Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

So if the Minimum Wage increases...

488 replies

missbunnyrabbit · 25/10/2021 20:20

My own wage in a public sector job seems lower than ever. The article I read suggests the public sector pay freezes will end, but I doubt we'll get such a large pay rise!

Aibu to feel like packing my teacher job in to go and work a minimum wage job instead?

OP posts:
missbunnyrabbit · 27/10/2021 01:27

Also, I actually don't mean to bang on about teaching - I have heard countless stories from nurses and social workers etc that are awful. I could never be a nurse, I think they should be paid in gold for what they do.

I'm trying to (not very succinctly) say that if nmw rises without giving rises also to the trained jobs in the public sector especially, then the pay bridge between jobs closes and makes it less worthwhile to go into these careers.

Furthermore, yiu definitely can progress in nmw jobs. I'd seen colleagues promoted to higher positions over time. One of my friends started as a bar worker in a spoons, now he's one of the managers and looking to go further. So it's a lie to suggest there is no progression.

OP posts:
missbunnyrabbit · 27/10/2021 01:18

@Ddot

So because you got a decent education and training you should earn more than minimum wage people because their jobs are easy. 🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣 try working in a factory, it's so easy and not at all stressful the people are very kind and respectful. No danger, grime, sweat, early mornings, night shifts. Piece of cake. Shop work is great, stand for eight hours, chatting to customers who love to chew the fat. Organize stock and just mill around selling stuff. Bloody hell you are delusional
Sooooo many completely ignorant and ill thought out claims on this thread. I honestly don't know where to start with all the points/corrections that need making.

Although, I am glad some sane people with a basic understanding of society and economics have joined the thread.

I worked out my hourly salary equivalent. It's £9.45!! That's based on my typical 60-70 hour week.

@Ddot Are you a communist by any chance? Of course trained jobs should be paid more than minimum wage! Otherwise why would anyone bother training for anything?

Think someone also decided that I only think degrees are worthwhile and not apprenticeships. Absolutely not true, I'm talking about any form of long term training or qualifications, definitely not necessarily a degree.

Someone said that teaching is a stable job - I have only just, in my third year, received a permanent contract, and I am the only one out of the teachers I know from uni to have got one! I am very lucky. So many teachers do not have stability due to schools being very reluctant to offer permanent contracts.

After 6 years in minimum wage jobs (I actually had three jobs at once for two years - start at a children's breakfast club for 7.30 then work as a TA during the day, until 3.15 when I worked at the club again for an hour, then had to go to my other job in the supermarket for 4.30-10.00. That was a 14 and a half hour day!!) I can't believe anyone has the audacity or presumption to claim that I or other people "don't know what it's like working nmw". Erm, I do. I have done the long hours. I have worked all the bank holidays. I did back breaking work in the supermarket (I'm tiny and had to carry heavy boxes and use machinery in the warehouse). I know exactly what it is like to have yiur hours changed at the last minute, be spoken to like shit, be utterly run off my feet. I can honestly say that teaching is more stressful and exhausting than any of that.

I'm also not saying having a degree or whatever entitles you to a job. But if you get a job that uses your qualifications, I think it is perfectly reasonable to expect your wage to reflect that, especially in comparison to entry level jobs. It's really not a hard concept.

This is not me looking down on nmw jobs at all. I have considered going back to it for years, throughout my difficult training years. Everyone is entitled to a living wage. But the more training you need for a job, the more you should earn in comparison.
I have no idea how anyone thinks society would work if everyone was paid the same.

OP posts:
MadameTuffington · 27/10/2021 01:02

I earn under £10 per hour as a Support Worker in the Care sector - yes, the job is bloody tough - it is very physically and mentally draining (yet rewarding) and we juggle a huge number of daily tasks with the management of challenging behaviour and inadequate staffing, We deal with multiple healthcare professionals and family members and have to accurately record everything that takes place - I don’t however manage and/or supervise colleagues or have ultimate responsibility for decisions and outcomes - I believe this is why our wage is low - I still think carers specifically should earn at least £10 an hour after the horrors of Covid and also because the cost of living is now spiralling.

