Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Who's unreasonable?

135 replies

OnlyGin · 26/10/2021 17:48

Ben and Sally are married and have DC together. Ben has two DC from a previous relationship as well who live with them 50% of the week.

Sally's parents are well off and like to spoil their grandchildren. They are kind to Ben's other children but don't view them as their grandchildren nor do the children think of them as their grandparents.

Sally's parents like to take her DC out regularly, buy them treats etc etc. Same with Christmas and birthdays, they get LOTS from Sally's parents. Ben's children do as well but not as much as their grandchildren.

Ben has started suggesting this is unfair. For example, this half term Sally and Ben's joint DC have been / are planning to go out to various fun amusement places with Sally's parents but Ben's other DC haven't been invited and Sally and Ben can't really afford to take them themselves, they often come back from these places with treats from the gift shop.

Ben's other children have grandparents on their mothers side who treat them the same way as Sally's parents treat her DC so Sally doesn't see the problem. She doesn't believe it's her parents responsibility to pay for all DC to go to these places and she won't make her DC miss out by saying they can't go unless they all go. She also thinks it's fine for her parents to have a unique relationship with their grandchildren especially as her step children don't see them as their grandparents anyway.

Who's unreasonable?

OP posts:
DysmalRadius · 27/10/2021 11:36

Ben and Sally chose to 'blend' their families for their own benefits - the fact that this comes with significant disadvantages for the children involved shouldn't come as a shock to any of the adults in this situation, and it's not for third parties such as grandparents to rectify.

If Ben is sad that his kids feel left out, this is something he should have considered when moving in with and starting a second family with someone else. His lack of foresight and consideration for his older children is his to bear.

corblimeygov · 27/10/2021 11:23

If I was Sallys parent I'd spoil all of the children the same. However I don't have a six seater car so days out might be a tad awkward?

Kids are kids and it shouldn't matter if they are his not hers, they are family and deserve as much love and attention. Especially as they are still to young to understand fully in my opinion.

OnlyGin · 27/10/2021 11:04

What would be your perspective if it was your dc who were the second class kids in the family?

I don't think anyone's children are second class, they just happen to have different grandparents.

Someone asked if they really are "lavished" with gifts or whether it's just a few extra at Christmas and days out... I'd say Sally's DC definitely are spoilt by her parents. In material things and experiences. They also have a savings account which Sally and her parents pay into so there should be a substantial amount for them when they are 21. Ben's DC don't have this (although may do at their mum's home).

OP posts:
WimpoleHat · 27/10/2021 10:50

Could you imagine having your siblings going to Legoland and you are stuck at home

The whole ideal of the blended family is lovely, but it’s unlikely to work this way in practice. The older kids do not live full time with Sally and her kids. They are therefore (the 11 and 9 year olds) likely to regard themselves as a sibling unit of 2, even if they get on really well with their younger half siblings. And it’s very unlikely that they’d want to go to Legoland and spend at least half the day queuing for the baby rides. As long as there’s kindness and sensitivity, there’s nothing wrong at all with Sally’s parents taking out their own grandkids.

MrsElijahMikaelson1 · 27/10/2021 09:29

The problem with having a day out for all of them is that the little ones are really young and there’s a big difference in age and interest/ability.
I think Ben is being very unreasonable-his DC have other grandparents who treat them. Your DC only have one set. Ben’s DC already get more as they do benefit from a relationship and gifts from your parents. Do Ben’s ex’s parents treat your DC to gifts and days out?

OnlyGin · 27/10/2021 09:27

Ben has offered to cover the costs. I can understand step parents not wanting cover four children but it would be polite to offer.

It's not just about money, Sally's parents would like to just spend time with their GC sometimes.

OP posts:
CrazyTimesAreOccurring · 27/10/2021 00:33

Team Sally.

Leave the GP to treat their own the way they want to. They sound kind to the others, but they didn't chose to be a blended family Ben and Sally did.

beautifullymad · 27/10/2021 00:26

You can only be responsible for your own attitudes as a blended family. You cannot expect extended family to share your views.

Grandparents cannot be expected to take on (the extra effort and cost) of extra children on days out. With the best will in the world the step children are not their grandchildren.

They are respectful and I'd courage the children to be respectful too. This might mean leaving toys from a shop at the grandparents house for a while. Or bringing a small gift home for step children after a day out.

It's entirely reasonable that all the children have a good relationship with their maternal grandparents. And by the sounds of it they do.

MargaretThursday · 26/10/2021 23:20

@OnlyGin

and b) because there’s no way that his kids would want to do this things a 2 and 4 year old would want to do

I think this is the issue because sometimes it can be things Ben's DC would probably enjoy too i.e. the zoo, aquarium, Legoland that type of stuff.

Yes but what they'd be doing at those places would be totally different.

For example: Legoland I know quite well.
When my youngest was 2yo, my oldest was 9yo. Yes I did take them all at times, but there were things my 9yo wanted to go on which my 2yo wasn't allowed on. If we only went on things my 2yo could go on, my 9yo could be seen looking enviously at the other rides. Splitting between the two meant they all felt they'd done a lot of queueing for the amount of rides they'd done.

Just try queueing for 30 minutes with a 2 and 4yo then explaining to them having queued then they now had to stand there and watch the others do it and they're not allowed to...

It's also a lot more work taking 4 children then 2. I used to find that any two of mine was much easier than taking all three. (And any one was easier than taking any two).

Bellevu · 26/10/2021 23:10

Ben is being unreasonable. Sounds like he's resenting having to parent and entertain his children instead of being able to off load cost, planning and emotional labour elsewhere

EggsellentSmithers · 26/10/2021 22:59

@OnlyGin

and b) because there’s no way that his kids would want to do this things a 2 and 4 year old would want to do

I think this is the issue because sometimes it can be things Ben's DC would probably enjoy too i.e. the zoo, aquarium, Legoland that type of stuff.

