Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

With how my SIL reacts to this situation?

241 replies

Ihateeveryone56 · 27/10/2021 09:31

My brother, SIL and niece are all visiting my house for a few days. They go home tomorrow and I can not wait just because of how they pander and react to this situation!

I have a dog who is a rescue. She is 2 and half but trained. It’s taken a lot of hard work on my part and my dogs part to be trained and get to the point we are at. We still go to weekly classes and have constant training sessions. My niece is 5 coming up to 6 and she reacts to my dog very badly. My dog is a medium sized breed that comes up to roughly knee height. Every single time my niece comes into a room my dog is in/comes down the stairs/just sits in a room and my dog walks in she screams at the top of her lungs. I mean a really high pitched cut through your soul kind of scream. This in turn scares the crap out of my dog which makes her run away and in turn makes my niece scream louder (which I didn’t know was possible)!

I tell my niece to stop screaming because it’s not nice and there’s no reason too. She then demands to be picked up by her mom (SIL) and she does it straight away. Instead of sitting there and saying you’re being silly, she’s fine, there’s nothing wrong she panders to her picks her up and thus re- starts the cycle of screaming/picking up and not accepting my dog. This is my dog, my dogs home and not theirs. I’ve put up a stair gate for the last 2 days so I can stop my dog coming into the lounge but I feel like I shouldn’t have to do that? My niece will then stand the other side of the gate calling her a bad girl and a naughty dog when all she’s doing is lying there. I do tell her off for saying this but doesn’t seem to change a thing.

For context they own a terrier type dog who is a lot smaller than mine however that dog has actually bitten my niece on her cheek in the past but they still have the dog. My dog has never once bitten and is certainly not aggressive.

AIBU to be annoyed at the pandering to the behaviour she is showing? I have explained to my SIL and my brother if she stops screaming everytime the dog comes in then we have no issues but they still don’t correct her.

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
Anotherlovelybitofsquirrel · 26/12/2021 14:11

In our house if you are a guest and you don't like or are rude to our many animals, you get shown the door. Screaming children would be removed also. Not fair on the poor dog!

KaycePollard · 26/12/2021 12:44

People who are not scared of dogs never understand people who are scared of dogs. Telling off your niece is not the way to deal with this.

You & her parents need to work together to find a way that the dog can be around your niece. And that your niece can be calmer around your dog. Shouting at a 5 year old will not work.

mathanxiety · 04/11/2021 02:35

Agree @Sidehustle99.

This child's needs are being ignored.

Petlover9 · 01/11/2021 14:33

@10yearwarranty

I can't understand why they are visiting for a few days when their daughter is terrified of the resident dog. What a daft idea. Everyone would be better off if they stayed somewhere else and visited you.
Agree with this ^.
Sidehustle99 · 01/11/2021 14:32

@Petlover9

And the OP knew there was a kid coming with a rational rear of dogs. All of the adults failed the dog and child.

Petlover9 · 01/11/2021 14:29

[quote Sidehustle99]@Petlover9 the child is 5 and has been bitten before. It is a completely rational fear of the dog. All of the adults in this situation have handled it badly.[/quote]
I don't agree. They knew the OP Had a pet dog and also knew their child was frightened, so did they expect that the dog would be kept outside? They should have booked accommodation nearby and visited for a few hours while the family dog was taken for a walk.

Sidehustle99 · 01/11/2021 14:22

@Petlover9 the child is 5 and has been bitten before. It is a completely rational fear of the dog. All of the adults in this situation have handled it badly.

Petlover9 · 01/11/2021 14:18

@trulyconfuseddotcom

That's ridiculous. Your poor dog, this sounds quite stressful for everyone involved. I think that if they want to visit again, they need to find alternative accommodation, at least until the child is a couple of years older. I have two dogs and wouldn't want this situation in my home, it's not great for you, your dog or the child. You've tried to deal with it in a reasonable way but unfortunately you can't make the parents act sensibly if they don't want to.
Quite agree with this ^. They are in the dog's home. Ask them to go early and next time they ask to stay, make excuses. The child is a brat and pets are more important
Sidehustle99 · 01/11/2021 13:10

Poor kid, poor dog. What an awful situation to be put in because of the grown us. I wouldn't do it to either of them again. It's not fair.

