Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Stop teaching child that it’s okay to refer to someone’s skin colour

707 replies

CannotThinkOfName · 26/10/2021 17:39

Calling someone - a random person you don’t know - black is racist. I don’t care if your personal friend or your family member or someone else you’re close to doesn’t mind being referred to like this because they’re speaking for themselves as individuals.

Pointing out someone by skin colour is rude at best and at worst a form of racism. This is because

  1. Skin colour that I was born with is brown.
  2. Skin colour that I was born with does not define anyone. It doesn’t define your traits, characteristics, hobbies, goals, ambitions or anything else that truly defines who a person is.
  3. It’s a form of racial harassment to start bothering someone at random and bringing up their race and colour for no real reason and singling them out by it.

I’ve seen people say there’s nothing wrong with their child referring to people by skin because they are just “saying what they see”. This is wrong because as a child, I never ever saw myself as “black” or described myself “black”. This is taught as a way to refer to people, it’s not simply a child “saying what they see”.

Please stop teaching your child that it’s okay to refer to people that you don’t know this way. If you do know someone and they’ve told you to call them black then that’s their choice as an individual. They don’t speak for anyone else but themselves.

If you don’t know someone’s name, - just ask them what their name is and call them by their actual name. Not “that black girl” or “the black woman” or “that black lady”.

OP posts:
CannotThinkOfName · 26/10/2021 19:12

@SickAndTiredAgain

I don’t think I’ve ever heard anyone teaching their kids to call people “the white man”. Race is only acceptable to mention, from what I’ve seen in real life if you’re pointing out that someone is black. I’ve never heard people point out someone is white before. Could be just me though.

I’m not sure that’s always true. Generally speaking I do agree that race is mentioned when the race isn’t white but as a descriptor of one person amongst a group of people then whatever is distinguishing is referenced.

For example, if you say to someone “you need to speak to Dave, he’s over there.”
And the person says “which one is Dave” your reply will depend if what distinguishes Dave. If Dave was the only black person in the group, you’d say that, but if he was the only white person, you’d say that too. Or if he was the only one sitting down, or the only one with a beard, or the only one holding a cup of coffee. When you’re describing one person out of a group, you use the thing that will distinguish them, in group of people where half were black and half were white, you wouldn’t describe Dave using his race, whatever it was. But if it was a group of men, similar ages, all in shirts and ties all standing round in a group, and all were white except Dave (or all black except Dave), it would be unusual to come up with another descriptor - “oh Dave? He’s the umm third tallest guy over there”

Exactly. If you’re a “black lady”, then that’s all you are, ethnicity or nationality apparently don’t exist for “black ladies” but it does exist for Chinese, Spanish and Indian ladies.

Is that better? Because I’d hazard a guess that plenty of people described as “Chinese” based on looks alone are in fact not Chinese at all. Or even have Chinese ancestry. And they quite possibly don’t appreciate the many countries in East Asia all being seen as “Chinese.”

But to me and others, we’re not black at all but if it’s fine to refer to random people as black if you don’t know if that’s how they consider themselves, then it should be fine for you to call random East Asians you meet Chinese, even if you don’t know whether they consider themselves Chinese or not. It’s the same thing.
OP posts:
AccidentallyOnPurpose · 26/10/2021 19:12

Exactly. If you’re a “black lady”, then that’s all you are, ethnicity or nationality apparently don’t exist for “black ladies” but it does exist for Chinese, Spanish and Indian ladies.

Except Chinese can and is used for people from Japan, Philippines, Korea etc.

That Indian lady? She's just as likely to be from Bangladesh, Pakistan etc.

Spanish? South American (with it's many countries) or Greek, Turkish, Portuguese etc.

Add in Eastern European .

The majority of people that use those terms about someone they don't know , generalise just as much as using black.

EchoNan · 26/10/2021 19:11

@AccidentallyOnPurpose

I'll be honest, this thread will eventually get full of comments from racist posters ,end up in a bun fight and get very upsetting for the people OP is trying to "protect". It always ends that way . So one might wonder if she really is that naive.
It's a dog whistle racism thread. It's purely here to goad, like the pp who got brave enough whinge about "Black Lives Matter" We see them for what they are.
shylatte · 26/10/2021 19:11

Race and terms can be such a minefield, and I think so many people are afraid of saying the wrong thing. My dps think that Black is politically incorrect, and that "you aren't allowed to say that!". I have no idea where that came from but they would say 100 descriptions about someone before saying Black.
I was trying to educate myself so started following Black women on social media (as they were talking about issues pertinent to race) and one of them described herself as WOC. I started using that, but when I commented on another (Black) woman's page using WOC she jumped down my throat, saying that it was lazy and racist as I was lumping together all non white women. I was totally mortified, so avoid saying anything in fear of offending someone.

