Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Why aren’t you obese?

961 replies

Spottyphonecase24 · 26/10/2021 14:11

A bit of a weird one but I have just got off a zoom call with my therapist. We were talking about my weight (I am obese).

Why isn’t everyone else obese? What stops you? I don’t seem to have an off button. I remember going from a 10 to a 12 and thinking that’s it I’m not going to get any bigger but I did and now I am in a size 24 and they are getting a bit tight. I’ve read lots about how people have their light bulb moment to lose weight and that has not happened to me, or maybe it has and I’ve ignored it.

What stops you eating a tub of icecream or picking up a large bar of chocolate instead of a small one or one bag of crisps instead of a family size bag?

I honestly don’t know the reasons why people don’t eat more. Is it will power, feeling full?

OP posts:
Konstantine8364 · 26/10/2021 22:21

Honestly I'm not sure the posts from the people who say they couldn't eat, for example a tub of Ben and jerry's are helpful. You aren't going to be overweight as your body makes you feel sick/stops you. I can happily polish off a full tub of Ben and Jerry's after a decent sized meal and feel absolutely fine. No uncomfortableness, no sickness etc. At that point I feel full. During a normal month I probably feel full once or twice when I have a meal out/large takeaway and eat what I want. I don't ever feel full from the normal/healthy food I cook and eat daily, but I know that's what I need to eat to remain a normal weight. For me food is life, I'm hugely greedy and I love food. It's purely willpower that I don't want to be fat that keeps me a normal size. If I did any kind of intuitive eating I'd be the size of a house. But for someone who is a normal amount of hungry but maybe eats because they are bored, that can work really well.

Not-fat people come in 3 categories in my opinion. Those who aren't fussed/don't like eating much food, those who do a lot of exercise and those who restrict their food intake in some way. If you aren't type 1, you need to either find ways to restrict your food intake or exercise a lot. Food wise for some this is portion sizes, or low carb or cooking from scratch, or no snacks in the week etc. It's different for everyone. Try some lifestyle/diet changes and see what's easiest to stick to!

Kapdedhona · 26/10/2021 22:21

Also check Dr. Becky Gillaspy

Courtier · 26/10/2021 22:19

The bulimic comment was tongue in cheek btw was NOT a recommendation.

Courtier · 26/10/2021 22:19

Well I used to be bulimic so that worked for a while. As it is now I go from 8st to 9.5st every couple of years and then lose it again and repeat. Probs not the best method. I'm probably not a good person to give eating advice out. I don't keep anything like biscuits, sweets, crisps in the house. I'll eat them all if I do.

spaceghetto · 26/10/2021 22:16

I like being thin too much.

Thefartingsofaofdenmarkstreet · 26/10/2021 22:13

The 'naturally slim' people I know just aren't into food. They eat for fuel, not because they particularly enjoy eating. They can leave half a sandwich, won't even bother with things like biscuits, will just have a couple of chips off a plate and leave it at that. They just don't eat very much, they can take it or leave it.

Kapdedhona · 26/10/2021 22:11

@Spottyphonecase24
look up Jason Fung on YouTube.

For me intermittent fasting works but ever so often I forget the principles and lose the plot.

I was down to 59kg in June just with eating a balanced OMAD OR TMAD but the summer parties proved to be tricky and seemed to have gained nearly 5kg since. Desperately trying to lose it again.

I try to avoid having treats in the house but with kids it’s not that straightforward. Sometimes I designate items as for someone else so not allowed

It’s a constant battle

Good luck

Violinist64 · 26/10/2021 22:10

@OrinocoGlow

Genetics is often mentioned and there could be something in that- whether it makes you more or less pre-disposed to gain weight easily. I wonder if genetics also affects your appetite, how you react to stress or attraction to certain foods. For some people, creamy foods or sweet foods don't appeal and others crave them. I don't know the answer, just thinking having read some of the comments which show how different we all are.
I was 9 1/2 lb at birth and short so chubby from the word go. I was a short, slightly chubby (but never overweight or obese child). My mother is nearly eighty,, so born during the war and there was rationing until she was practically a teenager. She was 9 1/2 lb at birth and a chubby child. In photos of us as children, taken a little over twenty years apart, we could almost have been the same child. I lost the puppy fat as I reached my teens and was slim until I had my last child. After that, the genetic hormonal conditions kicked in and l have struggled with my weight ever since. As I said earlier, I am now at a weight and size l am happy with. My mother has struggled with her weight her entire life and both of us say that we are conscious of every mouthful we take. I think for many of us it is a case of battling against genetics and taking responsibility for ourselves, unfortunately.
DBI78 · 26/10/2021 22:08

