Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Story repeaters

91 replies

NigellaSeed · 26/10/2021 23:01

DP always repeats the same things. Long, extensive critiques of why a film or TV show was in his opinion fantastic or terrible. Its thoughtful and sometimes interesting (the first time you hear it) but it's looong. We been together years so it's part and parcel that I hear the same stories or opinions over and over.

But the thing is, he tells it all to his parents, and they're his captive audience, as if they've never heard it before.. But hes already told them like 6 months ago. And then the year before that too. It starts the exact same discussion with no new ideas. I find it so dull and usually kills the night for me.

I'm not the worlds best dinner guest but I can remember what I've said to someone and what they've already told me. All three of them are extremely bright and have so many interests (nature, tech, travel etc etc) but sometimes I just think they're so boring.

I try and steer things into a new direction but sometimes I can't get a word in.

Yabu - it's normal to have the same conversation over and over, just smile and look like you're having a good time

Yanbu - you can go to bed early and complain to wise MNtters

OP posts:
Hemingwayscats · 27/10/2021 13:20

My DH has always done this. When we first met I was too polite to tell him but now I just say ‘yeah you’ve told us this before, at least twice’ and he stops. Not arsed if it’s rude, I can’t be bothered listening to the same long winded story again.

DampSquidGames · 27/10/2021 13:17

My DH and I can be like this so we chatted about it and it turns out I sometimes do the repeating thing too. So now we have a little saying if either of us are doing it. It’s working well although not a nice feeling when you realise you are repeating but it at least I don’t relisten to any of my DH’s stories.

ShirleyPhallus · 27/10/2021 13:16

My MIL does this, except that she retells you a story that you’ve literally just heard from someone

Ie we were out for lunch with SIL, SIL tells us a story about her car breaking down. In the car on the way home, MIL then tells us the story as though it’s somehow her own story that she was party to and we haven’t possibly heard before. I want to scream “WE WERE LITERALLY THERE WITH YOU LISTENING TO THE SAME STORY AT THE SAME TIME”

It’s so weird!!

GillBiggeloesHair · 27/10/2021 13:11

@NalPolishRemover sounds exactly like my Mum.
No interests, no hobbies and only a few friends. She doesn't talk to my brother very much so I get it all.

saraclara · 27/10/2021 12:33

I have started doing this. I particularly don't remember which DD I've told things to, so one will get a story twice, and the other not at all.

I'm grateful when someone gently points out that they've heard something before. It's fine by me for people to interrupt gently and say, "oh yes, you mentioned that.."

Now I'll often say, "did I tell you about...?" or "tell me if you heard this already...", because I really don't want to embarrass myself, and I don't want people mocking me for it behind my back, having pretended they hadn't heard it at the time.

Butteredtoast55 · 27/10/2021 12:31

My BIL tells the longest, most rambling stories in minute detail and can repeat them verbatim to anyone trapped with him. He must have the memory of an elephant. MY DC call him Uncle Chloroform Blush

CouldIhaveaword · 27/10/2021 11:58

It's great when they forget parts of their own stories and you can chip in and remind them because you've heard them so often.

NalPolishRemover · 27/10/2021 11:32

@GillBiggeloesHair snap!
My mother is v similar. She repeats pretty boring stories endlessly & she gives huge amounts of needless detail about the lives of neighbours & people I don't know.

Always with a judgemental / negative slant.

She has v few interests & virtually no social life but never did..She had lots of opportunities over the years but gave them all up one by one as she just couldn't be bothered.

The thing that makes me sad is how she can recount stories from her childhood in excruciating detail in a monologue (Christmas dinner being her prime event for this) and when dh asked her to tell him something about my childhood she couldn't remember (She was banging on for the umpteenth time about how they'd no money growing up & her parents gave her a doll. Dh asked her what she thought my best Christmas present was as a child & she was genuinely flummoxed! And she got it wrong- she named a toy I'd never received)

She's fit & healthy & has no memory loss. She's just unaware of how much she repeats herself.

SweetMaryHell · 27/10/2021 11:14

@Mookie81

😂 bless her - there’s the story of how our Labrador ran after the milk man around 35 years ago

The story of how her sister called her fatty because she wouldn’t let her put her records on (around 60 years ago)

The story of how she slapped a yogurt lid on my dads arm (around 40 years ago - must admit I do find this one amusing)

And my personal favourite which I don’t mind her repeating … the time she was drunk on Malibu and deliberately batted a tray of sausage rolls out of my uncles hands at an army do. She was made to help clean up the mess 😂

N0tfinished · 27/10/2021 11:04

@Muchuseaschocolateteapot

My mother in law can remember any slight anybody has ever done or said against her but doesn’t remember telling us about it on numerous occasions before. She told us the same story three times in three hours one day. I just ‘smile and wave’ but DH loudly points out “yes mother you’ve already told us”. It doesn’t seem to stop her though and she usually finishes it. And she’s in full use of her faculties.
OMG we must be sister-in-laws. I come away from a visit to IL's just emotionally drained. The negativity just depletes me.

If I try to change the subject she'll just relentlessly drone on. I have recently refused to listen if the subject matter is especially awful- she has this weird obsession about her nieces' children.

Cherrysoup · 27/10/2021 10:48

My mil did this, same story 3 times in 3 hours. I think it was a precursor to dementia. My mother is start to do it, I keep stopping her and telling her she told me. I don’t see why 8 should have to put up with it, probably horrible of me, but hey, life’s too short and she is otherwise perfectly fine.