I worked as a secondary TA for 14 years and IMHO teachers should be on mega bucks - teaching is a ridiculously stressful and multi faceted job and this Government shows them very little respect.

JGB1987 · 27/10/2021 00:38

@Magicalwoodlands

effort doesn’t seem worth it

But you have already made the effort.

Do you seriously think that working as a care assistant, stacking shelves in Tesco, working in an Amazon warehouse, is somehow stress free and ‘easy’?

It isn’t. It’s hard, gruelling work, it often involves anti social hours (nights, evenings, weekends) no sick pay, no god forbid death in service benefit, no pension, no enhanced maternity pay, often dealing with very difficult situations and people.

I know there is a lot wrong with teaching and that it’s hard work, but as a minimum you’re on nearly 26,000. Minimum wage on a 40hour week isn’t that.

You are correct that for example tesco (or other supermarket jobs) are hard work and unsociable hours etc.. but I would like to correct you.. they do have good unions who are pushing and making sure supermarket employees have the benefits you mentioned.. during lockdown I actually worked as a supermarket employee as I wanted to be useful and didn’t feel like sitting on my arse for what I thought was gonna be a couple of months only. They get better treatment, benefits and hourly pay than people in hospitality, they get extra pay for these unsociable hours and bank holidays, also death benefit (or whatever it’s called if you die not only in service but while employed), enhanced maternity package and company sick pay and additional extra holiday time after some time. Also pension schemes are in place. Lets not forget about a employee discount! That’s also massive help and saves loads of money normal people have to pay out every week/month. It is not stress free and easy but the benefits are there. And comparing to some other jobs, you can just show up to work, do your job during your contracted hours and clock out on time. No phone calls, emails, messages at home about work. Some people just want that.. they are not looking for more responsibility and challenge.. just to go to work, fill some shelves and then go home..

Comparing to hospitality, it was like holidays for me when I started.. less mentally exhausting, better pay, optional overtime, work flexibility and great discounts..

PizzaCrust · 27/10/2021 00:35

@Morgysmum

One thing you need to take into account. A lot of minium wage, is also zero hour. So you don't get, sick pay, you don't get holiday pay, yoy might get 40 hours a week, or yoy might get 8 hours, can you cover your rent/mortgage on 8 hours at £9:50?
This. I used to work in a bar and before I was a supervisor there, I was on a zero hours contract. Now, don’t get me wrong, I was studying at the time so I had my student loan and this job topped up my loan so I was “ok” financially. I could afford rent, few takeaways a week, nights out, clothes, etc. It was basically spending money for fun as a student.

But if I wasn’t a student, therefore having that loan, that job wouldn’t have kept be afloat at all. I’d have barely made rent and groceries. There’s no way I could have afforded bills.

Over summer, when all the students went home from the city, I had two 5 hour shifts a week. In the Christmas period, I had 6 a week, easily anything from 8-12 hours long. This included Boxing Day and NYE. They were non negotiable. We all worked these shifts. And the shifts were fucking horrible. Sold out club nights, easily 2000 patrons in. Add alcohol and, unfortunately on occasion, drugs, into the mix, and you can imagine the chaos. Fights, vomit/shit/piss/other bodily fluids to clean up. Broken glass and spills made it a health and safety nightmare so you spent your entire shift running from place to place to avoid accidents from happening because walking just wasn’t quick enough. My hearing went funny after a couple of years of working there because wearing ear plugs meant you couldn’t communicate with staff properly, and the heat of the club while you’re running around made you feel dizzy at times. We often finished up at 4am in the morning after spending at least an hour cleaning the venue down top to toe, with all the grim things that came with it.
Plus, it was physically hard work. I don’t think people realise how heavy full kegs are, for example.
And, like most other NMW jobs, rotas were put up on the Saturday night if we were lucky for shifts beginning on the Sunday. Yep, the next day. I remember vividly having one of my managers ringing me on Sunday night wondering where the fuck I was because they changed the rota later on the Saturday shift (ie the day before) and because I hadn’t thought to check a rota twice in one day, I had no idea I was in. So, I frantically had to get dressed and rush over there.

