Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

So if the Minimum Wage increases...

488 replies

missbunnyrabbit · 25/10/2021 20:20

My own wage in a public sector job seems lower than ever. The article I read suggests the public sector pay freezes will end, but I doubt we'll get such a large pay rise!

Aibu to feel like packing my teacher job in to go and work a minimum wage job instead?

OP posts:
Finchall · 26/10/2021 19:09

But that pay will increase and take on TLR or SLT responsibilities in time you could be earning significantly more. Become a headteacher and you could end up on six figures

But only as the HT of a very large secondary. I was a HT earned around £42,000.

Bucanarab · 26/10/2021 19:01

Your middle example is a strawman. Nobody is suggesting a raise for the richest, but a huge rise to the minimum wage and fuck everybody else is just reinforcing the spiralling cost of living.

As it stands I know a lot of people like your hypothetical team leader who've worked hard to be able to get the security of a slightly higher pay bands which will now be swallowed up by minimum wage while their cost of living increases dramatically to pay for these minium wage hikes.

My middle example was just a reflection of what had been expressed on this thread. People in the middle are unhappy that people at the bottom might get a pay rise and feel they deserve one too. That same logic will be applied by people at the top and the status quo will remain.

It's also why I had written a third example and explicitly said "This is what we should be striving for" which you've completely ignored for some reason.

Your sums simply don't work. Reducing the pay of the few top management won't finance the wage increases for the masses at the bottom. All it will do is make you feel better for "punishing" the people at the top. Typical Labour politics of jealousy and envy.

Oh ffs, it wasn't a fully costed methodology for businesses to follow, just a way to illustrate how we need to reduce the gap between top and bottom.

Denise Coates (bet365's owner/director) earned £469m last year. That's 26,056 times more than someone who works as a customer service adviser for the firm. She could afford to pay every single one of her 4600 employees an extra £80k a year and still take home £100m. That's absolutely grotesque! And, while an extreme example the average CEO today still makes around 250-350 times more than the average worker (note average not NMW). Can you genuinely say this is a fair situation to be in?

Reducing the pay of a few top managers might not solve the issue, but ensuring fair wealth distribution most certainly will. I've mentioned this before but will keep doing so until people realise just how insane the gap between the top and bottom is.

The top 1% of the UK have enough personal wealth to wipe out the UK's national debt AND end homelessness and hunger (in the UK) AND would still have circa £1 Trillion to themselves. Thats just private individuals, not businesses. There's no justifying that level of inequality but I'm sure your typical Tory politics of hatred and greed will have you disagreeing*.

*I don't really believe that but can stereotype just as well as you.

P.s. I've never voted Labour in my life.

LittleBearPad · 26/10/2021 18:59

@Marelle

As for a teacher suggesting she will go for a minimum wage job instead of a teachers salary I find laughable Depends what you teach. If you teach primary or secondary school and have taught for several years then you probably earn a decent salary. But if you’re a new teacher, or if you teach in any other sector, you’re lucky if you’re earning a couple of thousand pounds a year above minimum wage.
But that pay will increase and take on TLR or SLT responsibilities in time you could be earning significantly more. Become a headteacher and you could end up on six figures. Let’s face it as a brand new NQT you have qualifications but no experience.

NMW is quite different. The scope for significant pay increases slim.

Badbadbunny · 26/10/2021 18:58

@Marelle

As for a teacher suggesting she will go for a minimum wage job instead of a teachers salary I find laughable Depends what you teach. If you teach primary or secondary school and have taught for several years then you probably earn a decent salary. But if you’re a new teacher, or if you teach in any other sector, you’re lucky if you’re earning a couple of thousand pounds a year above minimum wage.
Yes, but someone in a minimum wage job will still be earning minimum wage in 10 years.

Pay rates rise rapidly with years of service etc as you go through the pay scale for teachers, nurses, etc.

