Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

So if the Minimum Wage increases...

488 replies

missbunnyrabbit · 25/10/2021 20:20

My own wage in a public sector job seems lower than ever. The article I read suggests the public sector pay freezes will end, but I doubt we'll get such a large pay rise!

Aibu to feel like packing my teacher job in to go and work a minimum wage job instead?

OP posts:
BoredZelda · 26/10/2021 08:31

I never have because I like to pretend otherwise! No one wants to think they are working for less than nmw.

If you worked it out, you’d find you wouldn’t be.

Sorry, but I think those furloughed SHOULD be the ones to pay most of it back. Not massive amounts, not all of it. But it infuriates me to think of people (cough ex-boyfriend cough) sitting at home, binge watching TV, whilst still getting 80%, while key workers like me are slogging our guts out and putting ourselves at risk of covid.

This is probably the most stupid thing I’ve read. Do you know what the point of furlough actually was? If someone has been on furlough and is on a low wage, how on earth do you expect them to be able to pay it back?

I have no problem with asking companies who managed to still make a profit during last year to pay back any furlough or grant they got (and some already have) but asking individuals is a ridiculous suggestion.

HalfwomanHalfcookie · 26/10/2021 08:28

I work two jobs in a school at the lower end of the pecking order. There's no doubt that teachers work extremely hard, and I will always defend them when a ridiculous teacher bashing thread appears.
In this case Op I don't think you cast yourself in a good light. You sound almost resentful that the lowest paid are going to get a little extra help. Also, just because your minimum wage job was easy and stress free, it doesn't mean other minimum wage jobs are.
From what I've read, the public sector pay freeze is ending next year, so hopefully you'll get your pay rise anyway, and the gap between your wage and the security guard at Tesco won't be so small.

MarshaBradyo · 26/10/2021 08:26

Feta I agree. It’s madness

At least this version might get people to think about the reality of it rather than pie in the sky magic finances

nosyupnorth · 26/10/2021 08:24

YANBU

People work and stress themselves in order to earn more to be able to afford to live securely and what do they get? Minimum wage once again nipping at their heels as the government pushes through increases without considering the knock-on effects.

If the government really wanted to do something for the poor they'd have let the UC uplift stay which benefited poorer households but came out of the tax of the rich instead of a minimum wage rise which shops and services will fund by increasing their prices resulting in cost of living impacts which will just push more people into poverty as the impact of those effects are marginal and will mostly be felt by those who were already struggling.

Fetarabbit · 26/10/2021 08:23

@MarshaBradyo

What do we actually want and need? A reasonable cost of living! What don't we want? A vote winning headline that will do nothing more than drive up prices and affect those out of work even more yay!

What do you think if the £15 idea from Labour?

Fucking madness. Unless they're planning to proportionally increase disability benefits etc, public sector jobs, and support smaller businesses who will have to let staff go. Can you imagine how much food and everything else will increase if the supply chain has that big of a change? It just means everything will be more expensive, what's the point?
Thehop · 26/10/2021 08:23

@YouJustFoldItIn I’ve never seen a nursery job advertised over nmw.

After many years service and an early years degree I worked my way to baby room manager and got nmw plus 5p an hour. No sick pay, bare minimum holiday which had bank holidays deducted (nursery still charged parents!) and 2 weeks for Christmas closure. Left me 2 weeks to choose for my family over the whole year. It’s just not sustainable for most of us to work in them.

Xenia · 26/10/2021 08:21

I remember when the very first ever in British history minimum wage came in in about 1999 by Labour. My school friend had a tiny dry cleaning and repairs business. She had about 20 part timers all on different amounts based on seniority, skills etc and suddenly every single one of them was bumped up to the highest pay of all of them - chaos. We could remove minimum wages, restrict labour supply and get wages up that way instead but neither party is committed to that so the minimum wage is here to stay. Hopefully it will mean we stop having to pay any benefits at all to those in full time work other than child benefit as the current system means we tax payers pay for tax credits for full time working families whilst their supermarket employers are in effect subsidised to pay them a low wage.

KeyboardWorriers · 26/10/2021 08:20

I just find threads like these so mind boggling.

Of course the public sector pay freeze needs addressing.

But in a professional job like teaching you have - scope for promotions and career progression; a very good pension; permanent contracts rather than zero hours; and in the case.of teaching you get a huge amount of holiday too (and I don't know what the Mumsnet teachers are doing wrong because my friends and family who.are teachers definitely all take the vast majority of every holiday off )

TractorAndHeadphones · 26/10/2021 08:20

There’s nothing wrong with wages. Wages are fine. It’s the cost of living that’s too high! Staples like rent, gas/electricity, childcare.

They can increase the wage all they like only for it to be soaked up by all this + NI increase

MarshaBradyo · 26/10/2021 08:17

What do we actually want and need? A reasonable cost of living! What don't we want? A vote winning headline that will do nothing more than drive up prices and affect those out of work even more yay!

What do you think if the £15 idea from Labour?

Fetarabbit · 26/10/2021 08:16

@AlphabetAerobics

MN at its finest! Grin

What do we want?

Wage parity!

When do we want it?

Now!

No! Not MY wage!

What do we actually want and need? A reasonable cost of living! What don't we want? A vote winning headline that will do nothing more than drive up prices and affect those out of work even more yay!
AlphabetAerobics · 26/10/2021 08:13

MN at its finest! Grin

What do we want?

Wage parity!

When do we want it?

Now!

No! Not MY wage!

