Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Is it weird to keep her with me until 5?

391 replies

Whatwillyakkabetoday · 27/10/2021 09:17

Dd, is 3 and an August birthday. Is it unusual to keep her at home with me until she turns 5 and send her the September after she turns 5?
I’m a nursery teacher so do lots of activities at home etc.
She wouldn’t have any pre school etc until 5
Has anyone done this?

OP posts:
missingeu · 27/10/2021 11:27

My 18yr DD is end of August and she started school having just turned 4 - she was top off her class throughout school and we never had any issues with her being the youngest.

It's only when all her friends turned 18 and she was the last - as she couldn't go out clubbing as much was the only issue.

Whatwillyakkabetoday · 27/10/2021 11:26

@Dixiechickonhols Yes, I’ve thought that. But her main pre school for September (state and feeds into the school she goes into) will only take from September (we have to put her name down in April) I’m reluctant to start her somewhere else again and then change, especially after what she went through

OP posts:
Bluntness100 · 27/10/2021 11:26

@ancientgran

I mean this politely but you’re missing the point. It’s not the same as then all children were the same, and started at the same time. The op is taking about holding her child back when others will have two years of daily socialisation under their belt when her child starts.

I think you missed the bit about 3 intakes a year, September, January and April. That means they didn't all start at the same time.

No, I didn’t miss it, but you wrote that they started dependent on when their birthday was, so this indicated everyone whose birthday was in the same period tended to start together, this little girl is starting two years later.

I do understand though if your own kids didn’t start school till nine, and were several years after other kids you’d have a different experience.

Whatwillyakkabetoday · 27/10/2021 11:24

@NovacDino This has been my thinking more and more in the last year.

I’m quite shocked by some of the responses though. I think I need to stick to my plan of having to send her next September.
Surely doing as I’m doing with her at 3 years old isn’t going to be detrimental, is it?
Feeling quite shit now and worried.

OP posts:
Dixiechickonhols · 27/10/2021 11:24

Can you not try again for a Jan or Easter start and try a few sessions a week at a new school. If it’s social aspect she’s struggling with it is odd not to try and work on that. Maybe first school wasn’t right fit?

MiniPumpkin · 27/10/2021 11:24

Don’t see any issue with deferring school, I think kids are too young for school at 4 IMO. However I would 100% get her into nursery/pre school now. Due to work commitments I had to send dd to nursery age 1, now 3.5 she absolutely loves it. Friends have kept kids at home till 3 which I know is normal but what a struggle it was trying g to settle them.
Agree with others that the play dates you have just now is no where near enough

Whatwillyakkabetoday · 27/10/2021 11:20

@PopsicleHustler Yes, similar schooling here.

OP posts:
Shasha17 · 27/10/2021 11:20

It's absolutely fine. In a lot of places in the world, children wouldn't start school until this age anyway.

Whatwillyakkabetoday · 27/10/2021 11:17

@Briony123 I’m not in a rural area??!

OP posts:
Whatwillyakkabetoday · 27/10/2021 11:16

@lanthanum That was the plan this September just gone. I paid for a good nursery/pre school for her to go to a few mornings a week initially. We were both so excited, she’s always been so outgoing and confident etc. She was completely miserable, went into her shell. I persevered but she was just so unhappy.
Now I’m stuck with what to do next
My plan was definitely to start here next September when she’s just turned 4,(different school with pre school attached) but honestly worried how she’ll be.

OP posts:
NovacDino · 27/10/2021 11:10

As a teacher, I would definitely keep her at home. As long as you are providing her with learning opportunities and time with other children. Unfortunately, the EYFS is now, more often than not, too formalised and not developmentally appropriate for our youngest children. Many countries don't start formalised education until 7 and they out perform us in league tables. She will be fine joining in Y1... and hopefully you can find a school with a more play based approach to KS1 to send her to.

clockover · 27/10/2021 11:09

Once again we didn't all start school at the same time, we had 3 intakes a year.

I didn't say the same time. I said everyone's starting point was the same. Which is true no matter which intake you were.

