Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Is it weird to keep her with me until 5?

391 replies

Whatwillyakkabetoday · 27/10/2021 09:17

Dd, is 3 and an August birthday. Is it unusual to keep her at home with me until she turns 5 and send her the September after she turns 5?
I’m a nursery teacher so do lots of activities at home etc.
She wouldn’t have any pre school etc until 5
Has anyone done this?

OP posts:
Xtraincome · 27/10/2021 10:58

I think it's great but she does need socialisation with peers in the form of group sessions. Pre school etc isn't necessary. Are you planning to Home Educate her from age 4 to 5? If so, your local area will have peer group activities within that community.

Streamingbannersofdawn · 27/10/2021 10:58

I dont think it will be detrimental to send her to school a year later when the system would have done the same had she had been born mere days later. As a previous poster pointed out the outcomes for summer born children are poor just because we ignore that fact it doesn't make it any less the case.

I do think it would be beneficial for her to have some time in a pre-school though, it doesn't have to be every day. They aren't all the same though so have a look around, lots of different ways to do it.

iolaus · 27/10/2021 10:57

So because she wasn't ready last month you are assuming she won't be ready in 10 months time?

Can't you do what you did this year? Try her and if you don't feel SHE is ready then pull out

mugandspoon · 27/10/2021 10:56

@Jobsharenightmare is wrong about Scandinavia and @onlysomany and @Hollyhead are right. Although in Sweden, Denmark and Norway school is now compulsory from the age of 6 (Finland still 7, but 96 % start at 6), almost everyone goes to preschool many years before then. The whole society is based on two parents working, and for anyone other than people with extremely high incomes or extremely low standards, it is more or less impossible to live on one salary.

Swedish statistics from 2017 show that 50 % go to pre-school at age 1; 90 % at age 2, and approximately 95 % at age 4-5. So the fact that it is not compulsory is irrelevant - society 'makes it' compulsory.

(There have recently been parliamentary motions to make preschool mandatory from age 3 (party motion) and age 2 (individual motion).)

The comparison with the 50-60s is also not super relevant. Children today will start school with children today, and will be compared against other children today.

Although I am quite negative about the Scandinavian preschool model: too young children, too few teachers (no ratios, believe it or not in 'child-friendly' Sweden), too many hours (full-time + parents' commuting time is more or less the norm from age 1), I would struggle to argue the case that not attending preschool at all would be beneficial for an average child in today's UK.

LaetitiaASD · 27/10/2021 10:56

@HollowTalk

So she'd miss the first year of school? Why would you do that?
Because we send kids to school at least a year or two too early in this country?
clockover · 27/10/2021 10:54

@DelphiniumBlue

Your post is wasted. OP isn't even in the UK.

DelphiniumBlue · 27/10/2021 10:53

I'm not clear whether your question is "what year group would she go into" or "will she suffer from not being at school?"
It might be sensible for you to speak to the head at your local school and find out whether she'd go into Reception or Year 1 if she starts school the September after she tuns 5. She'll either be the oldest in her year group or the youngest.
I don't think it would be easy for her to go straight into year 1 unless she can already read at that point - whilst Reception is a lot about learning through play, they also do Phonics systematically and you wouldn't want her to miss that, unless you can teach that yourself.
It is difficult ( but not impossible) to change year group once a child has started school, but that could result in knowledge gaps, so it is important to make the right decision first.
As you are a nursery teacher, you must know some reception teachers - I think they would be best placed to talk you through the potential issues.
As for whether she will be OK home with you until 5, almost certainly yes. It is a comparatively recent thing for children to start school at 4, and to go to nursery or pre-school before that. When I was young, there were very few nurseries, and most children stayed at home until they were 5, mixing mainly with their own families. I think the mothers felt somewhat isolated but the children were fine!

Briony123 · 27/10/2021 10:52

No preschool and just one "playdate" once a week or once a fortnight? Until after she turns 5? In a rural area?
This post is a joke, surely?

Porcupineintherough · 27/10/2021 10:51

I was a late August baby and I wouldnt start a just turned 4 year old in formal education, I'd defer a year. I would send a 3 or 4 year old to preschool though.

lanthanum · 27/10/2021 10:49

It is unusual not to do any pre-school. Play dates cover some of the social skills, but don't cover the things that they have to get used to in a larger group - sitting still and listening in a group, taking turns to speak (quite different in a group of 15+ than 3/4), etc.

I don't know how it affects how they cope with being away from mum when they do start school, but I suspect that varies considerably between children. You might also want to get yourself used to being away from her!

She doesn't have to do pre-school every day. Perhaps look for a nursery where she can do a couple of days or half days. You'll still have loads of time to enjoy doing things with her at home, but she'll pick up those additional skills and begin to become more independent. Telling you what she's done while she was there is another new skill which she will probably enjoy.

StormyTeacups · 27/10/2021 10:46

Maybe. But maybe not, I'm not sure you can be quite so categorical after a few words on the internet?

As a teacher in primary school, I wouldn't be as confident as you seem to be!

clockover · 27/10/2021 10:46

@ancientgran

Back in the 50s most of us were at home with mum until the term we turned 5. Children started in the September, January or April depending on when their birthday was. I only remember one girl crying and she was screaming and pulling the teachers hair as well, the poor kid couldn't speak English so it must have been terrifying for her.

We didn't have playgroups, not many nurseries as all the wartime ones closed so women had to give up work and let men returning from war have the jobs. Certainly in the inner city area I was in no one went to pre school activities. I remember it being confusing for a few days but we were all fine as far as I know.

