Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

With how my SIL reacts to this situation?

241 replies

Ihateeveryone56 · 27/10/2021 09:31

My brother, SIL and niece are all visiting my house for a few days. They go home tomorrow and I can not wait just because of how they pander and react to this situation!

I have a dog who is a rescue. She is 2 and half but trained. It’s taken a lot of hard work on my part and my dogs part to be trained and get to the point we are at. We still go to weekly classes and have constant training sessions. My niece is 5 coming up to 6 and she reacts to my dog very badly. My dog is a medium sized breed that comes up to roughly knee height. Every single time my niece comes into a room my dog is in/comes down the stairs/just sits in a room and my dog walks in she screams at the top of her lungs. I mean a really high pitched cut through your soul kind of scream. This in turn scares the crap out of my dog which makes her run away and in turn makes my niece scream louder (which I didn’t know was possible)!

I tell my niece to stop screaming because it’s not nice and there’s no reason too. She then demands to be picked up by her mom (SIL) and she does it straight away. Instead of sitting there and saying you’re being silly, she’s fine, there’s nothing wrong she panders to her picks her up and thus re- starts the cycle of screaming/picking up and not accepting my dog. This is my dog, my dogs home and not theirs. I’ve put up a stair gate for the last 2 days so I can stop my dog coming into the lounge but I feel like I shouldn’t have to do that? My niece will then stand the other side of the gate calling her a bad girl and a naughty dog when all she’s doing is lying there. I do tell her off for saying this but doesn’t seem to change a thing.

For context they own a terrier type dog who is a lot smaller than mine however that dog has actually bitten my niece on her cheek in the past but they still have the dog. My dog has never once bitten and is certainly not aggressive.

AIBU to be annoyed at the pandering to the behaviour she is showing? I have explained to my SIL and my brother if she stops screaming everytime the dog comes in then we have no issues but they still don’t correct her.

OP posts:
DuckbilledSplatterPuff · 27/10/2021 10:19

I would keep the dog and the niece entirely separate and get your DBs co-op on this until they leave or if they are not willing to do that ask them to leave early because the loud piercing screams and the taunting could frighten your dog and might trigger an aggressive/defensive episode, which would not be your dogs fault, but could result in mayhem. And then don't have them to stay until the child is much older and can cope with your dog.

NewlyGranny · 27/10/2021 10:17

Send little Violet Elizabeth Bott home. And tell SiL NADALT (not all dogs are like that theirs.)

Poptart4 · 27/10/2021 10:15

@mountbattenbergcake OP's niece, OP's dog, OP's home, she absolutely has some responsibility here. Not all.... some.

If the dog reacted to the child screaming by biting her it would definitely be the OP's problem. It's in everyone's best interest to introduce the dog properly to a scared child. All 3 adults have dropped the ball here.

LocoCoconanas · 27/10/2021 10:15

I see both sides. She is being ridiculous when the dog isn’t doing anything but acknowledging her and acknowledging her fear is the right thing for her mum to be doing. You shouldn’t dismiss feelings based on your views. 5 year olds can’t be objective.

I also feel dog owners are blinkered. I personally do not like dogs and I don’t want your dog anywhere near me, well behaved or not. No I don’t want to touch it, talk to it or smell it. It’s just the way I am. Personally I wouldn’t go to your house, because as you say, it is the dogs home and not mine. Don’t invite them again.

Artie30 · 27/10/2021 10:15

I wouldn't have them visiting for a few days. Not fair on your dog, you or the kid!

Dog fear is very real but if they have a dog it doesn't even seem like she's scared of the dog, just being a bit of a brat!

TrashyPanda · 27/10/2021 10:13

@PetriDisher

It's hard to properly understand the dynamics without being there but assuming that your niece is genuinely afraid (which wouldn't surprise me if she's been bitten by a smaller dog before, and now here's a giant version of the animal that did it!) I don't think that your SIL is doing anything wrong by picking her up and comforting her.

I say this as someone with very little patience for people who are afraid of dogs generally because my instinctive feeling is that it's ridiculous (which I know is not really fair!) but if my 5 year old was afraid of something, however irrational, I would absolutely comfort them. Partly because I love them and it's just natural to comfort them, partly because I don't actually think anyone (young or old) is really helped by having their fears dismissed and bring told not to be so silly.

It would be helpful if your SIL could also work with your niece to introduce her to your dog and see that he's safe, assuming that is the case, but it's very easy to criticise from the outside.