Dixiechickonhols · 27/10/2021 11:09

Did you post earlier this year when you tried preschool and she was having social issues and you were worried there may be something else going on autism/adhd. Also you speak English at home but had put her in a different language school? Apologies if not you but your posting style reminded me.
It’s hard to advise as most posters on here are English based so no pre school, no playgroups plus deferring a year would be very unusual.
The thing that jumps out at me is child has no room to develop and navigate socially. A dance class is structured. A play date is structured - mum Clare’s not sharing and an adult intervenes. She won’t learn how to make friends and deal with stuff.
If the norm in country is preschool full time from 4 then she will be odd one out. If language is a factor too then pre school is a good chance to get her speaking it.
If you are concerned re additional needs then pre school may assist in getting ball rolling with early diagnosis and intervention.
I’m just thinking if you start her at 5 and she is distressed it will be fobbed off as not used to school, needs to settle. It may delay her getting help she needs.
Think long and hard why you don’t want to send her. If it’s because you suspect she won’t cope as she’s different then said kindly shielding her will just delay diagnosis. If you don’t want to send her why not?
Some people of course choose to homeschool for reasons they feel strongly about, if you felt that way then you wouldn’t be sending her at 5.

ancientgran · 27/10/2021 11:09

@speakout

*ancientgran Back in the 50s most of us were at home with mum until the term we turned 5.*

I actually doubt that.
In most areas there were tons of kids around, all playing together, most days, in the streets, in each other's gardens.
All the younger kids were in the same boat, and would seek out each other's company, encouraged by their mothers.
Most children had a big local gaggle of friends, so were well socialised before they started school.

This isn;t happening with the OP's child.

Well I was there and I can assure you that where I lived 3 year olds weren't out playing in the streets and we didn't have gardens, back yard was as good as it got.

Was this your experience in the 50s?

ancientgran · 27/10/2021 11:07

@clockover

Well I was at school with them for years so if it had some dire consequence it didn't show up for quite a while.

Or you didn't know about it. The thing is you are talking about a group of kids all at the same starting point, OP child would not be on par with her peers when starting school.

Mine started school at 9, no problems, both passed the 11 plus 2 years later, both got first class honours degrees, both have post grad qualifications, both in happy relationships with good jobs. That might not work for others but they are my kids and I, with DH, made the decision that was best for them.

It's not all about academia. Also, did you keep them at home with you the whole time with just the odd play date?

I didn't say it was all about academia though did I? They are well adjusted adults in happy healthy relationships. Once again we didn't all start school at the same time, we had 3 intakes a year.

We socialised much as the OP says she does with her DD going to parties with kids we knew, having play dates, dance class but we also did swimming classes but to be honest not alot of socialising in 30 minutes in a swimming pool. As they got older they did more after 5 like rainbows/beavers.

speakout · 27/10/2021 11:07

ancientgran
Back in the 50s most of us were at home with mum until the term we turned 5.

I actually doubt that.
In most areas there were tons of kids around, all playing together, most days, in the streets, in each other's gardens.
All the younger kids were in the same boat, and would seek out each other's company, encouraged by their mothers.
Most children had a big local gaggle of friends, so were well socialised before they started school.

This isn;t happening with the OP's child.

clockover · 27/10/2021 11:06

Oh for goodness sake OP.

Did you do this on purpose just so you can come back and tell people they are wrong? That's twice you have dropped in some vital information that should have been in your first post Hmm

PopsicleHustler · 27/10/2021 11:06

I am currently home schooling my 3 year old. She is 4 in April but will be attending infants that september. I love her dearly and am providing puzzles, games, flash cards, drawing and painting stuff etc. And have a schedule week by week. She also has 4 other siblings so she is definitely not missing out on social skills etc. I did that with my 3rd child too. And had him reading and writing two letter words by the time he started reception.

Whatwillyakkabetoday · 27/10/2021 11:03

She doesn’t only see playmates once a week or fortnight, these are the planned, more formal meets for those not in pre school etc. We’re out most days, she encounters and mixes with lots of different people, attends birthday parties, dance class and the playgrounds 4/5 times per week

OP posts:
clockover · 27/10/2021 11:03

Well I was at school with them for years so if it had some dire consequence it didn't show up for quite a while.

