Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Why aren’t you obese?

961 replies

Spottyphonecase24 · 26/10/2021 14:11

A bit of a weird one but I have just got off a zoom call with my therapist. We were talking about my weight (I am obese).

Why isn’t everyone else obese? What stops you? I don’t seem to have an off button. I remember going from a 10 to a 12 and thinking that’s it I’m not going to get any bigger but I did and now I am in a size 24 and they are getting a bit tight. I’ve read lots about how people have their light bulb moment to lose weight and that has not happened to me, or maybe it has and I’ve ignored it.

What stops you eating a tub of icecream or picking up a large bar of chocolate instead of a small one or one bag of crisps instead of a family size bag?

I honestly don’t know the reasons why people don’t eat more. Is it will power, feeling full?

OP posts:
stopgap · 27/10/2021 12:03

Another one to say vanity, as I like how I look in clothes and want to stay that way. But also it’s genetics. My dad is 6-feet tall and weighed 9.5/10 stone until he hit 70, and now he’s closer to 11 stone. He’s Italian, so eats pasta and bread on the daily, as well as pastries a few times a week. But he’s incredibly active, walks miles a day etc.

I have also always been thin. I’m 5’7 and 8 stone 9. I’m 44. I still eat 1800-2000 calories a day, but rarely (like, twice a year) have dessert or white carbs. I have always preferred home-cooked food on the healthier side, and I’ve always been sporty, so it’s part genetics, part natural inclination, part willpower.

peaceanddove · 27/10/2021 11:57

Vanity. Pure vanity. I'm 5ft 6 and a size 12 and I am simply not prepared to get any bigger. The pleasure and perks I get from being slim and looking this way massively outweigh any pleasure I get from scoffing a huge bar of chocolate.

whereislittleroo · 27/10/2021 11:53

I know what my triggers for overeating/eating crap food are. Eg. I seek high processed sugary or salty foods when sad, tired or frustrated.

I eat mindfully - i always sit down to eat and don't allow myself to be distracted by TV or phones while eating. I have learnt to fully savour flavours and textures so that I really enjoy the food. If we eat too quickly we don't taste the food properly, then feel the need for more of it.

I don't "swap" foods. Eg. If I want some crisps but don't allow myself to have them, I can end up eating 10 other slightly healthier things trying to feel satisfied. In doing so, I've ended up eating more calories and still feeling unsatisfied. So now I just eat the thing I want. But I don't take the pack, I take a handful in a separate bowl.

EvilPea · 27/10/2021 10:30

Eating until you’ve had enough not full.
Making choices such as porridge with water, no butter on crackers.
Not having empty calories (so only eating it if it’s got some nutritional value).

Not looking at every meal as a really tasty thing to enjoy - some are, but most arent. It’s just a way to stop you murdering people with hunger.

ThePoisonousMushroom · 27/10/2021 10:29

Just out of interest, for those who say they snack in the evenings, what time do you eat your evening meal? We have ours at 7.30ish which means there’s no way I could snack in the evening as I’m full from dinner.

Griselda1 · 27/10/2021 10:27

My work paid for us to have health screening recently and realising that I'd moved into the obese range for my BMI was a huge wake up. Listing everything I ate on fitness pal for a month has made a huge difference.It's been that and not having my trigger foods in the house which has allowed me to lose a stone in the last few months.I've another stone to lose and my weight loss has ceased so I'll probably start using the app again for a while.
I've always had a large appetite and know that I would eat crazy amounts of snacks if they were in the house.

LucentBlade · 27/10/2021 10:25

I do love food but I really never want to be fat. When I was young it was a vanity thing now I’m older it’s more of a health thing.

So I eat whatever I want but in small portions. I love cheese and crackers. All cheese types, I love for cheese! I could eat an entire round of Camembert on half a packet of crackers no problem but I don’t. I will have a couple of crackers.

I was also brought up to eat three meals a day and snacking was frowned on. My mother died in her nineties having never been more than a size 8 and she had six dc. She had contempt for anyone who had poor willpower whether that was food, men, whatever. She was a great believer in head over heart and tried to teach us to not be compulsive over choices.

