Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

So if the Minimum Wage increases...

488 replies

missbunnyrabbit · 25/10/2021 20:20

My own wage in a public sector job seems lower than ever. The article I read suggests the public sector pay freezes will end, but I doubt we'll get such a large pay rise!

Aibu to feel like packing my teacher job in to go and work a minimum wage job instead?

OP posts:
Teaandcakeordeath83 · 26/10/2021 17:09

I think this govt isn't stupid. Raising the rebranded minimum/ living wage means they get to claw more back in NI. The rest disappears on the increased cost of living and they get to pat themselves on the back for "levelling up". In reality they won't move any of the benefit thresholds upwards to accommodate a "higher" living wage so actually those on the least will lose out more because they'll tip out of the threshold levels.

Fetarabbit · 26/10/2021 17:04

If you can't afford to pay yours staff the bare minimum then your business has become unviable, you said the costs were mostly wages and fuel, mostly?

Yes lots of small businesses will fold, many of which either perform an important role within a supply chain of another product, or a valuable service such as nurseries.

Badbadbunny · 26/10/2021 17:03

@whispamint

Shareholder profits cannot, under any circumstances, be reduced so employees have fair working conditions. Those shareholder fund managers have to earn their millions each year.

This is the problem with the system. And the profits have to grow each year.

Considering most firms are owned by pension schemes, then yes, profits do have to increase so that they can pay the pensions!
Fetarabbit · 26/10/2021 17:02

@OnlyFoolsnMothers

The poster was reasonably saying that if their staffs wages increase, so should the supervisors who have a lot more responsibility; otherwise what's the incentive to take on more stress? None. That's not saying keep everyone's wages down, but that others should have theirs proportionately raised too my bosses wages dont naturally increase if I get a rise
I'm not sure if you are being purposefully obtuse or not, but usually if pay rises are awarded or if there's some sort of payment spine it applies to everyone at some point during the year, it's quite unusual to get a pay rise in isolation. In cases such as supermarkets where there might just be 50p between both, this could feasibly now just be pennies, if that, and already most struggle to find team leaders as people already think the extra worth isn't worth it. As a manager I would step down if I was going to be paid the same. Do you earn more than your bosses then?
JustAnotherPoster00 · 26/10/2021 17:01

@lovelyupnorth

Yep, minimum rage is going up - our costs are mainly wages and fuel - currently trying to negotiate 15-20% price rises with our customers. If we can't do that then it's either less staff - or thank you and good night. we are part of the supply chain so guessing prices will be rising everywhere add to that the 1.25% in both employers and employees NI.

Thanks to Covid and being caught in the middle of the support we are already on our knees so guessing 20 people going to be losing some or all of their jobs.

And that's before we had in the kick we've had from Brexit prior to this.

time to jack it in it's not worth the stress - get one of those lazy ass public sector jobs who seem to get away with creating chaos, delivering fuck all and then having massive pensions.

Do you feel that somehow your staff owe you a living or a business? If you can't afford to pay yours staff the bare minimum then your business has become unviable, you said the costs were mostly wages and fuel, mostly?

Employers have had it too good for too long, people need to be paid enough to live not paid just enough to not starve and in turn be exploited enough to make someone else richer, you are selling your time to your employer, an hour of my time is worth this much, and settle for no less if a majority would do that we would as a society be in a better place, we called call them a union of people...oh wait the Tories have gotten rid of a lot of union power and society is now suffering because of it

Remember through lockdown how we all were clamouring for share holders, and hedge fund managers....oh wait why are they important when lockdown showed us who was important to stop this country grinding to a halt how easy we forget

Marelle · 26/10/2021 16:48

The poster was reasonably saying that if their staffs wages increase, so should the supervisors who have a lot more responsibility; otherwise what's the incentive to take on more stress?
I quit teaching when the salary dropped low enough that I wasn’t getting paid enough to compensate for all the extra stress and hassle. I lost £4.5k by leaving teaching for a min wage job. But I only had to work 40 hours for 46 weeks instead of 60 hours for 39 weeks, so I was working a heck of a lot less hours overall and I had zero hassle.

People just aren’t going to take extra responsibility unless they’re getting extra money. A while ago I was asked to train a new employee, and I said no because I’m paid the same as her but I have the extra hassle of training her, why should I do more work for the same money? That’s just human nature.

whispamint · 26/10/2021 16:46

Shareholder profits cannot, under any circumstances, be reduced so employees have fair working conditions. Those shareholder fund managers have to earn their millions each year.

This is the problem with the system. And the profits have to grow each year.

lovelyupnorth · 26/10/2021 16:46

Yep, minimum rage is going up - our costs are mainly wages and fuel - currently trying to negotiate 15-20% price rises with our customers. If we can't do that then it's either less staff - or thank you and good night. we are part of the supply chain so guessing prices will be rising everywhere add to that the 1.25% in both employers and employees NI.