SrownBkinGirl · 26/10/2021 19:10

@MenimeMay

except there's no nationality called Black. It's obvious where the Chinese, Indian and Spanish ladies are from. What about the Black lady?

Are we confusing ethnicity and nationality though? Someone could have a Spanish nationality but be any ethnicity. I know someone who was born and raised in Nigeria, they are Nigerian by nationality, but they are "white".

No we're not. Are you? Chinese, Spanish and Indian are all nationalities. Black lady can be of British, Chinese, Jamaican, American, Nigerian, Ghanian or Kenyan nationality. Where is her nationality? Why mix nationality and race? That's all I'm saying.
MilkywayMonarch22 · 26/10/2021 19:09

I agree that black and white are inaccurate as no one is actually black or white, and they are terms that are rooted in racism. Black being bad (e'g blacklisted, black magic, blackmail) and white being good (white lie, fairest of them all etc) but I think it's very difficult to not refer to someone's ethnicity when pointing them out, same with disability/sex/dress style etc.

Also agree that race is a construct as it's been proven many a time we are all one race with tiny genetic differences to change our skin/hair/eye colour and features. Language is outdated for the most part ...

I refer to myself as mixed ethnicity. However I agree that sometimes someone pointing out skin colour can be hostile and racist, for example the age old question we always get 'But where are you really from?'

Context and intent as a PP said...

CannotThinkOfName · 26/10/2021 19:09

@Crankley

A question for the OP.

You're in a room with tnineteen other women, all black except one white woman, all are wearing an identical dress, all have black hair, similar style and brown eyes, all similar height and weight.

Someone asks you to verbally describe the one white woman in the room. How will you do that without describing her as white and when you do, are you being racist?

I’ve never been in this situation before. Genuinely, I’ve never faced a scenario where I was forced to bring up someone’s race, I can’t imagine where some people here live if this it happens regularly that you have no other way of describing someone and race is the only thing you can use.

Besides, my op wasn’t talking about pointing someone out of a crowd.

OP posts:
SickAndTiredAgain · 26/10/2021 19:08

I don’t think I’ve ever heard anyone teaching their kids to call people “the white man”. Race is only acceptable to mention, from what I’ve seen in real life if you’re pointing out that someone is black. I’ve never heard people point out someone is white before. Could be just me though.

I’m not sure that’s always true. Generally speaking I do agree that race is mentioned when the race isn’t white but as a descriptor of one person amongst a group of people then whatever is distinguishing is referenced.

For example, if you say to someone “you need to speak to Dave, he’s over there.”
And the person says “which one is Dave” your reply will depend if what distinguishes Dave. If Dave was the only black person in the group, you’d say that, but if he was the only white person, you’d say that too. Or if he was the only one sitting down, or the only one with a beard, or the only one holding a cup of coffee. When you’re describing one person out of a group, you use the thing that will distinguish them, in group of people where half were black and half were white, you wouldn’t describe Dave using his race, whatever it was. But if it was a group of men, similar ages, all in shirts and ties all standing round in a group, and all were white except Dave (or all black except Dave), it would be unusual to come up with another descriptor - “oh Dave? He’s the umm third tallest guy over there”

Exactly. If you’re a “black lady”, then that’s all you are, ethnicity or nationality apparently don’t exist for “black ladies” but it does exist for Chinese, Spanish and Indian ladies.

Is that better? Because I’d hazard a guess that plenty of people described as “Chinese” based on looks alone are in fact not Chinese at all. Or even have Chinese ancestry. And they quite possibly don’t appreciate the many countries in East Asia all being seen as “Chinese.”

Buttercup54321 · 26/10/2021 19:07

Well I passed a group of boys earlier playing football. The goalie missed and was referred to as the fat, white kid with ginger hair. Several of the boys were not white.
Were they racist??

Marelle · 26/10/2021 19:07

Honestly the poster who said skin colour isn’t genetic is insane. It’s hereditary, of course it’s genetic. Otherwise how do you explain black parents having black kids and white parents having white kids?!

imlostandfussy · 26/10/2021 19:07

This is absolutely ridiculous. What a world we live in nowadaysHmm

AccidentallyOnPurpose · 26/10/2021 19:07

I'll be honest, this thread will eventually get full of comments from racist posters ,end up in a bun fight and get very upsetting for the people OP is trying to "protect". It always ends that way . So one might wonder if she really is that naive.

SrownBkinGirl · 26/10/2021 19:06

so far I've not come across one black person who had an issue with being referred to as black.

I don't agree with the OP that calling someone black is racist but I've seen a few people say this quote. There are, in fact, Black people who'd rather not be called Black and since the OP says she's black (no reason to doubt or troll hunt), then I believe you've seen one today.

ZingDramaQueenOfSheeba · 26/10/2021 19:06

I wonder what you think about women of colour referring to themselves as women of colour.

