Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Suspicious behaviour

280 replies

PuzzlingPieces · 27/10/2021 15:01

Have toyed with posting this but here goes.

Recently, it has emerged that my DH has been accused of going through the underwear of a close female relative on two separate occasions when alone in their house. I knew absolutely nothing of this until family members accused DH directly of having a fetish. It has all come out since and I am devastated.

Context - the female family member is very particular about her belongings and refers to herself as OCD. The situation was presented to me as the female family member noticed on a recent visit after we had popped out for few hours leaving DH behind - that her underwear had moved. She found this odd but thought it could have been me or DC so tried to put out of mind.

On a further occasion a few weeks later the same thing happened - this time of an evening when DC in bed and everyone else out. She was obviously "looking" for this and feeling suspicious by this point.

In her mind there is/was no doubt that the belongings have moved as she is so particular. She doesn't leave her stuff around, ever, and the drawers are on the far side of the bedroom.

DH tells me that on first occasion, toddler age DC appeared with item earlier in day and he panicked, put it aside and then replaced it in the drawer when everyone was out so as not to look weird or draw attention to it.

On second occasion, he found a bra on the landing under our bedding (I know our bedding was on the landing) and panicked about this looking terrible especially after the first misunderstanding, so went to return it. Upon doing so he noticed just how organised the drawer was (hadn't done so on the first occasion due to speed) and panicked further so tried to "make" things look neat.

Family member referred to her drawer as a "total mess" after second occasion. Refutes the idea that DC could have obtained the item because the "nature" of the underwear was that it was at the back of the drawer not for day to day wear and child could not reach.

The landing where the bedding was is near to the laundry basket but I am told that the family member knows where her belongings are at all times (especially this one) and she is absolutely adamant it was removed from her drawer.

Family accused husband of the worst without explaining anything to me first. DH at first vehemently denied anything before later confessing that this was down to misunderstandings and gross oversteps of privacy, but not anything deviant as they suspect.

Family have now left me to it and say they will support my decision. I honestly don't know what to do or think. I am in total and utter shock. No previous indication of any inappropriate behaviour or fetish/sexual issues albeit my DH is someone that can have the odd social "clanger" so to speak.

We are happily married and I love my husband. I also love my family and don't think they have motive to lie and just want to protect me. They are willing to draw a line if I ask for that (easier said than done given how this was all explosively accused but that's a secondary issue until I can get this rationalised in my head!).

What would you believe / do?

And secondly, would you feel it reasonable to request a lie detector test in these circumstances? If a misunderstanding, very prepared to move on although very let down and devastated nonetheless. If the motive is something else (even just nosiness rather than anything more dreadful), what should I do? Appreciate in a marriage this should never be needed but I feel lost.

I want the truth even jf it's worst case scenario. My worst fear is that even if I choose to believe whatever I do, and move on (with help and counselling or whatever that may take) this may always niggle at me. It would also niggle at me if I left my husband, too. Totally lost.

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
Skysblue · 28/10/2021 19:28

His explanations just aren’t plausible, it’s beyond belief that he had an accidental visit to her underwear drawer twice!

(I actually had a friend of a friend go through my underwear drawer once when I popped out of the room, so grim but for some men it seems this is a turn on, yuck.)

I’m sorry OP. There are 3 different issues for you to think about here:

  1. His creepy sexual behaviour towards another woman.
  1. His lies to you.
  1. Whether you can accept the above enough to still love him and stay married or if this is a relationship destroyer.

He won’t agree to a lie detector test. He knows what he did and he knows what the result would be. He might agree to see a counsellor? Maybe individual and also couples counselling? If he admits what he’s done, accepts that it was wrong, and is willing to explore why he did it and try to change then perhaps the marriage could be saved. I’m always reluctant to say a marriage is over unless there’s cheating or violence etc. This is more he has a perversion and is being dishonest about it. But for me it would be difficult to find him sexy after that.

limitedperiodonly · 28/10/2021 17:35

@Lotusmonster I am not transphobic but would not find it acceptable for someone exploring his feminine side to be doing it via my knicker drawer. I'd feel violated and troubled even if it was my teenage son let alone an adult male who is a relative stranger.

In that case I would be furious and afraid and would ban him from my house. I would also absent myself from family gatherings where I knew he would be and tell his wife why. If it was impacting my relationship with the rest of my family I would tell them and let them decide who they wanted to see.

Anyone who takes from others while in a position of trust - whether touching their bra and knickers in their private room or "borrowing" £20 left in full view in the living room deserves that judgment. It is entirely right that someone in OP's relation's position should be able to do that.

Don't dismiss my response as transphobia - it is an entirely normal reaction for a woman finding a man has intruded on her private space.

