Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Am I right to feel left out- secret Santa related

181 replies

Brentmeister · 25/10/2021 22:59

Name changed for this as maybe outing.

I’ve been with my DP for nearly 4 years. Get on really well with each other’s family, see his siblings/partners/nephews regularly and get on well. Meet his sister for a coffee now and again and have baby sat for the kids a couple of times. We get on well and see eachother for a full day maybe once a month.

In my family we do secret Santa for the adults (budget £30-£40) and don’t buy kids as there’s too many, they have enough stuff and it’s just a waste. We’ve done it for a few years and it’s worked well. I’ve always asked him if he wants to be in it but he’s said no which is fine, it’s all women in our secret Santa and I get why he doesn’t want to be in it.

However him and his 3 siblings have always brought for each other + kids. As more kids have been born (5 nephews and I have one son, we have none together) it’s obviously gets dearer. Last week I saw one of his sister in laws (all his siblings are married except one who’s due to be married in january) and mentioned this is what we do in my family.

So fast forward to tonight. I’m browsing online and see a present perfect for one of his brothers. I show him and he agrees but then says ‘we are doing secret Santa this year’ I said oh right I wonder who’ll I get and he said oh I don’t think you’re in it. I said why wouldn’t I be and he said well no one mentioned your name.

I’ve had a hard week with some really bad family news so I’m not sure if this has tipped me over the edge because I’m emotional but it’s really upset me. It’s not about having a present, I’m an adult and can afford to buy what I want but I feel so left out. We are spending Xmas day with his family so they’d all be exchanging gifts and I’d have nothing. And I’m more hurt that DP didn’t just say ‘oh yeah what about Brent’.

As I said it’s not about actually having a gift it’s more the feeling of being totally left out and suddenly feeling like I’m not seen as part of the family. I’m really hurt 😢

Anyway AIBU?

OP posts:
Hathertonhariden · 26/10/2021 09:22

You do need to resolve this OP. If they decide they want to continue this in future years I'm assuming fiance will get included whether he likes it or not when he's married (given his dislike it will probably be left to SIL to organise on his behalf). So if the same no ring, no gift applies you will be even more isolated.

As they have always received gifts signed from the 3 of you and sent you presents in the same way, wouldn't it make more financial sense to say that the SS is a gift for each family group rather than individuals? We've done that before so rather than say have £50 per individual you agree £75 per household. This is particularly fair for the single person who previously shelled out for numerous gifts and only got one in return. Plus you put suggested gifts in an envelope with your name so that the person buying gets something they know the recipient will appreciate.

ancientgran · 26/10/2021 09:22

I wouldn't go Christmas Day. Tell him now that plans have changed. I'd rather be at home with beans on toast than spend the day with them.

thisplaceisweird · 26/10/2021 09:17

Bought = past tense of buy

Brought = past tense of bring

Katela18 · 26/10/2021 09:14

Hi OP,

You are right to be hurt by this.

I have 3 brothers and we do secret santa. I am married, as it one of my brothers, one is engaged and one has a girlfiend he has been with a year. All 8 people are involved in secret santa, I wouldn't dream of leaving anyone out since they will all know that's what we are doing.

This is a massive oversight by your DP and he needs to rectify it. Don't be a martyr by saying 'i don't even want to be involved anymore'. He needs to correct this and also make a point to his family that you are as much part of the family as any of the married spouses.

BungleandGeorge · 26/10/2021 09:14

@HoardingSamphireSaurus

But you don’t usually buy them presents? Your partner puts your name on the present he buys and you don’t have joint finances. They buy for you and your son and you don’t give them anything usually ... As you only buy one present for your family I’d presume you’re not keen on buying presents

Can you not see the contradiction there?

Her DP buys for his sibs, their partners and kids, presents are from him, OP and her DS.

His family buy for their sibs, kids, incl OP and her DS - who knows who pays, who cares?

In her family the rules of Christmas are different. Nobody in DPs family are affected by that!

No can’t see any contradiction at all. Her partner tacks her name onto the present he gives (would be embarrassing if he didn’t). I’d honestly expect to give them a gift if they were buying for me and my child , or contribute to their joint gift at the least. It’s not really a joint gift otherwise? I don’t think joint gifts are usual until you have joint finances, I’d feel embarrassed not getting them anything in return. Especially as it seems the partners family are also hosting (and not for the first time?)
MrsCardone · 26/10/2021 09:14

Who is organising it? I bet it’s his DSis as it usually is in these situations. Call them and ask them who your Secret Santa person is.

diddl · 26/10/2021 09:11

@ElevenSmiles

I think you're tight accepting presents from his family but not giving a penny towards theirs. Who would pay for your ss present ?
I was just wondering about this.

So Op & partner give gifts between them but are given individually?

ElevenSmiles · 26/10/2021 09:07

I think you're tight accepting presents from his family but not giving a penny towards theirs. Who would pay for your ss present ?

TravelLost · 26/10/2021 09:05

If his family is as welcoming as you say, I’m wondering what would be their reaction if you are at theirs at Christmas and everyone bar you has a present.
Or when they ask you how secret Santa has gone and you say you weren’t included….

I’m surprised that the sibling thought ‘your name wasn’t mentioned’ was enough of an explanation to not include you and I’d wonder what y9r DP has actually said to them….

whatsmyusername · 26/10/2021 09:04

As they would normally buy for you and they are still including all the other partners it does sound like a bit of a mistake. I doubt it would be deliberate as you say you would normally be included.

