Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

So if the Minimum Wage increases...

488 replies

missbunnyrabbit · 25/10/2021 20:20

My own wage in a public sector job seems lower than ever. The article I read suggests the public sector pay freezes will end, but I doubt we'll get such a large pay rise!

Aibu to feel like packing my teacher job in to go and work a minimum wage job instead?

OP posts:
name532 · 26/10/2021 09:27

Ok so if everyone gets the same pay rise (percentage wise) then its not really a pay rise and money begins to lose its value.

But that's essentially what needs to happen, everyone needs pay rises in line with inflation, yes things continue to increase but that happens anyway generally, has done for centuries.

TravellingSpoon · 26/10/2021 09:27

@Moaningturtle

Care worker here, I’d like to outline my daily conditions and work benefits. It would be AMAZING if more people could jack in their teaching/public sector/small business jobs and come join us in an industry that is rapidly loosing staff due to brexit and forced vaccination.

21:10 - arrive at work to start getting handover for the 30 clients we have, 18-64 year olds with severe physical and learning disabilities. Make detailed notes about their current wellbeing and any plans in place regarding medication, specialist equipment and therapies.

21:30 - start getting paid a few pence above NMW

21:30- 01:00am - with one other colleague (only 2 people on nights) put to bed 30 fully grown men and women, all of whom have continence needs (wee and poo cleaning up). None of our clients are mobile, we have to use hoists and our own backs to safely lift people up to 25stone into bed. Apply creams and use special equipment to prevent pressure areas. All while being buzzed all over the building to do small tasks like fetch drinks, turn tv channels, someone needs a wee etc etc

01:00- 6:00 - clean entire building, mop floors, disinfect all contact areas, deal with clinical waste, do laundry for all clients. All while answering buzzers for use of wee bottles, changing incontinence pads, someone’s been sick, some one needs an ambulance or OOH dr etc etc.

06:00 - start getting people up and showered, make breakfast and feed/observe them eating if they are choking risk. Do medications (carefully, I could actually kill someone)

07:30 - stop getting paid, but can’t go home as there’s not enough day staff to relieve us.

08:15 - probably get to go home by now.

(Currently you will be expected to work the whole shift in full PPE)

Benefits -

Sick pay after a year, maximum of 2 weeks then on SSP.

Peoples pension

Cycle to work (beware, a colleague was so tired after her shift she was knocked off her bike and the sick pay wouldn’t cover the recovery time. She is no longer physically able to work in care)

28 days annual leave plus bank holidays.

Ongoing mandatory training (this probably won’t be paid but might look good on your CV)

Full time hours will net you approx £1150 pcm.

You forgot to mention the facts that weekends and public holidays are just normal days!

And yes, if people do want to kack in a £30k a year job to come and help out, that would be great. We are a small unit and are losing 7 members of staff (from a team of 20) next month. I heard the Social Care minister say that the government have done some sums and they think the way to fix the crisis is to give carers money for more childcare, so they can work more hours as the government has judged there to be capacity in the system for those already in it to work more. I do a 45 hour week most weeks and barely see my children. Most of my colleages are the same. Its exhausting and can be thankless and you run the risk of being so tired you make mistakes - especially medication. (although Matt Hancock did give us a badge last year!)

Although I couldnt imagine doing anything else I often think that people on higher paid salaries who dream that being in a NMW job would be less stressed are like the woman that Jarvis Cocker sings about in 'Common People'.

Thecurliestwurly · 26/10/2021 09:26

@Moaningturtle

Care worker here, I’d like to outline my daily conditions and work benefits. It would be AMAZING if more people could jack in their teaching/public sector/small business jobs and come join us in an industry that is rapidly loosing staff due to brexit and forced vaccination.

21:10 - arrive at work to start getting handover for the 30 clients we have, 18-64 year olds with severe physical and learning disabilities. Make detailed notes about their current wellbeing and any plans in place regarding medication, specialist equipment and therapies.

21:30 - start getting paid a few pence above NMW

21:30- 01:00am - with one other colleague (only 2 people on nights) put to bed 30 fully grown men and women, all of whom have continence needs (wee and poo cleaning up). None of our clients are mobile, we have to use hoists and our own backs to safely lift people up to 25stone into bed. Apply creams and use special equipment to prevent pressure areas. All while being buzzed all over the building to do small tasks like fetch drinks, turn tv channels, someone needs a wee etc etc

01:00- 6:00 - clean entire building, mop floors, disinfect all contact areas, deal with clinical waste, do laundry for all clients. All while answering buzzers for use of wee bottles, changing incontinence pads, someone’s been sick, some one needs an ambulance or OOH dr etc etc.