Some people are less interested in food than others.
Some naturally like healthy foods.
Some are into health/fitness.
Some restrict diet.
Some do lots of exercise or have a hectic job/home life.
Some have a good metabolism.
Some people never feel full.
Some emotionally eat.
Some eat when bored.
Some have il health.
Also throw in age, gender, life style choices.
If you are happy and not in bad health accept yourself but if you want to change you will need to do the work x

Spidersinmyhair · 26/10/2021 22:03

I have zero desire to eat a tub of icecream or a family bag of crisps. Sounds like torture to me. I would feel so unwell. A couple of scoops of icecream is ideal. I had a normal sized bag of walker's crisps yesterday and regretted it as I felt a bit sick afterwards and I knew it hadn't done me any good.

DemBonesDemBones · 26/10/2021 21:59

@beingsunny well done on your loss, that's brilliant!

FlyingPandas · 26/10/2021 21:58

Why aren't I obese? Three main reasons OP.

  1. Genetics - I'm 5ft7, naturally slim-ish build, long legs and small boobs (the small boobs actually make a massive difference!)
  2. Energy levels - I do everything at speed, I rarely sit down.
  3. Sheer and unadulterated luck.

I don't restrict anything I eat - I grew up with a DM who was permanently on a diet and as a result I will deny myself nothing. I buy crap - sweets, chocolate, crisps, wine - I love it all and eat some kind of crap most days. Alongside three full meals. Plenty of veg, and plenty of good stuff, but plenty of carbs and crap too. Granted, I wouldn't eat a packet of biscuits in one sitting, but I'd certainly have two or three without even thinking about it and certainly wouldn't feel guilty about it. Likewise I'd never scoff an entire family bag of crisps - I'd feel sick - but treating myself to a couple of small packets with a glass of wine whilst watching TV? Hell yeah!

I've never gone above a size 12, not once (aside from when I've been pregnant) in nearly 50 years. Yes my stomach is not quite as flat as it used to be, and my legs are not quite as smooth and skinny as they used to be, but by and large my general body shape is not that different to what it was when I was 18.

So much of it is genetics and luck.

beautifullymad · 26/10/2021 21:53

@secretbookcase my husband was diagnosed as a diabetic with quite severe blood sugar. We looked into ways of reducing blood sugar naturally (plus medication) and fell upon this way of eating. Two years on we have lost 8 stone between us and feel a lot better.

I think the closest way of eating is a low carb diet. I'm not ultra low carb as that would be 20 carbs a day. I'm 40 as it's easier and doesn't make a lot of difference to me.

I joined a reversing diabetes Facebook group and my knowledge grew from them.

Justgettingbye · 26/10/2021 21:52

Hate the feeling of feeling stuffed and I know how quickly I put weight on. I'd love to eat crisps and chocolate and do crave them but I want to show good habits to my kids aswell

boredwithfoodprob · 26/10/2021 21:51

I think it’s partly genes but I’m not someone who just eat anything and rely on genes alone. Partly it’s just not having much junk food in the house although that’s hard with kids who like a few treats. It’s also getting into the habit of not necessarily exercising more but just moving more. So for instance, when I’m waiting for one of my kids to do a class/hobby I go for a 30 min walk. I also try and compensate by eating a small/healthy lunch if I’m planning on say a takeaway for dinner x

donemeover · 26/10/2021 21:49

Willpower - also even though I enjoy a cookie or tub of ice cream it's not nice enough eat all the time and makes me feel a bit sick of myself when doing it regularly to be honest. Almost sluggish

I'll have it in moderation

Meg87 · 26/10/2021 21:48

I think I'm lucky in that I find it harder to put on weight than other people. I've never really had to worry about dieting and having to exercise regularly in order to stay slim.

However, I don't know how long that will last so I try to make sure I don't have lots of snacks in the house. My willpower is non-existant when I know there's some chocolate in the cupboard, but I find it quite easy to avoid buying it when doing the weekly shop. The treats I buy during my shop are all things that I know I wouldn't eat in one sitting (as I don't like them enough), or that I don't feel are toooo unhealthy. Such as a tub of fruity yoghurt, some ready salted crisps, cereal bars. Buying my favourite chocolate biscuits or ice cream would be dangerous for me!

