Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Is it weird to keep her with me until 5?

391 replies

Whatwillyakkabetoday · 27/10/2021 09:17

Dd, is 3 and an August birthday. Is it unusual to keep her at home with me until she turns 5 and send her the September after she turns 5?
I’m a nursery teacher so do lots of activities at home etc.
She wouldn’t have any pre school etc until 5
Has anyone done this?

OP posts:
Whatwillyakkabetoday · 27/10/2021 20:01

@fourandnomore This is my hope. To leave it for a bit now and then see about the pre school attached to the school a walk away for us. They only take them at 4, so hopefully we will get in there and hopefully she’ll like it.
At the moment she says she never wants to go to school, so we’re not mentioning it at all and I’ve just said when she’s bigger, she’ll go to a different school and emphasised how great school is and all the fun things you do etc

OP posts:
pantjog · 27/10/2021 20:01

This reply has been withdrawn

This has been withdrawn by MNHQ at the poster's request.

Whatwillyakkabetoday · 27/10/2021 19:58

@ittakes2 She has no problem with simple things like hanging her bag up, we do this at home with her bag, coat, shoes away etc. She’s really independent and actively enjoys doing those things

OP posts:
MolyHolyGuacamole · 27/10/2021 19:56

I'd keep her home, seems like you do a lot. We send kids off to school too early IMO!

Melawati · 27/10/2021 19:55

Are other settings different? Where are the other three year olds going? In your position I’d do lots of research, lots of chatting to other parents about the details and visiting settings. Can you attend any events at the settings her friends go to? You may find a different setting makes all the difference. Also, having a good understanding of school life and routines will be like before starting may help her settle next time.

Whatwillyakkabetoday · 27/10/2021 19:54

*Nuturing enough

OP posts:
MrsSkylerWhite · 27/10/2021 19:49

Maybe a halfway house? We didn’t feel our youngest was ready for full time, even as a February baby so just sent him for half days for the first term. At half term included lunch then full time in second term. Worked very well, school were happy and he made excellent progress.

OhRosalind · 27/10/2021 19:47

I also think it’s important to keep expectations positive but realistic (for both of you), although this was obviously not the right place for her, lots of kids cry and don’t run in excitedly at first and those that do might have a wobble later on.

fourandnomore · 27/10/2021 19:44

Is there a way you could take her to look around options with you if possible later in the year once you’ve built her confidence again? I found my daughter had completely different reactions to different preschools we visited, it was so surprising. She had always been with me and was happy and confident. Two of them she pottered in and went to play immediately, one she clung to my leg then made me hold her on my hip and wouldn’t get down. Another she was shy at first but warmed up and talked about it lots afterwards. I then talked to her about them all and she said which one she liked best. She was 3 at that point.

A friend of mine had a very similar experience to the one you’ve described with your daughter. She sent her to a different nursery the following year and she was a completely different child - 4 rather than 3, happy and loved it.

I would leave things as they are with you at home until the new year and maybe try to look at some options together at that point? My heart goes out to you, it’s horrible when experiences knock their confidence so much.

OhRosalind · 27/10/2021 19:43

That sounds really disappointing and overly formal for the age group. Are there other (public?) settings around that you could visit/speak to for a better feel? Or ask locally/on Facebook for parent feedback?

ittakes2 · 27/10/2021 19:37

When my children started school this lovely mum who worked as a nursery nurse had told me she had done what you did - keep her son at home until he was 5. But unfortunately he was the kid running a muck in the playground - refusing to queue, excitedly causing merry mayhem, the teachers had to teach him all the basic things from scratch like hanging his bag up etc...and he was also the kid then that the other children did not want to be friends with because he was upsetting the other children because he was doing what he wanted when he wanted. And unfortunately he is still in high school a kid that other kids have not warmed to.
I sense you have anxiety? There is nothing wrong with holding him back a year academically if you and the school think this is best - but not socialising him will cause him issues in the long run.

Whatwillyakkabetoday · 27/10/2021 19:29

@Melawati @OhRosalind It wasn’t play based enough, she was being told to sit down constantly and there was lots of shouting 😢it wasn’t what I envisaged at all and it’s hard not to feel bitter about it. We were both so excited and I honestly thought she’d be running in. She cried for me, which she’s never done before, she’s clingy to me now still, but it’s getting better. They just weren’t untiring enough and had no playtime outside etc until the afternoon and she was only in mornings. Definitely not what I had in mind and I made a mistake choosing the place.
We wouldn’t go back there, but I’m worried for future places now, when before I was v relaxed about it all.
I would so love to send her to one of the International schools here with pre school attached, I’m confident she’d love it, but we simply can’t stretch to private school fees sadly.

OP posts:
TatianaBis · 27/10/2021 19:26

@Tillysfad

Children who are inherently shy and introverted will be more impacted than children who are inherently sociable.

If this is being put forward as a suggestion that introverted children particularly need to go to nursery, it is absolute tosh and out of the dark ages psychologically.

No such suggestion was made.
Bluntness100 · 27/10/2021 19:26

@TatianaBis, I get what you’re saying but nature over nurture is always a difficult one. But as @Tillysfad Said, If that’s the case then it would mean this little girl needs to get into school, keeping her home would cause even more damage.

OhRosalind · 27/10/2021 19:24

What do you think your DD struggled with - something specific to that setting or just being apart from you? I think I’d focus on trying to identify and deal with that and work out if any alternative settings would suit her better next year. They change so much in a year though.

