Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Why aren’t you obese?

961 replies

Spottyphonecase24 · 26/10/2021 14:11

A bit of a weird one but I have just got off a zoom call with my therapist. We were talking about my weight (I am obese).

Why isn’t everyone else obese? What stops you? I don’t seem to have an off button. I remember going from a 10 to a 12 and thinking that’s it I’m not going to get any bigger but I did and now I am in a size 24 and they are getting a bit tight. I’ve read lots about how people have their light bulb moment to lose weight and that has not happened to me, or maybe it has and I’ve ignored it.

What stops you eating a tub of icecream or picking up a large bar of chocolate instead of a small one or one bag of crisps instead of a family size bag?

I honestly don’t know the reasons why people don’t eat more. Is it will power, feeling full?

OP posts:
MrsAvocet · 28/10/2021 04:10

I never had any problems with my weight until I met my DH. I'd always seen food as a just a necessity but he is from a family where it's a big social thing. Well, from a country where that's more often the case than in the UK I think. Food is definitely associated with love and comfort in DH's family whereas in mine it was just fuel. We tend to follow more of his family's habits and I started eating more and gaining weight, gradually (over 15 years or so) going up from a 6-8 to 14-16. Hitting 16 was my lightbulb moment. Until then I had kidded myself that I was ok - size 14 is average - despite my BMI being in the obese range. I've lost nearly 3 stone over the last couple of years but put a few pounds back on recently, mainly comfort eating as a lot of stressful stuff has happened. I need to get back on the wagon really. I had managed to re educate myself back into my original healthy eating habits but have slipped back into some less healthy choices latterly.

rive · 28/10/2021 03:23

The only thing that has worked for me is a calorie diary. After every snack or meal I write down the calorie value in my notebook. I know that if I consume more than 1200 calories a day I will not lose weight. Over 1300 and I'll gain. I've heard that, if you can measure it, you an control it, and it works for weight.

PyongyangKipperbang · 28/10/2021 03:07

@JFM27

As a naturally slim person who hss always been a 6/8 i find it unbeliveable you went from a 10 to 24. If i started needing a 10 i would take a long hard look at my diet.Personally i dont eat biscuits cake,pastry or fast food..i power walk everyday.Ive always been very self controlled can eat i square of chocolate half glass wine etc in fact if eat too much i feel bloated and unfit, Perhaps thats what has kept me slim.i was an only child so my mum could always afford to give me healthy food in days when suet dumplings and stodge were normal in peoples diets l so i never ate stodgy food ever.She gave me what i wanted the med diet before it was invented.lol .
Well thank you for being so sneery but yes people can, for whatever reason put on a lot of weight. A lot of people eat to get through bad times or stress or whatever. I went from a 10 to a 22 for a variety of reasons including several close in time pregnancies. and went back to a 8/10 due to stress as I am the opposite of a comfort eater, I lost my appetite completely.

So just because you think it wouldnt happen to you doesnt mean that it doesnt happen to anyone Hmm Oh and FYI my size 6 DD is now an 18 thanks to the side effects of the medication she needs for a serious chronic condition, so dont be too smug yeah? There but for the grace of god go us all.....

JFM27 · 27/10/2021 23:53

As a naturally slim person who hss always been a 6/8 i find it unbeliveable you went from a 10 to 24. If i started needing a 10 i would take a long hard look at my diet.Personally i dont eat biscuits cake,pastry or fast food..i power walk everyday.Ive always been very self controlled can eat i square of chocolate half glass wine etc in fact if eat too much i feel bloated and unfit, Perhaps thats what has kept me slim.i was an only child so my mum could always afford to give me healthy food in days when suet dumplings and stodge were normal in peoples diets l so i never ate stodgy food ever.She gave me what i wanted the med diet before it was invented.lol
.

Kate0902900908 · 27/10/2021 23:52

Truth is I never could control myself. Never had a lightbulb moment when I stopped over eating and things just gradually got worse until I was 20st.
I made the decision 1 year ago to go abroad after doing a lot of research and have a full gastric bypass. Before bypass I had type 2 diabetes, chronic psoriasis and felt generally sluggish and poorly. 1 year on I don’t crave food, I eat normal amounts that I’m satisfied with, I don’t crave sugar, I no longer have diabetes and don’t take any medication. No skin problems of any kind and after 11 years of trying I’m pregnant.
It was the best thing I ever did and I am so happy I did. It wasn’t easy I did struggle to adjust but when you have no choice and that option to over eating is taken away you adapt quickly.
10at lighter and 100x happier! X

Why aren’t you obese?
Judystilldreamsofhorses · 27/10/2021 23:44

I started reading this thread last night and have come back to it now - really interesting reading.

