Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

So if the Minimum Wage increases...

488 replies

missbunnyrabbit · 25/10/2021 20:20

My own wage in a public sector job seems lower than ever. The article I read suggests the public sector pay freezes will end, but I doubt we'll get such a large pay rise!

Aibu to feel like packing my teacher job in to go and work a minimum wage job instead?

OP posts:
Chill09 · 26/10/2021 13:56

@Dishwashersaurous you’ve just totally hit the nail on the head! Which is why the preschool I run will most likely have to close. I would love nothing more than to pay my staff the wage they deserve. But my hands are tied by the funding rate from the local authority. If the rate does not increase in line with the new minimum wage it won’t be a few nurseries closing it will be literally hundreds and before anyone says lobby the government for more funding early years settings have been for years with no luck.

Badbadbunny · 26/10/2021 13:51

@Bucanarab

It's sad to see so many people here would begrudge someone on nmw a pay rise because of a misplaced sense of superiority. That's exactly the sort of attitude that's got us into the situation we're in now.

Broadly speaking we have accepted pay structures of something like the below

CEO/Director - £3000
Senior manager - £100
Manager - £15
Team leader - £9.
Worker- £8.91

What those objecting to a nmw rise apparently want to see happen.

CEO - £4000
SM - £125
Manager - £18
Team leader - £10.
Worker- £9.50

And this what we should be striving to see happen.

CEO - £500
SM - £125
Manager - £35
Team leader - £20
Worker- £15

We need to bring the bottom up and the top way way down, not just move everyone up a few % more.

Your sums simply don't work. Reducing the pay of the few top management won't finance the wage increases for the masses at the bottom. All it will do is make you feel better for "punishing" the people at the top. Typical Labour politics of jealousy and envy.
nosyupnorth · 26/10/2021 13:22

@Bucanarab

It's sad to see so many people here would begrudge someone on nmw a pay rise because of a misplaced sense of superiority. That's exactly the sort of attitude that's got us into the situation we're in now.

Broadly speaking we have accepted pay structures of something like the below

CEO/Director - £3000
Senior manager - £100
Manager - £15
Team leader - £9.
Worker- £8.91

What those objecting to a nmw rise apparently want to see happen.

CEO - £4000
SM - £125
Manager - £18
Team leader - £10.
Worker- £9.50

And this what we should be striving to see happen.

CEO - £500
SM - £125
Manager - £35
Team leader - £20
Worker- £15

We need to bring the bottom up and the top way way down, not just move everyone up a few % more.

Your middle example is a strawman. Nobody is suggesting a raise for the richest, but a huge rise to the minimum wage and fuck everybody else is just reinforcing the spiralling cost of living.

As it stands I know a lot of people like your hypothetical team leader who've worked hard to be able to get the security of a slightly higher pay bands which will now be swallowed up by minimum wage while their cost of living increases dramatically to pay for these minium wage hikes.

Rosebel · 26/10/2021 13:21

@phlebasconsidered

It's quite right that the wage is increased.

The op is getting a rough ride though. People have misconceptions about teaching today. I am still paying off my training debt. I've been stuck at the same payspine for 4 years because there's no money to move me up. This year too. I've lost 17% in real terms because of pay freezes. Teaching jobs are no longer secure- older teachers, ill teachers and expensive teachers are edged out, redundant. Most jobs specify cheap nqt or ect. There are not many older, experienced teachers anymore. Turnover is massive.

My oh is in a physical manual job as a caterer. We work similar jours and cover the same amount of steps a day - averaging 16k. He worries that as he gets older he's in trouble- but knows that I am too.

My pension is better than his but not by much. Tp are not final salary anymore and are significantly reduced ftom what they were. Obviously I get more time off than him, but he's able to take it whenever. He works long hours and overtime at events but gets overtime for this and TOIL. My long evenings (parents evenings till 9, open evenings till 9.30etc) are just expected, as are residentials etc. His work can be physical and stressful around events, but there's a lot of downtime and he is never constantly observed, pressured or criticised the way I am. A visit from Public Health to check his cleanliness is about it.

In the end, with overtime, he earns just a little less than me but I did 4 years of uni for an extra few grand and debt. So I get what the OP is saying. I certainly wouldn't want my kids to go into teaching. I think there used to be very many more benefits and safeguards to a teaching job than now. I am currently looking for different work.