Yes but the pace of visit to places like these for the two age groups is completely different on so many levels!! So that’s still no valid as far as I’m concerned.

Are the littles actually lavished with gifts? Or are they a bit spoiled at Christmas and get a toy from the gift shop on the way home?

MoreThanAnOffDay · 26/10/2021 22:58

It's a hard one.
I have 1 dc. Dh has 1 dc. Plus 2 together my parents and dhs parents treat all of our dcs equally they're all their grandchildren in their eyes! Whether that's a day out or a 20p lollypop they'd all get the same. Ahve done from day one.
Dsd has her dms parents who spoil her too but that doesn't mean she should get less from mine or dhs parents.
Even our grandparents have treated them all the same too!

FranklySonImTheGaffer · 26/10/2021 22:54

Do Ben & Sally's dc spend any time with his eldest children's grandparents?

I think Ben is being very unreasonable to expect his ILs to look treat his children with his ex the same way they do their daughters children.
If they were excluding them when it came to Christmas etc then that would be unfair but as it is I don't think they're doing anything wrong.

Also, the dynamic is different with children that aren't related to you and that you don't have that sort of relationship with. For example, I'm more than happy to take my nieces and nephews out for the day because I can discipline them if necessary (without any issues with my sister), they know me and behave for me etc. I wouldn't agree to take some of my friends children because the relationship isn't the same - I wouldn't feel comfortable dealing with them if they misbehaved etc.

Marelle · 26/10/2021 22:53

Ben is being ridiculous. Just wait until they die and leave all their money to their own grandchildren, Ben is going to go apeshit.

Lalastepmum · 26/10/2021 22:44

You do for all or none IMO.
If this was an every other weekend arrangement then I could understand however, it is 50/50.

Could you imagine having your siblings going to Legoland and you are stuck at home. Ben has offered to cover the costs. I can understand step parents not wanting cover four children but it would be polite to offer.

Sally is in an awkward position due to it being her parents. I do appreciate that.

KimmyKimdoo · 26/10/2021 22:42

Where is Ben when Sally is at Legoland with toddlers and Grandparents?

Is he at home with the older DC? If so, why doesn’t he either come along altogether and pay for his DC, help look after all four of his children OR organise a fun day with the older two on the same day??? Possibly a mix of the two as presumably Sally would enjoy some alone time with her parents too sometimes.

OnlyGin · 26/10/2021 22:35

and b) because there’s no way that his kids would want to do this things a 2 and 4 year old would want to do

I think this is the issue because sometimes it can be things Ben's DC would probably enjoy too i.e. the zoo, aquarium, Legoland that type of stuff.

OP posts:
zoemum2006 · 26/10/2021 22:34

Well ask the older kids and see how they feel. If they aren't unhappy then it's no big deal but if they feel left out/ less important then you need to fix the situation.

waterrat · 26/10/2021 22:33

I think this is a tough and not ideal situation and should be looked at from the children's point of view not the adults.

If you choose to blend a family and make children become siblings then you need to avoid unfair situations like this ...even if that is tough for the adults to adjust to.

I feel sorry for thr kids having very different experiences in a single blended family and think steps could easily be taken to reduce the disparity

WimpoleHat · 26/10/2021 22:30

I'd be led by their feelings. (and before anyone talks about spoiling kids if you've ever had a consistently different arrangement than your sibling it can be really upsetting)

But in this situation, you have two distinct sibling groups: Ben’s two kids who are significantly older - and then two very little ones. It’s not a question of kids who all live together all the time; the older kids know that Sally’s parents are not their grandparents and have a special relationship with their own. So I’d have thought that “Little X and Y are at the zoo with their grandparents” would be most unlikely to cause major upset, especially if at Christmas etc there’s a gift for them from Sally’s parents as well.

KimmyKimdoo · 26/10/2021 22:28

@zoemum2006 it’s up to their parents to make sure their needs are met. Their Dad and their own mum should be organising fun things for them to do. Sounds as though their Dad is offloading responsibility for that onto his new wife to be honest.

I’m not suggesting they aren’t a family unit, of course they are. The thing is though - the children have different parents and that’s ok. There’s no point pretending they don’t and trying to dictate how everyone around show behave/ feel. Sally and her parents should be kind to the older dc of course, but ultimately it isn’t up to them to ensure they are taken out for fun days out.

zoemum2006 · 26/10/2021 22:25

I think the most important thing is how the older kids feel about the situation. At 9 and 11 they'll be pretty aware.

I'd be led by their feelings. (and before anyone talks about spoiling kids if you've ever had a consistently different arrangement than your sibling it can be really upsetting).

WimpoleHat · 26/10/2021 22:23

Ben is unreasonable. A) because his in laws are not the GPs of his older kids and there’s no confusion around that and b) because there’s no way that his kids would want to do this things a 2 and 4 year old would want to do. Yes, these situations need to be handled sensitively, but there’s nothing wrong with Sally’s parents taking their own grandchildren out on their own.

KimmyKimdoo · 26/10/2021 22:23

Sounds as though both Mum and Grandparents want to do nice things for the toddlers. However, MAN isn’t happy because his woman should also be providing ample fun for his other children too.

Quite frankly, if Ben wants his children to have nice outings and holidays, why doesn’t he organise anything/ take them himself?

OnlyGin · 26/10/2021 22:19

@KimmyKimdoo

I would say though, I wouldn’t allow my parents to take my DC abroad without me at those ages - would Sally want to be on those trips too?
Abroad yes Sally will likely go too
OP posts: