Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Stop teaching child that it’s okay to refer to someone’s skin colour

707 replies

CannotThinkOfName · 26/10/2021 17:39

Calling someone - a random person you don’t know - black is racist. I don’t care if your personal friend or your family member or someone else you’re close to doesn’t mind being referred to like this because they’re speaking for themselves as individuals.

Pointing out someone by skin colour is rude at best and at worst a form of racism. This is because

  1. Skin colour that I was born with is brown.
  2. Skin colour that I was born with does not define anyone. It doesn’t define your traits, characteristics, hobbies, goals, ambitions or anything else that truly defines who a person is.
  3. It’s a form of racial harassment to start bothering someone at random and bringing up their race and colour for no real reason and singling them out by it.

I’ve seen people say there’s nothing wrong with their child referring to people by skin because they are just “saying what they see”. This is wrong because as a child, I never ever saw myself as “black” or described myself “black”. This is taught as a way to refer to people, it’s not simply a child “saying what they see”.

Please stop teaching your child that it’s okay to refer to people that you don’t know this way. If you do know someone and they’ve told you to call them black then that’s their choice as an individual. They don’t speak for anyone else but themselves.

If you don’t know someone’s name, - just ask them what their name is and call them by their actual name. Not “that black girl” or “the black woman” or “that black lady”.

OP posts:
Ciaobaby92 · 28/10/2021 13:24

Actually SrownBkinGirl, I did not address you in any way, you are the one who picked my statement "black is beautiful" out of this entire thread, and created an entire false narrative about me based on that one statement. Kind of like a person with prejudice would do. It was absolutely ridiculous to attack me over that statement. With all the injustice in the world, you're really going to go on a two hour rant at me because I dared say black is beautiful. Ok it's your energy, expend it however you wish. If you want to jump to conclusions and pretend I am someone I am not, and try to invent things I actually never said then suit yourself if it makes you feel better.

OrganicMooMoo · 28/10/2021 13:16

Hemingwayscats

It isn’t though is it? If it were a white woman in a group of black men and women and two were carrying red bags you wouldn’t just say “the woman with the red bag”....would you?
Why try to think up extra descriptors to avoid using one that identifies the person immediately?
If it is a black woman in a group of men I would say “that woman” (which opens a whole other can of worms) however if it is a black woman in a group of other black women I would not use “that woman” and I certainly wouldn’t use “the black women” as neither uniquely identifies the woman in question.
There are two children in dd’s class at school who both have the same name. If one was “white” and the other “black” it would make no sense for her to describe the one she sits beside as “the one with dark hair and brown eyes” because they both have dark hair and brown eyes. She’d say the one with “brown skin” (because that’s a term she uses). As it happens they both have the same colour skin, so this is not an identifier between those two girls, and she doesn’t use it to describe which is which. She calls one “the new girl”.

SrownBkinGirl · 28/10/2021 13:07

Grin Typical of someone with no point to add and not willing to reason.

Take a nap if you're tired or bored.

BelleOfTheProvince · 28/10/2021 13:03

@Hemingwayscats

I don’t like this either. You know how you’d point out a white person by saying ‘the woman with the red coat’ or ‘the man with the curly hair’ perhaps. You most likely wouldn’t say ‘the white woman’ so why is ‘the black woman’ somehow default.
That assumes you can see the person. In the example I provided, a friend was referring to another guest at my wedding they'd forgotten the name of. She tried brunette. Hundreds of guests. She tried brown eyed. Ditto. Gorgeous. Ditto. Neither of us could remember what she was wearing. Friend had straight hair instead of her usual braids or afro, so that didn't come up. We got there after a good ten minutes. I said, my mixed race friend. She immediately said yes. So instead of a nice conversation about how she enjoyed my friends company, it was made about race, uncomfortably so.

I think op is lacking in nuance and context here.

Eilatan2018 · 28/10/2021 13:03

@SrownBkinGirl

Referring to someone as black or white isn’t racist!!

I agree. What I was pointing out is saying others who don't want to be called Black are ashamed of it. It always comes down to the question - what does being Black mean and where has anyone said they are ashamed of that?

On the contrary, people who're accused of being ashamed of Black are rather very proud of their cultural heritage and all it entails (which is really what the Black is meant to represent, rather lazily). So it makes that accusation/question moot.

You'll find that they're not ashamed of it when you break it down (and those who throw that accusation/question around never do). They just don't want to be given that word as a label for who they are or a catch-all term for their identity.

What I don't get is the insistence for them to accept it. Comes across a bit "x supremacy" to me (and I'm not just talking about "white" supremacy. I include all kinds, western supremacy, whatever supremacy) and for them to accept what they've been given.

🥱
Hemingwayscats · 28/10/2021 12:56

I don’t like this either. You know how you’d point out a white person by saying ‘the woman with the red coat’ or ‘the man with the curly hair’ perhaps. You most likely wouldn’t say ‘the white woman’ so why is ‘the black woman’ somehow default.