Holiday pay was a lump sum whenever they could be arsed paying you it. We didn’t get payslips for months at a time. Pay was often wrong so you’d have to sit and work it out to the penny then present the evidence to your manager who would maybe front you your money early, if they were in the mood. People got sacked due to management’s mistakes (stock results wrong, assumed people were giving out free drinks so sacked them in front of everyone). Yep, in front of everyone. About 30 of us in the room watching this happen. And how were they sacked? “We’re sorry we’re going to have to let you go”?

No no. Try “get your coat and fuck off then”.

I guarantee every single person who worked there would take a teaching job over that shithole any day of the week. I quit, eventually, after a new manager decided that I was a prime target to bully because I was a female supervisor and he was a misogynistic pig. Couldn’t complain to our main manager because he had already tried it on with one of the girls (he had a wife) and was similarly pervy.

But, hey. Welcome to the NMW life when you’ve worked in a bar. I swear, for me to go back to that job now, you’d have to pay me at least £30 an hour. It was fucking horrendous. So yep, they definitely deserve a pay increase. It’s why I always tip when I’m out. Even though, I know, they’ll probably take half the wages anyway to cover any “losses”. But it’s the least I can do, having lived it and understood it. Fucking woeful.

PickUpAPepper · 27/10/2021 00:04

What a load of weird answers. Yes everyone who works an honest day deserves an honest day’s pay that actually covers the cost of living - the full cost of living, including housing.

But. If you’re in a job that requires education and qualifications and those qualifications cost money and time, you need more money to make that effort worthwhile.

If you want people with education in jobs requiring knowledge, then they have to be economically more worthwhile than doing nothing and being an illiterate cleaner. I’m no better off now with a postgrad qualification than I would have been getting myself pregnant at 12 and being given a council house and that makes me into a total mug. Im damned if I’m putting in extra effort for the kind of people who don’t recognise that and who think I should work for love. The combination of extreme left and extreme right attitudes at the moment is very weird.

AlbertBridge · 26/10/2021 23:46

OP, you seem to believe a degree makes you entitled to money. It doesn't. I get that you regret your career choice but don't take it out on supermarket staff.

Awalkintime · 26/10/2021 23:06

I would agree knowing how many extra hours you put in as a teacher takes you below minimum wage. While you might earn a larger salary, the hours themselves mean you earn less per hour than someone on a basic wage.

Do what you need to do and what is right for you. This year will mean many many teachers will leave because of this. You will be one of many.

Gingerandlemont · 26/10/2021 22:55

The minimum wage needs to go up. It’s inhumane to expect people to live in poverty.

Teaching sounds bloody hard though, and should also be better paid.

Where should the money come from? Tax the super rich more. The government should help pay the salary increase for socially useful min wage jobs like nurseries, and this should be funded by taxing the socially useless parasitical industries like social media giants, hedge funds etc…

Oh and although I agree with you OP that teaching sounds hard, so are a lot of minimum wage jobs. Can you imagine being a care worker during the covid crisis they deserve a medal.

And do stop saying things like “but I’ve trained therefore I’m entitled to xxx” doing three years at uni (mainly having fun I hope) and then a years training is hardly back breaking gruelling work that entitles you to a better quality of life than everyone else.

