Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

With how my SIL reacts to this situation?

241 replies

Ihateeveryone56 · 27/10/2021 09:31

My brother, SIL and niece are all visiting my house for a few days. They go home tomorrow and I can not wait just because of how they pander and react to this situation!

I have a dog who is a rescue. She is 2 and half but trained. It’s taken a lot of hard work on my part and my dogs part to be trained and get to the point we are at. We still go to weekly classes and have constant training sessions. My niece is 5 coming up to 6 and she reacts to my dog very badly. My dog is a medium sized breed that comes up to roughly knee height. Every single time my niece comes into a room my dog is in/comes down the stairs/just sits in a room and my dog walks in she screams at the top of her lungs. I mean a really high pitched cut through your soul kind of scream. This in turn scares the crap out of my dog which makes her run away and in turn makes my niece scream louder (which I didn’t know was possible)!

I tell my niece to stop screaming because it’s not nice and there’s no reason too. She then demands to be picked up by her mom (SIL) and she does it straight away. Instead of sitting there and saying you’re being silly, she’s fine, there’s nothing wrong she panders to her picks her up and thus re- starts the cycle of screaming/picking up and not accepting my dog. This is my dog, my dogs home and not theirs. I’ve put up a stair gate for the last 2 days so I can stop my dog coming into the lounge but I feel like I shouldn’t have to do that? My niece will then stand the other side of the gate calling her a bad girl and a naughty dog when all she’s doing is lying there. I do tell her off for saying this but doesn’t seem to change a thing.

For context they own a terrier type dog who is a lot smaller than mine however that dog has actually bitten my niece on her cheek in the past but they still have the dog. My dog has never once bitten and is certainly not aggressive.

AIBU to be annoyed at the pandering to the behaviour she is showing? I have explained to my SIL and my brother if she stops screaming everytime the dog comes in then we have no issues but they still don’t correct her.

OP posts:
HikingforScenery · 27/10/2021 14:21

@ITSSSSCHRISTMASSS

YABU to ask parents to stop pandering to their scared child YABU to expect a 5yo child to control her fear of your dog YABU for telling a 5yo child off

YANBU to want you dog to be able to wonder around your home freely without being scared or afraid.

YABU to invite them when you knew there was going to be an issue

All this
TrashyPanda · 27/10/2021 14:14

Sounds like the clouds have been cleared from your brothers eyes.

Funny how the niece seems unconcerned about auntie stepping in and telling her to stop screaming. Maybe it is an attention seeking behaviour.

stayathomer · 27/10/2021 14:12

I don't think either of you are being unreasonable because I think you're just all very different. People here who are going off on one about your sister-in-law forget that when you're in someone else's house you do not parent the way you parent at home. You are stuck between trying to keep the peace and trying to show who's boss but without looking like you're being over the top. Also I knew from the start of the post from how dedicated you are to your dog that anything to do with children was going to be a bit of trouble. I've a six year old and while I hope he wouldn't scream like that, anything anything is possible!! Hope you all get a nice bit of peace in the next few days OP!

Notonthestairs · 27/10/2021 14:00

I don't understand the references to the dog barking or being comforted or punished for barking. I can't see where the Op mentioned barking at all.

ChargingBuck · 27/10/2021 13:44

My brother gave me a hug thanked me for letting them stay and apologised for not acting better or quicker to the situation. He said he will be having a conversation with SIL about the dog at home and about getting my niece some help for her fear as he is worried about the sudden change in behaviour.

Positive update OP!
& well done for finally getting them to leave early - the situation was untenable for everyone.

It's really good news that he is going to tackle the situation by dealing with what's going on with their own dog at home, & getting some extra help for your niece about managing her fears & reactions.

TrueGrit54 · 27/10/2021 13:40

Phew! Well done, hope you and dog have a lovely rest of the week.

ChargingBuck · 27/10/2021 13:39

Well said, @Bookworm20

ChargingBuck · 27/10/2021 13:36

If the situation was reversed and the dog was incessantly barking at the child through fear would you comfort it and try and make things better or punish it?

Neither, @mumofbun. Because neither option would be effective.

I'd take the third option - which is to remove the dog from the situation.

Comforting the dog for barking would reinforce the behaviour.
Punishing the dog would do nothing to stop him barking, except make him scared of the unreasonable human who punishes him for being a dog.

But OP was more focused on it being her dog's own home, & the dog therefore having full rights to roam it, than she was on preventing her niece's behaviour by removing the source of stimulus.

That's not dog handling, it's ego.
I can just about accept that she preferred to assert the dog's rights over understanding how scared/defiant her niece is being about the dog.
What I can't understand is how she allowed it to go on for days, allowed her dog to keep being in the same room as the niece, & didn't send them all packing days ago, rather than have her niece acting out & her dog persistently scared.

Ihateeveryone56 · 27/10/2021 13:36

They have now left and instantly the house is calmer. My brother gave me a hug thanked me for letting them stay and apologised for not acting better or quicker to the situation. He said he will be having a conversation with SIL about the dog at home and about getting my niece some help for her fear as he is worried about the sudden change in behaviour.

SIL wouldn’t look at me and left my house without even saying goodbye or a thank you for hosting them so that was lovely…..

Niece gave me a hug and kiss goodbye and has asked when she will next see me so looks like visits to their house when I’m in the are for work sounds like the best decision for the time being.

OP posts:
paisley256 · 27/10/2021 13:36

They'd have to go.