We are also overseas with a youngest in the year group DS who has started preschool this year, aged almost 3. Unlike your DD he has been very shy post lockdowns and hasn’t found it easy settling in but has made a lot of progress already. I think in some ways he’s just a bit young and would have been better starting in a few months time but only September starts are possible here, like where you are. And as another pp mentioned, if preschool is the norm (here it’s not compulsory till 6 but almost all kids attend at least mornings from 3) all their peers are there so there are fewer opportunities for socialising outside preschool, so that affected our decision. We spend a lot of time in playgrounds and activities since they’ve opened again but it’s a completely different experience from a preschool or school environment.

Tillysfad · 27/10/2021 19:22

Children who are inherently shy and introverted will be more impacted than children who are inherently sociable.

If this is being put forward as a suggestion that introverted children particularly need to go to nursery, it is absolute tosh and out of the dark ages psychologically.

TatianaBis · 27/10/2021 19:14

@Bluntness100

That’s the point - some children adapt and some don’t. Children who are inherently shy and introverted will be more impacted than children who are inherently sociable.

Thus the issue is a multifactorial one - interface of nature and nurture.

AmyandPhilipfan · 27/10/2021 19:13

My mum started teaching in the 60s in an area where children started school aged 5 and there was no nursery provision. She said most were at home with Mum (or sometimes Grandma if Mum did work) and there were no playgroups around. She always said that most of those kids came to school far more ready to learn, and used to listening to an adult, than the kids she was teaching just before she retired in the early 2000s; lots of whom had been in full time nursery provision. It’s a societal norm now for children to attend nursery but that doesn’t mean it’s a necessity. Yes, for some being in nursery is preferable to them spending all day every day in their own home environment, but for others while they might enjoy nursery it won’t do much for them that an attentive parent can’t.

Bluntness100 · 27/10/2021 18:52

@TatianaBis, she can blame it on that. It’s her life and she knows better than you do. You cannot tell someone what they can and cannot base their experiences on, especially an anonymous stranger.

As said earlier, plenty of children do adapt and are fine, others do not and really struggle and it can be life long. What is absolutely a given is that child hood experiences can shape our future.

I grew up in a deeply abusive home. I am not damaged by it as an adult. Plenty of people who went through similar ar and never mentally recover. I would not deem to tell them their problems as an adult did not stem from their child hood. As humans we all adapt and overcome differently, we all react differently. Some survive, some thrive, some do not.

It is not the fault of the child or the adult they become.

TatianaBis · 27/10/2021 18:37

@Marelle

My mum did this to me. It caused social problems that have lasted my entire life. I didn’t learn how to relate to other children and it affected my ability to mix at primary school, which had a knock on effect on secondary school, and really on everything since then.
Hmm a friend of mine was homeschooled on a remote farm in Africa with no friends but her parents and animals until she went to primary school - and she was absolutely fine. Very sociable and outgoing person.

I don't think you can blame problems with socialisation on one cause like that.

abstractprojection · 27/10/2021 18:35

I was kept at home until 5 but that was the norm then. More because I was an only child my Mum took me to various play school type things which were just a few hours but have me the chance to socialize

They were play only and apart from educational toys and activities that my Mum greatly encouraged I did no formal education until starting schools at 5 and was an above average to top student throughout, but as I said was the norm then. If it’s the norm where you child would start school I don’t see an issue.

My Mum later became a primary school teacher and early years specialist, it is her opinion that the focus on formal education in EY is to the detriment of most kids learning and they should be left to play for a lot longer with a mix of in school/nursery/kindergarten and at home

Marelle · 27/10/2021 18:29

My mum did this to me. It caused social problems that have lasted my entire life. I didn’t learn how to relate to other children and it affected my ability to mix at primary school, which had a knock on effect on secondary school, and really on everything since then.

Melawati · 27/10/2021 18:25

OP, do you know what it was about the nursery setting that didn’t work for your DD? If you’re overseas is it language, or even just culturally a different way of doing things to how you are at home.
When my older DDs were young we lived overseas. DD1 didn’t settle at all at the local private nursery which was very structured, but was very happy at the preschool of the international school which was more play based.
I wouldn’t have said it knocked her confidence though, or set her back. Just that it didn’t really suit her. That sounds quite serious and as a parent I’d want to understand if the difficulties for my DD were related to that particular setting or school in general.

WrapAroundYourDreams · 27/10/2021 18:19

Both my DC did the nursery class at the primary school they currently attend, I took advantage of the 15 hours free so they did 5 mornings a week, my daughter from when she was nearly 4 (she just did the full year of the nursery class) and my son from just after he was three (so he did the full year plus one extra term).

I think it benefitted them (and me!) hugely. I'd actually been nervous about them going to nursery/school, but they loved it. Early years curriculum is very play based and they had a great time, and learnt so much, including social skills. It was great that they were able to attend the nursery class at the primary school- they basically have one huge classroom with one side for reception and the other for the nursery class. They wore their uniform every day, got to know lots of the school staff, got used to going there every day. I know this is very specific to nursery classes attached to a school but it helped them get used to school- when they started reception they were already at the school so it felt like the hard bit was done.

I do think it's been really beneficial to my children. Particularly my son, because at 6 and now in year two, he was in reception when the pandemic hit and schools were shut. That extra time in the nursery class proved so important- he was already used to school and so I think it was less disruptive than it might have been. I know it's really specific but it's a benefit I had obviously never even thought of. I think for most children, going to a nursery or pre school is really advantageous

Justheretoaskaquestion91 · 27/10/2021 18:19

@LobsterNapkin

Excellent post