Thanks to Covid and being caught in the middle of the support we are already on our knees so guessing 20 people going to be losing some or all of their jobs.

And that's before we had in the kick we've had from Brexit prior to this.

time to jack it in it's not worth the stress - get one of those lazy ass public sector jobs who seem to get away with creating chaos, delivering fuck all and then having massive pensions.

OnlyFoolsnMothers · 26/10/2021 16:44

The poster was reasonably saying that if their staffs wages increase, so should the supervisors who have a lot more responsibility; otherwise what's the incentive to take on more stress? None. That's not saying keep everyone's wages down, but that others should have theirs proportionately raised too my bosses wages dont naturally increase if I get a rise

ColinTheKoala · 26/10/2021 16:37

Also, as harsh as it is, fashion retail doesn’t have the same level of security that food retail does. It’s highly unlikely Asda will go out of business, but we’ve seen what’s happened with Topshop, Gap etc. It just doesn’t have the same security

Good points made here. I did work in a library for a bit though, not earning much above minimum wage and although I thought there was a fair amount of responsibility for the few pence above minimum wage that I earned, it wasn't a stressful job. Close the door, go home and don't worry about it. Of course there is always the risk of losing your job but that's the case in most sectors I think.

Moaningturtle · 26/10/2021 16:34

@ColinTheKoala it’s so depressing

ColinTheKoala · 26/10/2021 16:30

@Moaningturtle

Tesco made over a billion in profit last year. That’s a huge huge huge amount of money. They can afford to reduce the shareholders profits slightly.
They won't though, they'll just put the prices up and/or sack a few people (or not replace them if they leave).

Shareholder profits cannot, under any circumstances, be reduced so employees have fair working conditions. Those shareholder fund managers have to earn their millions each year.

Fetarabbit · 26/10/2021 16:27

@OnlyFoolsnMothers

So everyone should be the same level without any supervisors etc? I'm sure that would work well, everyone can sort their own HR stuff out, no one have overall responsibility for stuff so it's a free for all and everyone can fend for themselves training wise not at all but justifying poor wages by saying but this person earns less is a depressing race to the bottom. Defend your right to earn more dont just keep others down.
The poster was reasonably saying that if their staffs wages increase, so should the supervisors who have a lot more responsibility; otherwise what's the incentive to take on more stress? None. That's not saying keep everyone's wages down, but that others should have theirs proportionately raised too.
OnlyFoolsnMothers · 26/10/2021 16:12

So everyone should be the same level without any supervisors etc? I'm sure that would work well, everyone can sort their own HR stuff out, no one have overall responsibility for stuff so it's a free for all and everyone can fend for themselves training wise not at all but justifying poor wages by saying but this person earns less is a depressing race to the bottom. Defend your right to earn more dont just keep others down.

Wife2b · 26/10/2021 16:05

Oh come off it you know exactly what I mean. Obviously a lot of jobs are essential to society that are NMW, of course they are otherwise the country wouldn’t run. Why would someone become a social worker or police officer to receive abuse daily if they’re barely paid more than other lower paid jobs? There has to be an incentive otherwise no one would want to do it. Dealing with abuse is no ones idea of fun.

Explosivefarts · 26/10/2021 15:50

@Wife2b

It’s not about not wanting people to earn a decent living. It’s about making the really stressful jobs that are essential to society (teachers, doctors, social workers etc) more attractive otherwise why would anyone bother? The hours I put in is ridiculous, most weeks I feel like I live to work, I have poor work life balance and the workload is unrealistic. If the pay gap is reduced - where is the incentive for people to continue putting themselves through jobs like this? It’s not about superiority at all that some have suggested - I don’t think I am any more important than anyone else but I need a decent pay otherwise I’m killing my self in my job for nothing. I suspect a lot of people feel this way.
There are lots of jobs that are stressful and essential to society that only pay minimum wage.
Fetarabbit · 26/10/2021 15:30

@OnlyFoolsnMothers

So instead of earning more due to her experience and supervisory skills she will be on almost exactly the same minimum wage as junior new starters to be fair this sums up the UK wage structure entirely, you are paid well if you can look down on others so best to keep people down.
So everyone should be the same level without any supervisors etc? I'm sure that would work well, everyone can sort their own HR stuff out, no one have overall responsibility for stuff so it's a free for all and everyone can fend for themselves training wise.
LakieLady · 26/10/2021 15:23

@Clocktopus

Of course they should earn enough to live, no one is disputing that. Please don't make things up.

Literally your whole thread is about how people in "low skill" jobs shouldn't be paid as much as people in professional jobs and that this NMW increase will put their wages too close to some professional wages.

My concern isn't that people in some sectors shouldn't be paid as much as those in others, it's that differentials are shrinking to the point where it will be difficult to recruit and retain staff to work in areas like homelessness, mental health support, social care etc.

