Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Who's unreasonable?

135 replies

OnlyGin · 26/10/2021 17:48

Ben and Sally are married and have DC together. Ben has two DC from a previous relationship as well who live with them 50% of the week.

Sally's parents are well off and like to spoil their grandchildren. They are kind to Ben's other children but don't view them as their grandchildren nor do the children think of them as their grandparents.

Sally's parents like to take her DC out regularly, buy them treats etc etc. Same with Christmas and birthdays, they get LOTS from Sally's parents. Ben's children do as well but not as much as their grandchildren.

Ben has started suggesting this is unfair. For example, this half term Sally and Ben's joint DC have been / are planning to go out to various fun amusement places with Sally's parents but Ben's other DC haven't been invited and Sally and Ben can't really afford to take them themselves, they often come back from these places with treats from the gift shop.

Ben's other children have grandparents on their mothers side who treat them the same way as Sally's parents treat her DC so Sally doesn't see the problem. She doesn't believe it's her parents responsibility to pay for all DC to go to these places and she won't make her DC miss out by saying they can't go unless they all go. She also thinks it's fine for her parents to have a unique relationship with their grandchildren especially as her step children don't see them as their grandparents anyway.

Who's unreasonable?

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
ClaryFairchild · 29/10/2021 16:31

They are not her children and they are there to see their dad, not some other children's grandparents.

They're not there every other weekend, they are there 50% of the time. Completely different scenario.

Sally IS their step-mother, and her home is also their home. I just think every now and then, Sally could bring them along as well and they could spend time with their half siblings. Not all the time, not even half the time, just some of the times, particularly if it's something they would really enjoy.

But, I can't see anywhere that Ben ever joins them? If he doesn't then why not? It would be far easier for his DC to be more a part of the extended family if he also joins in.

WimpoleHat · 28/10/2021 20:34

they are there to see their dad, not some other children's grandparents.

I hadn’t thought of the issue this way round, but it’s a very good way to think about it!

Brefugee · 28/10/2021 17:17

I think a bit of both. I think when Sally goes along then SOMETIMES she should take all 4 DC, regardless of grandparent preference, but not all the time.

Nope. They are not her children and they are there to see their dad, not some other children's grandparents.

FlowerArranger · 28/10/2021 17:03

I mostly agree with @smoko, especially this:

There is nothing wrong with Sally’s folks wanting to just spend time with their grandchildren either.
Ben is being unreasonable to try to force them to create false intimacy of a grandparent/kid relationship that isn’t authentic

Except this:

If I were Sally & her folks would be saying a hard no to hosting in future - Ben’s attitude that he is owed childcare duties & automatic bonus grandparents would have put me off wanting to accomodate his requests & made me feel less like seeing his children.

Yes, Ben seems somewhat entitled, but I wouldn't want to see his children punished for his attitude. I think Sally's parents have the balance right as they seem to include Ben's kids in many activities. And the older kids seem accepting of the current situation, which isn't surpriding, given the age difference and the fact that their maternal GPs seem to be very caring and involved.

I'm a grandmother and it isn't always easy to be involved without risking overstepping boundaries or otherwise doing 'the wrong thing'. But if my GD's mum were to have more children with amother man, there is no way I could feel the same way about them. It would simply feel forced.

HotSauceCommittee · 28/10/2021 16:41

Ben sounds very entitled and a bit of a dick. He should not be bulking Sally into harassing her parents to take on his children too.
What did he think would happen when he went on to have two more children with a different woman?
Have you lost respect for him yet, OP, or does he have you so beaten down that you are questioning yourself?

OnlyGin · 28/10/2021 16:40

@Justheretoaskaquestion91

How long have sally and Ben been together?
5 years.
OP posts:
smoko · 28/10/2021 16:28

There is nothing wrong with Sally’s folks wanting to just spend time with their grandchildren either.

Ben is being unreasonable to try to force them to create false intimacy of a grandparent/kid relationship that isn’t authentic

Ben should be mindful that encouraging a forced relationship could lead to disappointment if he & Sally break up one day, as his children at well mourn the loss of 2 people who don’t actually feel that connection with them

Ben should make more of an effort to treat his children so that when they complain he can point out the treats they get.

Is Ben wanting to offload his kids onto Sally’s folks to avoid parental responsibilities?

Why when it’s his time with them is he wanting them sent away? His kids have come to see him, that’s what his time with them is for.

If I were Sally & her folks would be saying a hard no to hosting in future - Ben’s attitude that he is owed childcare duties & automatic bonus grandparents would have put me off wanting to accomodate his requests & made me feel less like seeing his children.

AryaStarkWolf · 28/10/2021 16:22

Ben is

OnlyGin · 28/10/2021 16:15

@TheDivineOddity

How many seats does the grandparent's car have? If it's a regular five seater then there won't be room in the car for the older DC on the days out anyway.
To be fair, there is room if they went in Sally's car (which they sometimes do).

To answer the question about where Ben is, a lot of the time he's home if it's in the school holidays, but sometimes he has to arrange other childcare through the holidays if he's working or before/after school clubs in school time.

OP posts:
TheDivineOddity · 28/10/2021 07:06

How many seats does the grandparent's car have?
If it's a regular five seater then there won't be room in the car for the older DC on the days out anyway.

