Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Is it weird to keep her with me until 5?

391 replies

Whatwillyakkabetoday · 27/10/2021 09:17

Dd, is 3 and an August birthday. Is it unusual to keep her at home with me until she turns 5 and send her the September after she turns 5?
I’m a nursery teacher so do lots of activities at home etc.
She wouldn’t have any pre school etc until 5
Has anyone done this?

OP posts:
Dixiechickonhols · 29/10/2021 00:22

No I’m not knocking you on putting her in local school (presumably one reason to live there is she will grow up bilingual) but not speaking language is a massive consideration and I suspect your replies would be very different if that was in your first post. I do wonder if language issue was a big part of her not settling and making friends in preschool. Yes she’ll catch up eventually but I’d ask again specifically for replies from people with experience of dc starting school in a foreign language. My understanding is start them asap so they get full immersion experience and she’ll be fluent by time she starts school.

GrandmasCat · 29/10/2021 00:13

Friends groups. Difficult to break in when everybody knows each other and have their own friends, especially if the other kids have been together in pre school / nursery since they were tiny. DS moved schools in year 1, the clicque was so strong the only friends he made were other children who joined later than him, who as DS, were bullied by the other ones.

Icanflyhigh · 29/10/2021 00:05

Dd2 was born 31st Aug, and is doing just fine in school.. now year 8 secondary and never had an issue.

readwhatiactuallysay · 29/10/2021 00:04

Defering is a perfectly valid option, providing the child is being socialised with peers, if you feel that's what best do it.

But so look into how their years work out and they wont reach a certain year group and need to move or something like that.

Annabellerina · 28/10/2021 23:54

Many people don't realise (and why would you unless you've been through it) that the reason some of us choose not to send our child to full time nursery/pre-school/school was because it is absolute torture for the child. SOME KIDS HATE SCHOOL and if you have a child like that it starts at the beginning when you try to put them in nursery. It's not that they hate school because they haven't been enough and they're not used to it, they hate school because they hate school! A lot of school refusers also have undiagnosed additional needs. It really isn't as simple as, send them more often so they get used to it.
Follow your instinct OP!

Tillysfad · 28/10/2021 23:33

Several kids were August born and I saw no disadvantage to their social and academic achievement. Unless your child is particularly immature I'd send them to school.

Great peer reviewed research there.

maofteens · 28/10/2021 23:19

My son is a late July baby. He was soooo ready for school though! He was a bundle of energy and Mr Social - still is at 18.

Several kids were August born and I saw no disadvantage to their social and academic achievement. Unless your child is particularly immature I'd send them to school.

Tailendofsummer · 28/10/2021 23:18

I'm in my 50s and we absolutely had preschool.

notoldjustpastyoung · 28/10/2021 23:06

Not so long ago there was no such thing as pre-school. So enjoy her while you've got her.

Tillysfad · 28/10/2021 22:59

A lot of parents here seem oblivious to the poorer outcomes experienced by children who are very young in their year.

The statistics demonstrate that children don't speed up their development to convenience our academic year. Who knew.

Tillysfad · 28/10/2021 22:56

nannykath

She really doesn't.

nannykatherine · 28/10/2021 22:34

Have you thought about the social aspect of nursery ?
As a nursery teacher I’m sure you know the benefit of playing alongside and with other children ..
Even if it’s two sessions a week she needs to learn to detach from you and learn independence skills ready for school ..

Kind2Bkind · 28/10/2021 22:26

I’ll be honest, I’ve not read all the other posts. I’ve read only a few. I am a teacher too and I firmly believe that the education sector is not one size fits all. Please keep your daughter off for as long as she needs. Home education is fine. People are going on saying that it’s not fair to keep her out of rhe socialising at school. Let’s face it, in our adult lives how many jobs require you to work in close proximity to 29 other unruly individuals?! As long as she can socialise in her dance class and other social situations that’s ok that matters.
If she’s not ready for mainstream education, delay it. Even consider a different route. Please don’t get swept up in what the masses do.
Love to you all.

AllOfMyLove · 28/10/2021 22:20

Sorry about the typo’s Confused getting used to my new (smaller!) phone.
That’s my excuse, anyways… Halloween Grin

AllOfMyLove · 28/10/2021 22:18

I’ve never posted here before, but I started reading this feed out of curiosity and then I jumped to just reading your posts. I really feel for you because we had something similar happen to us. My daughter is a summer born baby and being a reception teacher of 8 years, (and having taught year two and year 6 for two and one years respectively) I have always noticed the difference between the younger and older children in my class.
My daughter sounds a little like yours - even though she was young, she was verbal early and is very academically bright, but I felt her social skills and confidence were not particularly good. I deferred my daughters school entry because of this and because I believe that formalised schooling starts too early in this country.
She started reception this year, and I am so glad that we made the decision we did. I see such a difference in her. She loves knowing she is one of the oldest and nurtures the younger ones, this gives her self confidence. Her teachers have commented that she is s joy to have in the classroom because she is ‘so ready for school’ and she recently won form prize for her enthusiasm and behaviour.

