Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Stop teaching child that it’s okay to refer to someone’s skin colour

707 replies

CannotThinkOfName · 26/10/2021 17:39

Calling someone - a random person you don’t know - black is racist. I don’t care if your personal friend or your family member or someone else you’re close to doesn’t mind being referred to like this because they’re speaking for themselves as individuals.

Pointing out someone by skin colour is rude at best and at worst a form of racism. This is because

  1. Skin colour that I was born with is brown.
  2. Skin colour that I was born with does not define anyone. It doesn’t define your traits, characteristics, hobbies, goals, ambitions or anything else that truly defines who a person is.
  3. It’s a form of racial harassment to start bothering someone at random and bringing up their race and colour for no real reason and singling them out by it.

I’ve seen people say there’s nothing wrong with their child referring to people by skin because they are just “saying what they see”. This is wrong because as a child, I never ever saw myself as “black” or described myself “black”. This is taught as a way to refer to people, it’s not simply a child “saying what they see”.

Please stop teaching your child that it’s okay to refer to people that you don’t know this way. If you do know someone and they’ve told you to call them black then that’s their choice as an individual. They don’t speak for anyone else but themselves.

If you don’t know someone’s name, - just ask them what their name is and call them by their actual name. Not “that black girl” or “the black woman” or “that black lady”.

OP posts:
MumOfBoys16 · 26/10/2021 20:41

I've not read all the comments, so apologies if I'm repeating.

My son is 4, he commented the other day when at the park look at the squirrel mummy, I said where, he said by the man with brown skin. I was surprised by what he'd said as he'd never used someone's skin colour to describe someone before. I was left thinking should I say to him not to comment like this, I've decided no i shouldn't he was right, and purely describing what he saw. Surely me telling him not to talk about someone's skin is making more of an issue out if it?

MolyHolyGuacamole · 26/10/2021 20:41

@secular39

Seriously. This is a non issue and I would have no problem of someone referring me to my race.
I bet you're white.

You don't feel the same when your local Facebook group is littered with reports of 'suspicious looking black man'. White people are rarely mentioned in these posts, they don't draw the same attention unless they're behaving in an incredibly unnaturally way or have an extremely unusual appearance.

Black people are seen as suspicious for just walking.

Beefmeupscotty · 26/10/2021 20:37

I feel like this is just a repeat of last week's thread (maybe 2 week's ago?)

Who's Ella?
The black one. The black lady. The dark one. The brown one. - Big fat no!

Who's Ella?
She's over there, short, black, long curly hair, wearing a big jumper... - Fine.

Context is everything.

SrownBkinGirl · 26/10/2021 20:37

Children will do that to you @JayDot500 . I know mine have opened my eyes/mind to so many things I just went along with without critically thinking and questioning and like you, this is one of them. It's through "batshit" discussions like this that the term coloured, etc have changed. Always "batshit" with the ones who start out.

CannotThinkOfName · 26/10/2021 20:33

@Pontypandytaxpayer

We never really hear from people with views like mine so it’s important for me to share this to inform people that there are people who don’t like being called black and only want to be called by their name.

But has anyone who knows your name actually referred to you directly as 'black'? I can't imagine this situation.

It’s actually has happened to me and does happen. It might be hard for you to believe but many people feel like bringing up someone’s race for no reason (not giving a police report) is completely acceptable.
OP posts:
JayDot500 · 26/10/2021 20:33

Tbh, I didn't care about this sort of thing until I found myself trying to explain to my 5/6 year old that he is black (with two black parents). He got quite heated about it, as he's obviously not the colour black but there I was trying to explain myself. One day he'll understand that he is 'black', and 'brown' means a whole different thing. It's quite sad when it's your own kid making you question what you've previously had no issue with.

oblada · 26/10/2021 20:33

Racist is, etymologically speaking, to put race at the heart of the discourse, to see it as a defining factor, as the most important defining factor when considering differences in people.
Describing the colour of someone's skin is not racist. It is just describing the colour of someone's skin. In some context it can an element indicating racism. But on its own no it is not racist. We all describe people based on their visible characteristics and black/brown/white is one of them. Big, small, strong, short, tall, heavy build, slim are other factual descriptions.
When people cannot remember my name they sometimes refer to me as the lady with the accent (i have a non British accent and I mostly work on the phone so my accent/voice is an easy defining factor). That isn't racist either. It is factual.
Asking me if I've had a good time 'at home' whenever i go to my country of birth for holidays however, that does grate me and could be seen as having some racist undertones as it suggests that i wouldn't have my home here. But again it doesn't make the people racist. Just clumsy.

Xillow · 26/10/2021 20:32

I respect your right to identify and call yourself whatever you want. However, I feel that your post is just adding to an already confusing (for many) discourse.

The dominant term in this country and at this moment in time is ‘black’ and the vast majority of black people, including myself, are fine with it (evidenced by the numerous articles written by black journalists, authors, academic literature, never heard any outrage at ‘Black History Month’).

There are so many more important conversations to be had. This isn’t one of them.

Language and social norms change. My late grandma identified as ‘coloured’, which would raise an eyebrow from her grandchildren today.

I acknowledge that individual differences exist too, in terms of what you would be preferred to be called. But you have to consider if it is a reasonable expectation for someone to know that, given the current information that is circulating.

Plus, all the black people I know would comfortably say, ‘the white woman’ or ‘the black woman’ if they need to provide a description for someone they don’t know. It is merely a descriptor.