Also, my family are all pretty slim, as is my partner, and so I feel like there's an expectation I'll remain slim. I think it would be a lot easier to not care much about putting on weight if the people around me were all on the larger side.

shinynewapple21 · 26/10/2021 21:44

Frequent Antibiotic use is known to be linked to an increased risk of obesity.

@NannyGythaOgg

Is that just in childhood or does it also apply in adulthood ?

TheGoogleMum · 26/10/2021 21:43

I'm obese (never been bigger than size 16 mind so perhaps a bit different!). I'm working on it very slowly - I have reduced my sugar in drinks (I have tea so switched to sweetener, switched to diet pop). I am trying to do intermittent fasting too (no food after 8pm or before midday!). I think with things like ice cream don't be tempted to eat straight out the tub portion some up and that's your pudding no seconds. If you know you'd eat a family size bag or large chocolate bar to yourself in one sitting then don't buy it! Good luck :)
I initially tried slimming world and it was a good start I think to limit treats

beingsunny · 26/10/2021 21:43

I'm very overweight, I'm also tall so the tipping point from carrying it well to just a fat person took a while.

I've just started seeing a nutritionist, no calorie counting, just portion sizes.

I've never been skinny, in fact I wasted my 20/30s thinking I was fat.

Now I have 20kg to lose to get back to my normal.

I can't eat when I'm stressed, I've been in a bad relationship for the last couple of years and he cooked all our meals, portion sizes were too big so the weight has crept on despite often only eating once a day.

Don't do fad diets, they aren't sustainable.

I lost 4kg last week (week 1) just by eating 3 small meals a day and one snack (the snack can even be a small glass of wine because it's a lifestyle change and let's face it a glass of wine is nice sometimes)

I've buggered my metabolism with disordered eating, so part of it is ensuring I eat enough, so a piece of chicken for dinner should be around 100g which after you add a couple of veg portions is actually a lot and I'm full.

I'm very unhappy with my body, I'm in my 40s now so feel this is my chance to sort myself out one love and for all and so it's a lot willpower, I've pullled out all my pre kids dresses and hung them up as a goal.

Change one thing at a time if it's too hard, stop buying treats if you can't control yourself, I do have a fridge full of chocolate and snacks for the kids but don't tough it because it's not mine.

PyongyangKipperbang · 26/10/2021 21:40

Trauma that led to an eating disorder.

Not the answer you wanted I guess, sorry.

Dontbeamugallyourlifesucker · 26/10/2021 21:35

Op Flowers I do all the shopping so No biscuits, cakes, bread, crisps or cheese.. Lots of fruit to fill me up.. Saccorine instead of sugar, low fat margarine and no alcohol.. It has made such a difference (size 18 to size 12) and walk a lot more and swimming 3 times a week.. I have been size 12 for about 5 years and feel so much better.. So used to living this way that I don't feel hungry.. I have 3 meals a day of of normal food.

WanderingFruitWonderer · 26/10/2021 21:28

I don't have a car, and so I walk everywhere. I think that makes a massive difference to me. I'm also a vegan, and often fill up on veggies, which you can eat an unlimited amount of, and not gain weight.
I am a foodie, and love food and cooking. So, I reckon I could put on weight if I wasn't careful. I'm not skinny (used to be) but a healthy size 12.
I do eat very naughty treats sometimes though, such as crisps. I love them, but only have them occasionally, and consume them mindfully. That's a big thing - eating treats mindfully rather than mindlessly.
I wish you well OP

OrinocoGlow · 26/10/2021 21:28

Genetics is often mentioned and there could be something in that- whether it makes you more or less pre-disposed to gain weight easily. I wonder if genetics also affects your appetite, how you react to stress or attraction to certain foods. For some people, creamy foods or sweet foods don't appeal and others crave them. I don't know the answer, just thinking having read some of the comments which show how different we all are.

cooker321monster · 26/10/2021 21:27

I love eating. (don't we all). So I do not keep anything "treat like" in the house, unless its for that evening. So no fizzy drinks, fancy cereal, choc cakes, sugary stuff, fatty stuff etc. You will only find the basic pure food groups in our house, so once u have had dinner that's it. (unless u starting cooking up a whole meal). But if I want a cake when Im out or some chocolate on a friday night I will have it.