What I will say is that she attended full day nursery 2x a week from 7mo (my mum had her the other three days) and then, because of a cross country move, did a month at a random nursery whilst we were (mid pandemic homeless!!!) and then when we had moved, joined a school nursery 5x a week 9-3 until her September start. The moving around worried me so much, but in the end turned out to prove a blessing… she adapted so well (not at ALL what I was expecting given her prior experiences!) and this made me more chilled and confident that we were doing the right thing.

Maybe instead of a preschool you can do a regular playgroup? Or heard term activity club? See how she does with that and then liken it to school for her. We read lots of book slike ‘Lucy and Tom - start school’ and Janet and Allen Alberg’s ‘Starting school’ over and over again.
It helped that I was a teacher and I would come home and show her what I had son that day. It got her very excited!

Hope this helps you!

Thund3rMumma · 28/10/2021 22:08

I have an august baby and sent her to nursery just after she turned 3 and she thrived did better at adjusting than some of the older kids and went to reception just after turning 4 and now she's in year one doing excellent. You might find your child loves it and will do so much better than other children

SmellyOldOwls · 28/10/2021 22:01

Depends on the child. My DS is like a border collie, he's smart and full of beans, a few days out of school like now at half term and he's bouncing off the walls because I can't stimulate him the way they do at school. But then you are a teacher so maybe that won't be a problem for you!

whatwillyakkabetoday · 28/10/2021 21:58

@Dixiechickonhols Yes, this is a huge part of it, but what option do we have? We can’t afford the expensive, private, international schools where they teach in English. Also I’m not so sure about that as how would she ever integrate. From my experience, they learn the language really quickly and she will adapt, but I feel awful throwing her in at the deep end like that. She knows a few words of our now home country and we try to teach her when we can, but I’m mainly focusing on phonics etc in English and it can all be too much, don’t want to overload her.
It’s really made me seriously think about coming home to the U.K.

OP posts:
whatwillyakkabetoday · 28/10/2021 21:55

Thanks so much everyone for your views and feedback, such divided opinions! 🙈

OP posts:
Helpneededbyanoutsider · 28/10/2021 21:47

I work for (I’m a nanny) a family that never used childcare facilities and home educate. They don’t follow an online curriculum or home education curriculum. Their children are 7,5,1 and a few weeks.

Honestly their children are all much more intelligent and more developed in all areas than they should be for each of their age.

7 year old is at GSCE level for maths and science and 5 year old isn’t far behind…

They are young for their age in obvious ways eg. Still believe in Santa, watch and enjoy peppy pig/ other young kids shows. I think that has more to do with there being younger ones around though.

Socially these children are polite, act appropriately in public and you genuinely couldn’t tell are educated any different. They meet a new friend in the park their sort of age and they’re best friends within a couple of minutes.

Obviously some children are naturally shy/ find socialising difficult but I can say this has nothing to do with going to school/ nursery or not.

The plan is to be home educated until each is 11 (join year 7) and it’s a school where there’s no feeder and is a private school so kids come from all sorts of backgrounds.

These children are very privileged and love a country life with no sort of limits eg. Baking everyday, arts/ crafts always offered, learn instruments, pursue any interests. Anything broken immediately replaced.

What I’m trying to say is keeping your child at home is not going to hold them back in most circumstances. I will say financially think carefully about not taking the free 30hrs but obviously don’t know your circumstances.

dementor72 · 28/10/2021 21:37

So long as the class she goes into is all the same year group I wouldn’t see any problems ….
But …
my August born went into a class that was multi year (80’s idea 🥴)
so she was with kids aged up to 7
Bullying and lack of control was dreadful and she suffered and regressed .
After being moved to a more traditional school she did very well and no longer feared going to school.
I quote ‘school taught me that the world isn’t nice ‘

Dixiechickonhols · 28/10/2021 21:24

You’ve not answered potential language issue OP?
You are abroad. She’s English speaking at home with you and you are expecting her to go to a local school speaking a foreign language?

lightsout · 28/10/2021 21:20

Go for it
My august born son didn’t start school until 5. He did have 2 years at preschool though so wasn’t socially isolated.
4 is too young for formal education and he wasn’t ready. Have you looked at the summerborn campaign? They’ll help you figure out how to speak to schools about it.

summerbornchildren.org/2015/09/08/minister-says-school-admissions-code-will-be-amended-and-summer-born-scandal-stopped/

liveforsummer · 28/10/2021 21:15

I don't think once a fortnight is enough social contact with peers after age 2 never mind 3 or older.

partyplanner82 · 28/10/2021 20:19

My eldest child had a staggered start to primary school as he maintained a few days at forest school when starting reception at the local primary.

My youngest missed preschool due to covid.

Both my children are flourishing and whatever they missed in those early years / months has been caught up and evened out, so we barely even remember their delayed start to formal education.

Both made friends fine. Children who move schools find nee friends quickly so ignore people who say that your child will miss forming the friendship groups.

Sounds to me like all the posters telling you it's wrong to delay your daughter's start, are just jealous that they couldn't keep their darling children at home longer.

Do what is best for your child. By the time they get to year 3, like my eldest (aged 7) it will make no difference!