Finchall · 26/10/2021 18:56

Don't worry about it.
Public sector wages will increase but funding to schools won't. I work with so many schools with huge deficit budgets. I think some local authorities will just collapse.

Rosebel · 26/10/2021 18:52

@GreenLunchBox

Tesco made over a billion in profit last year. That’s a huge huge huge amount of money. They can afford to reduce the shareholders profits slightly

Not sure why Tesco is getting singled out here ...they already pay more than minimum wage. The lowest paid get £9.43 during the week and it's something like £11+ on Sundays

No supermarket pays more for Sunday staff and haven't for quite a while. At least the big four don't, not sure about the others.
HarrietsweetHarriet · 26/10/2021 18:46

I've worked in a supermarket as a temp after being made redundant from private sector job. Supermarket was bloody hard work- 12 hour shifts - absolutely knackering.
DH is qualified HLTA but can't find a job as such. He works as TA as it's better than nothing but is expected to teach (alone in a class with no support). They don't employ HLTA s because they can use a TA on a lower salary to do the same role. They shouldn't , of course , but they still do.

GreenLunchBox · 26/10/2021 18:46

Tesco made over a billion in profit last year. That’s a huge huge huge amount of money. They can afford to reduce the shareholders profits slightly

Not sure why Tesco is getting singled out here ...they already pay more than minimum wage. The lowest paid get £9.43 during the week and it's something like £11+ on Sundays

antsinyourpanta · 26/10/2021 18:44

I think there is sometimes a misconception that people working in the private sector get pay rises every year...?
I've had one pay rise in the last 10 years....and I now earn the similar to a NQT.
I wouldn't swap though, I (mostly) enjoy my job.

I feel ashamed that until my Dad was in a care home, I didn't really know or appreciate what care work involved. I definitely don't think it can be wafted away as a "low responsibility, low pay" job. And I imagine the mental stress is huge.

I certainly couldn't be a teacher or a care worker, but I'd never assume that care was an easier or less stressful sector just because the pay is lower.

Angrywife · 26/10/2021 18:43

YANBU
I work in the public sector, child safeguarding.
My son does an unskilled job in a warehouse. He earns only slightly less than I do.

I'm not really bothered about me but it does annoy me when nurses, teachers, carers etc are paid so little. I did hope Boris would realise they need more recognition in their wage packet when he had his own brush with death. It appears not

Rosebel · 26/10/2021 18:40

@Wife2b

Oh come off it you know exactly what I mean. Obviously a lot of jobs are essential to society that are NMW, of course they are otherwise the country wouldn’t run. Why would someone become a social worker or police officer to receive abuse daily if they’re barely paid more than other lower paid jobs? There has to be an incentive otherwise no one would want to do it. Dealing with abuse is no ones idea of fun.
Do you seriously think people in lower paid jobs don't get abuse daily? I can tell you that care workers and retail staff are abused verbally and often physically on an almost daily basis. So why don't they get the money to compensate? Because no one gives a damn about those people that's why.
Marelle · 26/10/2021 18:38

As for a teacher suggesting she will go for a minimum wage job instead of a teachers salary I find laughable
Depends what you teach. If you teach primary or secondary school and have taught for several years then you probably earn a decent salary. But if you’re a new teacher, or if you teach in any other sector, you’re lucky if you’re earning a couple of thousand pounds a year above minimum wage.

Sillyname63 · 26/10/2021 18:32

when you think about is if you earn more you pay more tax, NI is going up so your "pay rise" will be negligible and you might be worse off. 😓

Vynalbob · 26/10/2021 18:16

not unreasonable but.....
watching on TV earlier it was all about
National Living Wage not
National Minimum Wage
I thought one was company kudos the other legal.... even if it was NMW I daresay there's a lot of exceptions

Elephantsparade · 26/10/2021 17:57

I dont think working in a supermarket us easy. But they actually are advertising most of their roles at £9.50 an hour in my local ones anyway. Its mainly care work and nursery work that are actual minimum wage in my town.