SrownBkinGirl · 28/10/2021 12:40

Referring to someone as black or white isn’t racist!!

I agree. What I was pointing out is saying others who don't want to be called Black are ashamed of it. It always comes down to the question - what does being Black mean and where has anyone said they are ashamed of that?

On the contrary, people who're accused of being ashamed of Black are rather very proud of their cultural heritage and all it entails (which is really what the Black is meant to represent, rather lazily). So it makes that accusation/question moot.

You'll find that they're not ashamed of it when you break it down (and those who throw that accusation/question around never do). They just don't want to be given that word as a label for who they are or a catch-all term for their identity.

What I don't get is the insistence for them to accept it. Comes across a bit "x supremacy" to me (and I'm not just talking about "white" supremacy. I include all kinds, western supremacy, whatever supremacy) and for them to accept what they've been given.

ReturntoSpamfritters · 28/10/2021 12:27

There are no literally black or literally white people, or red or yellow. These are social constructs. Often used in pejorative ways. The range of colour in human skin tones is amazing.

www.demilked.com/skin-tones-pantone-colors-photos-humanae-angelica-dass/

Why use skin colour as the main descriptor at all?

Eilatan2018 · 28/10/2021 11:54

@SrownBkinGirl

You are black.. are you ashamed of it?

I know this was to the OP but again, this is a tired line and people keep trotting it out.

What is there to be ashamed and why is it the main thing that comes to mind when people say this? What does it mean to be Black and can you pinpoint, from that, what the OP is supposed to be ashamed of? Is it culture - which Black culture, and has OP said they're ashamed of that culture? Is it skin colour - has OP said they hate their colour? Is it other Black people - has OP said they don't like to be seen with others?

If you wanting to argue about people being ashamed, I'd say those who try to change their skin colour (whether darken or lighten), hair texture/length, nose, lips, cheekbones, etc are more ashamed of what they have and not happy with parts of who they are. Not someone whose only gripe is not liking a label given to them and hasn't said or shown that they don't like where they're from or any part of themselves.

There’s absolutely nothing to be ashamed of hence why I don’t get the issue here? They’re making an issue about something unnecessarily and I find it infuriating! Referring to someone as black or white isn’t racist!!
AccidentallyOnPurpose · 28/10/2021 11:50

What still confuses me (probably not quite the right word) is what to use when we talk about a collective. Putting everyone together is problematic anyways due to the various ethnicities,cultures and countries of provenance.

Other variants are also considered offensive/not accurate enough.

I do agree that if an individual expresses a specific preference,for whatever reasons , it's dickish to ignore that . It's also a lot easier to comply.

But how do we navigate/apply that when talking about a group of people?

DottyHarmer · 28/10/2021 11:29

I can see it’s all quite problematic, and not many people deliberately want to cause offence.

I would say that when describing people it depends what the prevailing ethnicity is in the area. Eg, in a room full of white people, you may describe person A as being black. If, however, everyone was black except person B, you’d say “the white lady”.

Agree though that white/black descriptors are rarely accurate. Perhaps in time we will use a more helpful “shadier” vocabulary.

ReturntoSpamfritters · 28/10/2021 11:15

Thank you to the OP and SrownBkinGirl (among others) for this really educational thread. Flowers

SrownBkinGirl · 28/10/2021 10:19

You lost with your last post. No actual point made. Just flinging insults. It came across a bit 'Backed into a corner, fight or flight! Quick, throw anything and hope it sticks'.
It came across a bit overwrought. Hence, I won't take offence.

fashionSOS · 28/10/2021 10:00

@mustlovegin

I am fat and uncomfortable with my weight, that's why I used it as an example

I misunderstood what you were saying, apologies

No worries, reading too fast is easily done. Smile Hopefully I make more sense to you now!
SrownBkinGirl · 28/10/2021 09:58

You're missing the point and that's fine. I see you've not touched on any of the points I made besides claiming what's not real and that I'm offended as if you want it to stick, and frantically defending yourself from what? I don't know. Don't worry, you're not being accused of anything. If you read my posts here (you don't have to but it will help with your assumptions), you'll find I'm not offended but if that's what you hope to hold on to, fine by me.

Glad I gave you something to laugh about. Makes me happy.

Ciaobaby92 · 28/10/2021 09:57

This reply has been deleted

Message deleted by MNHQ. Here's a link to our Talk guidelines.

mustlovegin · 28/10/2021 09:55

I am fat and uncomfortable with my weight, that's why I used it as an example

I misunderstood what you were saying, apologies

Ciaobaby92 · 28/10/2021 09:51

SrownBiknGirl, apparently I am important enough that you picked out my post to pick apart out of the hundreds here and for that I am flattered. If anyone should have a guilty conscience it's you, for being so skeptical that I believe black is beautiful. Of all the things to pick out to be offended about...I actually find it hilarious.

fashionSOS · 28/10/2021 09:50

@mustlovegin

Although we have a similar fight in some ways, it's still not the same one, and it's more respectful to keep our own colour reclamation projects separate

Could you explain the colour reclamation projects aspect? How and why do you need to reclaim them, from whom?