Anotherbrokenairer · 27/10/2021 10:44

I will add they're not boring stories though and people who hear them for the first time do find them amusing.

Anotherbrokenairer · 27/10/2021 10:40

My dad does this. He's a sensitive soul and never been very sociable. So when my mum tries to cut him off in an annoyed way telling him he's been telling the story for years I chuckle and recount some of the story so he can finish it off. We then have a little laugh together when he's finished. There are lots of stories so there is a variety 😊(even if I have been listening to them on rotation for 30 odd years).

ColinTheKoala · 27/10/2021 10:23

My mum does this a bit - she says that her argument is that she lives alone and she doesn't always remember what she's told me and what she's told others. Which I suppose is fair.

Both my mum and a friend like to talk about books they've read or TV programmes they've seen in great detail (or in the case of my mum a radio drama she listened to). I will say "oh I saw x programme and it was about y". Done - 30 seconds at most. They'll be talking about it from start to finish for about 10 minutes.

That said, apparently you get on in life more if you talk in detail about things. Those of us who make our point and shut up, don't. See the book "Why men win at work" for more!

Technosaurus · 27/10/2021 10:17

My brother is like is - he's in his thirties. Everything in a pre-prepared script format, like he's told it a hundred times. 6 months later, word for word the same. Surely he knows he's said it to me because I didn't even feign interest the first time!

My Dad got like it later in life, but in fairness he had an interesting professional life and had to retire with ill health, so I didn't really mind - he was happy regaling, sort of living in the past, and it would have hurt his pride to be told to shut up.

But when they're doing it about films/TV shows I just switch off and make a mental note to try not to bring it up again...

Mookie81 · 27/10/2021 10:10

@SweetMaryHell

My mum does this and always has. The thing is as she’s never worked and doesn’t socialise her stories tend to be very mundane events that most people just wouldn’t remember. Here are a few of her favourites:

A large spider walked across her living room floor around 10 years ago. Step sister threw a catalogue at it. It missed.

My uncle said he couldn’t find a decent pillow anywhere (around 15 years ago).

About 7 years ago my mum got on a bus and the driver dropped his change down the side of his chair. He responded with the comment “it’s not my day today”.

These stories are drawn out with acting and “comical” impressions but the story remains the same and are told at least once a month,?for years and years …

Can it get more boring than these examples? GrinGrin Give us some more.
Mumoftwoinprimary · 27/10/2021 09:57

“You’ve told your mum and dad this already Fred. Why don’t you tell them about….”

And then insert something that won’t make you want to eat your own eardrums.

Notesandmemos · 27/10/2021 09:37

Like a PP we've been treated to PIL's never-changing accounts of their local supermarkets so often they have become part of our family 'in joke' language. If anyone starts repeating themselves in a tedious manner someone will alert them with ' Is there a Lidl near you?'.

NigellaSeed · 27/10/2021 09:02

@jg7445 yes luckily I can get away with jokily snapping "heard it" if he tries to give me a lecture on why this or that is a masterpiece.

From reading all your comments, I'm starting to wonder if his parents are actually just amazing at the smiling and nodding routine. It seems easier to believe than the three of them are just that forgetful.

I guess this is my life. Mentally checking out and let them get on with it Halloween Grin

OP posts:
NigellaSeed · 27/10/2021 08:55

@SweetMaryHell

My mum does this and always has. The thing is as she’s never worked and doesn’t socialise her stories tend to be very mundane events that most people just wouldn’t remember. Here are a few of her favourites:

A large spider walked across her living room floor around 10 years ago. Step sister threw a catalogue at it. It missed.

My uncle said he couldn’t find a decent pillow anywhere (around 15 years ago).

About 7 years ago my mum got on a bus and the driver dropped his change down the side of his chair. He responded with the comment “it’s not my day today”.

These stories are drawn out with acting and “comical” impressions but the story remains the same and are told at least once a month,?for years and years …

That made me a little sad. It reminds me of my mum, she doesn't repeat stories but she also had no social life and her stories are of what someone said at Asda or her neighbours daughters son. :(
OP posts:
blink18two · 27/10/2021 07:46

Currently I'm hearing all the same pregnancy stories from MIL that I heard multiple times the first time I was pregnant.

Yes, I know you 'didn't even want to try breastfeeding'. Really fucking hate this part of the conversation considering I tried my hardest and never really managed it.

blink18two · 27/10/2021 07:43

My PILs and BIL/SIL do this.

Fucking tedious.

jb7445 · 27/10/2021 07:40

This reply has been withdrawn

This has been withdrawn by MNHQ for breaking our Talk Guidelines.

MacNTosh · 27/10/2021 07:38

My Step Father has always done this, right back from when he was in his 40s. One of his stories is about the time my longwinded Aunt said someone’s eyes had glazed over while she was talking and he said, perhaps your were boring them! Oh the irony.

Seriously though, is smile and nod the only way forward?

SweetMaryHell · 27/10/2021 07:34

My mum does this and always has. The thing is as she’s never worked and doesn’t socialise her stories tend to be very mundane events that most people just wouldn’t remember. Here are a few of her favourites:

A large spider walked across her living room floor around 10 years ago. Step sister threw a catalogue at it. It missed.

My uncle said he couldn’t find a decent pillow anywhere (around 15 years ago).

About 7 years ago my mum got on a bus and the driver dropped his change down the side of his chair. He responded with the comment “it’s not my day today”.

These stories are drawn out with acting and “comical” impressions but the story remains the same and are told at least once a month,?for years and years …

Swipe left for the next trending thread