I’m at the top end of “normal” BMI at the moment after 18 months of working from home - I’m about 5lb up on my “fighting weight” and don’t like it. It’s been a mixture of too much wine, sitting at the kitchen table instead of being on my feet all the time in actual work, and food being a “nice thing” during a difficult time.

Usually I operate on a kind of 80/20 basis - no treats except at the weekend. We eat healthy ,eats but have got into a bad habit of something sweet after dinner, and a couple of biscuits mid-afternoon when I have never been a snacker previously.

My DP is away with work for a fortnight next month and I am planning for a bit of a “reset”. Soups, eggs, chicken, veg - no junk. I find it much easier to do this without him here, as he’s 6ft 5 and needs proper meals, and cooking separate things is a faff.

So I guess the answer to the question is vanity. I am not up a dress size, but some of my waist bands feel tight, and I really don’t want to be buying a new wardrobe in the next size up.

cakeallday · 27/10/2021 23:44

For me I think not becoming overweight is down to:

  1. portion control (knowing what is the right amount for me, I don't mean it's dictated by a diet plan or something)
  2. stopping eating as soon as I'm full, I have always hated the feeling of overeating
  3. having a reasonable amount of treats in one go, eg. three biscuits not the whole packet

I eat whatever I like but nothing to excess if you see what I mean. I deny myself nothing and live by "a BIT of what you fancy does you good".

However if I wasn't so physically active I wouldn't be able to eat as much as I do and get away with it.

Buggritbuggrit · 27/10/2021 23:44

This is going to sound silly, but - while I have always understood that a lot of people struggle with food/their relationship to food - I had no idea it was this widespread. Or this constant.

This has been an eye opening thread, so thank you.

Fatflump · 27/10/2021 23:41

SOME of it starts in childhood. But let's not assume all fat people fat parents/parents who couldn't cook/ etc.

Neither of my parents were overweight, my mum in particular lived on one meal a day, coffee and cigarettes. My dad occasionally gained a few pounds and did a week of just black coffee and consommé til he was back to his usual weight.

Both my parents were also excellent cooks, my dad in fact worked as a chef for a few years. We used to have icecream occasionally; a Viennetta would be split into 6 or 9 portions.

However love and care was shown through food. If I went to my grandmothers house she'd make me huge plates of fresh crusty bread and butter. If you were happy - have something nice to eat. If you're sad, food will cheer you up. If you've done well at school, lets have a treat to celebrate.

I was a chubby child, not fat exactly but not thin. In my teens I got into a pattern of eating 1 meal a day, and that kept my weight in check.

In my early 20s my parents died, and I ended up in an abusive relationship. where food really was my only comfort. He would abuse me about overeating which in turn made me eat more.

If my parents were still alive, I would never have ended up the size I am now. I know how sad it would make them.

poppymaewrite · 27/10/2021 23:38

Everyone’s body reacts differently to food. Maybe when you eat sugar, your body has a more extreme reaction. Maybe higher blood sugar spike, maybe your brain produces more dopamine. Everyone telling you that they just have more self control is talking bollocks, a lot of people hardly put effort into not being obese, it’s just their nature!

Ddot · 27/10/2021 23:37

I now watch my weight by eating healthy mostly veg as sadly I cant tolerate much fruit. I'm gluten sensitive and struggle with alot of foods, especially high calorific and sugary stuff. I will always have problems with eating now but still have those bloody chunky legs.

cadburyegg · 27/10/2021 23:32

I have always been self conscious about my weight. I remember being 12 years old thinking my thighs were too big. But I have a very sweet tooth and go through stages where I think "fuck it" and don't have a lot of willpower. Being pregnant and having babies didn't help. After DS2 was born 3.5 years ago my BMI was 32.7, so in the obese range. The first 2 stone came off fairly quickly and I've battled and just about got another 1.5 stone off. My BMI is 24 now and I'm sort of average, a size 12, not thin or fat. I'd like to lose another stone then I'll be slim, I think.