06:00 - start getting people up and showered, make breakfast and feed/observe them eating if they are choking risk. Do medications (carefully, I could actually kill someone)

07:30 - stop getting paid, but can’t go home as there’s not enough day staff to relieve us.

08:15 - probably get to go home by now.

(Currently you will be expected to work the whole shift in full PPE)

Benefits -

Sick pay after a year, maximum of 2 weeks then on SSP.

Peoples pension

Cycle to work (beware, a colleague was so tired after her shift she was knocked off her bike and the sick pay wouldn’t cover the recovery time. She is no longer physically able to work in care)

28 days annual leave plus bank holidays.

Ongoing mandatory training (this probably won’t be paid but might look good on your CV)

Full time hours will net you approx £1150 pcm.

I'm sorry you are being treated like this. It reminds me of when I worked in care. I used to work a few days a week while at uni and never got above 8 stone in weight because I had to work so bloody hard on my shifts! Same with the next SW job where I was on my feet for 14 hour shifts. I don't think people understand how bad it is. You stay because you care about your clients and working in care doesn't give you many options career wise. I now sit on my arse all day so am much fatter, better off financially and feel much more appreciated and respected.

My niece asked about working in care and I was honest - you don't get paid much, you get abused quite a lot and it can be a dead end career wise. The lovely feeling you get when you start a care job goes after a couple of years and you just end up burnt out. Care workers, nurses, teachers, public services definitely deserve a pay rise. I think everyone does as wages have not kept up with inflation.

BitterTits · 26/10/2021 09:26

@Notashandyta

I'm pretty sure that you don't resent the minimum wage increase, you just want a fair wage yourself. If you worked out how much teachers actually get paid 'per hour', it would be far, far less than the minimum wage.

This isn't true and makes teachers a laughing stock (I'm a teacher). You'd have to be woefully incompetent to be making 'far, far less than the minimum wage'.

newtb · 26/10/2021 09:20

The problem with increasing the minimum wage irrespective of others is that it erodes the difference between someone who's just started and someone who maybe has several years experience and additional qualifications.
The big problem is that it's a one sizr fits all, which is not the case.

Warmduscher · 26/10/2021 09:18

@Moaningturtle

Thank you for all that you do for vulnerable people Flowers

Thecurliestwurly · 26/10/2021 09:16

I used to think this when working as a support worker. I was paid more than minimum wage, but not much more. I was frequently abused by service users, had no career progression and never had breaks. It seemed much more appealing to lose 20p an hours for a job with less stress.

I do believe that minimum wage should increase though, but there will come a point where other jobs won't see the increase and they will be hard to recruit into. It will be swallowed up with inflation though. Nobody will be better off apart from the government who have ticked their box. It is just reducing the impact of inflation. It isn't more money to save or spend above what people have been spending.

I do think a payrise should be seen across the board, but no idea how you would implement that. Ultimately businesses will past the cost on to consumers as they believe they can't afford it. For some this will be a reality, but for many it isn't, it is just greed or large companies not managing their finances properly and on paper are successful businesses but are actually in serious debt.

Clocktopus · 26/10/2021 09:11

We could remove minimum wages, restrict labour supply and get wages up that way instead

Except it wouldn't work and part of the reason NMW was brought in was because of employers paying, frankly criminally, low wages. I was in sixth form and had a weekend job in a shop when NMW came in, my wage was just £1.15 an hour prior to that.

Warmduscher · 26/10/2021 09:11

@BoredZelda

and yes I know you still have to work but school is closed so you don’t have to be in the classroom

When I speak to teacher friends who are actually honest about it, this whole “we work all through the holidays” turns out to be a little bit of nonsense. Of the 13 weeks holiday, my teacher friends have maybe about two or three weeks work to do. It isn’t the hardship we are led to believe it is.

No, you’re right, I probably worded it wrong.

It just used to rankle when people would talk about how great it must be to have long holidays - as a school family support worker, I wasn’t paid in the holidays. My salary was stretched out over the year so I had something coming in every month. Not sure if it’s the same for teachers.