Whenthedealgoesdown · 26/10/2021 08:12

In most low paid jobs their are often layers of workers where a supervisor will be paid 50p an hour more, surely these people will all need a rise as well so the difference stays the same. How Labour's £15 an hour would have worked, I do not know

name532 · 26/10/2021 08:12

Whilst I have no issue with minimum wage rising of course, it doesn't work to just have one section of workers having rises. Whenever there was a minimum wage rise our nursery would need to increase their prices, this was when my pay wasn't hugely more than minimum wage and frozen, so it would be a big struggle for us. Now we aren't reliant on childcare and have much higher wages it doesn't impact us in that way anymore, but back then it was really difficult. Those just outside of help are expected to bear the biggest brunt in changes like this.

CeeJay81 · 26/10/2021 08:06

I can understand where the op is coming from cause I do think teachers are undervalued. I'm sort of lucky in my minimum wage job(currently it's £9.50 ph, we might get £10 when it goes up). I have job security, 30 hr contract, sick pay, decent amount of holidays(not 12 weeks a year like a teacher but I get 7). So I get how teachers feel under valued for what they do. However you couldn't work my job without childcare issues. The store is open from 7am(you work from 6) till 10pm. So the hours are very variable, it's rubbish if you've got kids. Minimum wage jobs are rarely 9-5 and having the school hols off is a great benefit for a teacher.

vickibee · 26/10/2021 08:02

I also think it depend where you live in th UK, a teacher or nurse’s salary in Yorkshire will go further than in the south east. Maybe public sector wages should be adjusted to reflect the cost of living ? Just a thought.My friend is a classroom teacher and earns £35 k which is a good salary in this part of the world where you can buy a decent house for £200k in a nice area.

MarshaBradyo · 26/10/2021 08:01

I wouldn’t leave op for this, but up to you of course

But also if this small rise causes question on thread Labour’s £15 must seem crazy

Iirc that was their version

Fujimora · 26/10/2021 08:01

If the jobs that don't need such education or training, and have much less stress and workload, are paid closer and closer to what trained professionals earn, then why would anyone choose to be a trained professional? Unless they genuinely loved the job

You are wrong to think that minimum wage jobs come without stress or workload.
Most also come without any kind of benefits (sick leave, decent pension) status, progression or job satisfaction.

If you want to stop being a teacher and start working as a delivery driver go for it!

RubyJam · 26/10/2021 08:00

@MissM2912

Op- you are coming across as really quite arrogant and immature. I earn more than a teacher, and have a stressful (at times) job also in the education sector. Could my staff on minimum wage do my job- many of them probably couldn’t because of the skills, education and experience needed. However- I also know that in terms of over all job satisfaction and life standards mine is much higher and I in no way equate what I should earn based on what they do. Many of those on minimum wage jobs have a pretty rubbish time and significantly reduced life expectancy as a direct result of living in poverty and doing manual/ physical work. That alone should compensate for the fact they haven’t had the privilege of a university education! Show some compassion and stop playing the victim. Nothing grates me more than teachers who complain about a career they chose.
Great post Totally agree
Tigerblue · 26/10/2021 08:00

I wonder what will happen at work. One of my jobs is public sector, and yes a pay freeze - they'll have to pay us all the minimum wage whatever. However, a few of us are paid more due to the fact that when we were taken our job was on a different pay scale and we're on a different grade. Either way, we're all paid below the new minimum wage, so wondering if there'll be any acknowledgement for those of us who have a lot more experience and confidence to deal with everything.

I've survived three lots of redundancies in my other job. Most staff will now be due a pay increase, but worrying as we're on bare minimum of staff and takings are well short of pre-lockdown.

Postapocalypticcowgirl · 26/10/2021 08:00

Oh, and FWIW, the pay for qualified early years staff is criminal.

Fetarabbit · 26/10/2021 07:59

And their benefits aren't rising.

Fetarabbit · 26/10/2021 07:59

hate the idea of it actually paying anywhere near like enough ( and this rise still isn’t enough to live on)

It's astounding the amount of people who don't understand economics. There are plenty of ways the government could make the cost of living more affordable without intervening in stuff, like taking the energy cap off and reviewing some stuff. When the cost of everything inevitably rises, how do you think those on benefits- such as long term disability etc will fare? It's not as simple as yay raise wages and everyone will be better off.

Postapocalypticcowgirl · 26/10/2021 07:57

I don't think it's a good idea to argue about "who has it worse" and I totally agree that NMW should go up, but if teachers' pay and conditions are soooo good, then why do we have so many shortages? Like a PP, my school tried to recruit maternity cover in a core subject recently, and not one person applied.

Yes, in some areas, there are plenty of teachers, but for some subjects there are massive shortages, especially in places where it's pretty expensive to live.

Last half term was especially tough, and I do think some people fantasize about leaving for a minimum wage job where they could leave their work at the door!

A lot of people don't stay in teaching long enough to get any real benefit from the pension- that should tell you something too.

Fetarabbit · 26/10/2021 07:56

@YouJustFoldItIn

My preschool is likely to close, I won’t be able to afford to pay the nursery staff any more money than I already do, unless the government increase the funding rates which I doubt they will. We barely survived last year. We won’t survive this increase.

I also run a preschool and we are in exactly the same position. With this and the staff shortages meaning we can't have enough children on the books to keep us afloat, our preschool is in real trouble.

So you both employ staff who have had to undergo lengthy training in ad vocational qualification to do what they do, and you pay them minimum wage?

It's almost as if the government should properly fund childcare provision isn't it (no, not fully fund, but adequately). Blaming providers is pointless, many are desperately trying to make ends meet, increasing fees often isn't an option as already a full time place is £1k plus and it would become even more unaffordable to many families. 'Free hours' at 2/3 are very costly to nurseries and childcare settings, keen to hear your ideas though as to how pay staff a higher wage (many managers would love to be able to offer this), whilst being accessible (if no one can afford to use you then you won't fill spaces)?