Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

So if the Minimum Wage increases...

488 replies

missbunnyrabbit · 25/10/2021 20:20

My own wage in a public sector job seems lower than ever. The article I read suggests the public sector pay freezes will end, but I doubt we'll get such a large pay rise!

Aibu to feel like packing my teacher job in to go and work a minimum wage job instead?

OP posts:
Moaningturtle · 26/10/2021 10:41

[quote Moaningturtle]@ancientgran yes, elderly care is a lot less hands on. But we are dealing with adults who want fully active lives involving going out late, drinking, watching Netflix until 3am like the rest of us! Not content to be tucked up and fast asleep by 11pm, our jobs would be much easier!!.

There are plenty of care homes for 18-64 year olds and people seem to forget about that and assume it’s all old people. Also 18-64 yr olds are fully funded by the local authorities, so the profit is minimal. Hence no extra money to pay for training.

It’s great that you get better conditions, let’s hope it has a knock on effect 💕[/quote]
Also, the added health complexities of those with conditions such as severe cerebral palsy or spina bifida or MND means it’s much more medical than elderly care. Much more like proper nursing actually, but we still get paid NMW and it’s assumed that we have a low responsibility job.

MasterGland · 26/10/2021 10:39

Before I became a teacher, I had a corporate career. Part of my role involved monitoring the gross margin throughout the year. There was a target % that had to be met. No question. Any cost rises from currency movements, transport increases etc. were passed on to the customer. This was generally non-negotiable. The company was privately owned. The chairman took a personal payment of several million a year. He would not accept anything less.
This is why prices will rise with the nmw. Because those at the top will refuse to reduce the profit they make.

I earn £40k in teaching. I think that's fine. But I think there should be contraction either side of my position in the hierarchy; those at the top should be paid less and those at the bottom should be paid more. I think people struggle to fully comprehend just how much money is paid to those at the very top.

berlinbabylon · 26/10/2021 10:39

Working in a shop is stressful but when you go home you forget it. No waking up in the middle of the night stressing about whether you said the right thing to Little Johnnie's parent or how you're going to cope with your awkward Y9 Maths class tomorrow, etc. I can completely see why you might take a pay cut to do a less stressful job and people do it all the time. Plus the fact you don't have to work in a supermarket - there are nice retail jobs like working in a bookshop or a nice clothes chain like Fat Face.

As for people whinging about affording pay rises - if you need to exploit your staff to make a profit, your business isn't viable. It's that simple.

Moaningturtle · 26/10/2021 10:31

@ancientgran yes, elderly care is a lot less hands on. But we are dealing with adults who want fully active lives involving going out late, drinking, watching Netflix until 3am like the rest of us! Not content to be tucked up and fast asleep by 11pm, our jobs would be much easier!!.

There are plenty of care homes for 18-64 year olds and people seem to forget about that and assume it’s all old people. Also 18-64 yr olds are fully funded by the local authorities, so the profit is minimal. Hence no extra money to pay for training.

It’s great that you get better conditions, let’s hope it has a knock on effect 💕

Dishwashersaurous · 26/10/2021 10:30

OK. So take a small preschool nursery.

Great provision, wonderful staff, loved by families.

84% of costs are staff costs.

95% of income comes from funded hours paid by the council.

The council funding is not going up.

The wage bill for all staff will have to go up. Unqualified staff on minimum wage. Qualified staff and team leaders to maintain the differential.

So a 6.6% rise in wage bill roughly.

And a 0% increase in income.

How are they supposed to survive?

Moaningturtle · 26/10/2021 10:26

@Marelle

The issue is that you have a worker earning min wage and a supervisor earning min wage plus 50p. So as soon as min wage goes up by 50p the supervisor says “well I’m not doing the extra work of being a supervisor if I’m on the same wage as the worker underneath me who doesn’t have that responsibility”. So then the supervisor has to receive a 50p wage increase too. Apply that throughout the company pay structure and there are a lot of people needing pay increases, not just the staff on min wage.
The supervisor should have been paid more in the first place. If the company can’t run a viable pay structure then it’s not a viable company. They should look at where else to cut costs rather than staff salaries. By doing things such as - negotiate better rents, cheaper and more sustainable energy, look at external contracts etc. You’d be surprised how much wastage big businesses have, they could pay staff appropriately and not have to increase the price to the consumer.