An organisation whose work I am familiar with is currently looking for someone to undertake group work with clients with addiction issues. The pay rate equates to £13.00 an hour and you have to be a qualified counsellor/psychotherapist.

I think someone who has studied for years and is prepared to work with some of the most challenging and vulnerable people in society deserves a bit more than 1.5 times NMW, tbh.

I've worked with clients with addiction issues before and would want at least double that salary to do it again.

Feelingoktoday · 26/10/2021 15:16

@Marelle

Hopefully someone who's been to uni will get a job with prospects and progression, probably earning far nore than NMW after a few years and likely to have a good pension with tax free lump sum on retirement You obviously don’t understand what’s been happening in teaching, especially FE and HE. In my FE college the pay scale was completely removed a few years ago. We were re-categorised as Teacher A (£23k) and Teacher B (department heads etc with extra responsibility, £25k). The only progression available was from Teacher A to Teacher B. So you start as Teacher A and your salary remains the same forever, someone with ten years experience earns the same as someone who started last week. If you get promoted to Teacher B you earn slightly more but that’s the most progression you can ever achieve.

If you work out the salary for Teacher A, 60 hours a week for 39 weeks means you get paid less than £10 an hour. That’s before you add on hours worked during the holidays. They also reclassified us as self employed so they didn’t have to pay sick pay or maternity or pension. There has been a huge amount of unsuccessful opposition from the unions, but basically there was no way round it because the government had cut FE funding by 20% and the only place they could save that money was on salaries. Unsurprisingly there has been a huge exodus of FE teachers. The HE sector is experiencing similar issues.

It’s the same in local government too. Maximum of 4 years to the top of the grade and then you can sit there for ever on the same grade.

But it happens in private sector too. Most jobs don’t have careers internally. You have to change jobs etc

Eeiliethya · 26/10/2021 14:56

On the flip side of this are you suggesting the NMW shouldn't go up so that people with "skilled" jobs don't feel under compensated?

Because making pay rises mandatory through different jobs would be unsustainable. You might have a higher salary but you better believe we would all be paying £3 for a loaf of bread. Multiple businesses would fail to remain profitable, only option being increase service/goods costs. Then us (aka Joe public) will be the ones to absorb that cost. Suddenly NMW needs to increase again > rinse and repeat.

LakieLady · 26/10/2021 14:55

@ArtfulScreamer

YANBU. I absolutely don't begrudge anyone a decent wage but whilst I remain more or less wage static in my public sector job were I'm often in confrontational and dangerous situations I do wonder how long it'll be before the financial implications of obtaining a minimum wage job aren't great enough to prevent me from jumping ship. Admittedly I'm only one person so the country won't fall on its knees but if I think like this there'll certainly be others.
I think that's a very valid point.

I work in the voluntary sector. Public sector cuts have meant that wages haven't come close to meeting inflation for more than 10 years (all the projects are funded by social care or health money).

When I started there, the hourly rate for the job I did was 2.5 times NMW. Now, that job starts at £9.37 per hour, less than the new NMW.

Why would people do a job that is difficult, demanding, stressful and challenging for the same rate of pay that they could get for stacking shelves in a supermarket?

OnlyFoolsnMothers · 26/10/2021 14:27

So instead of earning more due to her experience and supervisory skills she will be on almost exactly the same minimum wage as junior new starters to be fair this sums up the UK wage structure entirely, you are paid well if you can look down on others so best to keep people down.

BrilloPaddy · 26/10/2021 14:27

@CherryHug we've had to close over lockdowns meaning we couldn't sell anything; our suppliers have increased everything by at least 15%, and we are literally just keeping our heads above water.

Do we sell a kidney each to pay our staff what they're worth Hmm

What a stunningly ignorant comment to make.

cuttlefishgame · 26/10/2021 14:23

@LittleBearPad The argument does work for others though. My own DD has been working in a role for some time, and was on a wage a fair bit higher than the minimum. The last two occasions the NMW has gone up, hers hasn't. The next time it goes up, it will be 3 pence an hour less than her current hourly rate. So instead of earning more due to her experience and supervisory skills she will be on almost exactly the same minimum wage as junior new starters. How is that fair? To say she is pissed off is an understatement.

OnlyFoolsnMothers · 26/10/2021 14:20

If the rate does not increase in line with the new minimum wage it won’t be a few nurseries closing it will be literally hundreds and before anyone says lobby the government for more funding early years settings have been for years with no luck Its not a campaign winner- no one cares about childcare settings, there has been a decades long campaign to demonise those that have children to say "pay for them yourselves", whilst every government trips over themselves to protect the assets of the aging baby boomers. It was evident on a recent thread where an OP asked why don't we protest over childcare costs and the overwhelming response was "why didnt you think about this when you reproduced"

Swipe left for the next trending thread