IntermittentParps · 01/11/2021 11:57

The OP's criticisms are of her SIL and brother, not niece.
The niece gave her a hug and kiss goodbye and asked when she would next see her, so it doesn't sound like their relationship is suffering or the OP is passing on her frustration about SIL and brother to her.

AnnaSW1 · 01/11/2021 11:53

@IntermittentParps where's the empathy??

IntermittentParps · 01/11/2021 08:40

Why don't you have empathy for a small child that's scared of a dog?
The OP doesn't not have empathy. She would just like the child's behaviour to be addressed.

AnnaSW1 · 01/11/2021 07:03

You sound like you don't like your little niece at all. I think YABU. Why don't you have empathy for a small child that's scared of a dog? I'd have left the house due to your behaviour if I was them.

mathanxiety · 01/11/2021 04:09

I really don't think you are in your rights to call a child you do not know the names you have called her there @TheGirlCat.

TrashyPanda · 31/10/2021 23:08

TheGirlCat - you are on a hiding to nothing here.
You are speaking complete and utter sense, obviously.
To use an appropriate analogy, some posters are like a dog with a bone. Or a child with a piercing scream.

TheGirlCat · 31/10/2021 23:07

@mathanxiety

Good thing the father has realised her behaviour and her fear requireto be addressed, something her mother is ignoring, which does the child no good. The mother is not ignoring the fear and the screaming. She is responding to her child's obvious distress by picking her up and soothing her. This is exactly what the child needs. Long term, what she needs is for her family to rehome the terrier who bit her. If apples don't fall far from the tree, I suspect her father won't do that. She'll just have to get used to playing second fiddle to an animal in her own home.

However, OPs responsibility is to her dog and the screaming is undoubtedly disturbing to it, so it can’t be tolerated.
The OP's responsibility is to the people in her home, including children. She should be trying harder to make sure they are all comfortable.

The mother is not ignoring the fear and the screaming. She is responding to her child's obvious distress by picking her up and soothing her. This is exactly what the child needs. Long term, what she needs is for her family to rehome the terrier who bit her. If apples don't fall far from the tree, I suspect her father won't do that. She'll just have to get used to playing second fiddle to an animal in her own home.

The mother is pandering to the spoiled brat's attention-seeking. She is irresponsible and creating a rod for her own back, which is why I suspect she is the one keeping the dog at home. The only one who is stepping up as a parent (or seems to be) is the father who is not being played by the brat and doesn't approve of her vindictive, cruel behaviour.

The OP's responsibility is to the people in her home, including children.
The OP's responsibility is not to allow a future animal torturer to abuse a rescue dog that is doing nothing more than sitting in it's own home. The parents' responsibility to prevent their child from turning a cruel spoiled brat (a bit late for that) who will go on to torture and abuse animals for attention. It's clear the mother is incapable of stepping up and being a responsible parent, lets hope the father can try and change the course his ill-disciplined bully of a daughter is on.

TheGirlCat · 31/10/2021 23:00

@mathanxiety

She's not hurting the dog's feelings by saying 'bad dog' from behind the gate.

Of course she is! Do you honestly think the dog doesn't know what she is saying? And isn't feeling confused, hurt etc? Of COURSE the dog knows! Have you ever owned a dog? If you had and seen the look on a dog's face when said 'bad dog!', 'bad!' or even 'no, naughty!' you'd know better than to write what you wrote!

I think you and TrashyPanda win the boiled sweet for first class nonsense, TheGirlCat. I hope you don't mind sharing.

Are either of you parents? I mean of real children, not 'fur babies'.

