Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Stop teaching child that it’s okay to refer to someone’s skin colour

707 replies

CannotThinkOfName · 26/10/2021 17:39

Calling someone - a random person you don’t know - black is racist. I don’t care if your personal friend or your family member or someone else you’re close to doesn’t mind being referred to like this because they’re speaking for themselves as individuals.

Pointing out someone by skin colour is rude at best and at worst a form of racism. This is because

  1. Skin colour that I was born with is brown.
  2. Skin colour that I was born with does not define anyone. It doesn’t define your traits, characteristics, hobbies, goals, ambitions or anything else that truly defines who a person is.
  3. It’s a form of racial harassment to start bothering someone at random and bringing up their race and colour for no real reason and singling them out by it.

I’ve seen people say there’s nothing wrong with their child referring to people by skin because they are just “saying what they see”. This is wrong because as a child, I never ever saw myself as “black” or described myself “black”. This is taught as a way to refer to people, it’s not simply a child “saying what they see”.

Please stop teaching your child that it’s okay to refer to people that you don’t know this way. If you do know someone and they’ve told you to call them black then that’s their choice as an individual. They don’t speak for anyone else but themselves.

If you don’t know someone’s name, - just ask them what their name is and call them by their actual name. Not “that black girl” or “the black woman” or “that black lady”.

OP posts:
difficultdayahead · 27/10/2021 02:56

Oh what bollocks. Saying the colour of someone's skin is descriptive, not racist.

But I find #blacklivesmatter discriminatory. Yes, of course they do, obviously. But you know what? White lives matter equally, but where's our campaign? Where's our protests, etc?

Posts like this really piss me off. The vast majority of people who use the terms 'black', or 'coloured', etc., do not mean any offence at all, yet people who are determined to be offended will always find a way.

Live and let live - even if that means stating the colour of someone's skin.

geesearego · 27/10/2021 02:41

you would refer to him as South Asian or ethnically Indian (unsure of correct terms), but it wouldn't be related to his "browness"

One of the things I've adjusted to in the USA is that the word brown is a pc descriptor for people, often used alongside black, so black and brown people.
I've noticed that what the USA starts the UK often follows so you may find yourself using that descriptor.

SrownBkinGirl · 27/10/2021 02:31

For those who keep saying they've never seen a single black person not want to be called Black. They exist. You're probably only looking where you want to look. OP is one, so you've seen one person who doesn't want to. I'm one too (although I don't think it's racist to say).

OP has also shared a link and clip of at least two more people.

Here's another one - an American man.
www.pbs.org/video/kmele-foster-doesnt-self-identify-black-yw7cow/

mobile.twitter.com/kmele/status/1001470244836335616?lang=en

www.spiked-online.com/podcast-episode/i-dont-identify-as-black/

I personally know three other Americans (a man and two women) who do. There are others on the thread someone mentioned and the bmn forum. Hopefully, you'll have no need to make that claim of 'never seeing someone blah blah'... anymore. You can disagree with it but don't make it out to be stupid, then expect the OP to respect your preference.

Sydendad · 27/10/2021 02:27

I think we need to stop people from calling everything some "ism"
racism,.. blabla-ism. Why be offended so easily? Wh are coming to a point where we can't joke about race or sex or gender or anything anymore because people like you have to call everything an "ism"
See I was called shimpansee, monkey, poopface and god knows what. I never called it racism though I just called it insulting. See racism for me is when i left my white home country for holidays - the country where i grew up, went to school and worked - to come back to customs officers who picked me out of line with white people in front of me and behind me to question me on my reasons for entering my own home country and search my bags. That is racism and they didnt even have to call me any colour.

BubbleCoffee · 27/10/2021 01:53

By saying ‘the black lady’ suggests that the standard is white

I don't think that's necessarily implied. If you say 'the blonde woman' or 'the man with glasses' or 'the black woman' or 'the elderly man with the green T-shirt', or 'the woman with Downs Syndrome' it doesn't mean you think they're 'not standard'. It just means that this particular characteristic helps distinguish them from the other human beings who happen to be in the room on that occasion. It isn't some kind of judgement or insult, in the way it would be if you said 'the ugly man' or 'the tarty woman' or 'the boring guy' or 'the woman with the hideous dress and massive backside'.