You've said some men do this late in life. If you would be happy for any man in this case a relative stranger to do this to you then that is your prerogative. But it is also the prerogative of other women not to agree with you.

A grown man who wants to explore being trans has no excuse for using the underwear or any clothes or personal possessions belonging to women without their express permission.

If not there are credit cards and Amazon. Surely you would agree.

2bazookas · 28/10/2021 17:22

You don't need a lie detector; he already confessed he's been messing with her underwear.

  • DH at first vehemently denied anything before later confessing that this was down to misunderstandings and gross oversteps of privacy*

Blaming the toddler, pretending its a "misunderstanding" and denying his motive was sexual were all lies. You don't need a lie detector to work that out.

He should to admit to the owner that he did it and apologise. Then he can never go to her house again. Possibly other family members will also refuse to lety him in their house , because he abuses trust and privacy.

It isn't your job to either cover for him or explain his behaviour or apologise for it. You should say to family " Yes, I know he did it, I can't begin to explain it , excuse it or understand it. I'm as shocked as you are. "

Where that leaves your marriage and future with him I have no idea. I'd find it hard to forgive the lies and denials and subterfuge and the breach of family trust in their homes.

ChargingBuck · 28/10/2021 17:13

Oh ffs grow up. Don’t tell me what I think. That’s not what I think at all.

If you weren't thinking it, why mention it, @Lotusmonster?
If you agree that a possible gender identity issue doesn't mitigate the wrongdoing, why bring it up?

Same as PP saying it's a harmless kink.
It's not harmless when it drags another person in, unwittingly, & invades their personal space. Many women would feel violated by this odd behaviour.

ChargingBuck · 28/10/2021 17:09

@THEDEACON

There's an awful lot of over reaction going on So your DH isn't as vanilla as you thought but he's hardly a sexual predator either
Fairly low bar to set.

"Not a sexual predator" doesn't make "man indulging his vanilla kink by invading female relative's bedroom space & committing 2 acts of 'gross overstepping of privacy' (his own words) in any way acceptable.

He can kink to his heart's content.
No need to drag his relative's underwear into it.
Unless that's the kink - the secrecy.

Derbee · 28/10/2021 16:59

I think it’s a normal instinct to trust your husband.
But the more you think about it, the more holes you’ll see in his story, and the weirder you will realise it actually is

Derbee · 28/10/2021 16:58

Why would your husband put a bra in someone’s underwear drawer? Even IF she decided it was ok to pick it up and return it to her room, why not put it on the bed/on top of the chest of drawers etc.

Very strange to open drawers, and actually go into an underwear drawer

Terfydactyl · 28/10/2021 16:53

@ifIwerenotanandroid

I've only got as far as page 7 but what I'm wondering is this:

If husband noticed a bra under their bedding on the landing (I'm assuming it was the end of their stay & their bed had been stripped), why didn't husband assume it was his wife's & put it in their luggage? Wouldn't he think that the likeliest scenario was that in stripping the bed, some of their own items had been swept up with the sheets?

It was one of the first things occuring to me too. I guessed that he knows his wifes bra size and that the other womans was nothing close. But still if the man has an underwear fetish then he needs to buy his own.
limitedperiodonly · 28/10/2021 16:51

@TheGirlCat would this "heightened sense of fear" you attribute to OP's husband extend to being exposed as prowling in someone's knicker drawer or do you think he should be able to keep his paws off?

Derbee · 28/10/2021 16:36

@THEDEACON

There's an awful lot of over reaction going on So your DH isn't as vanilla as you thought but he's hardly a sexual predator either
He IS a creep though. He’s crossed a massive line, twice. You have no idea if he is a predator, or if/how his behaviour may escalate
THEDEACON · 28/10/2021 16:30

There's an awful lot of over reaction going on So your DH isn't as vanilla as you thought but he's hardly a sexual predator either

Lotusmonster · 28/10/2021 16:21

@FrenchieFromGrease

The only part I'm inclined to believe is the "nothing deviant" - although I suspect have a very different view from him about what constitutes deviance. I suspect DH means "don't panic, I didn't put them on, or wank over them" - so considers himself non-deviant. I believe this could be true. All he wanted was quick fumble & visual thrill. But I don't agree with DH's "not deviant" stance. I think it's fucking deviant to enter someone's bedroom on the sneak, ditto open their underwear drawers, & reckon yourself still a good bloke just because you didn't jizz all over your relative's underwear.

Also ... Peeping Tom stuff like this usually escalates.
It goes hand in hand with the brazen entitlement.

@ChargingBuck has nailed it

Your husband is a creep. A true dirty mac wearing, thigh rubbing creep. He has repeatedly invaded your relatives private space to get sexual thrills out of her belongings. He feels entitled to use your relative - a real life woman he has a close relationship with - to bolster his fantasies.

