Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

AIBU to feel so hopeless and sad about the cruelty to children in this world?

67 replies

Shimmylikejoanholloway · 26/10/2021 21:20

I probably sound melodramatic but recent news - poor, poor little Star Hobson, Arthur Ljanbo-Hughes and the little girl in Afghanistan has just broken me. And those are just a few.
It seems to be getting worse? Everywhere I look there seems to be horrific stories of abuse and human suffering and I feel so helpless, disturbed and heartbroken by it.
I genuinely look at my toddler and wonder what on earth I've brought him into.

I know this kind of thing has always happened (disgustingly) and now we have more access to news/social etc so we hear so many more details than we would have done, but it feels really awful at the moment.

And I know I shouldn't read it if it upsets me but these poor children lived through it, I feel like we should read it and know what they suffered so lessons can be learned. I doubt they will though, and that's the saddest thing. I wish there was more I could do than just cry for these little ones when you hear about it in the news.

Sorry for the rant but it's really getting to me lately.

OP posts:
Justheretoaskaquestion91 · 30/10/2021 14:52

I’m pleased there’s a thread on this as it’s actually so distressing and feels like a huge influx of this sickening cases that it’s good to have somewhere to discuss/share our thoughts. I made DH read about Star because I just needed someone else to read it and be sad with me.

I don’t understand how people can do these things.

Itsnotover · 30/10/2021 14:46

In the case of Star it was two women.

I've been following the trial. A lot of Frankie's relatives have already given evidence. They talk about how Frankie changed into an unrecognisable person, that she started talking differently, dressing differently and when family questioned her about her bruises she said that she doesn't feel pain any more. So strange ...

Amdone123 · 30/10/2021 14:45

YANBU op. Nor melodramatic. It's heartbreaking and we just can't understand how these so called human beings can do this to a precious child.
It keeps me awake at night too. I sometimes wish I hadn't read it and I admit I don't always get to the end as it's too upsetting. It stays with me for a while.
One thing I will say though. We can't stop these bastards, but we can support children's charities and we can raise awareness through safeguarding. Everyone needs to be vigilant wherever you are, live or work, if you see something, report it as best you can. ( I appreciate this is difficult in some situations).
Also, I see on a daily basis how well the majority of children are looked after, loved and nurtured and whilst this doesn't help the children lumbered with these vile excuses for human beings, it does help me feel a bit better.
I had my granddaughter yesterday with my 3 great nieces. I loved watching them play - happy and safe, the way it should be. And hugs and kisses from Nana lasted slightly longer than usual.

amsadandconfused · 30/10/2021 14:34

I seriously question the relatives and friends of these creatures that didn’t see or suspect abuse!
I am sickened that a mother would introduce a man to her child and fail to protect their child.
I have friends that cannot have children and would have taken these poor children and loved and cared for them .
Unfortunately these creatures have absolutely no problems with their fertility…it makes me sick !

Itsnotover · 30/10/2021 14:21

The UK cases have affected me really badly. I just can't understand it. I made a donation to both of the crowd fund pages in an attempt to acknowledge those children and their families. I think I heard that Arthur doesn't have a headstone Sad

It's my view that these cases have come about because of covid and lockdowns. Which disconnected these children from family members that could help them. Arthur apparently only ended up living at Tustin's house because they were there when lockdown was announced.

chaosrabbitland · 28/10/2021 07:09

@PickUpAPepper

The issue, I gather, isn't that abuse isn't reported. It's that it's not acted upon. In Star's case the BBC says social workers were 'kept away' from here - how?? We all get checked and watched so much now, yet these horror events still happen. Signals getting lost in the noise?
in at least a couple of articles iv read on star yesterday , her grandmother frankie smiths one , had phoned ss and they dismissed her report as malicous .if this is indeed true it was a terrible failing that cost the child her life . its a haunting terrible case , such exteme prolonged sustained cruelty . there was a video of the partner holding star and trying to be all affectionate to her and the child was just expressionless , there is also a pic in the papers of the child looking the same being held by her , arthurs case is every bit as bad

both stars mother and arthurs father could have just told social services that they didnt want their children and at least even in care these children would have had a chance at a decent life , but they just just keep their children to torture as a source of fun . its evil

im watching to see what sentences stars mother and partner get .
it says much about our criminal justice system that these killers dont receive whole life sentences as in WHOLE LIFE , i just cannot understant why they dont , peter connollys mother was released at one bloody point , i fail to understand why men like wayne couzans can get a whole life sentance for rape and murder which of course he fully deserves , but a mother can collude with her partner to torture and beat her child to death and not get the same , it will never make sense to me . but then i think this pair and arthurs murderers should be hanged anyway

NeverDropYourMooncup · 27/10/2021 22:51

The reason why they're being reported on is that it gets the papers clickthroughs and increased advertising revenue. It's a particularly unpleasant equivalent of Meghan Markle stories, miracle diets and salacious murders - the last of which have been making newspaper owners obscenely rich for a good couple of centuries.

