Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Is it weird to keep her with me until 5?

391 replies

Whatwillyakkabetoday · 27/10/2021 09:17

Dd, is 3 and an August birthday. Is it unusual to keep her at home with me until she turns 5 and send her the September after she turns 5?
I’m a nursery teacher so do lots of activities at home etc.
She wouldn’t have any pre school etc until 5
Has anyone done this?

OP posts:
LabiaMinoraPissusFlapus · 27/10/2021 18:00

My children loved nursery and reception as it is play-based. They look back fondly on those times. When I home educated one of my children for a while, and then when another had to have a delayed start to reception due to a prolonged staggered start, they really missed their school friends.

Tailendofsummer · 27/10/2021 17:33

I was little in the 70s and nursery was absolutely a "thing" then but my mum chose not to send me. Starting school was a horrendous shock to me at 5 with no experience of being away from my mum and mixing with large numbers of children. I wouldn't do that to my dc, even if work was not an issue.

Whatwillyakkabetoday · 27/10/2021 17:28

@Happylittlethoughts Why would you keep her at home?

OP posts:
Happylittlethoughts · 27/10/2021 16:07

I absolutely would keep her if you can.
In Scotland you can defrler if they are not 5 by enrolment by end of Feb. Huge bodies of research to back you up.

LobsterNapkin · 27/10/2021 15:34

@Kokeshi123

I don't really get why this would be weird. It was perfectly normal in society until about 5 minutes ago.

No. being with just your mother all day and one playdate a week has never been normal.

Not many people only go out once a week, and the OP doesn't, so possibly not a relevant comment.

Though in some more remote settings, it wouldn't be so odd, and children in those places also turn out fine.

Net123456 · 27/10/2021 15:16

You say you're not in the UK OP. Does your child need to learn the local language? I'm in Spain here they can start school from the year they turn 3 but its compulsory till the year they turn 6. I chose to send mine from age 3 purely due to the language aspect and picking it up more easily the younger they started. If it hadn't been for the language side of things I might have started them at 4 instead. There's a lot of difference between a child at 3 and the same child at 4, come next September you might find she is happy to go and more ready for it

zingally · 27/10/2021 15:11

There's a HUGE difference between a child who is only recently 3, and a child who is 4 or 5.

Give it another year and see how you feel then.

Personally, I'd apply for school at the right time for her age cohort, but there's no rule saying you have to take up the place when the time actually comes.

LobsterNapkin · 27/10/2021 14:22

Oh, I would have loved a "gradual start" into nursery, but, you know, i had to get back to my workplace.

Nothing against you, it's just that everytime I read this kind of posts I still feel freaking guilty.

It really sucks, but it's important that it gets said. Back just before there was almost a mass exodus of mums to work, there was a real live debate about the implications of FT childcare for children. That wasn't resolved by showing it was better/fine for kids, it was resolved when it became impossible for most families to do anything else.

People mostly stopped talking about it because they had no choice anyway. No one wants to feel guilty about it when they have no options. And more than that, a lot of pepole felt more comfortable if they could tell themselves it was better. A lot of the younger parents now have been told it is better, most were in care themselves, and they can't imagine anything different.

But this masks addressing the real issues, or asking whether two FT working parents is really the best set up for society, or what kinds of other options there might be.

So many people on threads like this seem to think that before every child was in care at age 1, or went to school at four or five, kids were unsocialized and stupid.

Dixiechickonhols · 27/10/2021 14:19

All those saying children start at 6 or 7 in other countries the children go somewhere before that age it’s just called something different to school - kindergarten etc. It’s not the norm for children to stay home just with mum in a 1-1 until age 6 or 7 not least because mum will usually be working or minding siblings.
Child is encountering children but not socialising independently in same way they do in a pre school. If OP is bucking norms in her country she will also find her DD’s peers will not be around much as they are in pre school so further limiting opportunities to socialise - the weekly play dates can’t happen if the other 4 year olds are in full time pre school.
If your desire is for a bit of alone time would a nanny share or childminder work plus it has benefits for DD as she’d have regular playmates but less formal than school.

flirtygirl · 27/10/2021 14:16

Not all children suit, preschool, nursery and school. The replies you have mostly got are because people don't like to think about this and would rather go along with the status quo.