One of my kids is likely to start atthe bottom end of wages. I'm glad things might be better for him. It isn't a race to the bottom. But we do still need to recognise that some jobs in the public sector do need some rewards- or noone will want to do them! I don't mean huge payouts. I mean not freezing pay for a decade and underfunding them to such an extent that there is no pay rise possibility or portability (by which I mean no mid or late career teacher can move jobs now because there's only money for lower payscale positions).

I think people are annoyed with OP as she's basically said she deserves more money and those in unskilled but physically exhausting jobs don't deserve a rise in wages. I have no doubt teaching is a hard job but it's better paid than a lot of other jobs which are also hard work. In my previous job I did over 2 years of training then gained 5 years experience but was still on minimum wage. How is that fair?
phlebasconsidered · 26/10/2021 12:47

It's quite right that the wage is increased.

The op is getting a rough ride though. People have misconceptions about teaching today. I am still paying off my training debt. I've been stuck at the same payspine for 4 years because there's no money to move me up. This year too. I've lost 17% in real terms because of pay freezes. Teaching jobs are no longer secure- older teachers, ill teachers and expensive teachers are edged out, redundant. Most jobs specify cheap nqt or ect. There are not many older, experienced teachers anymore. Turnover is massive.

My oh is in a physical manual job as a caterer. We work similar jours and cover the same amount of steps a day - averaging 16k. He worries that as he gets older he's in trouble- but knows that I am too.

My pension is better than his but not by much. Tp are not final salary anymore and are significantly reduced ftom what they were. Obviously I get more time off than him, but he's able to take it whenever. He works long hours and overtime at events but gets overtime for this and TOIL. My long evenings (parents evenings till 9, open evenings till 9.30etc) are just expected, as are residentials etc. His work can be physical and stressful around events, but there's a lot of downtime and he is never constantly observed, pressured or criticised the way I am. A visit from Public Health to check his cleanliness is about it.

In the end, with overtime, he earns just a little less than me but I did 4 years of uni for an extra few grand and debt. So I get what the OP is saying. I certainly wouldn't want my kids to go into teaching. I think there used to be very many more benefits and safeguards to a teaching job than now. I am currently looking for different work.

One of my kids is likely to start atthe bottom end of wages. I'm glad things might be better for him. It isn't a race to the bottom. But we do still need to recognise that some jobs in the public sector do need some rewards- or noone will want to do them! I don't mean huge payouts. I mean not freezing pay for a decade and underfunding them to such an extent that there is no pay rise possibility or portability (by which I mean no mid or late career teacher can move jobs now because there's only money for lower payscale positions).

MarshaBradyo · 26/10/2021 12:37

Looks like public sector will increase next year so maybe don’t worry about this rise

RubaDubMum89 · 26/10/2021 12:36

It's obviously up to you, but for comparison...

I work a minimum wage job in a very busy restaurant kitchen as head baker. I work 12 hour shifts 5 days a week. It's a physically gruelling job, hauling about sacks of flour and mix that weigh more than my 5yo. I'm on my feet 11hours of that shift, batch baking all morning until lunchtime service then it's chaos until closing when I have to start dragging out industrial fridges and units to clean down before the morning.

Most days I'm literally jogging around the kitchen with deserts. The minimum covers we take on a slow lunch day is 100. The maximum covers I've done in a day is 600. Every shift I get changed into fresh scrubs on my break because I'm drenched in sweat. In summer the kitchen can reach 40 degrees easily.

Now, my partner works a management position at the local University. He sits at a desk doing easy work - his own words - for 6 hours 5 days a week and earns triple my wage.

For me, overlooking my opinion that the increase will be pointless because of price hikes, but still, its about time some places were forced to pay their staff more than pennies for bloody hard graft!

JustSinginInTheRain · 26/10/2021 12:26

Agree with minimum wage increase.

JustSinginInTheRain · 26/10/2021 12:26

I don't know what the answer is but I do know that retention in teaching is a big problem.

Lots of young trained teachers leaving and plenty of early retirements.

Wife2b · 26/10/2021 12:20

Oh ffs it’s not about ‘the plebs’ not getting a decent wage. It’s about everyone getting a decent wage. Why is that so hard to understand?

Moaningturtle · 26/10/2021 12:07

Tesco made over a billion in profit last year. That’s a huge huge huge amount of money. They can afford to reduce the shareholders profits slightly.