The actual level of abuse is likely to be less than it ever has been in history. It would be great if the level were zero, but when there are humans involved, that's never going to happen - there will always be people with mental illnesses, people with personality disorders, people who are irrevocably damaged by their own childhoods, drug abuse or are just plain wicked. And weaker people will always suffer at their hands. It's not right, but it is, for want of a better word, Normal for humans.

Now yes, salacious stories also have the advantage of getting laws put in place in order to keep particular politicians in power, so there are more laws as a result of publishing those accounts of how much defenceless children have suffered and how nobody helped them or somebody tried but wasn't listened to - but you're being upset by it because the news organisations know it makes them money, so you hear of more than you would have done.

Some people act on this by being more vigilant in their daily lives and reporting things they feel are wrong, some find meaning in religion, some almost completely reject the human race can't say I blame them. But it isn't worse than ever. It really, really isn't; 1.5 million innocent children were murdered in just four years in Europe in the period from 1941-45 for the crime of existing - Jewish, Roma, Polish, Catholic, Disabled. 1,500,000 innocent babies, toddlers, infants, juniors, pre teens and teenagers. Nothing now can be as awful as that.

It's not getting worse. It's awful and everything possible should be done to try and protect the children. but it isn't getting worse.

Basicbitch40 · 27/10/2021 22:37

I know. It just reminds me how I would die for my dc and do anything to stop them being hurt. I don't understand why other parents don't feel the same.

EezyOozy · 27/10/2021 22:15

My husband and I took our daughters abroad recently and we each shared a room with one of our children (intrusive thoughts about Madeline McCann) and I just can't relax in most situations thinking that harm will come to them. I'm not sure how normal this is?

I have a 2 and 3 year old and I'm exactly the same, and would have done same as you on holiday. I'm probably on the higher end of the anxious parent spectrum, but I consider myself quite sensible!

Mayorhum21 · 27/10/2021 21:04

Rubbish @bluewanda I can remember horrific cases like this going back to the early 2000's

Mayorhum21 · 27/10/2021 21:00

@PickUpAPepper yep and I'll know i'll likely be flamed but social services....what a useless sack of sh*te, they are as bad as the parents in my book no excuses. They need to start prosecuting those who are supposed to be working on these cases for causing or allowing this, let's see how quickly they book their ideas up then.
.

Shimmylikejoanholloway · 27/10/2021 20:21

@Eightmagpies you've articulated so well how I feel most of the time. I suffered from anxiety prior to DS due to some traumatic events in our struggle to successfully have a child, and I've realised the anxiety is still there, brimming beneath the surface it's just focused on different areas.
I do the same - automatically see all the perceived threats.

I can't comprehend how parents can want to do anything other than love and protect their children. I stayed away from the news today, I feel pathetic when I say things like this but my heart can't take it.

OP posts:
Shimmylikejoanholloway · 27/10/2021 20:19

I'm not glad others are feeling like this, although in a way I am as these children deserved love and at the very least I hope they somehow know how many people are mourning them and SO angry about their suffering.
I think the same @Bumblenums1234 my DS doesn't stand still for 30 seconds and definitely wouldn't stand in a corner facing the wall. That poor little girl. Poor poor babies, all of them.

I really wish there were something more we could do, I feel compelled into action on their behalf - something needs to change, but I have no idea what will make a difference.

@AbsentmindedWoman I'm so sorry for your difficult journey, mine isn't the same but we had a lot of trouble and loss before we had DS. This is the thing that cuts deep in me too - so MANY people out there would love these babies, would adore and cherish them and keep them safe. It's all kinds of wrong.

My heart is heavy today. My little DS has a cough and every time I go up to comfort him after he wakes I can't help but wonder if these children ever had a moment of comfort in their short lives.

OP posts:
Eightmagpies · 27/10/2021 09:36

I have recently recognised that, since having my first dd 4 yrs ago, I am in a constant state of anxiety and despair about the cruelty in the world. I weep at stories all the time and feel so helpless. My husband and I took our daughters abroad recently and we each shared a room with one of our children (intrusive thoughts about Madeline McCann) and I just can't relax in most situations thinking that harm will come to them. I'm not sure how normal this is? I'd also like to know how I can contribute to helping vulnerable children but don't know where to start.