I also note that your dog is a rescue and it's taken a lot of work to train them. This suggests to me that he perhaps has an unknown history and has maybe behaved in ways that would naturally scare a small child in the past? (Even if just overly boisterous or jumping up). That would make me a bit cautious as a parent too which might explain why your SIL isn't as forthcoming with the reassurance and introductions with your niece as she might be.

Honestly, I don't think anyone is particularly in the wrong here but it sounds like they shouldn't stay with you for a while until your niece and your dog have had the chance to meet lots more in neutral settings and hopefully get used to each other more.

The girl is deliberately taunting the dog from behind a stair gate.

This deliberately nasty behaviour is not indicative of fear of the dog. It’s actually pretty disturbing and nasty.

She is fine with her own dog, so screaming (not covering or whimpering in fear) suggests attention seeking behaviour mak8ng the poor dog a scapegoat

mountbattenbergcake · 27/10/2021 10:13

*DB not BIL

BlibBlabBlob · 27/10/2021 10:12

My DD used to be terrified of SIL's dog. Wouldn't scream but would beg me or DH to pick her up and keep her out of reach. Which excited the dog even more! But it was an understandable reaction: we don't have a dog, this particular dog wasn't big but was very excitable and would jump up at DD. This was very frightening when she was small because the dog reached her shoulders when it jumped up and nearly knocked her over. Nothing was done to train the dog out of jumping up at visitors.

This situation sounds different, however: you've got a well-trained dog who would not react to your niece in any way if she just ignored it? And she stands there berating the dog from the safety of the opposite side of a stair gate and her parents don't see fit to intervene?

Is there any part of the story we're missing here? Did your dog, when you first rescued it, perhaps behave in a way that scared her e.g. jumping up or aggressively barking at her?

And of course it could be bundled up in her little brain with the attack from her own dog and she isn't thinking straight about it all.

But either way, it doesn't sound like the situation is being effectively managed by your DB and SIL. The bit about her being scared and needing to be picked up seems reasonable to me, although the piercing scream isn't - if she's that scared, don't put her in the position where she feels vulnerable in the first place. The screaming is going to terrify the poor dog. But her being allowed to stand there taunting the poor dog makes me really angry!

Thehop · 27/10/2021 10:12

Send them home early

mountbattenbergcake · 27/10/2021 10:12

@EdgeOfTheSky

Neither you nor your brother (why is it SIL who gets all the blame?) are handling this well.

Telling her off and telling her not to be ‘silly’ is surely not the right way to go about it?

And your dog is a dog, and at least half the height of the child.but you out a dog’s rights above that of a child family member.

Maybe a dog so close to her face height is scary for her since she has been bitten by a smaller dog.

Couldn’t all the adults here talk snd make a plan for enabling her to feel confident rather than getting defensive and resentful?

I suspect it would be pointless. BIL and SIL don't give a shit, so why should OP?
EdgeOfTheSky · 27/10/2021 10:12

And the OP clearly says she explained to BOTH parents

Yes, but she names SIL in the thread title.

EdgeOfTheSky · 27/10/2021 10:11

Neither you nor your brother (why is it SIL who gets all the blame?) are handling this well.

Telling her off and telling her not to be ‘silly’ is surely not the right way to go about it?

And your dog is a dog, and at least half the height of the child.but you out a dog’s rights above that of a child family member.

Maybe a dog so close to her face height is scary for her since she has been bitten by a smaller dog.

Couldn’t all the adults here talk snd make a plan for enabling her to feel confident rather than getting defensive and resentful?

mountbattenbergcake · 27/10/2021 10:08

@Poptart4

I'm terrified of dogs. I don't care how many owners insist that their dog is nice and nothing to be afraid of. They still scare me. I don't know why I'm this way. But I'm an adult so I can just avoid situations where I have to be around dogs.

Your niece is 5 so she can't help the way she reacts to her fear of your dog. Telling someone who is afraid that they are being silly really doesn't help Halloween Hmm

You and your brother should have sat her down on day 1 and brought the dog over to her, dad with dd and you holding the dog. Introduce her to him in a way that felt safe and let her rub him and see that he's a nice dog. Maybe let her tell him to sit and then give him a treat when he does it.... this is how my brother got my child used to his dog.

You can't criticise a mother for picking up a distressed and screaming child. That's a natural reaction.

Side note, its interesting how your focusing your annoyance on your SIL and not YOUR brother who is also the child's parent.

