Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To give a heads up to anyone using the M25 tomorrow....

262 replies

Ilovepearjuice · 26/10/2021 22:31

"To reduce your speed to 20mph to reduce the risk of accidents"

Um... Or perhaps they should thinking about scraping their backsides off the tarmac of a busy motorway during rush hour?!

Here we go again...

To give a heads up to anyone using the M25 tomorrow....
OP posts:
jetadore · 29/10/2021 14:27

@torquewench

Could IB, or their protestors (theoretically) be sued by people who have suffered a loss (e.g. for loss of earnings) as a result of their actions?
Could oil companies and the politicians in their pockets (theoretically) be sued by people who have suffered a loss (e.g. illness, death) as a result of pollution or climate change?
FromMumToMeAgain · 29/10/2021 14:25

I don’t get this type of protest at all. They are targeting people trying to go about their business and work to pay taxes. It doesn’t affect the people making decisions on the running of the country at all so won’t change anything as they don’t care about inconvenience to the little people.

Why should the government pay to insulate people homes anyway? That’s a personal responsibility surely. Weren’t there government grants for insulation a few years back?

Insulating Britain is not going to contribute much to reducing carbon emissions while China, the US, India, Russia and Japan are merrily burning away to their hearts content.

Absolute nutcases with nothing better to do.

jetadore · 29/10/2021 14:23

@Puzzledandpissedoff

... the direct action becomes symbolic of the changes that occurred

I'd suggest the key word there is "symbolic" - otherwise known as trying to get the credit for something which actually came about through the efforts of others

Hence the thing about the suffragettes "getting women the vote" when history shows it's their war efforts which did that. It's a shame all those excellent women so often miss out on the credit, but then hard practical work isn't as exciting as locking yourself to things, shouting and having a bit of a dance

It’s not ‘trying to get credit’, it’s what has stuck the minds of the general public and popular knowledge/opinion, which counts for a lot, (as is the case here as well). Not many people are “well, actually...” history buffs like you and pp. Direct action important and necessary in achieving change.
Dragongirl10 · 29/10/2021 14:21

I feel an overwhelming urge to help my neighbouring farmer out by taking his full muck spreader for a drive and dispatch around the M25 tomorrow.....

Skatastic · 29/10/2021 14:10

Ooh also I got free underfloor insulation and a free boiler this year through a government scheme.

Skatastic · 29/10/2021 14:10

@Handsoffstrikesagain

IMO you lose all rights to support, a voice and protection under ‘peaceful protest’ as soon as you prevent people accessing chemo, do something that means a woman is now paralysed, stop fire engines and other emergency services responding to incidents and prevent people being with Their loved ones in their final hours. They are utter scum and it’s a shame we can’t get the water cannons on the lot of them.
This with shiny bells on. If this had been a while ago when we were visiting my dying Mum in law I dread to think what my husband would have done if the selfish shits were blocking the road. A bit more than putting dye on them.
itsgettingwierd · 29/10/2021 14:09

And there have actually been government schemes for solar panels and insulation in the past. Most recently the green home scheme which needed in March this year.

There's no denying more could be done but it is being done.

The same with cars. The green zones etc and the introduction of charging points in supermarkets.

These people though don't have realistic ideas. They think the world for their children will end in 3-4 years. Some of these people have children under 10 and say we've been seeing and know this will happen for decades. So why being children into the world and then throw yourself across the M25?

I agree with improving expectation of new builds and having policies about insulation etc. So do lots of people. They lobby government about it.

But I see a huge difference in people who are lobbying, campaigning etc and can explain their cause and reasons and these IB who are quite clearly extremists in thought.

torquewench · 29/10/2021 14:02

Could IB, or their protestors (theoretically) be sued by people who have suffered a loss (e.g. for loss of earnings) as a result of their actions?

Sparklingbrook · 29/10/2021 14:01

Exactly @itsgettingwierd.

itsgettingwierd · 29/10/2021 13:59

[quote jetadore]@Sparklingbrook

Do you really believe that their bizarre antics are helping their cause? That glueing themselves to the road and ranting manically on morning TV is going to make a huge difference? confused
It’s just switching people off from whatever the messages is.