I have had insight via a close family member who worked at the very top of a now defunct big business (one that looted the staffs pensions…say no more) and the company was run appallingly, lots of big contracts going to friends - all the profits being used to make the top of the chain richer and the workers suffered.
I bet many work places (big retail especially) are run in a similar manner.

Brefugee · 26/10/2021 10:25

Years of study by social scientists and economists have shown that when the pay differentials between the top ones (CEOs etc) and the bottom ones (people on NMW and other low paid jobs) is smaller, overall happiness is higher. That is the Scandinavian countries, i think (not sure if they have changed)

And it is quite hilarious reading people on this thread basically wanting to protect pay differentials (pp's story about the dry cleaner's made me cringe - that was absolutely an exploitative business) which is what Unions bang on about all the time. I wonder how many of you are in a union? (and it doesn't matter if your company doesn't recognise your union, your industry would probably benefit from collective bargaining elsewhere anyway, and you certainly can use them for help whenever you need it)

OPs taken a bit of a bashing, but given the tone of their posts, that was to be expected. I think the biggest misunderstanding about low-pay and NMW jobs is that it can't be extrapolated over a year, because the hours fluctuate and there aren't that many of them that are 40 hours a week regularly enough to do that.

There are no easy answers here.

ancientgran · 26/10/2021 10:19

Just to add we get paid NMW or NLW whatever they want to call it for the sleep hours.

ancientgran · 26/10/2021 10:19

@Moaningturtle

Care worker here, I’d like to outline my daily conditions and work benefits. It would be AMAZING if more people could jack in their teaching/public sector/small business jobs and come join us in an industry that is rapidly loosing staff due to brexit and forced vaccination.

21:10 - arrive at work to start getting handover for the 30 clients we have, 18-64 year olds with severe physical and learning disabilities. Make detailed notes about their current wellbeing and any plans in place regarding medication, specialist equipment and therapies.

21:30 - start getting paid a few pence above NMW

21:30- 01:00am - with one other colleague (only 2 people on nights) put to bed 30 fully grown men and women, all of whom have continence needs (wee and poo cleaning up). None of our clients are mobile, we have to use hoists and our own backs to safely lift people up to 25stone into bed. Apply creams and use special equipment to prevent pressure areas. All while being buzzed all over the building to do small tasks like fetch drinks, turn tv channels, someone needs a wee etc etc

01:00- 6:00 - clean entire building, mop floors, disinfect all contact areas, deal with clinical waste, do laundry for all clients. All while answering buzzers for use of wee bottles, changing incontinence pads, someone’s been sick, some one needs an ambulance or OOH dr etc etc.

06:00 - start getting people up and showered, make breakfast and feed/observe them eating if they are choking risk. Do medications (carefully, I could actually kill someone)

07:30 - stop getting paid, but can’t go home as there’s not enough day staff to relieve us.

08:15 - probably get to go home by now.

(Currently you will be expected to work the whole shift in full PPE)

Benefits -

Sick pay after a year, maximum of 2 weeks then on SSP.

Peoples pension

Cycle to work (beware, a colleague was so tired after her shift she was knocked off her bike and the sick pay wouldn’t cover the recovery time. She is no longer physically able to work in care)

28 days annual leave plus bank holidays.

Ongoing mandatory training (this probably won’t be paid but might look good on your CV)

Full time hours will net you approx £1150 pcm.

It varies alot. I work in a care home where everyone is in bed settled by 11pm. Staff are then on call but most nights sleep through till 6 am. If someone is ill you can end up having a waking night but not the norm at all. We all have paid time for mandatory training and any training is paid for.
Marelle · 26/10/2021 10:16

The issue is that you have a worker earning min wage and a supervisor earning min wage plus 50p. So as soon as min wage goes up by 50p the supervisor says “well I’m not doing the extra work of being a supervisor if I’m on the same wage as the worker underneath me who doesn’t have that responsibility”. So then the supervisor has to receive a 50p wage increase too. Apply that throughout the company pay structure and there are a lot of people needing pay increases, not just the staff on min wage.

ancientgran · 26/10/2021 10:14

@Stompythedinosaur

You aren't worse off because someone else has a pay rise.

