Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Stop teaching child that it’s okay to refer to someone’s skin colour

707 replies

CannotThinkOfName · 26/10/2021 17:39

Calling someone - a random person you don’t know - black is racist. I don’t care if your personal friend or your family member or someone else you’re close to doesn’t mind being referred to like this because they’re speaking for themselves as individuals.

Pointing out someone by skin colour is rude at best and at worst a form of racism. This is because

  1. Skin colour that I was born with is brown.
  2. Skin colour that I was born with does not define anyone. It doesn’t define your traits, characteristics, hobbies, goals, ambitions or anything else that truly defines who a person is.
  3. It’s a form of racial harassment to start bothering someone at random and bringing up their race and colour for no real reason and singling them out by it.

I’ve seen people say there’s nothing wrong with their child referring to people by skin because they are just “saying what they see”. This is wrong because as a child, I never ever saw myself as “black” or described myself “black”. This is taught as a way to refer to people, it’s not simply a child “saying what they see”.

Please stop teaching your child that it’s okay to refer to people that you don’t know this way. If you do know someone and they’ve told you to call them black then that’s their choice as an individual. They don’t speak for anyone else but themselves.

If you don’t know someone’s name, - just ask them what their name is and call them by their actual name. Not “that black girl” or “the black woman” or “that black lady”.

OP posts:
Elisheva · 26/10/2021 19:32

If I’ve understood correctly I think you mean that describing someone as black is or can be offensive because it is a constructed term, and not actually describing their skin colour.
So in the situations mention above would it be appropriate to describe people as ‘The lady over there with brown skin’? rather than ‘the black lady’, as one is a description and one is a label?

Puzzledandpissedoff · 26/10/2021 19:32

It's obvious where the Chinese, Indian and Spanish ladies are from

Is it?

Show me someone who insists they can always and reliably distinguish an Indian from a Pakistani, a Chinese from a Korean and a Spaniard from a Portuguese and I'll show you someone who's almost certainly lying

Madwife123 · 26/10/2021 19:32

@CannotThinkOfName What would YOU like us to tell our children to use then?

When they innocently ask why does that person have a different colour face then me etc.

Children use innocent descriptive terms that can in fact be offensive unknowingly. Would you prefer to leave children using offensive words inadvertently or give them a widely accepted word to use such as black?

Or do you expect me to stop ever non white person we ever meet in the street to ask them what description they would like and expect my child to remember all of these?

Morgan12 · 26/10/2021 19:31

In my DS class there are two boys with the same name. One is black and one is white. They are described that way. It's really not racist at all. It's just a description.

FirewomanSam · 26/10/2021 19:31

Interesting thread, OP.

I’m white. The other day a friend was talking to me about an actor in a TV show. She described him based on a storyline that happens to him in that show (‘he’s the one who…’) and I immediately said ‘oh yeah, the black guy’. Then I wondered why I’d said that. I knew who she meant from her description and I know I wouldn’t have felt any need to say ‘oh yeah, the white guy’ if it had been any other character. It just highlighted to me how in my head ‘white’ still is a default and anything else needs to be commented on.

I do think there are times when skin colour needs to be part of a description, like when reporting someone missing or describing a suspect to the police, and I’m not sure how you can do that without saying ‘black’ unless you substitute in something equally contentious. But I do notice that in my predominantly-white social circle and indeed in wider society, ‘black’ regularly gets used to describe people where ‘white’ would be assumed as a default and never mentioned, and I think that’s very telling.

fulanigirl · 26/10/2021 19:29

@CannotThinkOfName are you seriously comparing the term black to b*tch? I actually find that really offensive. Why are you so offended with the term black? I'm black and I would question anyone that refuses to acknowledge that! Do you have an issue with who you are?

