Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Why aren’t you obese?

961 replies

Spottyphonecase24 · 26/10/2021 14:11

A bit of a weird one but I have just got off a zoom call with my therapist. We were talking about my weight (I am obese).

Why isn’t everyone else obese? What stops you? I don’t seem to have an off button. I remember going from a 10 to a 12 and thinking that’s it I’m not going to get any bigger but I did and now I am in a size 24 and they are getting a bit tight. I’ve read lots about how people have their light bulb moment to lose weight and that has not happened to me, or maybe it has and I’ve ignored it.

What stops you eating a tub of icecream or picking up a large bar of chocolate instead of a small one or one bag of crisps instead of a family size bag?

I honestly don’t know the reasons why people don’t eat more. Is it will power, feeling full?

OP posts:
strivingtosucceed · 28/10/2021 22:09

@BlibBlabBlob

I don't have an off button either. So I gave myself an actual on/off button by taking up intermittent fasting.

I don't make good food choices. Prone to bingeing and not being able to stop once I start eating.

So (except for right now, because I have COVID and it doesn't feel right to fast so much) I have an eating window of 4-6 hours per day. Outside of that, I'm Not Eating. Black coffee and water only. So I don't have to make any food choices at all and there is literally a button on an app on my phone that says I am Not Eating.

Then, in my eating window (which I have in the evening), I don't have to restrict at all. I eat what I want. Sometimes I make good healthy choices, sometimes I don't. But it's enough to keep me reasonably healthy, and a healthy BMI too.

I am convinced that if I didn't have this particular lifestyle, if I tried to start eating every morning with a 'healthy' breakfast etc, I would just keep eating all day and I would become obese eventually.

What I do probably isn't entirely healthy either (not the intermittent fasting - that's been proven to be very good for people, but the fact that I have to hit the 'stop' button on all food instead of eating intuitively). But it's the best way I've found to not think about food all the time and not eat all the time. Because actually, eating all the time and especially eating a lot of junk food just makes me feel rubbish.

This is exactly why I started IF. I AM obese though only for my height as i'm a solid size 12. I have no off button because for some reason I LOVE eating. I eat myself silly sometimes until I feel physically sick (TW i'm a former bulimic so I did make myself sick till I managed to find a way through).

I saw the way my weight was going so decided to only eat 2ce a day and within certain hours so I could manage it. Now I work from home and do no exercise and have managed to keep stable at the 7 or so Kg I gained during lockdown for months now.

At the end of the day OP you need SOME discipline, whether it's to not buy junk food, or portion control, or calorie counting, or fasting or even hiring a chef/meal service to deliver your meals. You have to take responsibility for your weight and find the method that works for you. There is no magic switch.

Kitkat151 · 28/10/2021 21:59

@WouldBeGood

I allowed 1900 a day for weight loss 😱
I would gain weight eating 1900 calories a day...I expect you are younger and fitter than me though😁
WouldBeGood · 28/10/2021 21:43

I allowed 1900 a day for weight loss 😱

rive · 28/10/2021 21:40

Of course I meant to say a calorie total of 1200 - 1300 per day, not per meal. I was hoping I'd make it back to the site to clarify, if I had made the omission, but I didn't make it in time.

cricketmum84 · 28/10/2021 21:30

[quote beautifullymad]**@cricketmum84* @MagpieMary*

I use a loaf tin liner in a bread tin as I like a deep quiche.

I make it to eye so it's all approximate.

First finely slice onions, I use two large. And sauté them until cooked. This takes ages.

Whist they are cooking tip one cup of ground almonds straight into the liner with salt &pepper. Then drizzle it with olive oil and use a fork to mix. Pat it down firmly using something flat. I use the underside of my cup measure.
Into an oven on 180 for a quick 10 mins. Turn oven down to 60 once you remove the tin.

Chop smoky bacon or left over gammon and fry this off in the sauté pan after the onion.

Grate whatever cheese you have. Approx two cups of grated cheese.

6 large eggs or 7-8 small eggs beaten with salt, pepper, onion powder and 100-150ml double cream.

Layer onions, cheese and bacon and repeat. Then pour over the egg and cream mixture.

In a low oven (60) until it's cooked through by testing with a knife. It takes a good while, I'd say check after 30 mins but usually it's longer. You can open a bit up from the top to check if the egg has set all the way through.

Once cooked, lift out and allow to cool.

It's very low carb and feels like a delicious treat mid afternoon .
[/quote]
Sounds absolutely gorgeous! Thank you!

WouldBeGood · 28/10/2021 21:08

@Ddot that sounds brilliant

Ddot · 28/10/2021 20:54

You can make pastryless quiche, mix eggs with cottage cheese. Add whatever you like bacon tomato caramelized onion, put in greased deep dish and top with strong cheese. Its really delicious, I'm a bit sensitive to wheat so like this alot

MagpieMary · 28/10/2021 20:22

I’m drooling! Thank you!

beautifullymad · 28/10/2021 20:14

@cricketmum84 @MagpieMary

I use a loaf tin liner in a bread tin as I like a deep quiche.