TrashyPanda · 27/10/2021 13:32

@SilverBirchWithout

Absolutely. The relationship between these 2 women is over.
Very true
IntermittentParps · 27/10/2021 13:26

If my dog was behaving g like that, I’d put it into another room away from everyone until it learned to behave. Every time it barked, it would get removed
The OP's dog isn't behaving like this. The niece screams when she comes into a room the dog is in, or when the dog simply walks into a room. And when the dog then runs away. And she stands the other side of the gate calling the dog a bad girl and a naughty dog when the dog is simply lying quietly.

HelloBambinos · 27/10/2021 13:25

These types of parents are the worst. Stop pandering to a child screaming at the poor dog
Especially when you kept the dog who actually bit her. And it's not like she's a small baby. How terrible for your poor dog. I would have made it clear they either need to stop encouraging her behaviour by pandering to her and not correcting her or they would be leaving straight away. As others have said at least you won't have to host them again.

AmyDudley · 27/10/2021 13:23

If she screams again I would tell her off very firmly 'stop that screaming at once, you are frightening the dog and she hasn't done anything wrong.' and if SIL isn't willing to reinforce and picks the child up then tell them both to leave the room.

I'd get your brother on his own and tell him that there will be no more visits because of this behaviour unless he can guarantee it will not happen again. It is very unfair on your poor dog, and totally unacceptable for the child to tell her she is naughty for being in a room or eating her dinner.

If the child is scared (and I don;t believe she is - she's found a behaviour that gets her a lot of attention and because it has been reinforced by SIL she is continuing with it), then she needs to be told firmly that she will be fine if she behaves sensibly round the dog. I would take her out on a walk with the dog so there is more space, I would show her how to gently stroke the dog etc. But she has a dog in her own home, so she knows all this. I suspect she got bitten by their dog because she was teasing it.

But the main thing is to make clear to DB DSIL and DN that this screaming is not acceptable and there will be no more visits unless it can be guaranteed not to happen again.

SilverBirchWithout · 27/10/2021 13:08

Absolutely. The relationship between these 2 women is over.

Yourstupidityexhaustsme · 27/10/2021 13:03

@SilverBirchWithout

I’d be fuming if my SIL tried to dictate how I comforted my distressed DC. Don’t worry OP they will not visit you and your Ddog again.
I'd be fuming if my SIL shouted at my dog to leave the room as she encouraged my niece to scream at him.

They wouldn't be invited back!

Subbaxeo · 27/10/2021 13:00

@mumofbun

I think the only thing wrong here is how everyone has let the situation continue for a few days.

I can't blame the mum for trying to comfort her scared child anymore than i can blame you for wanting your dog to be comfortable in their own home.

If the situation was reversed and the dog was incessantly barking at the child through fear would you comfort it and try and make things better or punish it?

I think the parents should've decided to leave after the first couple of instances where it became clear the child couldn't leave the dog alone.

If my dog was behaving g like that, I’d put it into another room away from everyone until it learned to behave. Every time it barked, it would get removed. No attention or comforting.
Cascascascas · 27/10/2021 13:00

@Ihateeveryone56

Ask them it’s stops or they have to go early

SilverBirchWithout · 27/10/2021 12:59

I’d be fuming if my SIL tried to dictate how I comforted my distressed DC.
Don’t worry OP they will not visit you and your Ddog again.

AuntMargo · 27/10/2021 12:55

What a brat, tell them to go home and if she's cannot behave then tell them not to bring her again.

TrashyPanda · 27/10/2021 12:54

Children need to learn boundaries, empathy and consideration to others. And that includes animals.

Hopefully now that your brother has realised that her behaviour is unacceptable, he can work on helping her develop.

ddl1 · 27/10/2021 12:52

I sympathize with your niece, if she's been bitten. Many children have phobias of dogs or other animals. And I think you are being U to treat this as essentially naughtiness and any accommodation as 'pandering'.

However, they are also U in bringing a child who has a fear of dogs to stay in (not just visit) a house where there's known to be a dog. Maybe the child should have some sort of treatment for her fear, though I realize that's not so easy to get nowadays. I would also suggest that it may be U for them to keep a dog which has bitten their child, though I admit that I don't know the full story. But it does sound as though they are all (the child understandably, the adults less so) in a sense taking their own dog's behaviour out on yours.

WeCalledTheDogIndiana · 27/10/2021 12:49

Do you have children, OP? Or a lot off experience of looking after children?

I ask because I agree that the best thing here would be for your DN to stop screaming, but I don't understand why you are so sure ignoring her is the best or only way to achieve it. If it's attention seeking, your suggestion (tell her to stop being silly/sit still/not pick her up) might work but it's high risk - would require the dog to be scared multiple times before that took effect, situation might escalate to dog being aggressive, and it's asking the adults to take a hard line with her when they don't know for sure what the reason behind the behaviour is.

If she's scared, ignoring her won't work and will only make the problem worse.

And no one seems to have tried anything else. You seem to be stuck on "just ignore her", you SIL seems to be stuck on "I'm the only one willing to look after her", and your DB just seems to be dithering between the two of you.

You know your dog. Your SIL presumably knows what works with your managing DN's behaviour. So you could work together to fix it but instead you've drawn battle lines.

I feel really sorry for both the dog and the little girl.

GreenFingersWouldBeHandy · 27/10/2021 12:38

Cut the visit short and book them a taxi now!

IntermittentParps · 27/10/2021 12:34

I'm glad you've told them to go. The SIL sounds thick as mince.

Swipe left for the next trending thread