TheLastLonelyBakedBeanInTheTin · 27/10/2021 10:25

I have been obese due to gaining a lot of pregnancy weight, short periods of binge eating during very emotionally difficult times and, the big one, the side effects of antidepressants giving me an insatiable appetite. I also really struggled with food cravings when I ate a lot of low fat food, diets like weight watchers and slimming world just made me feel hungry all the time. I have also lost weight due to being too depressed, stressed and anxious to eat (and then bounced back totally the opposite way on antidepressants) and spent a lot of my adult life underweight due to poor health. So my weight has yo-yo'd all my adult life.

The big changes for me were when I stopped fighting my body and started listening to it. I had become so far removed from my own body that I didn't even know the difference between thirst, anger, misery and hunger. I didn't know the difference between full and over full. I didn't know the difference between a bit peckish and actually starving. So when I was thin it was because I was not listening to my bodies needs, and when I was obese it's because I was not listening to my bodies needs. I gave up dieting completely for a year and I got stuck in to intuitive eating, and a magic thing happened, I stayed exactly the same weight. I didn't gain, I didn't lose, I just stayed the same. I rarely weighed myself, but about once a month when I did I found that I was exactly the same weight, maybe give or take a kilo.

I did reduce caffeine, give up smoking and stop antidepressants, so I think that was massive because one I used as an appetite suppressant and the other gave me an insatiable appetite so that I basically had an eating disorder. I was in a binge/starve cycle and had also started becoming more extreme in these behaviours, over exercising, and intermittently using laxatives and diet pills. I was really in trouble with my eating. Intuitive eating and the body positivity movement (mostly which I accessed via Instagram) absolutely saved me from myself. I started to see food as a way to reward myself and my body not as a method of punishing myself by depriving myself of calories, or binge eating (sometimes combined with other forms of self harm).

I started by not banning any foods. I had a month where we ordered A LOT of takeaways and I ate one hell of a lot of sugar, too. But I never ate this in secret. I shared my joy of bad food with others, and took my kids for a lot of McDonald's. I was like "here kids, let's have some joy in food". And then after about a month I started cooking again properly for the first time in years. Baking with the kids, dinners for family and friends, all the food I had been depriving myself like creamy pastas and loaded nachos. I ate more slowly, savouring my food and enjoying it as something social, and joyful and connected not private and shameful like before. Through that process I started to actually change my taste buds and my kids too, so that we moved away from the takeaways and McDonald's and baked treats, and towards being open to trying new things and having fun with cooking at home.

I hate that over full feeling now. I have got used to listening to my bodies satiety signals, and I love that I don't have to have a sit or Lie down after a meal. For me it will always be an issue I have to keep in check, i have food demons no doubt about it, but I am so pleased with the pay off in my life when I live this way and my kids have a great attitude to food. They eat sweets and cream cakes and have McDonald's sometimes, but they also eat loads of fruit, veg, healthy fats and lean proteins. We don't ever do low fat anything and I cook with cream, sugar, butter, all the things I used to deem 'bad' but because food is about fun, joy and connectedness I can see that my food demons will not be there's. There are no bad foods, no syns, nobody is counting points or calories or carbs in things, we just eat some tasty food and crack on doing more exciting things.

5128gap · 27/10/2021 10:13

Two years ago I was 10 stone 10 at 5 foot 4 and just in the overweight category for BMI (which I obviously dismissed as being outdated!) I ate pretty much what I wanted, averaging about 2300 calories most days, and did very little exercise.Due to the way I carried the weight, hourglass with proportionally slim waist (though still 30 inches) clever dressing and generous clothes sizing that had me believing i was still a 12; I felt, and was considered fairly effortlessly slim. Since going on a health kick, I've lost 2 stone and 6 inches from my waist, and am now genuinely slim. Maintaining it takes a lot of effort. I now gain weight if I go above 1800 calories or cut back on my exercise. So while I think a few people may be lucky in that they are naturally genuinely slim, despite eating what they like, I think slim can also be relative and subjective. Retaining a low BMI and in particular minimal abdominal fat, does take effort for most people I think, and a surprisingly low calorie intake.