Do you really believe people are "switched on" to their cause? The problem has been known for decades and action is way behind where it needs to be. Many posts on here contain insults or accusations of anarchy/conspiracy. People don't care, most people's priority is getting on with their commute/shopping/'normal' life and continue ignoring the the issue.[/quote]
To be fair I'm more than willing to be switched on to the cause and educated.

So far when I e watched these people on media outlets to learn more all over seen is hysterical people, 3 line prose and avoidance of questions.

But I have learnt one of the male ringleaders lives in a big single windowed non insulated home HmmWinkGrin

When I discovered they didn't practice what they preached and didn't give a shit about the deaths of people who can't receive medical care my mind did switch off from the cause.

bordersroaming · 29/10/2021 13:57

Approved channels haven't worked

It was over 10 years ago that I first heard about suggestions being made to government about hone insulation... suggest that new homes have strict targets, retrofitting insulation as a priority

It hasn't happened and now it is almost too late

WalkingOnTheCracks · 29/10/2021 13:55

@LemonSwan

WalkingOnTheCracks

Because I would be a danger to myself and others.

Yes we are allowed to make unwise decisions and they might argue they have capacity to endanger themselves and others.

But once they start spouting that the must walk up and down the motorway or lie in the middle in order to save the world from impending doom and mass deaths then it gets pretty borderline. Thats quite disordered thinking.

And yes I have previously had delusions/ psychosis and been sectioned. So I try to keep a grip on what would be disordered thinking/ what not when I am well so I can hopefully recognise it if it ever returns.

If I did that - I would consider it disordered. So I am not going to think they are exempt.

I didn't understand why you think you'd be sectioned if you did that, when they're doing it and not getting sectioned.

Hence the question, why would that happen to you?

And you've explained why. Thank you. And I hope that you remain well. All the best.

Puzzledandpissedoff · 29/10/2021 13:54

... the direct action becomes symbolic of the changes that occurred

I'd suggest the key word there is "symbolic" - otherwise known as trying to get the credit for something which actually came about through the efforts of others

Hence the thing about the suffragettes "getting women the vote" when history shows it's their war efforts which did that. It's a shame all those excellent women so often miss out on the credit, but then hard practical work isn't as exciting as locking yourself to things, shouting and having a bit of a dance

Sparklingbrook · 29/10/2021 13:48

www.bbc.co.uk/news/uk-england-essex-59089013

Sparklingbrook · 29/10/2021 13:47

www.bbc.co.uk/news/uk-england-essex-59089013

The protest group said the decision to stop sitting in the middle of roads had been made following "feedback" from frustrated drivers

Hmm
Sparklingbrook · 29/10/2021 13:36

@jetadore

Who is looking for excuses? They are indeed twats. And who wants to listen to twats?

You are making excuses. The behaviour of IB is being used to excuse and reinforce the complete apathy that has lead to their existence in the first place. The amount of vitriol in this thread is evidence that people are conditioned to maintain the status quo and fight change that doesn't come via "approved" (controlled) channels.

I am not making excuses. I don't understand why you would think I am. Confused

'Approved channels' would be ones that don't involve glueing yourself to the street or preventing ambulances getting to hospitals ,surely? Sounds sensible to me.
You can see the cause but still be raising an eyebrow at their ways of going about it.

LemonSwan · 29/10/2021 13:28

WalkingOnTheCracks

Because I would be a danger to myself and others.

Yes we are allowed to make unwise decisions and they might argue they have capacity to endanger themselves and others.

But once they start spouting that the must walk up and down the motorway or lie in the middle in order to save the world from impending doom and mass deaths then it gets pretty borderline. Thats quite disordered thinking.

And yes I have previously had delusions/ psychosis and been sectioned. So I try to keep a grip on what would be disordered thinking/ what not when I am well so I can hopefully recognise it if it ever returns.

