Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Stop teaching child that it’s okay to refer to someone’s skin colour

707 replies

CannotThinkOfName · 26/10/2021 17:39

Calling someone - a random person you don’t know - black is racist. I don’t care if your personal friend or your family member or someone else you’re close to doesn’t mind being referred to like this because they’re speaking for themselves as individuals.

Pointing out someone by skin colour is rude at best and at worst a form of racism. This is because

  1. Skin colour that I was born with is brown.
  2. Skin colour that I was born with does not define anyone. It doesn’t define your traits, characteristics, hobbies, goals, ambitions or anything else that truly defines who a person is.
  3. It’s a form of racial harassment to start bothering someone at random and bringing up their race and colour for no real reason and singling them out by it.

I’ve seen people say there’s nothing wrong with their child referring to people by skin because they are just “saying what they see”. This is wrong because as a child, I never ever saw myself as “black” or described myself “black”. This is taught as a way to refer to people, it’s not simply a child “saying what they see”.

Please stop teaching your child that it’s okay to refer to people that you don’t know this way. If you do know someone and they’ve told you to call them black then that’s their choice as an individual. They don’t speak for anyone else but themselves.

If you don’t know someone’s name, - just ask them what their name is and call them by their actual name. Not “that black girl” or “the black woman” or “that black lady”.

OP posts:
3scape · 27/10/2021 15:00

OP you as an individual of course get to be treated as such and can assert that in interpersonal situations but you as an individual are also in this thread using "we" as though you are part of a group of people. What would your group be comfortable with? Are you certain you speak for the whole of this group? What is this group? The problem with using any "catch all" term is that it is vague and doesn't suit everyone. It's all very well you saying black isn't appropriate but some people within that group that you choose to decide you are in have disagreed with you. Just as I know some people are more fine with being called white than others. But plenty of people will tick other or prefer not to say. If presented with an option. General terms take a very long time to be overthrown, as is clear during the half hearted efforts made by the media and schools for black history.

geesearego · 27/10/2021 14:51

I've had several conversations were I've been told "we are all Irish on Paddy's day"
What, no. I like the Irish fine but I'm definitely still Scottish.
@Cameleongirl

Americans like a range of heritages but seem to be particularly fond of clinging to Irish ones.

Cameleongirl · 27/10/2021 14:43

@geesearego

It has taken a while as an immigrant to the USA to realize that Asian here doesn't mean what it does in the UK. The default settings of Asian without any further identifiers are completely different groups of people.
@geesearego. I remember someone telling me at a conference that he was Irish. I asked where he was from in Ireland…then I discovered that he was talking about his heritage, I think his great grandparents had emigrated from Ireland to the US!
jcyclops · 27/10/2021 14:34

If referring to someone without malice by their skin colour is racist, then approaching 100% of humans are racist, and I feel I can no longer condemn racists with opprobrium. Racist just becomes a synonym for human.

geesearego · 27/10/2021 14:25

It has taken a while as an immigrant to the USA to realize that Asian here doesn't mean what it does in the UK.
The default settings of Asian without any further identifiers are completely different groups of people.

Cameleongirl · 27/10/2021 14:14

[quote Brefugee]**@NameChangeNamaste i find it really fascinating how race/ethinc origin is handled in the States. So people will very happily describe themselves as African American, Irish American, German American and so on. It's an up-front "yeah - my roots are elsewhere" which not entirely unexpected in a country which has historically had a lot of immigration.

Also the use of Asian, IIRC, tends to mean what in the UK we'd be more likely to call east Asian, and they use south Asian where in the UK they'd say Asian.

It's all a matter of perspective, and familiarity i guess. There is definitely a lot to think about when conversations like this crop up, and it's often a very interesting and educating process. One thing is always clear though: context is important, and things change constantly.[/quote]
@NameChangeNamaste. That’s interesting. Where I’m living in the US, I think South East Asian, rather than Indian, might be used to describe you if someone was trying to point you out in a group,

I know from friends who’ve emigrated from India that their children born in the US can’t hold dual American/Indian citizenship. Calling them Indian is therefore technically inaccurate, it really is complicated!😂

Most people who identify as Italian Americans, German Americans are likely blends of various European heritages as well, like my DH. They choose to identify with one nationality more than the others. It’s such a melting pot here.