Careless of what people say it would be awkward on the day if they are not swapping presents in advance and doing it face to face. As no one knows who has who they wouldn't even realise their mistake until the time comes.

DP just needs to casually mention you haven't got someone to buy for so he thinks you've been missed out can they redraw. If everyone has brought their presents just make a joke and buy your own secret Santa and pop it in the pile.
Is it possible they would still buy for you and DS anyway and are expecting gifts in return?

MrsSpringWater · 26/10/2021 09:02

@Brentmeister I have no real advice, sorry but I just wanted to say pretty much the exact same thing happened to me a few years ago (not being included in my long term partner’s family secret Santa)

It’s been years since that happened and I’m still very sad about it. Sorry as I said no real advice here but I just wanted to say that your feelings are valid. I was made to feel at the time that I was imagining things (I was not…)

Best to have a chat with your DP. Just be honest about how you feel and ask honesty from him too. Hopefully he genuinely hasn’t thought about it and not purposely left you out x

user1471538283 · 26/10/2021 09:01

I wouldn't go on Christmas Day and I would have nothing further to do with this. Your DP can source his own presents for his family; nothing to do with you and do not even suggest anything.

This is cruel. It is Christmas. I wouldn't let a stranger sit there and be the only one not to open anything let alone my partner! Could you go elsewhere this year? Maybe you have a girlfriend to spend the day with?

rainbowstardrops · 26/10/2021 09:00

Absolutely not being unreasonable! I'd be really hurt too.
I hope your partner has just got it mixed up and you are actually included. If not, I'd be telling him he can shove his family Christmas up his arse!

Monsterpumpkins · 26/10/2021 08:59

Sadly I think your dp will dig his heels in here and keep you out of the ss. He won't be admitting your feelings are valid anytime soon.
He won't admit he has goofed up.

HoardingSamphireSaurus · 26/10/2021 08:57

But you don’t usually buy them presents? Your partner puts your name on the present he buys and you don’t have joint finances. They buy for you and your son and you don’t give them anything usually ... As you only buy one present for your family I’d presume you’re not keen on buying presents

Can you not see the contradiction there?

Her DP buys for his sibs, their partners and kids, presents are from him, OP and her DS.

His family buy for their sibs, kids, incl OP and her DS - who knows who pays, who cares?

In her family the rules of Christmas are different. Nobody in DPs family are affected by that!

HoardingSamphireSaurus · 26/10/2021 08:54

[quote lughnasadh]@HoardingSamphireSaurus

OP says:

Yeah I have had a present off them since the first year we were together (this will be our 5th Christmas as a couple), always lovely presents. And they buy for DS as well. But this year they are just doing the secret Santa plus kids so DP will still be buying for all the kids.[/quote]
Oooh! I have had a present off them since the first year we were together I read that quite differently the first time round. My apologies

In a later post OP explains that the presents her dp gives are form him, her and her DS. DP will be paying for them but they are from all of them, as a family unit.

BungleandGeorge · 26/10/2021 08:50

But you don’t usually buy them presents? Your partner puts your name on the present he buys and you don’t have joint finances. They buy for you and your son and you don’t give them anything usually. Before moving in together and joining finances I think it’s more usual to buy separate presents. As you only buy one present for your family I’d presume you’re not keen on buying presents but I agree it would be polite to ask anyone at the Christmas dinner whether they want to be involved

lughnasadh · 26/10/2021 08:50

@HoardingSamphireSaurus

OP says:

Yeah I have had a present off them since the first year we were together (this will be our 5th Christmas as a couple), always lovely presents. And they buy for DS as well. But this year they are just doing the secret Santa plus kids so DP will still be buying for all the kids.

Branleuse · 26/10/2021 08:49

Id tell him that its really awkward now as youre supposed to go there for xmas but if youll be the only one empty handed its pretty mean and hardly makes you feel included

TheOccupier · 26/10/2021 08:49

Jeez, it's still two months away. He just needs to tell them to include you. Or why not start a Christmas Planning whatsapp group with all the adults who will be together on the day and mention it in there?

It sounds like his is the sort of family where if you're not married or even engaged, you aren't going to be considered one of them in the same way as the other married siblings' DPs. Maybe think about whether you're really OK with that before you commit to buying a house together without a ring on your finger!

MilduraS · 26/10/2021 08:49

Maybe he didn't want to include you in his family secret Santa because he chose not to be included in yours. Some people see presents as an obligation rather than a bit of fun so he might have assumed he was doing you a favour.

weebarra · 26/10/2021 08:49

DH's family do a secret Santa (£5 present) where we all buy something worth £5 for every member of his family. We included DH's DSis' now wife when they got together and other DSis' boyfriend, who's no longer on the scene. They're a very close family and wouldn't dream of not including even a new partner.

HoardingSamphireSaurus · 26/10/2021 08:44

@Polmuggle

Hang on a sec, have I got this right?

Every year they get you a present.

But you never get them one? DP does and you suggest ideas, but he pays for it and it's from him?

In which case, surely that's the problem?

No, you haven't got it right.

a) they don't get her a present every year
b) Every year she chooses their persents and they are sent from her DP, OP and OP's son

She pays for the presents for her family, he pays for the presents for his family.

timeisnotaline · 26/10/2021 08:42

You aren’t overreacting at all. There is no way I would go anywhere near his family for Christmas or have any gift suggestions for him if he doesn’t take steps to fix this, I’d rather poke my eyes out with needles.

FatCatThinCat · 26/10/2021 08:41

I wonder if he's told them not to include you as he's not included in your family's secret santa.