MasterGland · 26/10/2021 22:20

With regard to wage increases pushing up prices, I don't thinkthis holds true for all goods and services. Food, energy and housing are non-negotiables, and so you have to pay what is charged. But there must be a price cap on other discretionary items? If you have a company that makes novelty mugs, for instance, there will be a ceiling price for that product. At some point, as volume sales drop, the price must drop. There will be a point at which a lower margin is accepted, due to falling sales. I imagine we will see quite a lot of this discounting next year, as inflation hits 5%. I also expect we will see some more retailers go under.

Ddot · 26/10/2021 21:46

So because you got a decent education and training you should earn more than minimum wage people because their jobs are easy. 🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣 try working in a factory, it's so easy and not at all stressful the people are very kind and respectful. No danger, grime, sweat, early mornings, night shifts. Piece of cake. Shop work is great, stand for eight hours, chatting to customers who love to chew the fat. Organize stock and just mill around selling stuff. Bloody hell you are delusional

CallMeNutribullet · 26/10/2021 21:26

@Fetarabbit

If you can't afford to pay yours staff the bare minimum then your business has become unviable, you said the costs were mostly wages and fuel, mostly?

Yes lots of small businesses will fold, many of which either perform an important role within a supply chain of another product, or a valuable service such as nurseries.

People have been saying this since minimum wage was introduced.
Morgysmum · 26/10/2021 21:14

One thing you need to take into account. A lot of minium wage, is also zero hour. So you don't get, sick pay, you don't get holiday pay, yoy might get 40 hours a week, or yoy might get 8 hours, can you cover your rent/mortgage on 8 hours at £9:50?

Marelle · 26/10/2021 21:05

Pay rates rise rapidly with years of service etc as you go through the pay scale for teachers, nurses, etc.
As I said earlier, only school teachers have a pay scale nowadays. FE teachers don’t have a national pay scale and their pay doesn’t increase. The same applies to a lot of HE teachers and other types of teachers too. Pensions have also been removed in many cases.

Badbadbunny · 26/10/2021 20:00

@Tessabelle74

Unless something is done about the cost of living increases, then raising minimum wage will do nothing to make most of us better off! I'm already on £9.50 an hour and still had to take a 2nd job. Now fuel is at £1.42 a litre and rising daily, I guess I need to look for a 3rd!
Thing is that it's basic economics of supply and demand. People having more money in their pocket will increase prices as there's less pressure for discounts/cheaper goods etc. Firms having to pay higher wages will seek to increase prices. So inflation is stoked from both directions i.e. consumers having more money and suppliers wanting higher prices.

The country saw massive rent and house price inflation with Gordon Brown's tax credits and unlimited housing benefits - people having more money and the govt paying higher rents just stoked housing inflation.

Tessabelle74 · 26/10/2021 19:52

Unless something is done about the cost of living increases, then raising minimum wage will do nothing to make most of us better off! I'm already on £9.50 an hour and still had to take a 2nd job. Now fuel is at £1.42 a litre and rising daily, I guess I need to look for a 3rd!

Badbadbunny · 26/10/2021 19:46

@Bucanarab

Your middle example is a strawman. Nobody is suggesting a raise for the richest, but a huge rise to the minimum wage and fuck everybody else is just reinforcing the spiralling cost of living.

As it stands I know a lot of people like your hypothetical team leader who've worked hard to be able to get the security of a slightly higher pay bands which will now be swallowed up by minimum wage while their cost of living increases dramatically to pay for these minium wage hikes.

My middle example was just a reflection of what had been expressed on this thread. People in the middle are unhappy that people at the bottom might get a pay rise and feel they deserve one too. That same logic will be applied by people at the top and the status quo will remain.

It's also why I had written a third example and explicitly said "This is what we should be striving for" which you've completely ignored for some reason.

Your sums simply don't work. Reducing the pay of the few top management won't finance the wage increases for the masses at the bottom. All it will do is make you feel better for "punishing" the people at the top. Typical Labour politics of jealousy and envy.

Oh ffs, it wasn't a fully costed methodology for businesses to follow, just a way to illustrate how we need to reduce the gap between top and bottom.