Snoozer11 · 27/10/2021 09:40

Your body adapts quickly.

If you limit your calories and stop eating processed food, after a couple of weeks that becomes the norm and you don't particularly desire to overeat junk.

Chesneyhawkes1 · 27/10/2021 09:39

Will power. I've put on weight in the past, not a lot but I didn't like it and I just cut down on the treats.

I exercise a lot, everyday, sometimes twice and people think I can eat what I like because of this.

I can't. I still watch what I eat. I track it on mfp etc. I have a treat dinner once a week.

Rainbowshit · 27/10/2021 09:36

It just wouldn't occur to me to eat a whole massive bar of chocolate or a whole tub of ice cream. In fact the thought of it makes me feel quite sick.

I am overweight so not perfect in any way. My vice is wine rather than food.

EmeraldShamrock · 27/10/2021 09:33

My friend had a gastric sleeve. The surgeon removed part of her stomach I don't know the correct terminology, something about hunger hormones from her gut, she doesn't feel hungry anymore, she battled hungry with yoyo dieting for years.
She has lost 6stone.
If I was in your situation and could afford it, I'd have surgery.

scooterbear · 27/10/2021 09:18

I have to have cast iron willpower to avoid becoming overweight. I gain weight incredibly easily, always have. And now I'm over 40 it's even worse. Unfortunately I also love food and wine. Ive learned I have to be incredibly disciplined. The only think that works for me is planning. So knowing what I'm going to eat in the day for all three Meals, and sticking to it.
I allow myself some leeway-if I'm going out for dinner or for drinks or whatever, I don't say no to what I fancy- but whereas in the past I would have woken up on the day of and thought 'sod it I'm out for dinner this evening so I might as well have a full English, a lasagne for lunch, snacks and whatever else because the day is already a write off in dietary terms', I now limit that to the event itself and eat more lightly around it.
When I first started this I would plan the weeks eating actually on paper which made me more accountable. Now I don't need to do that as it's become more habitual, but I can easily fall off the wagon if I don't pay attention.
I'm currently a 12 whereas my ideal weight for me is about half a stone lighter, so lately I haven't been quite as Strict with myself and I need to get it in check.

Lunaduckdrop · 27/10/2021 09:02

I am different with ice cream than I am with chocolate.
I can't resist milk chocolate and will quickly demolish any that is in the house. So I don't buy it any more. DH prefers dark chocolate and I can't binge on that.
I like my ice cream in a pretty fruit bowl. I may add other sugar- based products to my portion and them some fruit to try to alleviate some of the guilt! I'm not interested in eating it from the carton, and although my portion is not in any way satisfying I may follow it with another dessert, perhaps cake, rather than more ice cream.
You will see that I eat too much sugar.
However, some things in my favour are that I don't eat takeaways or ready meals as I prefer home cooking from scratch. I'm vegetarian and dislike fried food. I eat breakfast as late as possible and try not to snack in the evenings (rarely works completely but I do keep trying).
Both DH and I are at the upper end of a healthy BMI so could do to lose a stone apiece, but we aren't (technically) overweight.
This thread had been great. Thanks, OP. Such a variety of insights and it shows how different people are. It had inspired me to try a bit harder to cut back on sugar.
Now I'm off to do some baking with the granddaughters.
None of us are perfect. Just keep smiling and trying, OP. Never give up!

Benjispruce4 · 27/10/2021 08:57

Half term this week so times are different. Normally breakfast at 7 and lunch at 12. Usually take a salad with tuna or feta to work with fruit.