If I did that - I would consider it disordered. So I am not going to think they are exempt.

ivykaty44 · 29/10/2021 13:21

It was much the same with protests 100 years ago trying to obtain equality for voting. There were many against the changes and the distruption wasn’t welcome

jetadore · 29/10/2021 12:26

Who is looking for excuses? They are indeed twats. And who wants to listen to twats?

You are making excuses. The behaviour of IB is being used to excuse and reinforce the complete apathy that has lead to their existence in the first place. The amount of vitriol in this thread is evidence that people are conditioned to maintain the status quo and fight change that doesn't come via "approved" (controlled) channels.

WalkingOnTheCracks · 29/10/2021 12:20

5G, microchips, lizard people, area 51, tin foil, country going to the dogs, foreigners taking out jobs, too much money spent on rehabilitation, throwing money away on overseas aid, policitcal correctness gone mad, aromatherapy, eating crusts give you curly hair

...all very funny. Except the lizard people. That's true. And they're not actually lizards. They're projections from the lower fourth dimension who represent as lizards. Well, as lizards who represent as people. Like the Queen. And Ken Barlow.

David Icke wrote a book on it. He has curly hair, as it happens. Which says it all really. Open and shut case.

WalkingOnTheCracks · 29/10/2021 12:11

@LemonSwan

Honestly what a load of drivel.

Do you know what would happen to me if I ran across the M25 shouting that I want to save the world and my children from impending doom?

I would get sectioned.

Why would that happen to you specifically?
Sparklingbrook · 29/10/2021 11:32

@jetadore

They might be able to switch people on and get the Government to take them seriously if they stopped their bizarre antics…

Just looking for excuses. People are incredibly apathetic and resistant to change. This has been coming for decades, if the protests are stopping people from switching on, who's been switching us off all that time? Those other arseholes, Gore, Thunberg, Attenborough, right? Insulate Britain, they may be twats, but they're right.

Who is looking for excuses? They are indeed twats. And who wants to listen to twats?
BewareTheBeardedDragon · 29/10/2021 11:29

I find it a little bizarre that a group protesting for government help to insulate our inadequately heat retaining housing stock - presumably because they recognise that huge swathes of the population cannot afford to insulate their own homes - are criticised for not 'putting their money where their mouth is' if they haven't personally insulated their own homes. They are asking for government help for a reason, are only people who can afford to pay for their own eco measures allowed to ask the government to step up and help those who can't?

I do agree that their tactics are not winning them support and they should rethink - but this criticism is ludicrous.

jetadore · 29/10/2021 11:05

They might be able to switch people on and get the Government to take them seriously if they stopped their bizarre antics…

Just looking for excuses. People are incredibly apathetic and resistant to change. This has been coming for decades, if the protests are stopping people from switching on, who's been switching us off all that time? Those other arseholes, Gore, Thunberg, Attenborough, right? Insulate Britain, they may be twats, but they're right.

jetadore · 29/10/2021 10:55

@TSSDNCOP

Let's pause for a second and consider that over 100 police officers needed hospital treatment after the London Poll Tax protest, and that arguably the real success of opposition protest was through people simply not paying it in staggering numbers and taking advantage of its administrative burden.

I have no issue with protest, I have protested, and would protest on climate change.

I will not protest with this shit shower who haven't even put their money where their mouths are, can't pull together an articulate credible spokesperson, are sticking themselves to the floor with toxic Loctite Henkel products produced in you guessed it and are stopping ordinary people getting to jobs, school and hospitals.

Christ, your whataboutery knows no bounds.

As I said nobody remembers the jockey or the 100 coppers, the direct action becomes symbolic of the changes that occurred.

Whatabout the toxic superglue? ffs

On Rosa Parks: Let's pause for a second to consider the loss of earnings of the bus companies and effect the decrease in take-home pay must have had on the drivers' families. Arguably the real success came as a result of political instability caused by the Vietnam conflict.

Muhammad Ali: Aligning himself with Islamic groups set the cause back and throwing his gold medal in the river was insulting to the goldsmith's craft, not to mention a waste of a precious metal that could have been used to fund worthy causes. Arguably the real success of opposition came when George Foreman knocked out Joe Frazier in the seventh... etc. and so on