Rainallnight · 27/10/2021 08:43

I’m the same OP. I’m an adoptive mum so fairly used to accounts of abuse and neglect but the stories of these poor little children have really got to me.

zaffa · 27/10/2021 08:41

[quote bluewanda]children's services cut back so much that it's impossible to keep children safe anymore.

@zaffa This isn’t only a recent issue though. Just read the horrific case of Tiffany Wright. Children weren’t being kept safe in 2007 either (and Tiffany is obviously just one of many tragic examples) Sad

www.theguardian.com/society/2010/feb/06/child-neglect-adrian-levy-cathy-scott-clark[/quote]
I did read that case the other day. It was horrific, that little girl clutching her shoes for comfort and pulling bits of wallpaper off to eat and play with. It's more than I can bear to read about but these children lived it.
Truly, I'm not sure there is any light out there - it's only going to get worse with budget cuts and demonizing SS - I'm not saying they shouldn't be held accountable but it won't attract new people to the role and they are already massively understaffed.

Families who relied on the extra UC top up will be under even more pressure now, places to seek help are closing every day.
The future is just looking very very bleak.

bluewanda · 27/10/2021 08:34

children's services cut back so much that it's impossible to keep children safe anymore.

@zaffa This isn’t only a recent issue though. Just read the horrific case of Tiffany Wright. Children weren’t being kept safe in 2007 either (and Tiffany is obviously just one of many tragic examples) Sad

www.theguardian.com/society/2010/feb/06/child-neglect-adrian-levy-cathy-scott-clark

zaffa · 27/10/2021 08:01

@Bumblenums1234

The Star Hobson case has really effected me, I'm not sure what it is about this specific case but I can't stop thinking about it. How could anyone do that to a poor defenseless little girl.

The fact she would actually stay in the corner speaks volumes to me. She was 16 months old! She must have been so conditioned and afraid to follow that sort of instruction at that tiny age. If I put my 18 month son in a corner, he would laugh at me and run on to his toys. I have been cuddling him extra tight since I read that story.

I agree with this, that really upset me. DD is almost two and she wouldn't stand in a corner and stare at it - she would think we were playing a game or if she was upset she would come crying to me for a cuddle. How terrified must that baby have been to follow through those instructions, to understand the consequences of not doing so. These cases have filled me with such sadness - it feels like there is so much sadness and hardship out there now with families living in poverty and children's services cut back so much that it's impossible to keep children safe anymore. Everything feels very bleak lately.
PickUpAPepper · 27/10/2021 07:51

The issue, I gather, isn't that abuse isn't reported. It's that it's not acted upon. In Star's case the BBC says social workers were 'kept away' from here - how?? We all get checked and watched so much now, yet these horror events still happen. Signals getting lost in the noise?

Darbs76 · 27/10/2021 07:32

It’s heartbreaking. Reading about poor Star and the fact they filmed her climbing up the stairs with a broken shin broke me. Poor Arthur, a friend described him as desperately needing a drink and clearly being abused, why didn’t they report it? People need to report any signs of abuse, whether they believe it or not

bluewanda · 27/10/2021 07:29

You’re not alone OP. I lay awake into the early hours last night thinking about Star and desperately wishing she could have been saved. Like others I have a daughter the same age and I just cannot comprehend how anyone could be so cruel. It’s horrendous Sad

Bunnycat101 · 27/10/2021 06:49

There has been an awful lot in the news and it is very upsetting. I just can’t understand how people can be so cruel on a sustained basis. I could get my head around someone having a breakdown and snapping but I just can’t comprehend the cold nature of abuse some of those children suffered and also the fact they could have been saved.

Thisisworsethananticpated · 27/10/2021 06:37

AbsentmindedWoman
I think the fact you are trying (wanting ) to be a parent puts you in that category anyway , sorry if my wording was clumsy
Flowers

Bumblenums1234 · 27/10/2021 05:00

The Star Hobson case has really effected me, I'm not sure what it is about this specific case but I can't stop thinking about it. How could anyone do that to a poor defenseless little girl.

The fact she would actually stay in the corner speaks volumes to me. She was 16 months old! She must have been so conditioned and afraid to follow that sort of instruction at that tiny age. If I put my 18 month son in a corner, he would laugh at me and run on to his toys. I have been cuddling him extra tight since I read that story.

Werehamster · 27/10/2021 04:56

It is awful. Does anyone else remember Brianna Lopez? They say she didn't spend a day of her short life that wasn't in pain. But I don't understand why no one reported what was going on. Why no one tried to help her. It's just heartbreaking.

Swipe left for the next trending thread