This goes way beyond a passing thought and makes me wonder what his next excalation will be. He's already made the jump from fantasising something to taking action in reality.

What exactly is the point in using this kind of horrible inflammatory language towards the OP? She’s not the perpetrator in this scenario. Sure, the guy may well be a creep. And as this unfolds, she and her family are going to struggle and suffer the realisation of this which could be long lasting. But she’s not committed the crime. So why speak to her like that?
Lotusmonster · 28/10/2021 16:13

@ChargingBuck

You didn’t read. I said it was 100% plain wrong!

I did read.
You wrote ... 100% plain wrong. But he might have gender identity issues.

The placement of that "But" is disturbing @Lotusmonster.
It shows your belief that despite his actions being wrong, if he had gender identity issues, it's understandable. Or mitigated. Or somehow ... well, something! - or why the fuck did you bring it up?

You might as well have written
"He grabbed her breasts, which was wrong, BUT he was only exploring his masculinity, 'cos he's got ishoos ..."

Oh ffs grow up. Don’t tell me what I think. That’s not what I think at all.
CaputApriDefero · 28/10/2021 15:59

If it was all just misunderstandings, why did he deny anything? Why didn't he just say? Because there's nothing wrong in what he says happened. Sounds like he denied and denied until he thought of something plausible.

Your relative should set up a motion detector camera.

Starcaller · 28/10/2021 15:07

The family member just refers to herself as OCD, which suggests she just means it as a personality trait rather than a clinical diagnosis. People often use it (when they shouldn't) to mean they are just anal about stuff.

ChargingBuck · 28/10/2021 15:05

Well I do have OCD, and I know that paranoia is often, if not always involved.

Which means you have both OCD and a condition that causes you paranoia, @TheGirlCat.

Either way, I am sorry you have to manage such uncomfortable symptoms, & hope you are getting expert help Flowers

CovoidOfAllHumanity · 28/10/2021 15:00

I am an actual psychiatrist and 'paranoia' is not a symptom of anything at all. It's not a term that appears in ICD or DSM or that any psychiatrist would ever use. It's a lay person term that has no agreed clinical meaning. People who have used it to me meant anywhere from 'a bit anxious about something' to 'full on delusional belief' and all points in between which is why we don't use it technically.

The core feature of OCD is obsessional thoughts (which specifically are not psychotic because the person knows they are irrational) and compulsive behaviours to neutralise the thoughts. Checking and ordering are examples of compulsive behaviours and there could be a range of obsessional thoughts driving that.

It's also completely irrelevant to the thread because
A) the relative didn't have OCD only 'describes herself as having' it ie pretty definitely doesn't have it
B) she was completely correct as he admitted it and therefore not 'paranoid' at all.

It is a derail but I felt I should counter it because it seemed to be perpetuating the damaging myth that people with a mental illness should not be believed that has led many vulnerable people to be abused.

TheChip · 28/10/2021 14:56

I'd like to know how, if the relative is OCD and knows exactly where her things are. This bra specifically known for being less used so placed at the back of the drawer. How did it end up in the bedding to begin with? How does he explain that one?

Honestly OP. It seems pretty obvious what he has been doing. The question is now about whether you can move on and live with this.

Was he trying to stash it to take home with him and then panicked thinking he was going to be caught, so quickly put it back, or was the whole part about it being in the bedding a complete lie.
If he was planning on taking it home, then that suggests his fetishis is escalating.

Have you ever stumbled upon underwear at home where you've thought "I can't remember buying this?"

TheGirlCat · 28/10/2021 14:51

@ChargingBuck

He sees it, is afraid he will be accused again, so tries to rectify it by putting it where he thinks it goes, in her underwear draw. He may have been better leaving it where he found it, BUT, whose to say she wouldn't have accused him of taking it and leaving it on the landing, anyway?

Nope, @TheGirlCat
At the time he sets eye on the bra - the second incident - he has not yet been 'accused' by SiL. So that defence doesn't fly.

Innocent people tend to blurt out the truth, even when embarrassed.
This man's first instinct was to lie - in fact he "vehemently denied anything*.
He then backed down to "misunderstandings and gross oversteps of privacy".
& said "nothing deviant" had happened, as per family suspicions.
He then started up on the convoluted Toddler Defence.

If it was true, why would he not have just ruefully spoken up about the Toddler Defence as his first reaction, rather than the fourth thing he could think of?

It's balderdash.
The only part I'm inclined to believe is the "nothing deviant" - although I suspect have a very different view from him about what constitutes deviance.
I suspect DH means "don't panic, I didn't put them on, or wank over them" - so considers himself non-deviant.
I believe this could be true. All he wanted was quick fumble & visual thrill.
But I don't agree with DH's "not deviant" stance. I think it's fucking deviant to enter someone's bedroom on the sneak, ditto open their underwear drawers, & reckon yourself still a good bloke just because you didn't jizz all over your relative's underwear.

