Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To wonder why communal parks are so biased towards boys

398 replies

arethereanyleftatall · 26/10/2021 08:49

Looking around our parks, it occurred to me all the normal type equipment paid for by the council is geared towards a certain type of play.
You tend to see a slide/swing type area (great for everyone) plus football goals, skate parks, and basketball hoops.
Of course either sex could play on the last 3, and do, but in general, these 3 types of equipment are occupied by boys.
Or, let's take sex out of it - these 3 types of equipment are played with by energetic/sporty/rough and tumble type children.
Where's the community stuff for the children who prefer more gentle/imaginative role play/dance games.
Where's the netball courts, the fairy houses?
I'm actually not even sure what you would build to make it more even, but at our local park yesterday.... 8 approximately 10 year old boys playing football; about 10 teenage boys on the skate park;basketball hoop unused; swing area equal girls/boys.

OP posts:
TakeYourFinalPosition · 26/10/2021 11:00

We have a park that has a little garden and some small paths and wooden chairs around the side of it... I imagine they were aiming for imaginative/fairy play in that.

I've got to say, though, it's rarely ever used. I see more teens sitting on the chairs; or occasionally drunk people, than kids.

We used to have wooden huts, but they were removed. Sadly anything small and under cover tends to get abused for drugs/sex or trashed by drunken people; which feels really sad to write, especially as I live somewhere that's considered very middle class!

smoko · 26/10/2021 11:00

@FrancescaContini But ALL little girls love fairies, don't you know that?!

Wink
BogRollBOGOF · 26/10/2021 10:58

@CatJumperTwat

It's sad but not surprising to see women falling over themselves to deny this is a problem. Recognising female socialisation is not "sexist" and we don't have to pretend everything is equal between female children and male children.
But we have two aspects of this, space and socialisation. Space is the smaller issue compared to socialisation which turns girls off active play and sport and means that they don't claim their entitlement to the space that exists.

Some of that is positive role modelling to girls. Some of that is boys' attitudes to girls.

Moot point as I don't have daughters. I have a sporty DS2 who loves traditional sport. I have DS1 who has dyspraxia and ASD so is not inclined to do more clichéd masculine sports and prefers solo persuits. They have both had a foundation in the more "feminine" gymnastics because I felt it developed skills that were transferable to other sports and generally beneficial. They swapped to Karate when they stopped enjoying it... largely because they were the only boys left in the class (it cuts both ways). They see me being active, doing weights classes, they join me at parkrun. I'd hope that whatever sex they are, I'm a positive role model to them for females being active, and hopefully they shouldn't develop attitudes that put girls off sport... (if they had been girls I'd hope that they'd feel empowered to keep activity up). DS2 has a girl on his football team and he respects her as a player and her skills, she just happens to be the only one of the opposite sex.

We are very slowly seeing progress on women's sport in the media, but it's a long process. Active women need to be an unremarkable image (and I don't mean rollerskating in white jeans to advertise sanitary products Grin )

smoko · 26/10/2021 10:57

I'm not saying sexism doesn't exist

But I do think some people see sexism which isn't there

I feel this is one of those times

Not all boys want to skate or kick a soccer ball.

A skate park could be used by someone on a scooter or bike - these don't have a gender.

What kind of equipment at a playground can encourage dance? Isn't a dance class required?

Also we had no internet in my day so doing gymnastics like turning cartwheels & handstands was the norm. We used to tuck our school tunics into our undies for modesty

Grin
icelollies · 26/10/2021 10:57

Perhaps one of the main issues is the lack of loos?

No clean and safe loos for girls means they cant stay at the park for as long, and may lead to a reluctance to go to the park? Of the 5 parks near us, only one has half decent loos to use (but still not ones you’d want to sit down!).

Let’s face it, boys use any available bush / tree with a carefree ease!

Clymene · 26/10/2021 10:57

@SoupDragon -perhaps you too should read the Make Space for Girls website?

A clue - some groups have talked to actual girls about what they would like in play spaces. I know it's a shocking concept to speak to intended users and ask them what they like rather than dictating to them and complaining when they don't use it.