Don't get sacked into thinking other workers are the issue.

Actually you are if prices go up. If you lived through the 70s you would be well aware that inflation and interest rates meant that many of us ended the 70s earning alot more than we did at the beginning but were no better off or were even worse off.
Fetarabbit · 26/10/2021 10:13

I do think the care sector should either be better regulated or government run (albeit well run as a opposed to many other government agencies). Whilst there is profit in it and a questionable funding model, its never going to be a sector where people are paid fairly, have chances of progression and structured training that's consistent across the board- and it absolutely should.

I'd extend this to unpaid carers too, who should absolutely receive more monetary support and access to actual support.

Caring as a whole is massively devalued, both monetarily wise and by society, but I don't think this will make much difference at all. Childcare is too, no one will ever really change that as they'll get the howls of well I don't have kids why should I pay etc.

Elephantsparade · 26/10/2021 10:12

Just to make it clear, I dont begrudge minimum wage workers getting a payrise and agree the issue is the top end of the pay structure not the bottom.

Bucanarab · 26/10/2021 10:09

It's sad to see so many people here would begrudge someone on nmw a pay rise because of a misplaced sense of superiority. That's exactly the sort of attitude that's got us into the situation we're in now.

Broadly speaking we have accepted pay structures of something like the below

CEO/Director - £3000
Senior manager - £100
Manager - £15
Team leader - £9.
Worker- £8.91

What those objecting to a nmw rise apparently want to see happen.

CEO - £4000
SM - £125
Manager - £18
Team leader - £10.
Worker- £9.50

And this what we should be striving to see happen.

CEO - £500
SM - £125
Manager - £35
Team leader - £20
Worker- £15

We need to bring the bottom up and the top way way down, not just move everyone up a few % more.

MimiDaisy11 · 26/10/2021 10:04

Funny how no one talks of increased costs being passed on when bankers or any high earners get extra millions paid to them but some shop worker being able to afford their rent is apparently terrible for the economy.

Wages as a percentage cost to employers has gone down over the past few decades yet we don’t get a benefit from that but we’ll all apparently suffer if wages go up for those on low earning jobs. Imagine if lower paid workers had more spending power then they’d actually be able to stimulate the economy more as a higher percentage of their money earned gets spent.

Elephantsparade · 26/10/2021 09:59

I work in a school but am probably more affected by this than a teacher because support staff terms and conditions are different than teachers. I earn £9.47 an hour so I presume I would go up 3p even though there is a pay freeze and then the people who are all a grade lower than me would now earn the same. But I dont think i would change jobs because my hours are regular and at social times and my employer does pay 8% into a pension wheras some employers pay the minimum which is more like 2%. I also get sick pay which would cover 6 months. Its also a nice environment to work in and I get job satisfaction. I might consider dropping a grade though if it is the same money as it doesnt seem worth the extra responsibility.
I think people forget a lot of public sector roles are set at or just above minimum wage and the qualifications or responsibilities to end up just 50p or so above minimum wage role in your same organisation are quite a lot of effort.

Stompythedinosaur · 26/10/2021 09:55

You aren't worse off because someone else has a pay rise.

Don't get sacked into thinking other workers are the issue.

Moaningturtle · 26/10/2021 09:50

@Moaningturtle

Care worker here, I’d like to outline my daily conditions and work benefits. It would be AMAZING if more people could jack in their teaching/public sector/small business jobs and come join us in an industry that is rapidly loosing staff due to brexit and forced vaccination.

21:10 - arrive at work to start getting handover for the 30 clients we have, 18-64 year olds with severe physical and learning disabilities. Make detailed notes about their current wellbeing and any plans in place regarding medication, specialist equipment and therapies.

