more space as the children are bigger size wise. The lockers are off the floor so wellies can be stored underneath, the children are tall enough to reach the top lockers.

In KS1 I would spend time picking up coats (always hung up by their hoods so easy to be swiped off) off the cloakroom floor that had been walked over by other children and find their pegs. Difficult if the coat is not labelled. All that is on the hook is a PE kit and a coat. There just isn't room to give over to a cloakroom when they need space in a classroom.

You cannot have bags in classrooms unless the school has been purpose built in the last 10 years. As an adult I struggle to fit my legs between chair backs as not every child pulls their chair all the way in, I have to kneel at tables as there are no free table spaces in a 30 pupil classroom.

You can buy bookbags with a shoulder strap if you as a parent wish to carry it. I am not a pack horse so never did carry it. If parents' evening every becomes face to face again, ask your child to show you their cloakroom.

PiddleOfPuppies · 28/10/2021 07:28

Bookbags were a massive pain when mine were at primary school. Trying to carry them plus homework projects, drinks bottle and swimming kit was just awkward for a small 5 year old. I never carried them either - I had 3 of my own plus extras if we had playdates or nephews.

This is an interesting thread for 2 reasons:

  • bags banned due to covid (bonkers! Who risk assessed this?!)
  • most parents are saying bookbags are a massive inconvenience and they don't like them. Teaching staff like them because they are convenient to put notes in. Surely the compromise is email and rucksacks?
londonrach · 28/10/2021 07:25

They used as they fit into the trays. I find they perfect for her books to read and best of all fit over me perfectly on walk back. Never heard anyone in real life hate them. My dd is five and I noticed the older ones got rucksack s as they take lunch and pencil cases. The book bag perfect for the little ones until the next stage

PizzaInLunchbox · 28/10/2021 07:11

DDs school don't allow backpacks until year 3, bookbags only until then. They were a nightmare as DD needed to take a bag with a complete change of clothes for YR and Y1, plus PE bag (both stayed at school somewhere), then lunchbox etc.

I have no idea how we managed without her backpack, everything goes in...just getting DD to carry it is another thing though.

MrTumblesSpottyHag · 28/10/2021 07:02

Oh and one day a week she had a packed lunch because the dinner option was 🤢🤢🤢.
Thankfully not a problem this term, they've changed the menu.

MrTumblesSpottyHag · 28/10/2021 07:00

DD2 couldn't carry hers for the first year, she was so small it dragged on the ground! She has to take her own soap/hand gel/cream due to allergies, always have gloves, hat and a coat with her (allergies) even on days when it is mild in the mornings. A drink which when put into the book bag drags it down and the Velcro wasn't strong enough to keep it shut. Reading book and record, a fold up shopping bag for the random days she has to bring home extra shit from school.
PE kit home for a wash every Friday, if it's a muddy day she wears wellies then changes into school shoes in the playground. Needs a snack every day. It was ridiculous so I just sent her with a backpack as well and gradually stopped sending the book bag at all.

Cattitudes · 28/10/2021 06:58

They used to drive me crazy. Had to be the school logo ones which were awful, the velcro didn't stick properly so they flapped open and with a 20-30 min walk across muddy country meaning they had to go in wellies and carry school shoes, drink, packed lunch (before free lunches) etc. I would just put the book bag in a small rucksack on their backs.

Some rucksacks are very small like these decathlon ones but better for their backs and they forget they are carrying them rather than the awful swinging that they did when carrying a book bag which inevitability would sometimes be too far when carried away with their friends and end up with stuff in the mud.

I don't know why TAs and teachers are swapping books, mine always chose their own and put their own notices in the bags. They all just sat on the carpet before hometime and letters were handed out which they put in their bag. I did help my youngest when he was in nursery but he was very particular about which book he would read next. To be fair, the Biff, Chip and Kipper books did make much more sense when read in order.