Do you think that perhaps the child had a look of fear on her face when she screamed every time the dog approached her?

The child is not 'taunting' the dog here. If anything, the OP is allowing the dog to taunt the child by letting it roam freely from room to room regardless of the fact that the child is frightened of it.

The mother is doing absolutely the right thing by picking up the child and acknowledging her fear.

I wonder if the OP's brother is refusing to get rid of the dog at home who bit his child? Going by the complete inability of the OP to see any pov except that of the dog here (and using the term 'correct' as a suggestion for how the parents should respond to the child, which is wildly inappropriate) I suspect the child is expected by her father, the OP's brother, to put the dog first. Hence the screaming. It's the only way the five year old has of getting a protective response.

You clearly have never had a dog. If you honestly think a dog doesn't know the meaning of commands, you've made a fool of yourself on here. I'm not even a dog lover and even I know that dogs understand commands and tone and words. You seem to have no knowledge of animals, not even the most basic of knowledge.

Do you think that perhaps the child had a look of fear on her face when she screamed every time the dog approached her?

What does that have to do with the fact the brat abused and taunted and shouted at the dog and that the dog clearly knew what she was saying to it?

If anything, the OP is allowing the dog to taunt the child by letting it roam freely from room to room

The dog is 'taunting' the child by merely sitting in it's own home? You've really won the Mumsnet aware for prize joker here! If you aren't trolling, you must be on some heavy substance to even think like that. If I were you I would ask to have that post of yours deleted because that is not something you want in your posting history. Confused

The mother is turning the child into a spoiled brat and rewarding bad behaviour, in addition to taunting and abusing a dog doing nothing but sitting in it's own home. With a 'mother' like that, unless the father steps up, the brat has no chance.

mathanxiety · 31/10/2021 20:10

Good thing the father has realised her behaviour and her fear requireto be addressed, something her mother is ignoring, which does the child no good.
The mother is not ignoring the fear and the screaming. She is responding to her child's obvious distress by picking her up and soothing her. This is exactly what the child needs. Long term, what she needs is for her family to rehome the terrier who bit her. If apples don't fall far from the tree, I suspect her father won't do that. She'll just have to get used to playing second fiddle to an animal in her own home.

However, OPs responsibility is to her dog and the screaming is undoubtedly disturbing to it, so it can’t be tolerated.
The OP's responsibility is to the people in her home, including children. She should be trying harder to make sure they are all comfortable.

mathanxiety · 31/10/2021 20:03

She's not hurting the dog's feelings by saying 'bad dog' from behind the gate.

Of course she is! Do you honestly think the dog doesn't know what she is saying? And isn't feeling confused, hurt etc? Of COURSE the dog knows! Have you ever owned a dog? If you had and seen the look on a dog's face when said 'bad dog!', 'bad!' or even 'no, naughty!' you'd know better than to write what you wrote!

I think you and TrashyPanda win the boiled sweet for first class nonsense, TheGirlCat. I hope you don't mind sharing.

Are either of you parents? I mean of real children, not 'fur babies'.

Do you think that perhaps the child had a look of fear on her face when she screamed every time the dog approached her?

The child is not 'taunting' the dog here. If anything, the OP is allowing the dog to taunt the child by letting it roam freely from room to room regardless of the fact that the child is frightened of it.

The mother is doing absolutely the right thing by picking up the child and acknowledging her fear.

I wonder if the OP's brother is refusing to get rid of the dog at home who bit his child? Going by the complete inability of the OP to see any pov except that of the dog here (and using the term 'correct' as a suggestion for how the parents should respond to the child, which is wildly inappropriate) I suspect the child is expected by her father, the OP's brother, to put the dog first. Hence the screaming. It's the only way the five year old has of getting a protective response.