Obecalp · 27/10/2021 01:47

How do you describe someone of the same skin colour? Do that.

Reading back, it is obvious I misinterpreted this to mean 'of the same skin colour as yourself', sorry.

melj1213 · 27/10/2021 01:34

People will tend to focus on the most obvious descriptor when trying to point someone out or when trying to describe them. Sometimes it will be a physical feature - gender, skin/hair colour, height, age, use of an obvious physical aid (wheelchair/walking stick etc) - and sometimes it will be another descriptor - clothes, accessories, something they're with/near etc.

The key factor is whether the descriptor is being used in an appropriate context. If you have a room with 25 white people and 5 POC, then if you are trying to tell someone who "Sam" is then referring to skin colour as part of the description is relevent if Sam is one of the POC (as it allows you to immediately discount the majority of the irrelevant people), whereas if Sam is one of the 25 white people then using skin colour doesn't narrow the description down much and so people are more likely to rely on other physical features.

I work in a supermarket and we have headsets so that we can communicate with each other with important information. This includes making each other aware of specific customers for various reasons and we will give as much information as possible whist trying to be as concise as possible as the headsets are all connected so everyone can hear every communication and someone going on and on with a description basically "blocks the line" so other information can't be passed on. The town I live in is a working class town in the NW of England where 96.9% of residents are white British, so almost every customer is white ... when we talk about someone on the headset we tend to refer to clothing/age/hair colour etc but if a black or Asian customer came in then the quickest way to distinguish them would be to refer to them as "the black lady in the green jacket" or "The Asian gentleman in the blue jumper" in the same way we would refer to "the lady with the purple hair", "the gentleman in the wheelchair", "the lady in the black hoodie with 3 kids". We pick something obvious and distinguishing - sometimes it is ethnicity, sometimes it is clothing but it is never something derogatory, negative or made with ill intent.

Cameleongirl · 27/10/2021 01:31

As Petridisher says, I honestly think it depends on the context. My DD has made friends with other three girls who play on the same sports team. In that group of four, she’s the only ethnically white girl. If someone asked which girl she was, I think it’s likely she’s be described as “the white girl.” But, I take your point about giving a fuller description, that’s definitely preferable to simply describing some one as Black or white. We’re in the US so there’s huge ethnic diversity.

ZingDramaQueenOfSheeba · 27/10/2021 01:18

so did JD & Turk in Scrubs get it right by calling each other Vanilla Bear and Chocolate Bear? Or will the crowd always talk & stare?
(And oh poor Caramel Bear.....😭)

Obecalp · 27/10/2021 01:07

At the same time, I think I get what OP is saying.

If you met an ethnically South Asian man, you would not describe them as "black", but often ethnically African people will he described as "black" despite having similar skin tones. It's a description of colour that actually isn't the colour of the person's skin. You wouldn't say "the brown man" when speaking about the South Asian man, you would refer to him as South Asian or ethnically Indian (unsure of correct terms), but it wouldn't be related to his "browness". Yet with ethnic Africans they get called "black", when they aren't even black colour-wise.

The same does happen to white people, although sometimes you get "European" although it perhaps should be ethnically European as anybody can come from any continent really. There aren't as negative connotations around whiteness though.

I am guessing OP is wondering why there is the white / black dichotomy but other ""races"" are described by geographical area of their ethnicity, and why the white / black dichotomy evolved that way.

Obecalp · 27/10/2021 00:57

How do you describe someone of the same skin colour? Do that.

Sometimes by their skin colour. We live in London and a lot of DD's friend group in school are of ethnically African descent (is that better than black?). Sometimes when she is in the playground after school she is in a group of 4 girls and she is the only one you would describe as white, so it would he an easy way to mark her out if someone were speaking about her but didn't know her name.

You can look for other markers. Sometimes skin colour is an obvious one, it depends on the group of people the person is among that you are trying to differentiate them from.