FrancescaContini · 26/10/2021 10:56

What are you talking about??
Girls like slides etc too.
What a load of sexist BS.
Fairy houses 🤬🤦‍♀️

smoko · 26/10/2021 10:54

How is basketball hoop different to netball?

There are skater chicks, does nobody remember Avril Lavigne?

In my town the fairy houses would end up being late night crack dens

BoredZelda · 26/10/2021 10:51

But and it's a big but for me it's for the benefit of Male dominated sports

But it isn't. It also isn't just for girls. It may have started out that way but it has evolved into what is essentially just a combination of gymnastics and dance.

Kljnmw3459 · 26/10/2021 10:50

Our local playgrounds are heavily climbing orientated. We have 5 different playgrounds within 15 minutes walk from us which is nice unless you have a DC who is afraid of heights. They all have different rope climbing equipment, climbing walls, steps, ladders planks for climbing. Forts that you access by climbing a wall. Monkey bars. It's also not great for younger children who aren't able to independently climb or reach the steps.

BoredZelda · 26/10/2021 10:50

Why should girls who prefer to sit and chat in the park be ‘encouraged’ to skateboard?

They shouldn't be. But it should be explored why they are choosing to sit and chat rather than exercising, which is what parks are supposed to be provided for.

notacooldad · 26/10/2021 10:50

Talking about girls doing physical activity elsewhere I was surprised at how popular in my area cheerleading is.
I have been a long to watch a few rehearsals and I have very mixed feelings about it.
It is very energetic, the girls are working as a team and they really enjoy it. The girls are committing to a regular weekly activity. But and it's a big but for me it's for the benefit of Male dominated sports. Its seen as something that is easy on the eye and a bit of a pastime. It is enjoyed by the ( mostly middle aged) dads at the events they cheerleading for which makes me uncomfortable.

SoupDragon · 26/10/2021 10:50

@Clymene

Obviously for some women on here, the lack of participation of girls in public spaces is because they're not enough like boys.

ConfusedHmm

No it isn't. It's because they are expected to be sitting down chatting nicely or playing "house"
SunShinesBrightly · 26/10/2021 10:48

But we do have to challenge the sterotypes and instead ask why girls aren't skateboarding and playing football and apparently prefer to sit and socialise rather than exercise in public.

Why should girls who prefer to sit and chat in the park be ‘encouraged’ to skateboard?

My DBs loved football, skateboarding and cricket. I wanted to play tennis or chat with my friends in the park.
They hated swimming and I loved it.
What’s wrong with that?

My DH loves to spend his leisure time walking up hills and cycling. Should I be ‘encouraged’ to join him?

Clymene · 26/10/2021 10:47

Obviously for some women on here, the lack of participation of girls in public spaces is because they're not enough like boys.

ConfusedHmm

Waitwhat23 · 26/10/2021 10:45

Girls aren’t ‘overlooked’ in parks, they choose not to use the equipment which is there for ALL to use.

Yes. Why though?

I mean, we can continue designing and implementing playparks which girls won't use, because they feel intimidated, or dominated over, or self conscious and then wonder why girls choose not to use public spaces. Or we can keep shouting that girls need to do more active exercise and wonder how they do that exactly when they won't use the public spaces.

Or we can look at ways to make public spaces more attractive to girls in general and the exercise part of it will follow on from there.

Summerfun54321 · 26/10/2021 10:45

I (as a girl) spent my entire childhood on football pitches and basketball courts. The reason they are there is because all you need is a ball. They are accessible for many many children who don’t have money for dance classes or gymnastics etc. If you don’t think your girls should be using them then more fool you.

DeepaBeesKit · 26/10/2021 10:44

Is the issue the fact that there's "nothing for girl's" or is it a problem with our attitude as to how girls should play?

This. The problem isn't the parks or the equipment in them. It's the social attitudes that give some girls the idea that exercise isnt for them.

The answer isnt to say "no dear, it isn't - we'll give you some pretty benches and a playhouse instead". That simply perpetuates the problem. We should be challenging the fact that girls don't want to exercise and trying to change the behaviours that lead to that.