Fetarabbit · 26/10/2021 12:07

@Maverickess

Oh my, some people really don't like the idea that the plebs might get something they're not do they?

Even if it's still less than they have already. If it's any consolation, many won't be any better off once you take into account the price rises happening and NI increase, it'll just mean we don't go totally under.

We'll still know our place, don't worry! 🙄

Or it's that other measures would be actually more beneficial to people on nmw or those who work part time or are on benefits, but they don't make such a nice headline, and more importantly, the onus doesn't fall on the government so they don't have to do anything structural to actually make life fairer for all. It's a crappy sticking plaster for votes.
Maverickess · 26/10/2021 12:04

Oh my, some people really don't like the idea that the plebs might get something they're not do they?

Even if it's still less than they have already. If it's any consolation, many won't be any better off once you take into account the price rises happening and NI increase, it'll just mean we don't go totally under.

We'll still know our place, don't worry! 🙄

Wife2b · 26/10/2021 12:04

It’s not about not wanting people to earn a decent living. It’s about making the really stressful jobs that are essential to society (teachers, doctors, social workers etc) more attractive otherwise why would anyone bother? The hours I put in is ridiculous, most weeks I feel like I live to work, I have poor work life balance and the workload is unrealistic. If the pay gap is reduced - where is the incentive for people to continue putting themselves through jobs like this? It’s not about superiority at all that some have suggested - I don’t think I am any more important than anyone else but I need a decent pay otherwise I’m killing my self in my job for nothing. I suspect a lot of people feel this way.

Explosivefarts · 26/10/2021 12:04

@Fetarabbit

I do think the care sector should either be better regulated or government run (albeit well run as a opposed to many other government agencies). Whilst there is profit in it and a questionable funding model, its never going to be a sector where people are paid fairly, have chances of progression and structured training that's consistent across the board- and it absolutely should.

I'd extend this to unpaid carers too, who should absolutely receive more monetary support and access to actual support.

Caring as a whole is massively devalued, both monetarily wise and by society, but I don't think this will make much difference at all. Childcare is too, no one will ever really change that as they'll get the howls of well I don't have kids why should I pay etc.

Oh yes completely forgot about unpaid carers £67.60 and must proved 35 hours care a week.
CherryHug · 26/10/2021 12:01

@BrilloPaddy

As a small business owner, I'm all ears as to where this 6.6% is going to come from. And how I then deal with my more skilled staff who are also going to want the same increase.

Angry

You of course should be paying your staff what they're worth!
OnlyFoolsnMothers · 26/10/2021 11:48

Where are aldi going to magic the extra money from? They pay their staff fairly well, but they have more demands on them. They also don't provide home deliveries etc which are a lifeline to some (that many supermarkets offer at no real benefit to themselves) of course aldi prices will go up, but comparatively if they gain more custom from the already more expensive supermarkets they will keep their profits up. Aldi have started click and collect I believe.

Fetarabbit · 26/10/2021 11:45

Where are aldi going to magic the extra money from? They pay their staff fairly well, but they have more demands on them. They also don't provide home deliveries etc which are a lifeline to some (that many supermarkets offer at no real benefit to themselves).

OnlyFoolsnMothers · 26/10/2021 11:43

Supermarkets will raise their prices to account for the increase, the supply chain is already squeezed trying to be the cheapest. Yes there are some managers on £££s, but on the whole there is no leeway in the day to day of it. Of course the ideal would be they take a wage cut but they're not going to, and it wouldn't cover the cost anyway. The cycle continues of people paying more for stuff and struggling to stay afloat yes and no- eg. take Sainsburys, they can keep upping the prices, and eventually more and more customers will leave and seek out Aldi etc.

Winter2020 · 26/10/2021 11:42

Hi OP,
I earn 9.80 an hour as a carer. I put that that in the salary calculator and it's about 19k full time.

My husband is a primary school teacher. He's part time but the full time equivalent wage is £37k. He's 10 years in and post threshold (1?) I think.

A teachers wage is not bad (not like the terms and conditions if you are full time which are horrific).

So as a 3 day teacher my husband earns around 22k ish. He works 3 (long) days and a few other hours additionally (maybe 3-6 hours on top). If he wants to leave and go to retail/hospitality or care he'll have to work 5 (or more?) days, unsociable hours and lose his extra holidays. He also might struggle to get fixed contracted hours and be expected to have a lower amount of contracted hours but work whatever he is put on the rota. He might change his job one day but it won't be while we have children in school.

