Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Who's unreasonable?

135 replies

OnlyGin · 26/10/2021 17:48

Ben and Sally are married and have DC together. Ben has two DC from a previous relationship as well who live with them 50% of the week.

Sally's parents are well off and like to spoil their grandchildren. They are kind to Ben's other children but don't view them as their grandchildren nor do the children think of them as their grandparents.

Sally's parents like to take her DC out regularly, buy them treats etc etc. Same with Christmas and birthdays, they get LOTS from Sally's parents. Ben's children do as well but not as much as their grandchildren.

Ben has started suggesting this is unfair. For example, this half term Sally and Ben's joint DC have been / are planning to go out to various fun amusement places with Sally's parents but Ben's other DC haven't been invited and Sally and Ben can't really afford to take them themselves, they often come back from these places with treats from the gift shop.

Ben's other children have grandparents on their mothers side who treat them the same way as Sally's parents treat her DC so Sally doesn't see the problem. She doesn't believe it's her parents responsibility to pay for all DC to go to these places and she won't make her DC miss out by saying they can't go unless they all go. She also thinks it's fine for her parents to have a unique relationship with their grandchildren especially as her step children don't see them as their grandparents anyway.

Who's unreasonable?

OP posts:
speakupattheback · 26/10/2021 19:26

Ben is unreasonable. His first DC are not the GPs' grandchildren. If my son in law had "expectations" like that then I'd have a word with him. Cheek.

EggsellentSmithers · 26/10/2021 19:19

It would definitely help to know if Ben’s DC are much older than the joint DC/general ages.

In theory if Ben’s DC are 12/14 and the joint DC are 8/10 then the older ones should be able to understand.

But if the younger ones are say 3/5 and the older ones 8/10 then that’s a bit harder, although not impossible to navigate, and would need some parental reminding that when they are at their mums, they have special times with their GPS that the smaller ones don’t get.

evrey · 26/10/2021 19:16

Very difficult for all involved, however if the GPS have to spend time with the younger children when Ben's older 2 are visiting , surely Ben could use this time to give his older children his undivided attention? Doesn't have to be anything expensive, just a picnic or something maybe?

TillyTopper · 26/10/2021 19:10

I don't think the GPs are being unreasonable by not including all children. They consider, it's not like they ignore them and they give them presents - but maybe they don't feel able to safely cope with all children together. I don't think you force the GPs to take all kids - it's up to them. Sounds like Ben has to step up his game if he feels his kids are left out.

Saoirse82 · 26/10/2021 19:04

If it were my parents I know they'd include all the children. It seems cruel to take out 2 children and let then come home with gifts etc and leave 2 behind. It would be absolutely fine on the days if the eldest 2 weren't there but rather mean if I isn't. I can't imagine anyone in my family doing that and I wouldn't treat children like that either. Obviously the GPs can't be forced to take the eldest ones out so I think I'd compromise by saying they can only go out when the eldest 2 aren't there.

HuhWhatNow · 26/10/2021 19:00

I was a step kid, not half sibling but no way would I have batted an eye at my stepbrothers family doing things with them and not us. I knew my stepbrother's grandparents really really well but they weren't MY relatives and to treat me like a grandchild when I wasn't would have been weird.
It's the same with Sally's parents. They aren't Ben's kids grandparents. Ben is BU.

Notaroadrunner · 26/10/2021 19:00

Ben is definitely being unreasonable. He doesn't get to say what Sally's parents spend their money on. His kids have grandparents on his ex's side who treat them well so it's balanced. Ben should be glad that the maternal grandparents of all his kids are so good to them given his parents aren't around.

Daleksatemyshed · 26/10/2021 18:58

Ben's being unreasonable. Sally's parents sound like decent people who include their SC sometmes but it's a big ask for them always to take all the DC together. There's a world of difference in paying and caring for a couple of children and taking them out and taking out three of four children together. It's hard on the DC too when they have to share their GP's but presumably don't get to see the DSC's GPs.

whistleryukon · 26/10/2021 18:58

Ben and his children don't get to commandeer every situation. Sally's mother and children are entitled to continue to share a nice relationship with one another without being made to feel guilty or have it tainted or undermined by other people being bitter or jealous.

If Ben's DC arrived with gifts from their family I am sure that he wouldn't expect them to hide them. What if his children's mother was very wealthy and his children were able to have a better lifestyle as a result? What if their mum or nan bought them designer clothes or a PS5? Would Ben not let them wear/use it in his house in case the other children felt sad? Or do emotions only count when it's about his kids?