Several reasons I guess. Vanity, health, but also I run now and that's a huge incentive because I feel much fitter and more able to look after my children as a result. I can run after them if they run off, i don't get breathless playing with them in the garden etc. When I was fat being a parent was much harder. I got breathless more easily, I was more tired. I sleep better now. I might not be thin but I'm definitely fitter than I ever have been, an example being one day last week I'd only had 5hours sleep but did a 5k run.

What has helped me not put weight back on is partly accepting that I will have to be aware of it for the rest of my life and keep an eye on it, and not overindulge too often. Once I finally accepted healthy eating is a lifelong thing rather than just a temporary thing to lose weight then it becomes much easier I think.

Idiotbasher · 27/10/2021 23:28

This thread is exactly what I need right now to help thank you Flowers

Ddot · 27/10/2021 23:22

I dieted for thirty odd years, I am an emotional eater or was! I managed to keep it in a ball park area. I ranged from size 10 to 12 from the age of 14 to 46.
I became Ill and was sent home, with instructions to put as much weight on in three weeks as I could.
10 pounds! Hows that for greedy.

MagpieMary · 27/10/2021 23:22

I think so much of how you eat and attitudes to food start in childhood. Sweet ‘treats’, having to finish everything on your plate, having a mother who could cook or not cook ( always the mother usually). I was brought up eating three meals a day and no snacks. We never had biscuits or cake in the house. No desserts. My mother was an awful cook. So I ate far too much at school even though the food was awful, because it was better than the food I had at home.
As a teenager I became obsessed with calories, and lost a lot of weight. I then had iron clad control over what I ate and stayed slim . Then it all went to pot gradually with pregnancies, as I didn’t apply the same rules to what I ate.
I realise now that I eat far too much. What I eat is generally very healthy. I don’t like fatty foods or junk food. I’m not bothered about crisps and chocolate. However my portion sizes are far too big and I’m greedy. In our society we have lost sight of what a normal portion size is. We have food on tap and we don’t recognise hunger. Everything has become very disordered.
Better to eat small portions and not snack. Eat un processed food and lots of veg and fruit. Drink loads of water. Cut out alcohol as much as possible. Exercise daily and don’t sit on the sofa too much. That’s the recipe for being slim and staying that way. We’ve lost the ability to live like that , most of us.
Food is also not the same as it once was. It’s filled with additives and sugar and grown in unnatural ways. It’s imported or shipped long distances and stored for long periods. We don’t eat seasonally, and what we eat is not fresh or unadulterated.
Wheat has been messed around with so that it isn’t digestible and causes bloating and allergies.

People used to grown their own veg and sometimes fruit much more often. They bought small amounts of food from the corner shop which weren’t stored for long periods. They cooked from scratch and ate smaller meals. They walked more and moved around much more. Women didn’t drink alcohol nearly as often, if at all. Our whole culture has changed.

TheBullfinch · 27/10/2021 23:17

Eating too much makes me feel sick, heavy, sluggish and bloated, so if I really want something sweet/fatty/'bad' I'll have a bite not a bowl. Then I dont have to deal with all the above, plus weight gain, muffin top, back fat, tight waistbands etc.. I also dislike how I look when I'm overweight as I get square, not curvy.

I suppose I just hate feeling uncomfortable so I do everything I can to avoid feeling like that.

Rosesareyellow · 27/10/2021 23:13

What stops you eating a tub of icecream or picking up a large bar of chocolate instead of a small one or one bag of crisps instead of a family size bag?

Nothing… I do some of those things. But I’m not obese because I don’t do them regularly. Because I don’t want to get obese. Or overweight. That’s what stops me 🤷‍♀️ I’m generally also satisfied by a small bag of crisps and the like - I know a massive portion of indulgent food will make my stomach feel like crap.
I understand most people don’t want to be obese but I’m guessing in that moment of binge eating you have the ‘fuck it, I don’t care’ moment? I don’t have that moment. I’m guessing if you’re obese you also don’t feel fullness in the way you should - massive bag of crisps would make me feel full and bloated. If you don’t have that feeling it must be very difficult to get on track.

dustofneptune · 27/10/2021 23:12

For me it's two things.