Moaningturtle · 26/10/2021 09:11

Care worker here, I’d like to outline my daily conditions and work benefits. It would be AMAZING if more people could jack in their teaching/public sector/small business jobs and come join us in an industry that is rapidly loosing staff due to brexit and forced vaccination.

21:10 - arrive at work to start getting handover for the 30 clients we have, 18-64 year olds with severe physical and learning disabilities. Make detailed notes about their current wellbeing and any plans in place regarding medication, specialist equipment and therapies.

21:30 - start getting paid a few pence above NMW

21:30- 01:00am - with one other colleague (only 2 people on nights) put to bed 30 fully grown men and women, all of whom have continence needs (wee and poo cleaning up). None of our clients are mobile, we have to use hoists and our own backs to safely lift people up to 25stone into bed. Apply creams and use special equipment to prevent pressure areas. All while being buzzed all over the building to do small tasks like fetch drinks, turn tv channels, someone needs a wee etc etc

01:00- 6:00 - clean entire building, mop floors, disinfect all contact areas, deal with clinical waste, do laundry for all clients. All while answering buzzers for use of wee bottles, changing incontinence pads, someone’s been sick, some one needs an ambulance or OOH dr etc etc.

06:00 - start getting people up and showered, make breakfast and feed/observe them eating if they are choking risk. Do medications (carefully, I could actually kill someone)

07:30 - stop getting paid, but can’t go home as there’s not enough day staff to relieve us.

08:15 - probably get to go home by now.

(Currently you will be expected to work the whole shift in full PPE)

Benefits -

Sick pay after a year, maximum of 2 weeks then on SSP.

Peoples pension

Cycle to work (beware, a colleague was so tired after her shift she was knocked off her bike and the sick pay wouldn’t cover the recovery time. She is no longer physically able to work in care)

28 days annual leave plus bank holidays.

Ongoing mandatory training (this probably won’t be paid but might look good on your CV)

Full time hours will net you approx £1150 pcm.

KevinTheKoala · 26/10/2021 09:05

Ok so if everyone gets the same pay rise (percentage wise) then its not really a pay rise and money begins to lose its value. Eventually professional wages will go up because that is what happens, the less skilled jobs begin to get paid more and the professional sectors start to struggle so they increase their wages to encourage more workers to train for that job. It can't all happen at the same time because that is not how the economy works. A 59p per hour wage increase will mean, as others have pointed out that there is less being paid out in benefits and more being paid in in taxes which then benefits the public sector in terms of funding. (Well it probably won't because we have a tory government who couldn't care less about the dregs of society but that's another topic).

Begrudging people on NMW who can barely afford to get by and many of whom do actually have qualifications and training and do jobs that others could not do - even if they do hold a degree - a tiny pay rise is a bit childish really and not looking at the bigger picture. We need 'unskilled' workers (I've never actually met a truly unskilled worker by the way) to function as a society, and so those people need to be able to afford to live.

Magicalwoodlands · 26/10/2021 08:51

By all means shoot me, but I don’t think salaries are a problem for teachers. I believe there are countless other issues that need dealing with regarding workload, but I don’t actually think the salaries are bad at all.

It isn’t (or shouldn’t be) about squabbling around ‘well you get this’ ‘well yes but you get that.’ Some roles have perks so integral to them that it isn’t really a perk at all, it is just how things are - you might as well say flight attendants have great jobs as they get to travel (you don’t say) or bar workers because they get free drinks.

But people complaining that it’s all the fault of the Tories that minimum wage is raised - er, what? The original Labour movement was about improving pay and conditions for the working classes, not ensuring that teachers stay a cut above them Hmm

BoredZelda · 26/10/2021 08:51

and yes I know you still have to work but school is closed so you don’t have to be in the classroom

When I speak to teacher friends who are actually honest about it, this whole “we work all through the holidays” turns out to be a little bit of nonsense. Of the 13 weeks holiday, my teacher friends have maybe about two or three weeks work to do. It isn’t the hardship we are led to believe it is.

Popcornriver · 26/10/2021 08:50

Fetarabbit

Oh I agree with everyone saying it's not a perfect solution. I can definitely see problems.

My post was in response to the OP who mainly disagrees because she wants her wage to remain well above others in 'lower' positions. Regardless if that 'lower' position means gruelling work, longer hours and the need to claim universal credit to buy food.

Fetarabbit · 26/10/2021 08:50

@BoredZelda

But many will actually be worse off. As the cost of everything increases, the government will deem them not eligible for top ups.