EveryFlightBeginsWithAFall · 26/10/2021 18:51

Well it's not how I'd treat my step grandchild but it is how plenty of people act

Piggy42 · 26/10/2021 18:50

I think Ben is unreasonable. He’s expecting the Gp’s to double the cost of the trips/double the work. His children have other GP’s to do stuff with.

Shoxfordian · 26/10/2021 18:46

It sounds like both sets of children have grandparents who treat them and pay for things so Ben sounds unreasonable to me

MarshmallowSwede · 26/10/2021 18:36

Ben is. His children from his previous relationship have grandparents of their own. Sally’s parents are not their grandparents. They sound like they treat them well and are kind to them, but they are allowed to spend time alone with their own grandchildren.

AwaAnBileYerHeid · 26/10/2021 18:36

Ben is being unreasonable. Why should the grandparents pay double for an outing and be overwhelmed with a bigger group of kids on a day out? Maybe the current amount of grandkids is all they can manage/afford at one time. And even so, they aren't their grandkids so owe them nothing.

Cocomarine · 26/10/2021 18:34

I think your second post is important here. I understand about the flexible schedule, I have one too, but I think it’s really not on for some kids to go out on a special treat whilst others are left literally in the same home. Can you imagine excited stepsiblingsxreturning back from the zoo with their spoils?!
These sound like under 10s, so no - in the moment it doesn’t help that they get trips their other home.

If Ben think all children on all trips - he’s unreasonable.
If he thinks no exclusive tips when the others are staying, then he’s right. But, it’s on him to manage the days better.

StoneofDestiny · 26/10/2021 18:33

They are kind to Ben's other children but don't view them as their grandchildren nor do the children think of them as their grandparents

Ben is unreasonable. They are not his kids grandparents and are not responsible for treating them..

JosephineDeBeauharnais · 26/10/2021 18:29

Ben and Sally chose to blend their family, presumably Sally’s parents weren’t consulted or considered about that (not saying they should have been). It’s not fair to impose Ben’s children on Sally’s parents, it’s up to them to decide what relationship if any, they want to have with them. Ben is BU.

girlmom21 · 26/10/2021 18:29

I think Sally's parents are being unreasonable as their family is blended now.

However, my maternal grandparents used to invite my step sister (dads new partners daughter) on days out with us so she wasn't left out, so I might be biased.

Step moms parents were fantastic with us too and never treated us any differently to their biological grandchildren. They didn't have to do that.

It is also feasible for Ben to find cheap/free days out for his children as well though.

MeanyJoany · 26/10/2021 18:23

What ages are the kids? It doesn't matter really I was just being nosey.

I'm 100% with Sally on this one and think your parents sound like lovely people. I think given Ben's parents are clearly useless for whatever reason that he has a bit of a cheek giving out about your parents who are clearly lovely

RedHelenB · 26/10/2021 18:22

@OwlinaTree

I think I'd be planning the trips that don't include the non invited children on days when they are at their mum's house.
This is the only fair way to do it But 50% of the time seems to me that all the children should be treated the same.
rrhuth · 26/10/2021 18:18

If the GPs were my parents I'd be disappointed they weren't including all the kids if they were there on the given day. I've experience of a blended family, fwiw. So I think on balance Sally IBU, but there is bugger all she can do, as really it is her parents who ABU.

OnlyGin · 26/10/2021 18:12

@Terminallysleepdeprived

Honestly, neither is being unreasonable to feel the way they do.

Could you clarify, are Ben's other children currently staying with him or are they with their mum? In my opinion this makes a big difference to the situation

Currently with Ben and Sally. But Ben works alternating shifts which mean his contact is not strictly every X Y and Z day, it can change regularly.
OP posts:
Motherland101 · 26/10/2021 18:11

Ben is BU. Sally's parents are more than considerate as it is, but are in no way obliged to treat Ben's children as their own grandchildren. Yes it may be nice every now and then if all parties agree, depending on family dynamics etc but it's definitely not a given IMO.

ShinyMe · 26/10/2021 18:07

How old are the children and how long have Ben and Sally been together?

I don't know what I think for sure, but I tend to think that if you're a family then you're one unit and shouldn't be treating children differently.

Terminallysleepdeprived · 26/10/2021 18:01

Honestly, neither is being unreasonable to feel the way they do.

Could you clarify, are Ben's other children currently staying with him or are they with their mum? In my opinion this makes a big difference to the situation