Moonface123 · 26/10/2021 17:53

Where on earth do people get the idea working in a supermarket is easy ?
Only someone who has never worked in one could ever think that.

Djmaggie · 26/10/2021 17:45

@Danikm151

I agree. It’s great that the minimum wage is going up but other wages aren’t increasing in line with this. you train and progress in the hope of a higher wage but the effort doesn’t seem worth it when that bridge between is even smaller.
This
Explosivefarts · 26/10/2021 17:44

I remember the last few times minimum wage has gone up people said the same that nursery’s wouldn’t survive. They did .

Owl55 · 26/10/2021 17:43

The minimum wage has gone up so they put people above the level to receive benefits. As for a teacher suggesting she will go for a minimum wage job instead of a teachers salary I find laughable , teachers are on a much higher hourly rate than most jobs , I know they work very hard for it but so does everyone else 🤷‍♀️

notoldjustpastyoung · 26/10/2021 17:43

I>m confused. You're a teacher so you must be getting a decent wage, from what my friends tell me, unless you're not fully qualified. My daughter left after 12 years of excellent success at teaching, but was not qualified, the upper echelons of the school did not appreciate the work she put in. She's now exhausting herself doing care work. I don't know what's right for her. She's no less stressed. Difficult choice check your options carefully. Make sure you will be earning more.

ohtwatbollocks · 26/10/2021 17:30

@Magicalwoodlands

effort doesn’t seem worth it

But you have already made the effort.

Do you seriously think that working as a care assistant, stacking shelves in Tesco, working in an Amazon warehouse, is somehow stress free and ‘easy’?

It isn’t. It’s hard, gruelling work, it often involves anti social hours (nights, evenings, weekends) no sick pay, no god forbid death in service benefit, no pension, no enhanced maternity pay, often dealing with very difficult situations and people.

I know there is a lot wrong with teaching and that it’s hard work, but as a minimum you’re on nearly 26,000. Minimum wage on a 40hour week isn’t that.

This^^ I've worked in shops, I've worked in care and I've worked as a Ta in schools, I know that's not a teacher so not out of school work but I got treated best at school(except by the headteacher), care I definitely didn't 'leave my work at work' I would be upset regularly, in shops I was always anxious because people can get so aggressive and nasty sometimes. I got paid best at the school, I got the best pension at the school and I got treated well, I also wasn't doing nights or weekends.
TheBlackHeart · 26/10/2021 17:18

Im actually sat here reading this with my boyfriend, we can't believe how deluded some of you are

Do you think anyone cares what your boyfriend thinks? 😂😂😂

worriedatthemoment · 26/10/2021 17:14

@User527294627 go away many businesses are just coping so if course large increases hit and thats a stupid thing to say
Even big companies are often on the brink and redunancies happen for this reason
Get in the real world

Fetarabbit · 26/10/2021 17:13

@Teaandcakeordeath83

I think this govt isn't stupid. Raising the rebranded minimum/ living wage means they get to claw more back in NI. The rest disappears on the increased cost of living and they get to pat themselves on the back for "levelling up". In reality they won't move any of the benefit thresholds upwards to accommodate a "higher" living wage so actually those on the least will lose out more because they'll tip out of the threshold levels.
Precisely. I doubt many people are adverse to people being better off, but many people won't be, and the people on benefits will suffer most when the price of everything gets pushed up. It really isn't as simple as pay people more and they have a higher standard of living. It's a vote winner that the government doesn't actually have to do anything towards does it, it pushes the responsibility onto businesses which for big business fair enough, but there are lots of valuable smaller businesses which actually do suit some people and aren't by any means dead end jobs; that won't be able to stay open. Lots of small local businesses here offer great flexibility for staff, its not all about paying the least amount possible, but being part of an economy where people want stuff as cheap as possible and if it can't be provided, they'll import it in from abroad.
worriedatthemoment · 26/10/2021 17:11

@delilahbucket exactly as will most small business so its in one hand out the other

Swipe left for the next trending thread