Or you didn't know about it. The thing is you are talking about a group of kids all at the same starting point, OP child would not be on par with her peers when starting school.

Mine started school at 9, no problems, both passed the 11 plus 2 years later, both got first class honours degrees, both have post grad qualifications, both in happy relationships with good jobs. That might not work for others but they are my kids and I, with DH, made the decision that was best for them.

It's not all about academia. Also, did you keep them at home with you the whole time with just the odd play date?

ancientgran · 27/10/2021 11:01

I mean this politely but you’re missing the point. It’s not the same as then all children were the same, and started at the same time. The op is taking about holding her child back when others will have two years of daily socialisation under their belt when her child starts.

I think you missed the bit about 3 intakes a year, September, January and April. That means they didn't all start at the same time.

ancientgran · 27/10/2021 11:00

@clockover 'As far as you know' isn't that far though, is it? Just because only one girl cried when you got to school doesn't mean everyone else was ok. It's not just about going to school. There is being at school. The thing about 'back in the 50s we did x' is that we have progressed over the years because through research, test and observation we know children perform/cope/manage better if they have the chance to develop socially before getting thrown into school

Well I was at school with them for years so if it had some dire consequence it didn't show up for quite a while.

One of my GC started school in September, I was asking her mother how it had gone, she said she missed her nursery so much, found it very strange that teachers don't give you a hug or sit you on their knee if you are upset. Didn't sound much easier than it was for us.

Is there any research about how the August born cope compared to the September born, they aren't one homogenous mass they are individuals with some being considerably older than others (11 months 3 weeks is a big gap at the age) some are going to be brighter or more confident, some will be big for their age some will be tiny, some have brothers and sisters. I dont think we can assume they are all the same and the OP knows her child far better than anyone on here, whatever research they have done.

Mine started school at 9, no problems, both passed the 11 plus 2 years later, both got first class honours degrees, both have post grad qualifications, both in happy relationships with good jobs. That might not work for others but they are my kids and I, with DH, made the decision that was best for them.

Bluntness100 · 27/10/2021 11:00

@ancientgran

Back in the 50s most of us were at home with mum until the term we turned 5. Children started in the September, January or April depending on when their birthday was. I only remember one girl crying and she was screaming and pulling the teachers hair as well, the poor kid couldn't speak English so it must have been terrifying for her.

We didn't have playgroups, not many nurseries as all the wartime ones closed so women had to give up work and let men returning from war have the jobs. Certainly in the inner city area I was in no one went to pre school activities. I remember it being confusing for a few days but we were all fine as far as I know.

I mean this politely but you’re missing the point. It’s not the same as then all children were the same, and started at the same time. The op is taking about holding her child back when others will have two years of daily socialisation under their belt when her child starts.

In addition at that time children were more likely to play with their peers more than once a week or fortnight in a supervised one on one setting with mummy present.

Also we now know more about child development and what benefits socialisation brings, plus many more women work.

In this context all the other kids will be in pre school daily, and the ops will be at home alone with her.

DuckbilledSplatterPuff · 27/10/2021 10:58

I've skimmed a bit, but I do see a lot of posters saying its normal for children in Scotland to start at 5.5 or in Scandinavia they start much later.. and I'd often wished I'd been able to start my August 30 DC later but its fine if all of them are starting later, but if that's not the case were OP is then her DC's classmates will all be getting experience of school socialising and structure earlier than her DC. That's not to say that her plan is wrong, just different, but I think it does need to be taken into account.
Also, her DC is 3 and it might be hard to imagine them coping right now but their development changes dramatically over the next year and they may be fine by the time they hit the right age for school. The one thing that my DC lacked starting reception was enough socialisation skills. They were bright and could keep up but looking back, that was the difficulty. Number two was fine because they were used to the playground and pick ups by that time.

Yourstupidityexhaustsme · 27/10/2021 10:58

I wouldn't.

Worst case ask if she can start full time in January after doing part time in the autumn term.

You'd really be surprised by how well summer born kids keep up. She may be a little behind some for a few months but she'll surprise you.

Starting her a year behind with no exposure to schooling will result in a massive social/educational delay.