Op, do what is best for your child. I decided to send my child to free hours at 3, she hated it but everyone banged on about socialisation, etc. I actually sent her for me so I could have a break.

At 4, she "should" have gone to school. But I kept her in the free hours setting to see if she would settle. At 4.5 she had not fully settled and still don't like it most days. So I decided OK, no more free hours and no school for now.

I thought she would go to school later on
Disclaimer: She is still at home but may go school at 13 (next Sept) ...

I'm not adverse to school, it absolutely is great for mass education and mass childcare.

However, if you have the options to do something else, that suits your child better then why would you not take that option?

DeborahAnnabel · 27/10/2021 14:10

YANBU for not sending her to school when she is just turned 4 but YABU for not sending her to nursery that year. You have 15 free hours or 30 hours if you earn under a certain income.

MilkCereal · 27/10/2021 14:08

See how you feel in another year. My August born dd we deferred as it was right for her. No regrets. But she was a preschool etc which she loved- at that age she will want to play with others not just you. Wanting to defer her is a different matter.

Whinge · 27/10/2021 14:04

@DockOTheBay

This isn't that unusual. All the people saying "keeping her at home til 5 is a terrible idea", what about children who turn 5 in the first week of September? They are also at home until 4 years, 51 weeks. What's the difference for an August baby who is 5 years 2 weeks?

I would probably send her to a preschool, she could just do a few mornings a week. But my daughter missed almost all of her preschool year due to covid and started school at 4.5 no problem

I'd imagine the amount of children born in September who never go to any childcare or preschool prior to starting Reception is a tiny amount. It's very unusual these days for a child to stay home until starting school.
Tillysfad · 27/10/2021 14:03

Many of these replies are ridiculous.

As a teacher you'll know that some children seem overwhelmed and anxious at school. Maybe they're just not ready. You'll also know that a committed, engaged parent can easily recreate the benefits of nursery and it's mainly playing alongside each other at that age.

If your child is dying for a challenge and for some reason under-stimulated at home, or would benefit from structured time with other adults, I'm sure you realise.

Children of course are just little people and do not need to be with other children exactly their age like a litter of puppies. You will have the best idea how much peer to peer your child needs and will benefit from.

So ignore the thread and follow your gut. You're highly unlikely to be able to speed up her developmental process by doing something that she finds overwhelming. You're also highly likely to make any decision with lasting consequences, as a caring parent, because it all works out.

The only thing I would say is that outcomes for children get young in the year can be disappointing. My very young but very bright child needs a lot of one to one to perform at her ability level, simply because she's been around for a quarter (ish) less time than some others doing the same work.

midnightpopcorn · 27/10/2021 14:01

It is unusual here but it's totally normal in many other countries. Some wait until 7.

Don't worry about people saying it's detrimental. It's just a belief we've been brought up to believe. There's so scientific evidence. Do what's right for your child.

Boopeedoop · 27/10/2021 13:57

My mum did this to me. School came as a huge shock, I struggled to make friends and I felt like an outsider.

I didn't stop crying before going to school until I was about 7/8.

I never got over the anxiety of going to school and I didn't partake in further education.

Your daughter might be fine, but it was horrendous for me.

Kokeshi123 · 27/10/2021 13:54

I don't really get why this would be weird. It was perfectly normal in society until about 5 minutes ago.

No. being with just your mother all day and one playdate a week has never been normal.