Biancadelrioisback · 26/10/2021 20:28

@BelleOfTheProvince

Hermione was based on jk herself as a teen, so I imagine in her mind's eye she saw herself, a mousey,.self proclaimed geeky white girl. Emma Watson was far too conventionally good looking for my mind, but then so was the stage Hermione we saw. I'd like a plain Hermione. Now that would be ground breaking.
I did not know that about Hermione being based on Rowling! Every day's a school day.
eeyore228 · 26/10/2021 20:28

What strikes me about this thread is that it confirms that regardless of how well-intentioned you might be there will always be someone offended, society throws up different terms that are accepted or not accepted. Is it POC or brown or black?. If I know someone's name I will use it but if I'm at work I'm often surrounded by hundreds of people who I am sometimes asked to describe. This just leaves me wondering how OP would genuinely expect me to do that? What is acceptable because reading the comments I'm not sure.

Jackofallsorts · 26/10/2021 20:26

All behaviour is learned.
This thread is absurd.

MissMaple82 · 26/10/2021 20:26

And who on their right mind says to their pals/colleagues or neighbours etc, look I'm black, white or brown it is ok to call me black/white/brown, you have my permission!

Comedycook · 26/10/2021 20:26

I think it's a shame you have such a blanket approach to this issue op because it's distracted most posters from the main point which is actually quite interesting and does have some merit

Pontypandytaxpayer · 26/10/2021 20:26

We never really hear from people with views like mine so it’s important for me to share this to inform people that there are people who don’t like being called black and only want to be called by their name.

But has anyone who knows your name actually referred to you directly as 'black'? I can't imagine this situation.

FreshFreesias · 26/10/2021 20:24

What a goady post.

Waahingwashingwashing · 26/10/2021 20:24

That’s a good point. If you can’t refer to skin colour, why is it ok to say the woman or the man?!

BelleOfTheProvince · 26/10/2021 20:23

Hermione was based on jk herself as a teen, so I imagine in her mind's eye she saw herself, a mousey,.self proclaimed geeky white girl.
Emma Watson was far too conventionally good looking for my mind, but then so was the stage Hermione we saw.
I'd like a plain Hermione. Now that would be ground breaking.

MissMaple82 · 26/10/2021 20:22

What on earth are you talking about?! Refering to skin colour, is not a form of racism! Just like pointing out a person's sex isn't sexism. This is utter nonsense, this is why society is so damn PC because of nations like this!

secular39 · 26/10/2021 20:22

Seriously. This is a non issue and I would have no problem of someone referring me to my race.

NeverDropYourMooncup · 26/10/2021 20:20

Surrounded by 1600 children, something happens that you need to report, like some of them were picking on one child. You don't know their victim's name so can't go and check to see if they're OK or if they want to make a statement. You go and see the Assistant Head because what you witnessed was absolutely wrong and the offenders are absolutely denying that anything happened.

What year was he?

About Year 9. Maybe a small Year 10 or a tall Year 8, I guess. About five foot five, anyhow.

What colour hair?

Dark. Short. Curly.

Curly? Do you mean Freddie Bloggs?

No, not Freddie Bloggs. Um, er, definitely not Freddie Bloggs.

Definitely not? Going to need a bit more description than that, then.

Um, erm. I don't think I can tell you that.

Sigh. So we need a child who is about five foot five, might be a year 8, 9 or 10, is male, short dark curly hair, might have a head injury or be very upset. Can you give me anything more than that?

Well, they have warm toned skin, very dark eyes, long eyelashes and was wearing exactly the same school uniform as everybody else.

So we're looking for - ?

Oh, uh, I'd rather not spell it out. Would it help if I say I think it might be an incident of racist bullying? Or is that too much?

Ah. I get you. However, as there are still many, many children that could refer to, can we narrow it down a bit further? I can assume that in the absence of long hair or a headcovering, it's not w, x, y or z child. Anything else?

Um, not really anything I'd be comfortable saying. We could go look out the window and see if he walks past, though. Or see if he passes out in the toilets sometime this afternoon due to concussion.

SrownBkinGirl · 26/10/2021 20:20

I feel like the “call me black” crew are always heard from to the point where they act like every “black” person agrees with them - we don’t. We never really hear from people with views like mine so it’s important for me to share this to inform people that there are people who don’t like being called black and only want to be called by their name.

I agree. There are many Black people with different views. I've said I don't agree with everything the OP's said but I agree with some and i see where she's coming from. Mocking her, calling her batshit, goady, troll, etc for her unpopular views (it seems) IS batshit. We keep saying Black people aren't a monolith and yet when a Black person says something completely different, their blackness is questioned. How bizarre!

And if you're not a Black person here, yet you're piling on the OP's views on race with your convenient excuse to throw insults, I see you! Hmm

BananaPB · 26/10/2021 20:20

Except there's no nationality called Black. It's obvious where the Chinese, Indian and Spanish ladies are from. What about the Black lady?

People regularly use Chinese, Indian, Spanish incorrectly ime so it's not the gold standard for describing people. I've heard people from Korea or Japan being called Chinese or the Person from Pakistan being called Indian. If the person is in your life eg a work colleague then you should know if they are from Vietnam or Singapore but can people really tell nationality without a cue like accent?

Do you prefer terms like African American ? How do people in the US distinguish Americans who are black from black people who are say Nigerian or Jamaican without asking or knowing them?

TattySlippers · 26/10/2021 20:20

You are not black are you OP? You come across as a white person who wants to be offended on behalf of all black people. You are failing, miserably.

I’m proud to live in a country that embraces everyone - regardless of skin colour, heritage, culture….

What about you?

MrsSkylerWhite · 26/10/2021 20:19

The “brown” people I know call themselves “black”

FoamyBanana · 26/10/2021 20:18

Er, who put you in charge? My husband and kids are black - that's how they choose to describe themselves. You don't get to speak for them thanks.