Goneback2school · 26/10/2021 10:43

I was at a skate park yesterday with dd and ds. I would say there was about a 50:50 mix of the sexes of all ages from about 3-40ish on skates, scooters and boards. I did notice multiple teen girls which was good to see.

sweeneytoddsrazor · 26/10/2021 10:43

But we do have to challenge the sterotypes and instead askwhygirls aren't skateboarding and playing football and apparently prefer to sit and socialise rather than exercise in public. I'd like to see that change before I agreed to see money ploughed in to making sure girls don't exercise.
Excellent idea, because this is not just when males are around. Groups of teenage girls tend to just want to hang out chatting whereas groups of boys tend to chat then start doing something physical.

newstart1234 · 26/10/2021 10:42

Yes I think this demonstrates that ‘girls prefer to sit and chat’ has now become engrained here. I entirely disagree. Space should be inclusive for girls before that judgment can be made. There are other places that accommodate girls better and have better participation. The U.K. is oddly behind on this.

footballfan1963 · 26/10/2021 10:40

And even if girls are seen less than boys in parks, it doesn’t mean that they aren’t engaged in physical activity elsewhere. Round here I see girls riding bikes, going running with a parent. My youngest dd does 8 hours of dance classes/week, my middle dd, having not enjoyed sport as a child, took up Thai boxing in her teens.

Technosaurus · 26/10/2021 10:37

I'm with @AllThingsServeTheBeam - if you had a sensory garden, before long vandals would have it pulled up or people would let their dogs shit in it. A fairy house would soon become somewhere for druggies to congregate.

Round here we have a wonderful 'Secret Garden' where local businesses have contributed benches for the adults and a wigwam for the children, but if you go down there at 8am its awash with drug paraphernalia and empty bottles from the night before. Sadly there was a man actually living in the wigwam for a short time last winter.

In that example we just tidy up because it's only small and volunteer led, but a council would have to do this for every single playground or invest in heavy security, something you don't have to do for football goals and skate parks which are much harder to damage and render useless. This doesn't answer why there are no netball courts mind you...

toomuchlaundry · 26/10/2021 10:37

I assumed skate parks were built to remove youth from skateboarding in other public places.

Our local park has a fenced off area for the play equipment for under 5s. It also has play equipment for older children. It then has a huge green space that isn’t permanently set up as football pitches but is used for football for children’s league at the weekends in the football season (both boys and girls). I have seen this space used for impromptu games of football, cricket, rounders etc. People having picnics. It’s used by males and females. There are also some woods with paths going through them. There are your normal benches and also a number of covered structures like old fashioned bus shelters where you can sit, but unfortunately these are often taken over by the anti social element of the town. Apart from the latter we are very lucky to have this park.

There are also tennis courts and hockey pitches that you can hire. These are also used by local clubs, again boys and girls. There is also a skate park and bike park.

We also get youth just hanging around and causing vandalism because there is nothing for them to do!

footballfan1963 · 26/10/2021 10:37

@makespaceforgirls

Hello, thank you for all the praise and references to our campaign. It's so good to hear that we are getting the word out. And for all those people saying, we are going to take this to our councillors: THANK YOU. There's only two of us and although I feel like we might have spoken to every council in the country, in truth we've barely scratched the surface.

I can't say too much now because I have to go into a meeting now, about a park. But I will try and come back later or this evening to answer the points which have come up. In the meantime, though, for a basic summary of the situation, we produced this research document:

makespaceforgirls.co.uk/wp-content/uploads/2021/02/Make-Space-for-Girls-Summary-of-Research-findings-December-2020-web.pdf

We are on Twitter and Instagram and have a newsletter you can sign up to - and you can find all of this on the website.

@makespaceforgirls I can’t quite believe your campaign TBH. You are setting gender inequalities back decades. Pink?? Seating areas because ‘girls like to talk face to face’??

Girls aren’t ‘overlooked’ in parks, they choose not to use the equipment which is there for ALL to use.

I am gobsmacked at this thread.