'As far as you know' isn't that far though, is it? Just because only one girl cried when you got to school doesn't mean everyone else was ok. It's not just about going to school. There is being at school. The thing about 'back in the 50s we did x' is that we have progressed over the years because through research, test and observation we know children perform/cope/manage better if they have the chance to develop socially before getting thrown into school (at whatever age)

I would not advise anyone keeps a child at home because it's what we did in the 50s Sad

NautaOcts · 27/10/2021 10:45

Especially when asking ‘what’s normal’

NautaOcts · 27/10/2021 10:44

Would’ve been helpful to include in the OP what country you’re in.

Breastfeedingworries · 27/10/2021 10:43

@sassbott

What? Why? You’re a nursery school teacher and you first hand see the benefit children in these environments get. Why would you deprive your child of these?

Is this for you? Or for the child? (It smacks me of the former).

And by the way, in my child’s reception year it was very clear the 2 children who had not been socialised via pre school. Every morning the meltdowns at the school gates were something to behold - these children were sobbing/ screaming and pushing their parents back from the school begging not to be sent. They regressed into soiling/ wetting themselves in school. And were quite unsettling influences within the classroom. I thought it was really cruel actually and not remotely fair on the other children.

I’m going to go back and continue reading but this needed to be quoted!!
itsallgoingpearshaped · 27/10/2021 10:42

Having seen young children (KS1) be yanked out of school for over a year due to covid and then come back ... don't do it. They are shockingly behind and don't know how to make friends or be around other children.

ancientgran · 27/10/2021 10:41

Back in the 50s most of us were at home with mum until the term we turned 5. Children started in the September, January or April depending on when their birthday was. I only remember one girl crying and she was screaming and pulling the teachers hair as well, the poor kid couldn't speak English so it must have been terrifying for her.

We didn't have playgroups, not many nurseries as all the wartime ones closed so women had to give up work and let men returning from war have the jobs. Certainly in the inner city area I was in no one went to pre school activities. I remember it being confusing for a few days but we were all fine as far as I know.

FrancineSmith · 27/10/2021 10:36

@Mistlewoeandwhine

My DS1 started school at about 4 and 9 months. He could read, articulate himself well etc and he went into school for the first time with no tears as we’d talked a lot a bout school and he could understand how everything worked. The kids crying round him were the ones who’d been in the preschool the previous year! I’m Irish (but living in England) so have a different way of looking at things but frankly, seeing tiny tots going off to school every day depresses the hell out of me. No one needs to be acclimatised to ‘systems’ when they are three.
@Mistlewoeandwhine “ No one needs to be acclimatised to ‘systems’ when they are three. “

This. Spot on.

speakout · 27/10/2021 10:36

Most go to nursery/pre school first though - we don't tend to simply keep them at home
Exactly.

My kids started school at 5.4 and 5.9 years. Lods of parents did the same.
But priot to that they were in pre school nursery for 5 days a week, moving up to big school with their peers.
Prior to that was playgroup 4 days a week.

zanzaa · 27/10/2021 10:34

From what you’ve said Op, it sounds fine. You know her best anyway. It’s only in the U.K. that children start school at 4 anyway.

Mine went to a nursery from about the age of 2 yrs 9 months, but it was only 9.15 to 12 for three mornings a week. If they didn’t want to go, I didn’t force them and we just did something else instead (but I was SAH so had that option). On the ‘no nursery’ mornings, we did Tumble Tots, of music groups. I’m in London though, so there was always something going on. I did loads of phonics with them and all four went into reception fine.

I think children do need socialising (daily), but that’s not to say they need to be all day in a nursery from a very young age. They don’t! Just a few mornings per week is enough and gets them used to a more ‘institutionalised’ setting (queuing up, etc). Is there nothing like this near you? If not, I would definitely take her to groups (messy play, gym, music, whatever) and have other children over every day.

BogRollBOGOF · 27/10/2021 10:31

The other consideration is that if the mass culture is to go to pre-school, that reduces other opportunities to socialise because there isn't the demand to provide them. You don't get many evening opportunities for young children because most are too tired to do much after pre-school.

clockover · 27/10/2021 10:31

@Phrowzunn

The amount of catastrophising on this thread is hilarious! In Scotland it’s perfectly normal for kids to start school at 5 or 5.5. I’m pretty sure the entire population of Scotland isn’t damaged / traumatised / socially inept etc etc 😂

Most go to nursery/pre school first though - we don't tend to simply keep them at home

MrsSkylerWhite · 27/10/2021 10:30

clockover

I’m a nursery teacher

So where will she be when you are at work?

Why, as a nursery teacher, are you not able to see the benefits of a child being in nursery?“

Our daughter was a nursery teacher. It had quite the opposite effect (certainly in respect of the baby stage).

JellyTotCat · 27/10/2021 10:30

@sassbott I don't know but as I said the kids who cried on being left for weeks/months in my children's classes had been to nursery and there have been plenty of examples people have given of kids settling in fine after being at home, so it's not as simple as
Stay home til 5 = children will struggle
Go to nursery = child will settle in fine
The kids in Our Yorkshire farm all start school at 5 after no nursery and seem to settle in fine
My own kids went to childcare/nursery from a young age so I've no skin in the game

SheikhMaraca · 27/10/2021 10:30

Have you thought about starting up your own playgroup op?

Swipe left for the next trending thread