Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Why aren’t you obese?

961 replies

Spottyphonecase24 · 26/10/2021 14:11

A bit of a weird one but I have just got off a zoom call with my therapist. We were talking about my weight (I am obese).

Why isn’t everyone else obese? What stops you? I don’t seem to have an off button. I remember going from a 10 to a 12 and thinking that’s it I’m not going to get any bigger but I did and now I am in a size 24 and they are getting a bit tight. I’ve read lots about how people have their light bulb moment to lose weight and that has not happened to me, or maybe it has and I’ve ignored it.

What stops you eating a tub of icecream or picking up a large bar of chocolate instead of a small one or one bag of crisps instead of a family size bag?

I honestly don’t know the reasons why people don’t eat more. Is it will power, feeling full?

OP posts:
Joystir59 · 28/10/2021 10:20

Less aches and pains, feel good about how I look in clothes. Also I have to say that people take me much more seriously as a person when I'm slim. I do think that obese people get judged instinctively. I think it's a bit how we regard any kind of obvious addiction- there is a subconscious (and unfair) tendency to judge the person as being out of control.

Pigeonpocket · 28/10/2021 10:19

Eat instinctively doesn't work if you're already overweight either. To lose weight you generally need to eat fewer calories than your body needs so it burns fat instead. Eating instinctively means you eat as much food as your body needs, so you will at best maintain your weight and most likely gain weight. It's fine as a way to eat if you're already a healthy weight. I don't know why people say it's a good weight loss method.

Joystir59 · 28/10/2021 10:17

The worst time for me was when I was working with a dietician. "Eat instinctively" doesn't work if you have hormone issues. That's the most weight I ever put on
Eating instinctively doesn't work for me either. I have to consciously manage my relationship with food. The pay off of having to consciously manage that relationship is well worth the effort,- just having one size of clothes in my wardrobe, being light on my feet, less a

frumpety · 28/10/2021 10:16

Once I finally accepted healthy eating is a lifelong thing rather than just a temporary thing to lose weight then it becomes much easier I think.

Completely agree with this ^

I found once I cut back on the processed carbs which was the majority of my diet in the past, my appetite changed dramatically, I just don't feel hungry in the same way. It probably helps that I drink a lot more fluids too, so no longer confuse dehydration and hunger signals.
I have the odd day when I am busy and get to 6pm and realise I haven't eaten anything, which is fine for me because my body still has a huge amount of reserves to tap into, my very slim friend would be chewing her own arm off because she needs to get all her calories from food.
I sometimes spend a few weeks plateauing around the same weight. In the past I would have seen this as a sign of failure and would have promptly dived headfirst into a big carbfest of sabotage ! I would then have blamed the 'diet' and not the fact that I had stopped. Instead I have accepted that to get to where I want to be weight wise, it will probably take me a year to 18 months and that there will be times when the scales won't move.

Whatiswrongwithmyknee · 28/10/2021 10:12

The worst time for me was when I was working with a dietician. "Eat instinctively" doesn't work if you have hormone issues. That's the most weight I ever put on

Agree. When I did that, I got to be the biggest I've ever been and clearly in the obese range. Instinctively led to an awful lot of chips and mcflurries.

Joystir59 · 28/10/2021 10:07

Part of maintaining a healthy weight for me, having lost 4 st two years ago, has been accepting that I will always have a dysfunctional.relationship with food. There is an inner unhelpful voice that says things such as ' you are really skinny now, you need to feed yourself up' or 'yiincan eat what you like, eat intuitively, you are naturally slim'. I am in my true self a slim person, but there is always a fat person trying to get out. I'm very unhappy when I'm fat. I look drowned in fat, when some people still look very attractive and voluptuous, and I feel so I healthy, heavy and unfit. It depresses me and makes life harder to cope with. I'm determined I'm not going there again having yoyo'd between size 10 and 20 all my adult life. I'm 64, I can't afford to do that any more. The irony is I love all the food that is good for you. I've learnt to nourish myself not kill myself with food.

orinocosfavoritecake · 28/10/2021 09:47

Always eaten whatever I wanted. Weight stays around top end of healthy BMI whether I exercise and eat healthy stuff or live off chocolate and pizza. I’m okay with that.

It’s not about will power or being a good person. It’s about luck and circumstances.

JonSnowIsALoser · 28/10/2021 09:46

Bad news - I'm not obese because my grandma and my dad, whom I take after, have always been skinny, so part of it is down to genes.

I don't drive, but walk or cycle everywhere instead. No other regular exercise to speak of.

Despite the genes and lots of walking, when menopause hit the pounds round the waist started appearing out of nowhere. The only way to keep them under control was to shift my eating times - big breakfast, big lunch, and a small nibble at about 5pm. No food afterwards. All the extra pounds are now gone and it's amazing how quickly you get used to the new eating routine. I make exceptions to late eating if out with family or friends for dinner.