Denise Coates (bet365's owner/director) earned £469m last year. That's 26,056 times more than someone who works as a customer service adviser for the firm. She could afford to pay every single one of her 4600 employees an extra £80k a year and still take home £100m. That's absolutely grotesque! And, while an extreme example the average CEO today still makes around 250-350 times more than the average worker (note average not NMW). Can you genuinely say this is a fair situation to be in?

Reducing the pay of a few top managers might not solve the issue, but ensuring fair wealth distribution most certainly will. I've mentioned this before but will keep doing so until people realise just how insane the gap between the top and bottom is.

The top 1% of the UK have enough personal wealth to wipe out the UK's national debt AND end homelessness and hunger (in the UK) AND would still have circa £1 Trillion to themselves. Thats just private individuals, not businesses. There's no justifying that level of inequality but I'm sure your typical Tory politics of hatred and greed will have you disagreeing*.

*I don't really believe that but can stereotype just as well as you.

P.s. I've never voted Labour in my life.

It's not the "average CEO", it's the average CEO wage of the largest companies, of which there are relatively few.

The CEOs/Owners of the majority of firms are in small/medium firms and won't be earning anywhere near that.

Rosebel · 26/10/2021 19:42

[quote GreenLunchBox]@Rosebel I just Googled it and it's time and a quarter on Sundays[/quote]
They got everyone to sign new contracts for normal time on Sunday but if they've changed it back I stand corrected. Asda certainly didn't. I know that as I work there.

EgonSpengler2020 · 26/10/2021 19:33

Minimum wage work generally comes with the bare minimum statutory entitlements (annual leave, maternity, sickness), and minimum wage doesn't often mean less effort. But if you want to give up your long school holidays in exchange for 5.2 weeks a year annual leave and £9.50 an hour you go for it OP.

LakieLady · 26/10/2021 19:24

@Teaandcakeordeath83

I think this govt isn't stupid. Raising the rebranded minimum/ living wage means they get to claw more back in NI. The rest disappears on the increased cost of living and they get to pat themselves on the back for "levelling up". In reality they won't move any of the benefit thresholds upwards to accommodate a "higher" living wage so actually those on the least will lose out more because they'll tip out of the threshold levels.
They claw back a fair bit in reduced benefit payments for those on low incomes, too.

Anyone on tax credits or UC will only be about 25p better off for every extra £1 they earn, after tax, NI and benefit clawback.

GreenLunchBox · 26/10/2021 19:15

And I was wrong, it's not £9.43 during the week, it's £9.55

LakieLady · 26/10/2021 19:15

@Elephantsparade

I dont think working in a supermarket us easy. But they actually are advertising most of their roles at £9.50 an hour in my local ones anyway. Its mainly care work and nursery work that are actual minimum wage in my town.
Even before the NMW announcement, a friend who works in care had her hourly rate increased from £9.50ph to £11ph. Today, they told the staff the rate was going up to £11.50, plus people working overtime would get £15ph.

They are desperate for staff, have trouble recruiting and even more trouble keeping people. And this isn't in a big city, but a smallish town in rural Suffolk.

GreenLunchBox · 26/10/2021 19:14

@Rosebel I just Googled it and it's time and a quarter on Sundays

Sunnysas · 26/10/2021 19:13

YABU - A teachers wage is still a lot more than minimum wage. People on minimum wage jobs often can’t afford to live without some kind of benefit. Universal credit etc. Everything is going up in price gas, food, rent/mortgage payments etc. How are those people expected to stretch their pay packet when it’s already not enough?

GreenLunchBox · 26/10/2021 19:09

No supermarket pays more for Sunday staff and haven't for quite a while. At least the big four don't, not sure about the others.

Well tell that to my local Tesco. DS got £11 something an hour on Sundays. He only left a month ago to go to uni

Swipe left for the next trending thread