Benjispruce4 · 27/10/2021 08:55

Yesterday:
B:9 am poached egg on granary toast(no butter as I’ve never liked it,) black coffee(no sugar,) tsp of ketchup.
L:1pm handful of almonds(20,) apple, banana and satsuma.1 rye bread toast from IKEA with humous.
D: 6pm. egg noodle and veg stir fry with a baked salmon fillet with 5 spice and lime.
Several cups of tea with skimmed milk(done like taste of other milk) and lots of water all day.
Walked for an hour and a half with dog in two walks.
This morning was first thing I’ve eaten since dinner. I’ve had half a hass avocado mashed onto a piece of granary toast with a drizzle of hot sauce, plus a cup of tea.

PurpleDaisies · 27/10/2021 08:45

I’ve found meal planning really helpful. Batch cooking is also great for those nights where I might eat a pizza or a take away. Having something healthy and easy in the freezer makes it much easier to avoid that lazy option.

gogohm · 27/10/2021 08:41

I have to limit food in the house, easier now no kids live full time with us. I don't buy cakes, biscuits etc. I buy quite a lot of preportioned carbs eg mash, rice which means we only eat one portion each. We do drink which means I'm overweight but it's under control

Straighttalking1 · 27/10/2021 08:14

Just had a thought. OP, one doesn't consciously choose to eat everything in sight without good reason. Your brain has no food sensor to put it in another way. Are you on any meds that you think might be contributing to the cravings ?

kungfupannda · 27/10/2021 08:13

A combination of things.

The main one is probably that I just don't have the appetite to eat a whole tub of icecream. I would feel sick and stop. That has nothing to do with willpower - it's just how my body is.

Exercise is the other big one. I put on a bit of weight after DC3 and it wasn't until I started exercising properly - regular running - that it shifted. I can put on weight if I'm ill or injured and can't run for a few days, but don't adjust my food intake, but it tends to only be by 3 or 4 pounds and then it comes off again once I'm back running.

I also tend to get 'stuck' on a particular type of food for a while. I'll only want a particular meal or crave a single, specific snack. It might be a particular flavour of biscuit or crisp or a specific type of chocolate, but it means that there's a limit to how much of it I can eat before I get bored of it. I'll want it again later, but a bar of chocolate or a tube of pringles or whatever can last me several days, eaten in mini-binges. It also means that when I run out of whatever it is, I won't start on something else - I'll just wait until I can pick up another bar/tub of that particular thing. So slightly addictive cravings I suppose, but for something very specific - usually with a strong or unusual flavour - rather than for food generally.

JustDanceAddict · 27/10/2021 08:03

Because I don’t eat that much above my calorie needs for the day & if I’m getting a bit bigger I try to cut down. I have always hovered within the same 10lbs or so, but I’m def the higher side atm!
I have a relative like you who was slim as a young adult, but is now obese (possibly morbidly) and has a multitude of MH and physical health issues. They are late 50s and less mobile than relatives in their 80s. It’s sad.
I was a v slim child & teen, never been above a 12, (apart from Post/pregnancy), I haven’t got a massive appetite, but I do like crap so have to be mindful esp as I’m entering the menopause.

Straighttalking1 · 27/10/2021 08:00

Of course one good point is NEVER to go shopping when you're hungry because you'll buy the whole shop. Try not to buy the bad stuff in the first place, or if you know you'll get a craving, only get a small one and ration yourself. Drink much much more water, even before a meal. I think I'd feel sick eating a whole tub of ice cream or bar of chocolate. However, there are these M&S biccies that are heavenly and I had 5 in one go the other day GrinSmileSmile

Dojacatpaws · 27/10/2021 07:56

Yes agree, it's a kind of addiction you get a high from certain foods, I don't crave foods much although I'd probably have a glass of wine than a cake but even then not much

SweetMaryHell · 27/10/2021 07:49

What stops me is the fear of getting fat outweighs my craving for food.

During first lockdown I put on 2 stone - eating/drinking too much and not exercising. It was the biggest id been and none of my clothes fit so I started to cut back. I lost a stone and am now working on losing the next stone. Whenever I fancy a donut or an extra portion of pasta I remember that feeling of not having anything to wear and it stops me.

Swipe left for the next trending thread