I’d like to see the actual maths on that.

If the government were really arsed they would make changes to make the cost of living more affordable.

How would they do that? The government can’t control private business prices, and nor should they.

The actual maths- like basic economics? Okay.

They don't have to control private business prices to stop the cost of living spiralling, there are plenty of ways, they set VAT on fuel, council taxes, subsidies they give to nurseries etc.

Eleganz · 26/10/2021 08:46

@Ilovegreentomatoes

It's a measly increase but its whipped up some into a frenzy.
I can only dream of 6.6% to be fair.
Ilovegreentomatoes · 26/10/2021 08:46

It's a measly increase but its whipped up some into a frenzy.

Eleganz · 26/10/2021 08:46

@nosyupnorth

YANBU

People work and stress themselves in order to earn more to be able to afford to live securely and what do they get? Minimum wage once again nipping at their heels as the government pushes through increases without considering the knock-on effects.

If the government really wanted to do something for the poor they'd have let the UC uplift stay which benefited poorer households but came out of the tax of the rich instead of a minimum wage rise which shops and services will fund by increasing their prices resulting in cost of living impacts which will just push more people into poverty as the impact of those effects are marginal and will mostly be felt by those who were already struggling.

My view is that we should be living in a society where anyone working full time shouldn't need propping up with benefits. Sadly this was the New Labour "third way" that has stuck one way or another even into UC. Sadly employers can't be trusted to raise wages during growth periods, particularly for the lowest paid workers. Even when shit employers are struggling to fill vacancies.

We have a low wage economy in the UK, particularly for professionals. I used to work for a German company and my colleagues in equivalent roles over there earned far more than me and other UK colleagues. Even after the supposedly higher taxes (let's not talk about the huge number of tax breaks there are in Germany) they were taking home considerably more. Cost of living isn't that different in Germany to here, how do they make it work?

I think most people are well overdue a decent pay rise after a decade of below inflation ones. Although the minimum wage rise is welcome I doubt the government are going to follow suit with public sector pay at large.

BoredZelda · 26/10/2021 08:43

But many will actually be worse off. As the cost of everything increases, the government will deem them not eligible for top ups.

I’d like to see the actual maths on that.

If the government were really arsed they would make changes to make the cost of living more affordable.

How would they do that? The government can’t control private business prices, and nor should they.

Warmduscher · 26/10/2021 08:41

OP, it sounds to me like you’re just burnt out from teaching.

I agree with PP that maybe stepping “down” into a minimum wage job sounds like the best solution, especially if you have previous experience. You’d walk into a job, I’m sure.

One thing you might want to consider though, if you plan to have children, is that having school holidays “off” (and yes I know you still have to work but school is closed so you don’t have to be in the classroom) means no childcare costs.

That’s why my DM chose teaching - she had three children at home and no other way to cover school holidays.

BoredZelda · 26/10/2021 08:41

She had about 20 part timers all on different amounts based on seniority, skills etc and suddenly every single one of them was bumped up to the highest pay of all of them - chaos.

Your friend was seriously underpaying staff if the most senior member was getting minimum wage. The taxpayer was subsidising the business and they were pocketing the profits. I’m glad the MW came in to correct that.

Fetarabbit · 26/10/2021 08:40

@Popcornriver

Yes let's just keep those lazy careworkers in their easy jobs on pay so low they need to claim top up benefits and use foodbanks. Then even better we can call them work shy and look down on them!

I'm in a position similar to you OP and I think you're being massively unreasonable.

But many will actually be worse off. As the cost of everything increases, the government will deem them not eligible for top ups. If the government were really arsed they would make changes to make the cost of living more affordable.
Popcornriver · 26/10/2021 08:38

Yes let's just keep those lazy careworkers in their easy jobs on pay so low they need to claim top up benefits and use foodbanks. Then even better we can call them work shy and look down on them!

I'm in a position similar to you OP and I think you're being massively unreasonable.

IsEveryUserNameBloodyTaken · 26/10/2021 08:34

As far as I can see the idea is to get less money paid out by the taxpayer for topping up wages that do not cover the cost of living especially housing,with benefits.
The government has thrown everything it can to keep house prices as high as possible.
This is where all the money has gone.

MarshaBradyo · 26/10/2021 08:32

Also I find it concerning any party who thinks plucking a high number (£15) out of the air is reasonable and economically sound.

Swipe left for the next trending thread