CannotThinkOfName · 26/10/2021 19:27

@SrownBkinGirl

Children do say what they see and would typically say brown or dark (or variations of it) unless the person's skin colour is dark enough that the child actually sees black (the colour, not the race) or the child sees anything darker than tan as black (again, the colour, not the race) or the child is colour-blind and any brown skin looks black to them. In that case, they'd say black. I think it isn't racist to use skin colour that way as a descriptor. *@Smeds*

I think what the OP could be saying [I could be wrong] is that children are taught to say Black (the race, not the skin colour] when they see a person with brown skin and this is what is racist.

Yes exactly @SrownBkinGirl, children are literal and they would usually say brown or dark skinned
OP posts:
Cameleongirl · 26/10/2021 19:27

Two of DD's friends have long curly black hair and brown skin so those characteristics alone wouldn't identify them. If she said that Friend M was Latina and Friend A was African- American, I'd know who was who.

Would that work for you, OP? DD is the white girl in the group.

cansu · 26/10/2021 19:25

Also of course someone should use someone's name but I can't imagine anyone referring to someone's skin colour unless they didn't know their name and were trying to differentiate the person from someone else. If I were the only white person in a group, someone might well say the white woman as a way of differentiating me from others. You sound like a professional in being offended. There are many people on here who disagree with you; many of these people are black or have a different skin tone. Why should you be more right than these people?

Workyticket · 26/10/2021 19:25

@SprayedWithDettol

I agree with your position OP. By saying ‘the black lady’ suggests that the standard is white and the person being discussed deviates from the standard. I don’t ever hear the ‘white lady’ as a descriptor. I am white and I think it is racist.
I think it depends on where you live/ work

I live in a predominantly white area but work in a very mixed area one city over.

A support worker knocked on my classroom door last week and said he was here to see x person. It's discrete support. I told him that x person was the white gent on table 3.

Quick, easy and hopefully acceptable. I'm still learning - I chat with my students all the time about preferences, what they experience etc. I hope I'm never offensive

Madwife123 · 26/10/2021 19:25

Black people have been saying for a long time that they want the word black being used to describe them as opposed to skirting around and using more offensive terms ‘coloured’ etc. You are the only person who I have ever heard say otherwise.

I am white. I have no issue being described as white. Technically I’m not white, I’m pink but racially I am white and I don’t argue the finer points of my exact skin tone because we all know that people don’t think I am actually white when they say white. The same as when someone says black to describe someone who is in fact brown.

I find it hard to take what you say seriously when you come out with comparisons using the word bitch which is derogatory (yes even in rap and I challenge you to provide an example of it being used in a non derogatory way). The word black is never derogatory. Derogatory terms to describe someone’s skin colour and yes I would be absolutely agreeing with you. This is not that.

Marelle · 26/10/2021 19:22

"Where are you really from?" is a) pig ignorant
I’d presume they were doing a poor job of asking which country your family was from before they lived here. It could be phrased better but I don’t think it’s rude to ask that? I get asked that all the time because my name is stereotypical of a particular country but I don’t look or sound like I’m from that country.

CannotThinkOfName · 26/10/2021 19:22

@AccidentallyOnPurpose

I'll be honest, this thread will eventually get full of comments from racist posters ,end up in a bun fight and get very upsetting for the people OP is trying to "protect". It always ends that way . So one might wonder if she really is that naive.
I feel like it seems like people are having pretty reasonable discussion or maybe I am just naive
OP posts:
Spidey66 · 26/10/2021 19:22

@Comedycook

I’ve never heard people point out someone is white before

Really?! Confused If I saw a crime being committed by a white person and I was describing the perpetrator to the police, I'd absolutely say that the person was white.

So would I. I live in a very diverse area of London and if for example had to describe someone to the police would, certainly say they were white.

As a white person I would not be offended by being described as white.

I'm all for learning from others but find the OP confusing and contradictory here.

MissTrip82 · 26/10/2021 19:20

What an astonishing number of posters who routinely describe somebody as white. Just as often as they describe somebody as black (presumably much more often if they’re living in Britain).

I’m sure they’re telling the truth.

twelly · 26/10/2021 19:19

If a child or adult is describing an individual then eyes, hair colour and skin colour are part of a description, in my view it is not racist.