Fetarabbit · 26/10/2021 11:14

The supervisor should have been paid more in the first place. If the company can’t run a viable pay structure then it’s not a viable company. They should look at where else to cut costs rather than staff salaries.

Supermarkets will raise their prices to account for the increase, the supply chain is already squeezed trying to be the cheapest. Yes there are some managers on £££s, but on the whole there is no leeway in the day to day of it. Of course the ideal would be they take a wage cut but they're not going to, and it wouldn't cover the cost anyway. The cycle continues of people paying more for stuff and struggling to stay afloat.

Whammyyammy · 26/10/2021 11:06

A couple of friends that are employers/owners of a production company are looking at 2 ways to cover their increased salary bill;

  1. Increae the cost of their product.
  2. Lay off 1 or 2 members of staff, and expect the remainder of staff to maintain current output.

But uts obvious, minimum wage increase, cost of living increases

PizzaCrust · 26/10/2021 11:02

@berlinbabylon

Working in a shop is stressful but when you go home you forget it. No waking up in the middle of the night stressing about whether you said the right thing to Little Johnnie's parent or how you're going to cope with your awkward Y9 Maths class tomorrow, etc. I can completely see why you might take a pay cut to do a less stressful job and people do it all the time. Plus the fact you don't have to work in a supermarket - there are nice retail jobs like working in a bookshop or a nice clothes chain like Fat Face.

As for people whinging about affording pay rises - if you need to exploit your staff to make a profit, your business isn't viable. It's that simple.

Not necessarily. Alarms do go off during the night and you have to rock up to the shop in the wee hours to wait for maintenance to come out and fix it, which could take a couple of hours depending on whether the engineer on call is nearby/with someone else/the issue is an easy fix or not. You’ll never see a teacher called into the school at 3am. There are plenty of customer advisors who have key holder duties; it’s not limited to just management.

Similarly, all retail stores have targets to teach and standards to attain. Yes, Fat Face might not be as stressful day to day as a busy, high turnover supermarket, but it’s compensated with the Christmas rush and Boxing Day sales and the like. I would hate to be a clothes fashion worker on Boxing Day because I realise how utterly shit it would be. Missing Boxing Day on its own is a bit crap, but then dealing with queues out the door and people scrapping over a top? No thanks.

Also, as harsh as it is, fashion retail doesn’t have the same level of security that food retail does. It’s highly unlikely Asda will go out of business, but we’ve seen what’s happened with Topshop, Gap etc. It just doesn’t have the same security.

Teachers have security. You can start in a school and stay there until you retire if you wanted unless, on very rare occasions, your school closes down.

OnlyFoolsnMothers · 26/10/2021 10:42

I earn £40k in teaching. I think that's fine. But I think there should be contraction either side of my position in the hierarchy; those at the top should be paid less and those at the bottom should be paid more. I think people struggle to fully comprehend just how much money is paid to those at the very top totally agree, hence the media spends a lot of time stirring up tensions between those at the bottom end of the pay scale, so they fight amongst themselves oblivious to the amount of money those above get.

Marelle · 26/10/2021 10:41

Hopefully someone who's been to uni will get a job with prospects and progression, probably earning far nore than NMW after a few years and likely to have a good pension with tax free lump sum on retirement
You obviously don’t understand what’s been happening in teaching, especially FE and HE. In my FE college the pay scale was completely removed a few years ago. We were re-categorised as Teacher A (£23k) and Teacher B (department heads etc with extra responsibility, £25k). The only progression available was from Teacher A to Teacher B. So you start as Teacher A and your salary remains the same forever, someone with ten years experience earns the same as someone who started last week. If you get promoted to Teacher B you earn slightly more but that’s the most progression you can ever achieve.

If you work out the salary for Teacher A, 60 hours a week for 39 weeks means you get paid less than £10 an hour. That’s before you add on hours worked during the holidays. They also reclassified us as self employed so they didn’t have to pay sick pay or maternity or pension. There has been a huge amount of unsuccessful opposition from the unions, but basically there was no way round it because the government had cut FE funding by 20% and the only place they could save that money was on salaries. Unsurprisingly there has been a huge exodus of FE teachers. The HE sector is experiencing similar issues.

Swipe left for the next trending thread