The first is that I have a kind of "buffer" range for my weight, where I know I'm happy and comfortable. If my weight goes outside of that range, I take it as a sign to sort it out. Sorting out can take ages. But it just makes me aware. It's so easy for me to gain weight when I'm not paying attention and making less than stellar lifestyle choices.

The other thing is eating whole, unprocessed foods. No processed foods, refined sugar, etc.

When I do this, I lose all cravings for junk food within a few weeks.

When I fall off the wagon / "treat" myself, the cravings come back.

Basically, the only way I eat healthily is to not have junk in the house, period. If it's there, I'll eat it.

I don't think it's as simple as a choice, though. If obesity was just down to making the choice to eat healthily and be aware of your weight, nobody would be obese. I think it's more complicated. But I hope some of the comments help you.

IggleyP · 27/10/2021 23:01

I eat a lot of sugary food as snacks - but I don’t eat big portions at main meals, which is probably why I get away with it calorie wise.

Also, I don’t eat meals at set times or think I need three meals a day. Sometimes I skip breakfast and just have two bowls of cereal as my food that day. Other times I’ll have days where I am really into cooking and eat lots and lots or go out for lunch dinner and eat a couple of courses and way over my daily calorie needs - but then have days of not being hungry again really. When I’ve used my fitness pal to track calories I can see the pattern there.

And it doesn’t always have to be a proper meal - if I fancy just a steak on its own mid morning then I’ll have it, in the same way I’ll have a cream tea for dinner if I fancy it. Sounds a bit haphazard but it seems to work as I have also been what people describe as “naturally slim”, although since 40 the weight has started to creep on, meaning I am currently a size12 and know I need to move more and cut down on the sugary stuff if I want to lose weight. I’m not motivated enough at the moment but I won’t get any bigger as I will cut down if I need to.

And no “diet” foods. Full cream milk, butter, cheese etc, as it’s nicer so I am much less likely to crave something else afterwards as I feel like I’ve had treat already.

Fatflump · 27/10/2021 23:00

Losing weight is easier than keeping it off.

3 years ago I lost 7st. I was BMI normal for the first time in nearly 20 years.

I put 6 stone back on since March 2020 because of working from home and not being able to exercise. And eating all the foods I have to avoid in order to lose weight.

I'm now again trying to lose it but I'm too fat to do much exercise at the moment.

Jewel52 · 27/10/2021 22:55

Tbh binge eating at the level you’re describing is a mental health/emotional issue and you’re not going to solve this with dietary advice. You need to understand what function food is fulfilling in your life and then find ways to replace it. Trying to diet and it not working out puts you in that vicious cycle of feeling a failure and emotionally eating more for comfort. This isn’t your fault, nasty junk food is marketed everywhere and, culturally, we’re not great at healthy living. And bollocks to anyone who berates you for being overweight, says more about them than you! Good luck 💐

Sleeplessem · 27/10/2021 22:50

@Idony

It doesn't occur to me. I would no more eat an entire tub of ice cream than I would lick a door handle or burst into song on a crowded train. I don't deem it a normal thing to do.
That’s the same for me. I can sit down with a pint of ice cream and have some and think oh this is nice, eat some, get bored and put it away for later.

Same with a big bag of crisps/ chocolate (although I’ve never bought a big bag of crisps or family bag of chocolate In my life with the intention of eating it alone ). Wouldn’t finish a pack of biscuits, might have 3/4 rich teas with a cuppa here and there or 2 chocolate digestives but I’d never want to eat the whole pack. Controversial but I also don’t think commercially bought snacks actually taste that good.

I think the binge mentality comes from the value put on foods, ie chocolate is a naughty food and must only be a treat, so it sort of triggers this binge mentality and then when you’ve started down that path it’s v easy to think oh well, I’ve eaten a lot now might as well carry on.

GoodbyePorpoiseSpit · 27/10/2021 22:49

@Ddot I’m sad to read about your shorts! All that negative thinking about your body :( those legs might seem chubby to someone enmeshed in diet culture and ideals of thinness but they have served you well since birth and carry you from A to B! Marvel in them and give yourself some love!

TatianaBis · 27/10/2021 22:47

I’m not lucky I’m lazy and there are other ways of balance your food intake without going anywhere near calories.

aimzxd · 27/10/2021 22:43

10 stone 🙈