Nope, none of this is OP's responsibility. This is on the parents.

And the OP clearly says she explained to BOTH parents.

Chachachawoo · 27/10/2021 10:04

How annoying and what strange parenting to keep the dog that attacked the child but not explain that this dog is a kind a dog... or whatever. Sil could make the situ easier but is obv not bothered by the screaming. I would not offer to host again and if they ask to come and stay I would ask first that they deal with the screaming in a more considerate way.

TrickOrTreat21x · 27/10/2021 10:01

She's clearly not scared of the dog though or else she wouldn't be taunting it. Hmm

Notonthestairs · 27/10/2021 10:00

The dog hasn't done anything wrong! The 5 year old is screaming for no reason!

Poptart4 · 27/10/2021 10:00

I'm terrified of dogs. I don't care how many owners insist that their dog is nice and nothing to be afraid of. They still scare me. I don't know why I'm this way. But I'm an adult so I can just avoid situations where I have to be around dogs.

Your niece is 5 so she can't help the way she reacts to her fear of your dog. Telling someone who is afraid that they are being silly really doesn't help Halloween Hmm

You and your brother should have sat her down on day 1 and brought the dog over to her, dad with dd and you holding the dog. Introduce her to him in a way that felt safe and let her rub him and see that he's a nice dog. Maybe let her tell him to sit and then give him a treat when he does it.... this is how my brother got my child used to his dog.

You can't criticise a mother for picking up a distressed and screaming child. That's a natural reaction.

Side note, its interesting how your focusing your annoyance on your SIL and not YOUR brother who is also the child's parent.

TrickOrTreat21x · 27/10/2021 10:00

I would cut the visit short and insist they go today. If they can't control their child then tough shit.

That's some really bad parenting skills, they are going to regret it when she's older.

mountbattenbergcake · 27/10/2021 09:59

You need to protect your dig and not have them round again.

girlmom21 · 27/10/2021 09:59

She's not scared of the dog or she wouldn't be taunting it.
I'd ask them to leave.

HikingforScenery · 27/10/2021 09:59

I don’t think it’s a big deal having to shut your door behind a stair gate and helping your niece get used to the dog. You’ve all had enough time to use positive reinforcement for trying to get your niece used to your dog. None of you has done anything effective

I guess you ( and your niece’s parents) have to decide whether your relationship is precious enough to work towards a common effective solution for the scenario.
If it’s not, they don’t come back or you don’t invite them back.

What a horrible situation for a 5 year old to be in . The three adults in the situation aren’t helping really

Furrydogmum · 27/10/2021 09:58

YABU to put your dog through that amount of stress for more than five minutes! Don't have them in your house period..

Returnoftheowl · 27/10/2021 09:58

If your niece is standing on the other side of the stair gate taunting your dog I wouldn't say she's scared of the dog.

Easiest way to sort this out would be not having them to stay again, at least until the niece is older.

PetriDisher · 27/10/2021 09:55

It's hard to properly understand the dynamics without being there but assuming that your niece is genuinely afraid (which wouldn't surprise me if she's been bitten by a smaller dog before, and now here's a giant version of the animal that did it!) I don't think that your SIL is doing anything wrong by picking her up and comforting her.

I say this as someone with very little patience for people who are afraid of dogs generally because my instinctive feeling is that it's ridiculous (which I know is not really fair!) but if my 5 year old was afraid of something, however irrational, I would absolutely comfort them. Partly because I love them and it's just natural to comfort them, partly because I don't actually think anyone (young or old) is really helped by having their fears dismissed and bring told not to be so silly.

It would be helpful if your SIL could also work with your niece to introduce her to your dog and see that he's safe, assuming that is the case, but it's very easy to criticise from the outside.

I also note that your dog is a rescue and it's taken a lot of work to train them. This suggests to me that he perhaps has an unknown history and has maybe behaved in ways that would naturally scare a small child in the past? (Even if just overly boisterous or jumping up). That would make me a bit cautious as a parent too which might explain why your SIL isn't as forthcoming with the reassurance and introductions with your niece as she might be.

Honestly, I don't think anyone is particularly in the wrong here but it sounds like they shouldn't stay with you for a while until your niece and your dog have had the chance to meet lots more in neutral settings and hopefully get used to each other more.

rainbowstardrops · 27/10/2021 09:54

Your poor dog. At least look on the bright side, you won't have to host them anymore!

Swipe left for the next trending thread