ZingDramaQueenOfSheeba · 27/10/2021 00:44

@Knackeredmommy

I don't understand what you mean? I'm black, if someone is describing someone to me, I'd much prefer they say "the black lady, white man" etc. If you mean people are describing you to your face as "that black girl", then yes that's offensive as you have a name and shouldn't just be defined by that. I taught my children they're black and that that's a wonderful thing.
❤❤❤
PetriDisher · 27/10/2021 00:40

Beefmeupscotty If I was referring to the only white person in a meeting full of black people, I would absolutely refer to them as "the white woman" because it is simple and effective as a distinguisher. In the UK it is much more likely to be the other way around due to the country's demographics. I would venture that that is probably why it sounds more common to you that a black person would be singled out based on skin colour.

In majority black or Asian countries it would be common and expected that a white colleague be referred to as "the white lady" for exactly the same reasons of clarity and efficiency.

I'm sure it sometimes happens that people are dicks about these things and say "black" in a tone or way that suggests the speaker views it as a subtle derogatory description, just as they could for "woman", but we all know how much difference tone and intent can make to otherwise perfectly normal speech. It's no good trying to ban people saying, "good morning" because one pervert once said those words to you in a lacivious tone while looking you up and down while liching his lips (true story). There's nothing wrong with the words; there's something wrong with the person delivering them in a particular way with a particular intent.

Knackeredmommy · 27/10/2021 00:34

I don't understand what you mean? I'm black, if someone is describing someone to me, I'd much prefer they say "the black lady, white man" etc. If you mean people are describing you to your face as "that black girl", then yes that's offensive as you have a name and shouldn't just be defined by that. I taught my children they're black and that that's a wonderful thing.

Rollingwiththehomies · 27/10/2021 00:29

@hotmeatymilk

But many Black people say it’s racist to avoid using Black when describing someone, because dancing around it suggests being Black is problematic – which obviously it isn’t. So isn’t it fair to say that you find it racist and others don’t, rather than it categorically being so?
This is my train of thought too.
nearly4o · 27/10/2021 00:28

How would we ever play guess who ever again???

Beefmeupscotty · 27/10/2021 00:25

I think we might have got wires crossed here...

I'm not fully in support of the OPs argument, I don't mind being called back as part of a description, but do find it offensive if it the only description of me. I am more than just my skin colour.

And I don’t honestly believe you would refer to someone as "the white woman". You'd go straight for the woman with short blonde hair and glasses. Do the same for black women. Offer a description, don't single them out.

PetriDisher · 27/10/2021 00:22

I...can. In my opinion. That was rather my point!

TirednWorried · 27/10/2021 00:22

my dd has very fair hair and skin.Her bf is se Asian and talks a lot about how white her skin is .Is this racist too?

Beefmeupscotty · 27/10/2021 00:21

@PetriDisher

Beefmeupscotty If they were the only white woman at the meeting, I would refer to them as "the white woman", of course. If there were several, I would supplement with additional physical descriptors, such as "the white woman with short, blonde hair and glasses".

Isn't this just how normal people speak to and about each other?

Some of you must have been rubbish at 'Guess Who?' as kids!

So why can't you do that with a black woman?
PetriDisher · 27/10/2021 00:14

Beefmeupscotty If they were the only white woman at the meeting, I would refer to them as "the white woman", of course. If there were several, I would supplement with additional physical descriptors, such as "the white woman with short, blonde hair and glasses".

Isn't this just how normal people speak to and about each other?

Some of you must have been rubbish at 'Guess Who?' as kids!

WorraLiberty · 27/10/2021 00:13

I don’t know all the details about the black mumsnet section because I wasn’t actively involved in creating that section.

Yeah, are you sure about that OP?

SkiingIsHeaven · 27/10/2021 00:12

If describing someone as black is racist, is describing someone as a woman or man, sexist?

Are you ageist if you say someone is young or old?

Get a grip.

AllTheWorldIsGreen · 27/10/2021 00:10

This thread is really stupid and I am black.

TableFlowerss · 27/10/2021 00:05

@PetriDisher

"Hey, colleague, did you meet Cantthinkofaname in yesterday's meeting?"

"I'm not sure, who is that?"

"The head of marketing"

"I'm not sure, I didn't catch job titles but I did stare at everyone for two hours over Zoom! Can you describe them to me?"

"Umm...the older (ageist) black (racist) lady (sexist) who wears glasses (sightist) and uses a wheelchair (ableist)...

...
...
...

No."

Absolutely nailed it!!!!