I make it to eye so it's all approximate.

First finely slice onions, I use two large. And sauté them until cooked. This takes ages.

Whist they are cooking tip one cup of ground almonds straight into the liner with salt &pepper. Then drizzle it with olive oil and use a fork to mix. Pat it down firmly using something flat. I use the underside of my cup measure.
Into an oven on 180 for a quick 10 mins. Turn oven down to 60 once you remove the tin.

Chop smoky bacon or left over gammon and fry this off in the sauté pan after the onion.

Grate whatever cheese you have. Approx two cups of grated cheese.

6 large eggs or 7-8 small eggs beaten with salt, pepper, onion powder and 100-150ml double cream.

Layer onions, cheese and bacon and repeat. Then pour over the egg and cream mixture.

In a low oven (60) until it's cooked through by testing with a knife. It takes a good while, I'd say check after 30 mins but usually it's longer. You can open a bit up from the top to check if the egg has set all the way through.

Once cooked, lift out and allow to cool.

It's very low carb and feels like a delicious treat mid afternoon .

Idontbelieveit14 · 28/10/2021 19:40

I also know exactly how to lose weight I lost 5 and a half stone a few years ago. I resent people who have never had a weight problem telling us it’s as easy as eating less and moving more 🙄

Idontbelieveit14 · 28/10/2021 19:39

I wish I had the answer, I’m obese too. Bigger than I’ve ever been. I hate myself and the way I look, but then I just seem to eat more because I’m miserable.

Sunnysideup999 · 28/10/2021 19:33

Eat when hungry. Stop when full. Don’t eat junk or lots of sugar. Keep Reasonably active.
Our bodies should regulate themselves . It’s about listening carefully to what your body is telling you .

HarryDresdensLeatherDuster · 28/10/2021 19:17

This reply has been deleted

Message deleted by MNHQ. Here's a link to our Talk guidelines.

PeriChristmas · 28/10/2021 19:08

@Arkestra

Some interesting answers here. For what it's worth, my take is:
  1. The first step - and first major achievement - is making up your mind to try losing weight. Just doing making that decision, and doing what you can to follow through on it, is a great thing and a victory, even if you don't get where you want as fast as you want.
  2. Willpower is a finite resource. A regime that is constantly involving you in a struggle against hunger is not likely to succeed over the long term. This is the most important thing to keep in mind - a daily struggle is not sustainable. Do whatever you can to help yourself out here. Be kind to yourself. Try to set yourself up to win, not to struggle.
  3. A pound of fat equates to around 3,500 calories. For many people with plenty of extra weight, running a 500 calorie a day deficit does not have to involve feeling hungry, and this will lose you a pound a week without having to combat hunger and so expend your limited stock of willpower (see point 1). Your body may take a few days to adjust, but after that you may be surprised how little effort you're having to make.
  4. It's possible to lose weight faster than this (2lb a week is achievable for many) but this tends to involve a regime that is so different from the post-diet one that it's not easy to then sustain weight loss once the diet is over. I have personally found going for a slower loss rate more sustainable in the long term.
3a. There is some evidence that rapid weight loss (e.g. much over 1lb a week) will increase your body's appetite for some time afterwards, also making it harder to maintain weight loss. The evidence is still somewhat patchy here, but it's another reason to take it easy and not kill yourself on a crash diet. Slow and steady wins the race.
  1. Avoid carbs: sweets, bread, chocolate - the problem with these is that they are broken down quickly and then you are hungry again. Protein and fat fill you up for longer, so you're not using willpower to combat hunger (see point 1). And veg is great too as it will fill you up. But the more carbs you eat, the more you'll get hunger pangs kicking in. I get this is really hard if you have a sweet tooth, but it is hard for me to overstate how much difference cutting carbs makes in terms of being able to manage eating habits.
4a. Space your meals. Eat something for breakfast, lunch and dinner. This is important as it will make it a lot easier for you because you are less likely to end up ravenously hungry at any point, and so you won't have to expend so much willpower (see point 1)
  1. Avoid booze as a regular habit. Not only does it carry lots of calories in itself (600+ for a bottle of wine), it has a similar "sugar crash" effect to carbs so you end up eating more snacks as a knock-on effect unless you exert lots of willpower (see point 1)
  2. Help yourself remember what things were like before you started the diet: take "before" pictures.
  3. Keep track of your weight. I weigh myself daily and track a moving average on this website: www.fourmilab.ch/cgi-bin/HackDiet/ - a big advantage of a moving average of the kind that this website calculates is that temporary fluctuations don't overly depress you, causing a general lack of motivation and so depleting your willpower (see point 1).
7a. Fluctuations are totally par for the course, by the way. Water retention can make pounds of difference between one day and the next. Also your body has a few pounds of low-energy-density storage - glycogen rather than fat. This comes off and regains quickest. So if you slip for a day or two and a couple of pounds go back on, this isn't somehow 7,000 calories of fat that have appeared from nowhere. It's water and glycogen, and it will disappear as quickly as it came.
  1. I find that setting targets helps my motivation/willpower, as long as I am tracking progress using 7. But that may not be for everyone.
  2. Tell your friends you are dieting. Friends worth having will want to encourage and help you.
9a. If someone is trying to sabotage your self-improvement efforts, they are telling you a lot about their relationship with themselves and with you - none of it good. 10. Don't feel you have to fall in line with what others are doing. People vary enormously in their appetites and general responses to food. Genetics, deeply-learned habits, medication - all these things can have profound effects. The long term goal is to come up with a way of living that you can sustain indefinitely without constantly feeling like you are having to deny yourself all the pleasure that makes live worth living. The compromises you arrive at may be very different from those that others arrive at. 11. Small daily differences add up - for good or for bad. I put on a stone over lockdown, which I am now most of the way to losing. This weight went on over a year and a half. My daily surplus in calories was about 100 - less than half a Mars Bar.