Justheretoaskaquestion91 · 28/10/2021 07:01

How long have sally and Ben been together?

Hydrate · 28/10/2021 06:50

I think Ben is being unreasonable. Sally's parents are not obligated to include the step-children, it is pushy of him to be asking. I feel embarrassed for Sally.

smoko · 28/10/2021 06:44

Ben is being a dickhead & trying to use Sally’s parents to make up for his own parents’ lack of interest.

Ben should offer to help pay for his children to go along if he wants them included

Sally’s parents are not a bank or free babysitters.

Ben is too concerned with what’s “fair” when the children could get equal amount of treats, if he wants to pay & organise it

ClaryFairchild · 28/10/2021 06:36

I think a bit of both. I think when Sally goes along then SOMETIMES she should take all 4 DC, regardless of grandparent preference, but not all the time.

I don't think it needs to be completely either/or.

ejhhhhh · 28/10/2021 06:08

Having read more of the OP's updates, it seems like Ben is hankering after the childcare, given that Sally sometimes goes out with her DC and parents. The obvious course of action is for Ben to take his own DC out to do something fun when the grandparents (+/- Sally) are taking Sally's children out. It's his responsibility to entertain them, not Sally's or her parents'. It's does comes across a bit like he can't be arsed to do that, and he's making out that it's about fairness an excuse. He's offered to pay, so it's 💯 not about cost, that's just a convenient excuse when it suits him! In the example that you gave, when Sally's parents and DC go somewhere like Legoland, and he's offered to pay, why on earth doesn't he just take them himself? It would be a better day for all the kids if he did that, but it's not better for Ben of course if he wants a day off. This isn't about them, it's about Ben, and what he wants! Definitely don't capitulate to this OP. Does he shirk his domestic responsibilities/is a selfish prick in other ways?

Brefugee · 27/10/2021 22:32

Sally's parents are under zero obligation to run their lives in keeping with the schedule of children that aren't related to them.

Hesma · 27/10/2021 22:05

Sally’s parents should organise these trips when Ben’s DC are with mum. Otherwise they are simply rubbing their noses in it which is quite unkind

funinthesun19 · 27/10/2021 13:23

What would be your perspective if it was your dc who were the second class kids in the family?

Hmmm. “Second class” because they don’t get absolutely everything from absolutely everybody. Hmm

Did you miss the bit where they have their own maternal grandparents to receive lovely things from and do lovely things with?

Did you miss the bit where there is an age gap? Why should Sally’s parents adapt their young-child centred days out for a 9 and 11 year old? Just for the sake of “fairness”? It will inevitably turn in to a day all about the older ones as they can speak up more than younger children. Sally’s children shouldn’t have to share their grandparents with older half siblings who have plenty of opportunities with other people.

thevassal · 27/10/2021 12:36

Oh and having just seen the ages can't imagine there are many days out an 11year old would enjoy as much as a 2 year old anyway!

thevassal · 27/10/2021 12:35

Agree Ben is being unreasonable. If Sally's parents did start to treat them all the same, would he then stop his children from previous relationship from going on holidays with their maternal grandparents, not bringing toys to the shared house their mother's parents bought them, insisting on any inheritance being shared jointly, etc. Because if he didn't then Sally's kids would be the one disadvantaged.

Agree that if Sally's parents are taking their biological grandkids out then that's the perfect opportunity for Ben to spend individual time with his own kids.

ErickBroch · 27/10/2021 12:13

I don't think parents are BU but I do think both parents need to manage the 'lavish gifts' better. Ensure it's not being rubbed in the faces of the other kids.

Brefugee · 27/10/2021 12:06

Step-grandparents is a weird thing though and it should be entirely up to them how they handle the relationship.

When Sally's parents, and Sally are taking Ben's children out where is he? The contact time is for their relationship, not to build something with Step-grandparents.

It does seem mean, but it is a fact of life. If my Daughter had a partner with children there is no way on earth they would automatically become my new grandchildren. They have their own family.

Motherland101 · 27/10/2021 12:06

@beautifullymad

You can only be responsible for your own attitudes as a blended family. You cannot expect extended family to share your views.

Grandparents cannot be expected to take on (the extra effort and cost) of extra children on days out. With the best will in the world the step children are not their grandchildren.

They are respectful and I'd courage the children to be respectful too. This might mean leaving toys from a shop at the grandparents house for a while. Or bringing a small gift home for step children after a day out.

It's entirely reasonable that all the children have a good relationship with their maternal grandparents. And by the sounds of it they do.

Very well put 👏🏻
AndSoFinally · 27/10/2021 11:57

You haven't answered the question about what Ben is doing when his 2 youngest are out? If he wants his older two to come, can he not facilitate this by coming along himself? Or taking the two oldest to something more appropriate while the youngest are with GPs so there's no bad feeling?

I think the fact that the ages are so wildly different gives Sally a bit of a get out card. It would be harder to justify leaving them if they were similar ages, but even if all four were Sally's children, a day out for children ranged between 11 and 2 would be hard to manage without splitting the kids on the day so all could do what they wanted eg rides at Legoland. The GPs can't be expected to do this

Cotswoldmama · 27/10/2021 11:43

I think it's fine as long as Sally's patents aren't taking the grandkids out whilst step grandkids are there for their 50% of the week. I think it's mean to take two out and essentially leave two at home.