TrashyPanda · 31/10/2021 16:17

Of course she is! Do you honestly think the dog doesn't know what she is saying? And isn't feeling confused, hurt etc? Of COURSE the dog knows! Have you ever owned a dog? If you had and seen the look on a dog's face when said 'bad dog!', 'bad!' or even 'no, naughty!' you'd know better than to write what you wrote!

Totally.
She has no right to behave in such an uncaring way to OPs dog, which is in its own home and doing no harm because it is behind a barrier.

At nearly 6 she should be reminded each time she goes visiting that she needs to be on her best behaviour in other peoples homes.

Taunting an animal is cruel behaviour and could escalate.

Good thing the father has realised her behaviour and her fear requireto be addressed, something her mother is ignoring, which does the child no good. However, OPs responsibility is to her dog and the screaming is undoubtedly disturbing to it, so it can’t be tolerated.

TheGirlCat · 31/10/2021 08:16

@mathanxiety

She's not hurting the dog's feelings by saying 'bad dog' from behind the gate. She's not pelting tomatoes at it, or kicking it, or any other harmful act. It's not cruel.

It's behaviour that is telling the adults something of whst she is feeling about dogs. She is still working through her response to the previous bite, and perhaps the sight of the OP's dog behind the gate has given her the courage to say what she thinks to the dog who bit her.

Children her age do not always communicate directly and we shouldn't expect them to.

Adults, otoh, have enough intellectual and emotional development under their belts to not respond the way all the adults in the OP's home are responding to the child. The adults here are behaving badly.

She's not hurting the dog's feelings by saying 'bad dog' from behind the gate.

Of course she is! Do you honestly think the dog doesn't know what she is saying? And isn't feeling confused, hurt etc? Of COURSE the dog knows! Have you ever owned a dog? If you had and seen the look on a dog's face when said 'bad dog!', 'bad!' or even 'no, naughty!' you'd know better than to write what you wrote!

Bunnycat101 · 31/10/2021 06:08

I think all of the adults have been unreasonable here. 5 year olds are little and often irrational with unformed ways of communicating emotions (especially this cohort of children lost lock down)

  • her parents haven’t protected her by removing a dog that has bitten her in her home
  • her parents didn’t try and address screaming or try to work with you to come up with a solution
  • you’re unreasonable for being fixated on her language to the dog and putting too high an expectation on the way she reacted.

My 5yo freaked out about a fly in her room the other day. She was screaming, jibbering wreck. No idea why but her fear was real and visceral despite not having had an issue with insects before. There was no point trying to reason with her. She just needed cuddles, reassurance and removing the fly.

mathanxiety · 31/10/2021 05:42

She's not hurting the dog's feelings by saying 'bad dog' from behind the gate. She's not pelting tomatoes at it, or kicking it, or any other harmful act. It's not cruel.

It's behaviour that is telling the adults something of whst she is feeling about dogs. She is still working through her response to the previous bite, and perhaps the sight of the OP's dog behind the gate has given her the courage to say what she thinks to the dog who bit her.

Children her age do not always communicate directly and we shouldn't expect them to.

Adults, otoh, have enough intellectual and emotional development under their belts to not respond the way all the adults in the OP's home are responding to the child. The adults here are behaving badly.

TrashyPanda · 30/10/2021 10:07

@mathanxiety

This is new behaviour. There is a dog at home.

Yes, and the dog at home bit her. Hence the new behaviour.

The adults who should be helping her handle her fear (by dealing appropriately with the dog) appear to have put the feelings of the dogs ahead of the child's interests here. Then they have taken her to stay in a home where there is another dog. The child has been backed into a corner here.

OP says the child was fine previously. She doesn’t say if the screaming started on first visit after the bite or if there were visits after the bite and the screaming only started this visit.

I read it as the latter, hence my opinion, but agree it could be the former.

However, her berating the dog when it is behind a gate is highly unpleasant and cruel behaviour that needs to stop. No amount of fear/dislike is an excuse for this.

mathanxiety · 30/10/2021 07:37

We ask why little girls don't report things that happen to them...