That's pretty much it.

Comedycook · 28/10/2021 09:26

@poppymaewrite

Everyone’s body reacts differently to food. Maybe when you eat sugar, your body has a more extreme reaction. Maybe higher blood sugar spike, maybe your brain produces more dopamine. Everyone telling you that they just have more self control is talking bollocks, a lot of people hardly put effort into not being obese, it’s just their nature!
Yeah interesting. My paternal side of the family has a very eat to live mentality. I remember hanging out with my cousin's...their mum had cupboards full of sweets, chocolate and crisps but my cousin's barely touched them. Or if they did, they'd have one and leave the rest. My sister andi were the opposite...if it was there, we'd eat it. I remember our cousin keeping her easter eggs for months before shed open them...we would ea them as soon as we got them. My mother's side of the family are very much live to eat kind of people and I take after them.
ehb102 · 28/10/2021 09:23

I'll answer your questions from my point of view.
(1) I have lipoedema. It's a fat disorder that ten per cent of women have
(2) I have an under-active thyroid and Hashimoto's syndrome.
(3) The treatment I got as a fat girl made me terrified of being hungry
(4) I wasn't active, not in the raise your heart rate way that makes a difference to weight.
(5) I didn't know what worked for me in terms of nutrition, and that includes calorie control.

Once I addressed the medical issues and the trauma I was STILL FAT. Not obese, I lost all my loseable weight. I still look like a photo from a Daily Fail article about obesity (except I have a head). I am now incredibly knowledgeable about foot and physical training as they apply to me, I wasn't twenty years ago.

The worst time for me was when I was working with a dietician. "Eat instinctively" doesn't work if you have hormone issues. That's the most weight I ever put on.

Duckrace · 28/10/2021 09:15

I think claim to need "a long hard look" at your diet if going from a 6/8 to 10 is nearer to anorexic behaviour than anything else.

Maggiejardine · 28/10/2021 09:13

Most of the replies suggest OPs have found ways of regulating their weight/eating which works for them. I do think this is an individual thing but speaking as a morbidly obese person I haven’t found one yet! I seem to summon up the motivation and willpower to lose 3-4 stone which I have done but I just can’t sustain it long enough to get to a healthy weight and the pounds gradually go back on. So I sympathise, you are not alone but I don’t have any answers sorry

Sparklybanana · 28/10/2021 09:08

I don't eat particularly healthily but I don't think I generally eat enough to be obese. I don't eat a lot of takeaways and dinners are vegetable heavy if I'm hungry. I do like pudding but I'll eat 1 chocolate bar or a yoghurt rather than a proper dessert.

cricketmum84 · 28/10/2021 08:56

I was a size 24-36. I had the "lightbulb moment" after a photo on holiday. Not sure how I hadn't realised how big I got!

I've lost just over 12 stone in 2 years and am in the healthy weight category now.

I was helped along by a diabetes diagnosis earlier this year so eat a very low carb and low sugar diet to manage my sugar levels which has lent itself very nicely to the last bit I needed to lose!

browneyes77 · 28/10/2021 08:48

I am the opposite of a comfort eater, I lost my appetite completely.

Same here! When I’m stressed or anxious, my central nervous system goes into overdrive and I lose my appetite completely.

MsTSwift · 28/10/2021 08:11

Sounds mad but use smaller plates. Simple way to reduce portion size.

I could eat what I wanted when younger never even had scales but was told at my age 45 medical I was officially overweight. Spurred me on to lose 2 stone which I have kept off. Bmi 22 happy with that. I love wine crisps and cake but have in moderation. IF works for me. In the week eat between 12 - 8.

ilovechocolate07 · 28/10/2021 07:55

Honestly, I'm not partly because although I can graze all day if I want to, I do get full/uncomfortable and don't like that feeling and more importantly it's psychological. I have obese family and cannot let that happen to me. I'm teetering on the cusp of overweight and I hate it. I feel happier when I'm slimmer so I cut out and calorie count to lose which is a struggle.

BustyLaRoux · 28/10/2021 07:54

A couple of things to add to my earlier post:

  1. I did IF for several years. I did lose weight and more than I meant to. And I kept it off doing this. But I did bring about some bulimic behaviours which were already present, but latent, if that makes sense. It can be very effective. But the restricting can also bring on eating disorders. Not in everyone obviously. I didn’t know this when I started. Hadn’t really researched it. Just saw my in Laws doing it and seeing it had worked for them. I had some baby weight to lose so I gave it a shot. Like I say I stuck with it on and off for 7 years. I think it created issues for me which have been difficult to overcome. Anyone doing this should research it properly and be quite sure it’s right for them.
  2. Someone on page 32 I think said there is no such thing as ‘emotional eating, it’s just eating!’ This is an entirely uninformed and unhelpful thing to say. Emotional eating can be anything from snacking unnecessarily when bored - which is so easy to do working from home all day every day, to stress eating and reaching for comfort food when there is emotional pain. The best way of overcoming this is to understand your triggers so you can recognise them as they are happening, to not have comfort food to hand (although you can emotionally eat any food, it doesn’t have to be comfort food. And you can’t rid your house of ALL food!), to really understand why people emotionally eat (upbringing, thinking of food as “treat” or “reward” and using it to make us feel better when we feel shit), developing strategies which can relieve boredom, stress, anxiety…whatever is your trigger feeling. It isn’t helpful to say ‘emotional eating is just.. eating!’ This has shame attached to it. Like you’re just a gluttonous pig who needs to get a grip of themselves. And shaming isn’t going to help you feel motivated or in control. If anything feeling shame has many people reaching for the comfort food (“it’s hopeless, I’m just a fat pig, might as well cheer myself up with this ice cream”) Please don’t listen to that. You can overcome emotional eating and it certainly does exist!!
Mollymoostoo · 28/10/2021 07:45

It sounds like you need to examine why you are not able to control the urge to eat and what food is fulfilling for you. It could be boredom, using food as a reward, comfort eating or actual hunger. Ruling out any medical conditions, then keeping a food and mood diary for a week, examine links between the situation, how you feel and what you eat can help you see what is going on.
Once you understand the why, you can figure out the how.
My daughter is overweight in part due to medication but she also choosing to eat unhealthy food for various reasons. Unless she addresses this she won't change.
There are websites that offer treated food journals but look at this as a long term thing as it won't be a quick fix. Wishing you all the best.

LaDamaDeElche · 28/10/2021 07:26

Some of it is genetics, as I go through stages of snacking a lot and don't really put on weight. I eat very healthy meals and don't go for big portions and I also exercise, so that definitely helps.

Cozytoesandtoast00 · 28/10/2021 07:23

loveyouradvice
Op I think she means Gin Stephens.
But yes l agree IF has really worked for me.
It re-sets your full signal. I fast by not eating until lunchtime.
I really believe giving up sugar really helps with avoiding the pain of food cravings. Yes it hurts to start off with but is easy after a period of about two weeks. Moderation is not always possible for some people that are obese. So just make it easier for yourself and take out sugar.
I was a previous binge eater btw

MimiDaisy11 · 28/10/2021 07:22

I feel gross if I eat lots of unhealthy food - that stops me and the feeling of it - especially if fried. I also think about the health benefits of healthy food and what benefits it has.

Beautybunny · 28/10/2021 06:06

I have been an 8 and a 22 in my adult life. My natural size is probably a 14 as I am tall. If I am unhappy I will eat until I pop. I now drink heavily due to stress and bullying at work. I don't do sweets, cakes etc but love cheese and wine. I have just ended up in hospital due to a long term illness and I am going to wfh for the next few weeks and try to get some help. I have never had a therapist but am going to get one privately. I was abused as a child, have a daughter with MH issues and hated people staring at my huge chest when I was a teenager, best be fat and they won't bother me. TBH a bindge makes me feel better. I spend huge amounts on imported designer clothes when I know I can loose weight. Food and drink is an addiction for me. I feel embarrassed every day about my size as I work in the beauty industry. I also have a nutrition qualification. Means nowt if you can't control the urges.

BobISMyUncle · 28/10/2021 05:41

I don't now if this will help, or hinder. I am naturally a small person. 4' 11" and about 7 stone, wringing wet, on a good day with the wind behind me. I can't help it. My school life was miserable. Apparently, I'm quite active. I am not!! Why walk, when you have a car? My exercise regime is ... I don't have an exercise regime, of any sort. I don't eat processed food. I don't like the taste of McDonald stuff. I don't eat takeaway food, I don't like the taste. I cook, from scratch, so I know what goes into my food. I don't add salt, to anything, ever. Only because, when I first learned to cook, I consistently forgot to add salt.
You would not believe the shit that my poor husband ate! He never raised an eyebrow at my salty rice. Uncle Ben DOES bloody stick! I try to have fresh vegetables, always. And "picky" fruit, i.e. berry fruits.
And here I am. 63 years old.

You can do this! I can't help doing it. I am not being unkind, I promise. My cholestorol level is 2.6. I don't even know what that means. I can only advise, do not eat processed food

MrsJamesBondi · 28/10/2021 04:14

Haven’t RTWT, seen a few judging posts ..I’m currently very fat. Brought on by medication over the last two years. I’m a size 18-20.

I’ve gained four stone in weight. I don’t snack, eat takeaways, drink calories, eat more than a couple of biscuits a week. Getting fatter has been a real eye opener as to how it makes daily life harder in all respects.

I don’t have an unhealthy relationship with food or an unhealthy diet or problems with portion control, just medication with weight gain as side effects x 2.

The world is a fairly judgmental place when you’re fat.