I mean, I'd rather be the Chinese lady with the short hair than the fat one
This can be very offensive towards people who are not comfortable with their weight, so you may want to be more careful about this in the future

I sincerely hope you're joking. I am fat and uncomfortable with my weight, that's why I used it as an example! I'd rather people refer to me by the colour of my skin than the size of my stomach! I don't feel emotional about my skin colour, but catch me on a bad day and describe me as fat, and I'll probably go cry in a toilet.

I don't mean a formal project. It's just there are certain words that people use to describe others in a negative way - and the best way to remove the power of those negative connotations is to own those words.

People typically use yellow in a racist way - so I often describe myself as yellow. I was very pissed off with MNHQ (and still am) for removing a post in which I described myself as yellow. It's my ethnicity and it's my word. If you're not East Asian, it's not a word for you to use, but if you are, you can take it back.

Similarly, I know a lot of Indian people who get called brown in a racist way. So they also describe themselves as brown - it's about taking back words other people have tried to turn into weapons in our lived experience.

Preech · 28/10/2021 09:39

If the community the OP lives in would refer to her as "the black lady" but to her white neighbor as "the lady", I can see how awkward that could feel. Because it still treats whiteness as the default. And even if you argued that the community might be majority-white, that kind of demographic can change with time, and in the meantime, the language is just setting one member of the community apart.

My children do notice different skin colors, because we have a growing Black population in our neighbourhood. When they speak out loud about details they notice, like skin color and hairstyles (my daughter admires her schoolmates' braids), I've tried to move the dialogue to their friend having brown skin, her and me having very pale peach skin (or white skin, but I'm usually corrected by my kids when I say that), that our tiny but several freckles are caused by melanin, and that her pal will have brown skin because her skin has more melanin. I'm hoping that kind of dialogue will allow acknowledgement of difference in appearance, which as far as I can tell is normal in children, without treating whiteness as the default.

AccidentallyOnPurpose · 28/10/2021 09:37

Caucasian is also not a thing anymore (unless you're actually from the Caucasus) , at least not in the UK. It slowly seems to die out in the US too.

mustlovegin · 28/10/2021 09:19

Although we have a similar fight in some ways, it's still not the same one, and it's more respectful to keep our own colour reclamation projects separate

Could you explain the colour reclamation projects aspect? How and why do you need to reclaim them, from whom?

I mean, I'd rather be the Chinese lady with the short hair than the fat one
This can be very offensive towards people who are not comfortable with their weight, so you may want to be more careful about this in the future

SrownBkinGirl · 28/10/2021 09:11

It is also very sad that some people believe that being anything other than Caucasian is something too shameful to mention, because that view only perpetuates the problem and prevents forward momentum.

There you go assuming it's shameful.

I have encountered confusion and disbelief by saying I believe black is beautiful, and that is something one should be ashamed of, IMO.

Missing the point. You can keep your sadness and pity. No one needs it from you.

My skin colour and that of everyone like me, brown is beautiful.
The colour, black, like our hair, is beautiful.
The culture of everyone who's considered a "black person" is beautiful.
Our languages are beautiful.
We are beautiful.

You think saying the Black race label is beautiful and pat yourself on the back for it when it has no meaning. I break mine down and tell you so that you know we know we are beautiful and exactly what's beautiful about us.

You just trot "Black is beautiful" and think you're the only one who knows it and everybody else doesn't agree, not thinking what does Black even mean and what are these people saying. Well there you go. We're probably saying the same thing, except mine is a clearer statement.

Checkedshirt · 28/10/2021 09:10

@CannotThinkOfName

“I do not think that referring to someone's skin colour is racist”.

It’s racist. It’s just that it’s a form of racism that has been normalised. People need to quit it.

I would disagree; it is not automatically racist - as other people have said.

I can be used in a racist manner, but it can also be used in a descriptive manner.

Stating that "People need to quit it" is the easiest way to get others on the defensive and comes across as quite arrogant. Who are you to (attempt to) instruct other in what they should / shouldn't do?

SrownBkinGirl · 28/10/2021 09:02

@Ciaobaby92

SrownBkinGirl, you presume way too much about me. You have no idea of my race or where I come from. Your reply just goes to show some people will really reach to find offense where none was intended. There is absolutely nothing wrong or hard to understand about me believing that black people are beautiful. If you don't like that I suggest you find a way to deal with it because you will not be "shaming" me to believe or say otherwise.
Ironic. You've just presumed my post was (solely) about you. I saw your post long before it was quoted and I was only prompted to post after it was. Perhaps read the post of the person who quoted your post (and others' post who're similar to it) before assuming out of a guilty conscience. If that's what you're feeling, you can go find a way deal with it. You're not that important to me.