TatianaBis · 27/10/2021 13:52

@Bluntness100

I also think the way this is written has been slightly misleading but I doubt on purpose

If the op had said

“I’m a sahm and am not in thr uk. Where I am children start preschool and go daily at four then graduate to school at six. I did put my daughter In nursery and she struggled and we needed to pull her out. She is at home with me most of the time, and is rarely socialised with other children, maybe once or twice a month on a play date. She does do lots of activities with me though as I was formerly employed as a nursery teacher. I’m considering delaying her start for a year till she is five, becayse she struggled last time, but am not sure if it’s in her benefit”

The responses would have been more considered. The op read like this was a child in uk schooling due to the four/five age range put forward.

Not accurate though. Nowhere does OP say her DD is “rarely socialised with other children”, on the contrary she says:

I have some friends homeschooling, plus lots of friends in nursery, we all regularly meet up. We have lots of days out, plus she has dance lessons once a week

Whatwillyakkabetoday · 27/10/2021 13:42

@DoItAfraid She still isn’t herself, but we’re working hard on building her confidence back. She was very outgoing and friendly before, she’s shy and almost not trusting of people. I have such huge guilt for what she went through and wish I’d made a different decision

OP posts:
Whatwillyakkabetoday · 27/10/2021 13:39

@NovacDino What’s happening to them? -In U.K. schools at least?

OP posts:
DoItAfraid · 27/10/2021 13:38

@Whatwillyakkabetoday

I’m a teacher but currently home with Dd

I’m not in the U.K., where I am, they start school itself at age 6.

They can start pre school at age 4, but have to go everyday, no option for part time etc

She tried a private pre school in September and really suffered, she was very unhappy, was super confident and outgoing before that. It clearly knocked her confidence.
I have some friends homeschooling, plus lots of friends in nursery, we all regularly meet up. We have lots of days out, plus she has dance lessons once a week.
I suppose I’m worried she won’t be ready next September for full time pre school or it will be a repeat of before where we saw our previously happy girl take a real hit in confidence.
Definitely not for my benefit. As much as I love being with her, I’d love a break too!

Thanks for all the feedback, how do homeschoolers justify it then, if it’s so wrong for the child (not in my opinion, I’m really unsure about that, but judging by some responses on here)

I think you failed to ride out the normal transition of children starting in a new environment. If she is ok now, I highly doubt that pre-school impacted her confidence etc - she was just finding her feet and needed a good shot - perhaps over a few months - to get settled in.
DockOTheBay · 27/10/2021 13:38

This isn't that unusual.
All the people saying "keeping her at home til 5 is a terrible idea", what about children who turn 5 in the first week of September? They are also at home until 4 years, 51 weeks. What's the difference for an August baby who is 5 years 2 weeks?

I would probably send her to a preschool, she could just do a few mornings a week. But my daughter missed almost all of her preschool year due to covid and started school at 4.5 no problem

NovacDino · 27/10/2021 13:34

[quote Whatwillyakkabetoday]@NovacDino This has been my thinking more and more in the last year.

I’m quite shocked by some of the responses though. I think I need to stick to my plan of having to send her next September.
Surely doing as I’m doing with her at 3 years old isn’t going to be detrimental, is it?
Feeling quite shit now and worried.[/quote]
Stick to your guns. You know your child and you know a bit about education. Give her the best start you can before she has to enter the system. If I had young children I would probably want to home school them until the end of Y2 because I see first hand what is happening in schools with our youngest children and it is not good for them, on the whole.

JustLyra · 27/10/2021 13:33

It sounds like the other place just wasn’t right for her. You’ll know yourself that some kids just don’t fit some settings.
I’d try her somewhere else. Or perhaps with a childminder for a morning or two at least. Just to get her used to not being with you all the time and give you a break.

ancientgran · 27/10/2021 13:31

No, I didn’t miss it, but you wrote that they started dependent on when their birthday was, so this indicated everyone whose birthday was in the same period tended to start together, this little girl is starting two years later. In the same class you would have, roughly, one third of a class starting in September, one third in January and the final group in April. So the older children in the year had two terms more in reception than the younger ones and very definitely all the children in that school year didn't start school together.

Swipe left for the next trending thread