AledsiPad · 27/10/2021 13:58

This right here, this thread, is why people have stopped listening, OP.

SrownBkinGirl · 27/10/2021 13:56

You are black.. are you ashamed of it?

I know this was to the OP but again, this is a tired line and people keep trotting it out.

What is there to be ashamed and why is it the main thing that comes to mind when people say this? What does it mean to be Black and can you pinpoint, from that, what the OP is supposed to be ashamed of? Is it culture - which Black culture, and has OP said they're ashamed of that culture? Is it skin colour - has OP said they hate their colour? Is it other Black people - has OP said they don't like to be seen with others?

If you wanting to argue about people being ashamed, I'd say those who try to change their skin colour (whether darken or lighten), hair texture/length, nose, lips, cheekbones, etc are more ashamed of what they have and not happy with parts of who they are. Not someone whose only gripe is not liking a label given to them and hasn't said or shown that they don't like where they're from or any part of themselves.

CuntyMcBollocks · 27/10/2021 13:55

I don't see how using a person's colour of their skin as a descriptive term is racist. It would be ageist by that logic to describe someone as elderly/a child/teenager etc. It doesn't make sense. It's all about context.

Eilatan2018 · 27/10/2021 13:40

You need to get a grip. You are black.. are you ashamed of it? Of course race is a thing. Why is it ok to say someone is blonde then? If you need to describe someone visually and there’s a white woman with dark hair and a black woman with dark hair, but it’s the white woman you’re trying to describe… surely you can call them white to differentiate them?

SrownBkinGirl · 27/10/2021 13:20

I've seen people say something like 'if race isn't real, then racism isn't real'.

I don't think it's as easy as that.

Race (black, white red, yellow, as it were) is a concept or label based on the (inaccurate) skin colour and general phenotype of people of/within a geographical or ancestral location.

I'd say it's one of the ways people lump each other together. We can't help it as humans to put everything in box.

Racism is just using this concept to express ignorance or hatred, as well as insecurity or superiority and all other things humans do. If there was no such thing as race, people would still express ignorance, superiority, insecurity and hatred in other ways (and they do. This is one of the ways). That's the essence of racism and it doesn't need to be called 'racism' to exist or be pointed out or solved. Not that it shouldn't, it just doesn't have to be, if that's what's keeping some people away.

That people don't want to be seen as a 'race', based on the superficial criteria, doesn't stop those opinions and behaviours from being present, perpetrated and tackled.

So call it racism or not, that is real.

If anything, it may be better to break it down so that when someone is accused/accuses someone else of racism, they're clear on what exactly they're being accused/accusing someone of, and aren't lumping ignorance, for example, with hatred or abusive actions, etc.

WhatATimeToBeAlive · 27/10/2021 12:44

Just when I thought the world couldn't be any more bonkers, I come across this thread. Give me strength. YABVU.

YouJustFoldItIn · 27/10/2021 12:23

“I do not think that referring to someone's skin colour is racist”.

It’s racist. It’s just that it’s a form of racism that has been normalised. People need to quit it.

Race is a made up thing.

Does that mean that White Privilege is either a completely imagined thing, or a very real but racist concept?

MolyHolyGuacamole · 27/10/2021 12:06

Okay I'll give you a real life example. We constantly have parties for Africans and you will have white guests. If no one knows your name, and they need to describe you, your race will come up! Are we racist?

Going around in circles. My point that it is not a regular occurrence for the majority of people still stands. You may 'constantly have parties for Africans' but it's not the norm. There's no point bringing up a 'what if' scenario, it doesn't change my point and the point that others have made, that in the UK, white is the default.

And as I've said before, context is everything.

mustlovegin · 27/10/2021 12:00

Race isn't based on genetics but phenotype in a very loose sense

Phenotype is determined by genetics though. So race (as in black or white, for instance which may cover many different ethnicities) may be too broad a concept but is still determined by genetics

Keke94LND · 27/10/2021 11:25

[quote QuizzlyBear]@Keke94LND - that's very odd, I'm also not Russian but was given a Russian nickname by friends when I lived in Tottenham.

Maybe I was just THAT pale that I looked as though I was from Siberia? Never seen sun?! It never occurred to me to feel offended, I agreed that I could do with some sun (I still could...) [/quote]
Haha are you blonde? I have blonde hair and assumed maybe that's why I was called the Russian girl 🤷🏼‍♀️

QuizzlyBear · 27/10/2021 11:23

@Keke94LND - that's very odd, I'm also not Russian but was given a Russian nickname by friends when I lived in Tottenham.