21:30 - start getting paid a few pence above NMW

21:30- 01:00am - with one other colleague (only 2 people on nights) put to bed 30 fully grown men and women, all of whom have continence needs (wee and poo cleaning up). None of our clients are mobile, we have to use hoists and our own backs to safely lift people up to 25stone into bed. Apply creams and use special equipment to prevent pressure areas. All while being buzzed all over the building to do small tasks like fetch drinks, turn tv channels, someone needs a wee etc etc

01:00- 6:00 - clean entire building, mop floors, disinfect all contact areas, deal with clinical waste, do laundry for all clients. All while answering buzzers for use of wee bottles, changing incontinence pads, someone’s been sick, some one needs an ambulance or OOH dr etc etc.

06:00 - start getting people up and showered, make breakfast and feed/observe them eating if they are choking risk. Do medications (carefully, I could actually kill someone)

07:30 - stop getting paid, but can’t go home as there’s not enough day staff to relieve us.

08:15 - probably get to go home by now.

(Currently you will be expected to work the whole shift in full PPE)

Benefits -

Sick pay after a year, maximum of 2 weeks then on SSP.

Peoples pension

Cycle to work (beware, a colleague was so tired after her shift she was knocked off her bike and the sick pay wouldn’t cover the recovery time. She is no longer physically able to work in care)

28 days annual leave plus bank holidays.

Ongoing mandatory training (this probably won’t be paid but might look good on your CV)

Full time hours will net you approx £1150 pcm.

I will add, we do get to sit down and eat/have a cuppa whenever we have chance too, at least an hour a night if not more. And that’s paid. I’m not a total martyr.
Feelingoktoday · 26/10/2021 09:41

I’m sorry but I don’t think bankers need a pay rise. I have friends in this sector who are still getting bonuses and good pay offs.

Not everyone needs a 6% pay rise.

Feelingoktoday · 26/10/2021 09:39

@TheFairPrincess

I do think this thread shows a bad nature toward others. Mustering up bitterness when comparing yourself to the bottom line is part of the problem.

Also, I don't understand how you cannot see the glaring difference between salaried and unsalaried work. If you or your DC are ill, you have to consider whether you can afford to be off. How stressful is that?

Exactly 100%. Why are we British so keen for everyone to be bottom. A 6% pay rise on minimum wage is not a lot because minimum wage is so low. When you don’t have a lot a 100% increase isn’t much.
LoisWooookersonsLastNerve · 26/10/2021 09:39

I hate all this pettiness over who works harder. Divide and conquer. Don't fall for it! I have had two professional jobs. One was very difficult, one was easy. I have also worked in care, horrendously difficult and now working in retail, fun and easy to some extent yes but the conditions are terrible. People need to be paid a living wage. Professional pay has stagnated and needs to be better too. Simple.

Warmduscher · 26/10/2021 09:39

[quote Moaningturtle]@TravellingSpoon I also forgot the little green “Care” badge Matt Hancock gave us at the start of the pandemic! That made me feel hugely more appreciated by the minister. Grin[/quote]
What a great substitute for a decent wage, I’m sure you’d agree Sad

TravellingSpoon · 26/10/2021 09:37

[quote Moaningturtle]@TravellingSpoon I also forgot the little green “Care” badge Matt Hancock gave us at the start of the pandemic! That made me feel hugely more appreciated by the minister. Grin[/quote]
A great ift that we cant wear on our uniforms as its too much of a risk. I think mine is in my locker still.

Moaningturtle · 26/10/2021 09:32

@TravellingSpoon I also forgot the little green “Care” badge Matt Hancock gave us at the start of the pandemic! That made me feel hugely more appreciated by the minister. Grin

Moaningturtle · 26/10/2021 09:27

[quote Warmduscher]@Moaningturtle

Thank you for all that you do for vulnerable people Flowers[/quote]
Thank you for saying that. It actually is my absolute pleasure, I love all my clients and am privileged to know them all.

But I am getting a teeny bit frustrated with people using our work as an “easy” option to get out of their “much harder and more responsible” careers.

Come join us in care, we will welcome you with very open arms. But please don’t come with the illusion that you’ll be getting an easy ride for not much less money than teaching. Because you won’t last a month and we need you to stay.