Do you think they are racist for calling themselves whatever they are comfortable with?
On whose behalf are you so offended?

InNeedOfaHobby · 26/10/2021 19:06

How do you describe a description of someone unknown to you in an emergency?

Cameleongirl · 26/10/2021 19:05

If you’re a “black lady”, then that’s all you are, ethnicity or nationality apparently don’t exist for “black ladies” but it does exist for Chinese, Spanish and Indian ladies.

Genuine question - what if people are all the same nationality, but of different ethnic backgrounds? We live in a very diverse American city, but most people are American-born (unless they're immigrants like me). Are you comfortable with terms like African-American or Asian-American? White people here aren't referred to as European-American, just white.

thepeopleversuswork · 26/10/2021 19:04

@Goldbar

Around here (London), 'black' would be a fairly poor identifier in many cases.

I imagine for people who live in areas of the county where it's a good identifier, it must get very wearing always to be referred to as the 'black' one. "Oh, this is Louise, she likes gardening", "Oh, Sam is the one who's a lawyer".
"Oh Anna, she's the black one".

It's a good point.

Being black in a part of a large town or city with a significant black population is a very different experience from being the only black person in a town.

Which is partly why BAME people understandably struggle with rural places, which which I don't blame them at all. I'm white and the whiteness in the British countryside is one of the main reasons I'd never move there.

YouJustFoldItIn · 26/10/2021 19:03

3. It’s a form of racial harassment to start bothering someone at random and bringing up their race and colour for no real reason and singling them out by it.

Yes. No argument from most people there I imagine.

Calling someone - a random person you don’t know - black is racist.

Well I respectfully disagree but you are entitled to that opinion.

You say you have brown skin. I have pinky beige skin, also known as white.

If I were the opposite side of the room from you and everyone else in the room but me was brown skinned, how would you refer to me, should you be required to?

MenimeMay · 26/10/2021 19:03

except there's no nationality called Black. It's obvious where the Chinese, Indian and Spanish ladies are from. What about the Black lady?

Are we confusing ethnicity and nationality though? Someone could have a Spanish nationality but be any ethnicity. I know someone who was born and raised in Nigeria, they are Nigerian by nationality, but they are "white".

Fetchthevet · 26/10/2021 19:02

But isn't the intention / circumstance the most important thing? I am not rascist and I call black people black. I'm in my 40s. I have been taught that it is ok to say black people, so that's what I say. My intention is not rascist.

EchoNan · 26/10/2021 19:01

@DecadentlyDecisive

Given that all I seem to get rammed down by my throat these days is -

"Black Lives Matter" or
"Black males are unfairly targeted by stop & search" or
"BBC boss offers to meet black executive after claims he was blocked from job"

It's not unreasonable for me to refer to Black people as Black.

Rammed down your throat? Really? Your arseholery is showing.
AccidentallyOnPurpose · 26/10/2021 19:00

@Goldbar

Around here (London), 'black' would be a fairly poor identifier in many cases.

I imagine for people who live in areas of the county where it's a good identifier, it must get very wearing always to be referred to as the 'black' one. "Oh, this is Louise, she likes gardening", "Oh, Sam is the one who's a lawyer".
"Oh Anna, she's the black one".

I've never used it or heard it used in that context. If someone you know is jumping from hobbies/jobs to simply black, then you have bigger issues with them than the fact the use the word black.
CannotThinkOfName · 26/10/2021 19:00

@liveforsummer

My black ex and his mates always used to laugh at how (white) people will in a really long winded way, try so hard to describe someone without using their skin colour, when by just saying the skin colour would have identified them immediately. It was a long standing joke so your view is not held by everyone.
I acknowledged in my OP that people might have friends or family or S.O. who tell them it’s okay to refer to them as black.

It doesn’t change the fact that black is a term that was imposed on people of African descent (who are actually brown in skin tone) and it became accepted, mainly because of Americans and African Americans don’t know their specific ethnicity. People here tend to follow a lot of what Americans do so as soon as African Americans became black, so did everyone else of African descent, whether they wanted to be called black or not.

Strangely, Indians, Arabs and other Asians can also be brown and very dark skinned yet it’s never acceptable to refer to them as black, only people at some kind of African descent can be referred to as such.

Random, mildly connected point: I know Americans who thought Nadiya Hussain was black and couldn’t believe she was Asian because of her skin colour.

OP posts:
ZingDramaQueenOfSheeba · 26/10/2021 19:00

oh dear

are you white?
so far I've not come across one black person who had an issue with being referred to as black.

facts are not the problem. you are being ridiculous

SrownBkinGirl · 26/10/2021 18:59

@Goldbar Noticed that in Harry Potter. Angelina Johnson was always 'the black girl'. Nothing else. Everyone else had more adjectives to describe them.