Maybe I was just THAT pale that I looked as though I was from Siberia? Never seen sun?! It never occurred to me to feel offended, I agreed that I could do with some sun (I still could...)

MintyCedric · 27/10/2021 11:22

Surely it's contextual?

My current home town is becoming rapidly more diverse, but if I was in room of people I didn't know and had to identify someone that happened to be a person of colour I would probably refer to them as black as it would be the quickest and most effective way to identify them.

If I went back to my birth city, which is much more diverse, I'd be just as likely to have to point out 'the white guy over there'.

Surely we just automatically default to the most obvious physical feature in situations like this?

In my case it would be the fat, middle-aged, blonde woman. Not particularly keen on that description but it's factually accurate and would identify me quickly.

Smallkeys · 27/10/2021 11:21

Sorry loads of typos. I am even worried now to ask someone with an accent where they are from in case of offense.

Smallkeys · 27/10/2021 11:19

I try not to to refer to race at all just in case of offending.,white has used as a catch all for anyone not another colour regardless of where they originated from. I’m old enough to remember that Asian wasn’t used it was Pakistani or Pali, the paki shop on the corner. I don’t remember our Pakistani neighbours being offended . What offended them were then yobs breaking their windows based on their ethnicity and occasionally they missed and got ours. That was racist. Then coloured was the accepted term in the Uk and that seemed reasonable at the time due to all the colours people can be. My understanding is we now use Black as a catch all because overall this is the term that
Most black people are happy and proud to use. The OP finds it offensive and am sure others might be offended too so I’m those individual circumstances people that know you would respect your views. There’s no denying it’s an absolute minefield but things change and they are changing for the better and happily faster than ever before.

BubbleCoffee · 27/10/2021 11:17

It's not always possible to know someone's specific ancestry just by looking at a person*
*
Yes. If I was asking someone to find my friend quickly in a noisy crowd, I'm not sure it would help to say 'look out for the Scottish/Icelandic/South African/German woman'.

Keke94LND · 27/10/2021 11:15

@QuizzlyBear

I lived for years in Tottenham in the 90s. I was frequently the only white person in the shop / room / bus. People often referred to me as 'the white girl' - not through disrespect but because it was a very obvious differentiator.

When I worked in offices in central London my best work friend was a lawyer in our firm. One day we had a temp receptionist and I stopped by to ask if my friend X was in the office. The receptionist didn't know her name and asked what she looked like. I absolutely blanked on what to say because both the receptionist and my friend were black. I stuttered 'she's this tall, dark hair, dark eyes, office down the hall, mum of two...'

The receptionist just stared at me as though I'd lost my mind. 'The black lady?' she asked. In fairness she then took the piss out of me relentlessly for the next month, as did my friend - the ONLY black lawyer in the firm....

This happened to me when I lived in an area with few white people, I was 'the white girl' or 'the Russian girl' (I'm not Russian so dunno why I was called that lol )
TableFlowerss · 27/10/2021 11:15

This thread is crackers.

If you’re of that disposition, then you’ll find offence in anything. Some people look for offence in everything, whether it be race, gender, sex and so on….

Sometimes people can’t win. Some people interpret someone specifically not using colour to describe a person (in a non racist situation) as racist, as they’re proud to call themselves black.

The next person doesn’t want to be referred to as black and asks why Asian people aren’t described as black but those from African descent are….

People can not win at all. You can’t please everyone all the time and what one person finds offensive, the next person finds it insulting that the first person finds it offensive. 🤯

Of course there are times when the colour of someone’s skin is irrelevant and there are racist undertones, but most people want to do the right thing and don’t want to offend people!

NerrSnerr · 27/10/2021 11:13

This thread reminded me of this comedy routine- about 3 minutes in.

Keke94LND · 27/10/2021 11:05

It depends on the context surely, if I'm having an argument with someone who is black, and I use the fact that they are black as an insult, such as saying 'you black bitch' or something like that (which I've seen happen before btw) then yes that is racist. But if someone is describing someone else, and they say 'they are black' that's not racist, it's descriptive, like saying 'they are white' (also white people aren't actually white, we are all shades of brown, some darker and some lighter)