MilkywayMonarch22 · 26/10/2021 19:19

@thepeopleversuswork of course it's different when a child (of a certain age!) does this, as they largely don't know any different and as humans (especially children) we are very visual. Also agree that there aren't much better terms than Black and White in the uk sadly.

Shuffalo · 26/10/2021 19:19

But then how do you teach children about ‘Black History Month’ which it is currently - what do you say it’s referring to?

Marelle · 26/10/2021 19:18

Knowing someone is black may help diagnosis...such as sickle cell anaemia*
Sickle cell is interesting because it’s not caused by being black, but there is a correlation with being black. The genetic mutation that causes sickle cell is favoured by natural selection in parts of the world where malaria is common because it also protects you against malaria. People with heritage in those parts of the world (where most people are black) are thus more likely to suffer from sickle cell.

Rover83 · 26/10/2021 19:18

So if I was walking down a busy street with my daughter and she said "mummy look at the beautiful dress that black lady is wearing" that would be offensive to you?

I can see it would be offensive if she knows your name, to me black is a descriptive term. I lived in a relatively small African country for 3 years and I was constantly referred to as the white lady

thepeopleversuswork · 26/10/2021 19:16

@MilkywayMonarch22

I agree that black and white are inaccurate as no one is actually black or white, and they are terms that are rooted in racism. Black being bad (e'g blacklisted, black magic, blackmail) and white being good (white lie, fairest of them all etc) but I think it's very difficult to not refer to someone's ethnicity when pointing them out, same with disability/sex/dress style etc.

Also agree that race is a construct as it's been proven many a time we are all one race with tiny genetic differences to change our skin/hair/eye colour and features. Language is outdated for the most part ...

I refer to myself as mixed ethnicity. However I agree that sometimes someone pointing out skin colour can be hostile and racist, for example the age old question we always get 'But where are you really from?'

Context and intent as a PP said...

I understand that but saying "where are you really from" is quite different from a child visually describing someone using the most obvious identifier available to them.

"Where are you really from?" is a) pig ignorant and b) dripping with the implication that the person on the receiving end is "not really one of us" so is pretty aggressive.

A child who has yet to learn that race is a social construct with the potential for offence but who has learned to identif people as "black" usually because they self-identify as "black" is simply picking up on identifiers they can use.

And as "black" is the least offensive and most widely-used identifier, its logical that their parents would prefer them to use this word than a more offensive word such as "coloured", surely?

TabithaTiger · 26/10/2021 19:15

My view is that context is everything. If I'm asked by the Police to describe an incident where I saw a woman get mugged, how can I do this without mentioning skin colour?

"The woman was black, with long hair and she was wearing jeans and a red coat, the man was white with ginger hair and a brown jacket"

If you take away the skin colour, the description is pretty meaningless.

However if I say "Have you met Louise, the black lady who works in Finance?", this in my view is racist as her skin colour is irrelevant.

cansu · 26/10/2021 19:15

You are very contradictory.

You don't object to the black mumsnetters section but you do object to anyone using the word 'black'.

How does this make sense??

stupiduser · 26/10/2021 19:15

I find this genuinely confusing and would hate to think that someone would consider me racist. My DD recently started secondary school. She came home telling me the new friends she made every day. I met a girl called 'sue' she is blonde, shorter than me (noted because my DD is short). I met a girl called 'Paula' I make a funny face as we have had issues with a girl called paula before. She says no not that one, she is lovely and not that it's interesting but she is black. Is she being racist? I don't think she is, we sadly live in a very very white area and so she is happy to have a mixture of culture in her friendship group. We had a chat about her surname the other day because My DD was saying it's beautiful but unusual to her ears. I feel that wasn't racist, she was saying how she felt, nothing negative just observations. She always comments on her hair as she has it in really nice styles, is that racist?

thewhatsit · 26/10/2021 19:14

Is the “Black Mumsnetters” section racist because of its name? Because I remember the thread(s) that led to its creation and lots of people were calling for it?

Swipe left for the next trending thread