Good luck OP. It is very easy to put on weight slowly over time and end up in a state one would never have expected to be in. But it is possible to get out of it again.

Great post indeed.
MagpieMary · 28/10/2021 18:23

Me too!

cricketmum84 · 28/10/2021 18:15

@beautifullymad I would love to hear your quiche recipe if you don't mind sharing?

beautifullymad · 28/10/2021 18:06

@gingercatsparky sorry for the delay I'd not read the updates.

We eat protein and good fats mainly. I swap in low carb bread, I get mine from either Waitrose or Lidl. I swap in cauliflower rice and low carb noodles depending on the dish.

So brunch might be boiled eggs with a slice of toast or scrambled eggs on toast. A full cooked breakfast without hash browns or baked beans is also ok. I also like kippers for breakfast.

I leave 18 hours between my last meal and my breakfast next day. In reality this is dinner at 6-7pm and brunch at 12-1 although often it's as early as 11am. This gives the body a rest from producing insulin constantly and rests the beta cells.

Dinner will be based on a protein. I very much like chicken. I swap out potato for celeriac and have lots of above ground veg and gravy. There is no limit, eat as much as you need to feel full. But that's it until brunch the next day. Below ground veg are eaten but only limited amounts as they contain more carbs.

I still enjoy a take away curry just with cauliflower rice and a popadom (5 carbs) rather than rice and nann bread.

If I snack it's on nuts or home made sugar free treats. I also make a almond based quiche with cream bacon eggs and onions. This is great snack food too.

It's a very easy way to eat, and the weight really does just fall away.

Ddot · 28/10/2021 18:01

Milk chocolate has changed or my taste buds have. It seems overly sweet and tasteless and doesn't seem to melt the same.
Dark kit kats are yummy, but I only eat one stick.

PurpleDaisies · 28/10/2021 17:59

I love chocolate but I heard if you give it up, even for three weeks it taste nasty. It does it really does. I prefer dark now one piece a day and I enjoy it

This isn’t true for me. I’ve given up chocolate for lent a fair few times. I still enjoy it. I prefer crisps though.

Aria999 · 28/10/2021 17:55

@Ddot I agree about the chocolate. It mostly tastes waaay too sweet, especially cheap stuff (I am amazed to find I don't like Kit Kats any more).

I also have occasional dark chocolate only now.

TrueGrit54 · 28/10/2021 17:42

Sound advice there from Arkestra.

IsFuzzyBeagMise · 28/10/2021 17:03

Great post, Arkestra.

Ddot · 28/10/2021 16:59

Their is no go to fix, what works for one will be no good for someone else. That unfortunately is why dieting is big business. But one thing works for all and that is to get your head sorted, eat to live not live to eat. Easier said than done, of cause. Find out why you over eat,
Childhood,
Relationships,
Abuse,
Boredom,
Bullying.
The list is endless. Sit down and be honest with yourself.
Oh just remembered
I love chocolate but I heard if you give it up, even for three weeks it taste nasty. It does it really does. I prefer dark now one piece a day and I enjoy it

MidLifeResurgence74 · 28/10/2021 16:46

Apologies - I haven't read the full thread but wanted to signpost to this documentary that was quite eye-opening to me about ultra-processed food and the way in which the body responds. Something that sticks out for me is: “Eating ultra-processed food became something my brain simply tells me to do, without me even wanting it”, he says, adding this is a similar brain response to taking substances we consider classically addictive such as cigarettes, alcohol and drugs.

www.bbc.co.uk/food/articles/van_tulleken

I've been obese and lost a lot of weight (which I've maintained for five years). For those saying 'how can you let yourself get like that' truly it was gradual, then it was habitual, then it was depressing, then it was soul-destroying. I hated myself but still I ate. It's a complicated relationship and for me (with counselling) I traced it back to having been deprived of food (boarding school for 9 years) so even now, binging is my go-to to make myself feel happy.

HeadNorth · 28/10/2021 16:30

Maybe the issue isn’t that women should care less about their weight, but that men should care more. Being obese isn’t healthy, whatever sex you are.

That is a reasonable statement, but the men in my life do care about their weight. No one want to be fat. I am not sure obesity is a gendered issue.