Abraxan · 28/10/2021 06:52

Beat should say near

Abraxan · 28/10/2021 06:52

@Rainallnight

So if it’s the case that there isn’t enough room at school for backpacks, how come it seems that it’s ok in the older years?
The junior school beat out infants (two totally separate schools) has proper cloakrooms with benches under seats, as offshoots from the corridor. They simply have a bit more room than we do.
Abraxan · 28/10/2021 06:48

@Heyiam

Genuine question.. those that are claiming there’s not enough space for backpacks if yr 4 or younger, surely there is a chair for each child that the backpack could be hung on? Also if a school has the room the host a p.e bag all the time bar half term when they are sent home to be washed it would be a fair presumption going by responses on this thread that parents would rather go in with a rucksack everyday and use the p.e hook than negotiate the school run with book bag lunch bag water bottle plus w.e else separately. For all the teachers / ta’s saying book bags are easier, there’s plenty of things that would make my job easier unfortunately I still have to do it the hard way. Suck it up. Putting 30 books in 30 rucksacks isn’t worth getting worked up about surely?
No way could we hang backpacks on chairs. The classrooms are also only just big enough for the children. The chairs and tables are already close together. Add a backpack and we wouldn't be able to walk behind them at all as the space between rows and table groups would be even worse. Means er couldn't circulate to monitor and mark work as we go, children couldn't easily get up and down to do stuff etc.

Remember the issue with no social distancing being possible in many of our classrooms? We weren't joking. Space really slid that tight. It's be even worse than having them in the very tight cloakrooms.

EnidFrighten · 28/10/2021 06:44

I take a tote bag (cloth bag with long straps that can go over my shoulder) to pick up, use it for water bottle, jumper, random artworks DD comes out with.

I try to get her to carry her own book bag but if needs must I thread the tote bag handle through the book bag handle so I'm still hands free and the book bag sits on top of the tote bag.

CallMeRisley · 28/10/2021 06:28

@UntilYourNextHairBrainedScheme

www.alamy.com/stock-photo-school-children-unpacking-their-bags-in-a-classroom-munich-bavaria-87483438.html

I wonder why English (or British? Or Uk? Is this a problem in Scotland, Wales and Northern Ireland or just England?) primary school classrooms are so overcrowded that there's no room for children to carry a practical backpack properly packed with an A4 folder for letters and worksheets and keep this by their desk, as they do in other countries...

Not being permanently at the desk is a complete red herring - they're not permanently by their tray either!

There's space at the front of German classrooms for every child and the teacher to put their chair in a circle to sit, whilst still having the desks set up with room for proper backpacks by each desk. As children walk to school without parents nobody carries multiple different awkward bags and seperate items for them, everything fits in their school backpack. Nothing gets crumpled because German primary school teachers value neatness and order above all else (not that that last part is actually a good thing imo).

The U.K. has the highest primary school class sizes in Europe

www.statista.com/statistics/1078190/students-per-class-in-europe/

CallMeRisley · 28/10/2021 06:27

@UntilYourNextHairBrainedScheme

www.alamy.com/stock-photo-school-children-unpacking-their-bags-in-a-classroom-munich-bavaria-87483438.html

I wonder why English (or British? Or Uk? Is this a problem in Scotland, Wales and Northern Ireland or just England?) primary school classrooms are so overcrowded that there's no room for children to carry a practical backpack properly packed with an A4 folder for letters and worksheets and keep this by their desk, as they do in other countries...

Not being permanently at the desk is a complete red herring - they're not permanently by their tray either!

There's space at the front of German classrooms for every child and the teacher to put their chair in a circle to sit, whilst still having the desks set up with room for proper backpacks by each desk. As children walk to school without parents nobody carries multiple different awkward bags and seperate items for them, everything fits in their school backpack. Nothing gets crumpled because German primary school teachers value neatness and order above all else (not that that last part is actually a good thing imo).

They’re not permanently by their tray, but things tucked away in a tray are safe and secure and stored away whereas they seat is being used by two or three other children at different points during the day.
UntilYourNextHairBrainedScheme · 28/10/2021 06:14

www.alamy.com/stock-photo-school-children-unpacking-their-bags-in-a-classroom-munich-bavaria-87483438.html

I wonder why English (or British? Or Uk? Is this a problem in Scotland, Wales and Northern Ireland or just England?) primary school classrooms are so overcrowded that there's no room for children to carry a practical backpack properly packed with an A4 folder for letters and worksheets and keep this by their desk, as they do in other countries...

Not being permanently at the desk is a complete red herring - they're not permanently by their tray either!

There's space at the front of German classrooms for every child and the teacher to put their chair in a circle to sit, whilst still having the desks set up with room for proper backpacks by each desk. As children walk to school without parents nobody carries multiple different awkward bags and seperate items for them, everything fits in their school backpack. Nothing gets crumpled because German primary school teachers value neatness and order above all else (not that that last part is actually a good thing imo).