Also ... Peeping Tom stuff like this usually escalates.
It goes hand in hand with the brazen entitlement.

Sorry I misread your post. Yes it's true he hadn't been accused, however if he had a heightened sense of fear he may have felt scared. With me, sometimes ordinary things have a side of paranoia. I am afraid I am not doing something right, and the second time and afraid I will be caught out, exposed as a failure. As one social awkward person to another (OP's DH) I can sense that he would be afraid people may come to the wrong conclusions especially if he felt uneasy about replacing something in the drawer the first time. His reasoning methods ring true to me, and I will give an outline of this thread to my therapist next week when I see her but my feeling is she will say the same. He being a male panicked and felt putting the bra in the drawer was a better option than the relative finding a bra under his bedding.
ifIwerenotanandroid · 28/10/2021 14:47

I've only got as far as page 7 but what I'm wondering is this:

If husband noticed a bra under their bedding on the landing (I'm assuming it was the end of their stay & their bed had been stripped), why didn't husband assume it was his wife's & put it in their luggage? Wouldn't he think that the likeliest scenario was that in stripping the bed, some of their own items had been swept up with the sheets?

Therealjudgejudy · 28/10/2021 14:44

I think OCD is derailing this thread.

Op, your husband is a creep, who has been going through your relatives underwear drawer, on more than one occasion. And admitted it!

He is the problem here. I wouldn't put up or make excuses for this behaviour.

TheGirlCat · 28/10/2021 14:38

@HoldingTheDoor

That is not a standard symptom of OCD. Your children may have it but your posts paint all people with OCD as unreliable witnesses. We do not all have paranoia,. The way you're trying to compare you putting away household members' washing to a man going through the underwear drawer of another woman in a house that isn't his says it all though.
@HoldingTheDoor You are misinformed. As any actual Psychiatrist will tell you, Paranoia is a BASE level symptom of OCD. As someone who had OCD as a teen, that worsened after a car accident, I can promise you paranoia is at the very epicentre of any/all OCD conditions. As an OCD sufferer, Paranoia is the very epicentre of most flare ups.
TheGirlCat · 28/10/2021 14:32

@ChargingBuck

He sees it, is afraid he will be accused again, so tries to rectify it by putting it where he thinks it goes, in her underwear draw. He may have been better leaving it where he found it, BUT, whose to say she wouldn't have accused him of taking it and leaving it on the landing, anyway?

Nope, @TheGirlCat
At the time he sets eye on the bra - the second incident - he has not yet been 'accused' by SiL. So that defence doesn't fly.

Innocent people tend to blurt out the truth, even when embarrassed.
This man's first instinct was to lie - in fact he "vehemently denied anything*.
He then backed down to "misunderstandings and gross oversteps of privacy".
& said "nothing deviant" had happened, as per family suspicions.
He then started up on the convoluted Toddler Defence.

If it was true, why would he not have just ruefully spoken up about the Toddler Defence as his first reaction, rather than the fourth thing he could think of?

It's balderdash.
The only part I'm inclined to believe is the "nothing deviant" - although I suspect have a very different view from him about what constitutes deviance.
I suspect DH means "don't panic, I didn't put them on, or wank over them" - so considers himself non-deviant.
I believe this could be true. All he wanted was quick fumble & visual thrill.
But I don't agree with DH's "not deviant" stance. I think it's fucking deviant to enter someone's bedroom on the sneak, ditto open their underwear drawers, & reckon yourself still a good bloke just because you didn't jizz all over your relative's underwear.

Also ... Peeping Tom stuff like this usually escalates.
It goes hand in hand with the brazen entitlement.

@ChargingBuck Use comprehensive and cognitive ability to re-read my post. I SAID he hadn't been accused then but he KNEW he would be accused. If you used comprehension it should have been more than obvious thus your post was null and void.
limitedperiodonly · 28/10/2021 14:20

In any case, he wouldn't be coming round to my house in future.

limitedperiodonly · 28/10/2021 14:19

I've read the whole thread and am still mystified why OP's bedding and her female relative's bra were next to the laundry basket. I don't have OCD or paranoia but I would be a bit ticked off about the laziness there.

More troubling thoughts: Whose landing was it? How did these items come to be mixed up? Was it the female relative's landing and the husband nipped into her bedroom to drop one of his usual clangers or was it his and OP's house necessitating a trip round to the female relative's house when no one was in?

It would have been much easier if after perving on her underwear he'd just thrown them away. But maybe he wanted her to know he'd been rifling through her undies. I have no idea how some people's minds work.