Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

So if the Minimum Wage increases...

488 replies

missbunnyrabbit · 25/10/2021 20:20

My own wage in a public sector job seems lower than ever. The article I read suggests the public sector pay freezes will end, but I doubt we'll get such a large pay rise!

Aibu to feel like packing my teacher job in to go and work a minimum wage job instead?

OP posts:
CherryHug · 27/10/2021 10:34

[quote BrilloPaddy]@CherryHug we've had to close over lockdowns meaning we couldn't sell anything; our suppliers have increased everything by at least 15%, and we are literally just keeping our heads above water.

Do we sell a kidney each to pay our staff what they're worth Hmm

What a stunningly ignorant comment to make.[/quote]
Soz, forgot to switch on my psychic abilities this morning, so had no possible way of knowing that Hmm

StargazerAli · 27/10/2021 09:33

I understand that you feel disillusioned, but I think you'll find this in any industry you can think of. Most minimum wage jobs are tedious and unappreciated and employees are expected to work long, inconvenient hours. I think you would feel more frustrated but with even less of a voice than you have now.

Ddot · 27/10/2021 09:25

Bloody hell that went wrong Haha whole spectrum of people

Ddot · 27/10/2021 09:24

I worked in a factory and lived it I worked with a while soectruif people a woman who passed the bar but couldnt take the cut throat part of it, aeronautical student, dental nurse the list was long, it was hard work but paid reasonably well. Unfortunately I left due to health issues. I don't have qualifications, I dont have fitness on my side so am doing a menial job. I dont mind as I dont rent but if I did I'd be buggered

bigpinkpants · 27/10/2021 09:08

I am in my mid 40's and for the past year, have been working as a manager of a charity shop earning pennies above the NMW. It is by far the most physically demanding job I have ever had, and also, relatively, the lowest paid by a long way. I am well educated, with a degree that I supported myself through in my early 20's. I have over 20 years experience in the pharmaceutical industry, working in various roles, including supervisory and middle management, on decent salaries. However, with the exception of one of these jobs (which ended through redundancy due to my department being closed down and responsibility being transferred to the U.S team), I have never found the fulfilment and enjoyment I desired.

Over the past couple of years, I have experienced significant personal issues, including the sudden passing of my mother and a second unexpected bereavement of a very close friend, that have made me question what life means to me, and what my priorities are with regards to my work.

I can honestly say that my career change has been one of the best things I've ever done. Yes, my wage has decreased significantly, and I know I'm extremely fortunate that I'm able to take that hit as DH has a decent salary........and I am physically exhausted most evenings (although, looking at the positives, I definitely get my 10,000+ steps in every day, and it could be viewed as being daily exercise that I didn't get in previous positions, so it has positively increased my activity levels). However, from a mental health perspective, I now feel so much better about myself, which has a positive knock on my family. I know that I'm doing something that helps other people and am giving something back and doing something truly worthwhile. The job is such hard work and you have to manage volunteers who can let you down at the last minute, leaving you to run the shop on your own, customers who are largely lovely and wonderful people, but who can really test your patience, and donations that can vary from being high quality designer items, to rubbish that just goes straight into the bin, but you just don't know what each day will bring, and I love that aspect of it.

So, what I'm trying to say, is that, to me, WHAT you do and your own enjoyment of what you do is more important than the status of being in a high earning career. Just because a role is NMW does NOT mean that the individual is someone to be looked down on or ridiculed...... some of us actively choose these roles and are happy to do so. You don't go into charity work for the money....... if that motivates you, then you need to better yourself, whether that be through education or experience, in order to get a job that is better renumerated. Again, I know that I am very lucky to be able to choose a low paid role, but not everyone who does one does so because they have no choice.

PickUpAPepper · 27/10/2021 09:08

I am in favour of better pay and conditions for everyone, lower and further up the chain, and a return to focus on the purpose of all jobs.

I did train and work up, only to watch my higher earnings being swallowed up as minimum wage increased and ours didn’t. I am no longer working in that area. I trained again in a different profession (teaching actually), only to be told that yes I could do the job, but that didn’t matter because I don’t socialise enough, don’t “look the part” (ie don’t perform feminity), and have no family connections into the profession. I’m now following the example of the men I work with who do the minimum and spend most of their time bragging or going on fag breaks to discuss who they want to shag next, but whose jobs somehow are never at risk in the same way mine is. All work is a waste of time and effort, min wage or professional level.

Magicalwoodlands · 27/10/2021 08:59

So you are in favour of better pay and conditions for the lowest paid then, @PickUpAPepper?

Cyw2018 · 27/10/2021 08:47

I worked out my hourly salary equivalent. It's £9.45!! That's based on my typical 60-70 hour week.

OP are you working 60-70 hours a week for 47 weeks a year as a teacher? Because I suspect your maths is all wrong (which is concerning for a teacher). You work annualised hours, which I have no doubt is tough at times, particularly in the long autumn term, but that is not the same as working minimum wage and only getting 5.2 weeks of leave a year.

My best friends works a full time minimum wage job with minimum statutory t&c. She works in an admin role and doesn't have anyone picking up the majority of her workload when on annual leave so has to play catch up when she returns all for £9.50 an hour. She also has responsibility for orders that involve significant £££. We live in a very 'poor' region of the UK (although house prices are high due to second home ownership) and it's not uncommon to have fairly high responsibility roles on minimum wage. Minimum wage does not equal low effort.

Onemorebaby · 27/10/2021 08:32

You may find it easier in the moment. However overall you will be worse off as a job is more than the wage. Think childcare after 9-5 hours and in the holidays. You will have hardly any annual leave. This will be difficult to cover with shift work and you may have to pay for days that you don't use. Also a problem for police, paramedics and nurses.
You will get minimum pension contributions so will have to work later than if you stayed as a teacher. You often see older supermarket staff for this reason.
Your contract is unlikely to be full time adding to unpredictable shifts to make up the hours, wage instability, fewer holidays, less income to base a mortgage on. You may have to rent and pay really high rent.
Minimum wage jobs are difficult and costly in ways beyond the lower actual hourly rate.
Add to that they are highly competitive. Hundreds applied for aldi when I did and their full time contract was 25 hours, no set shifts and targets you had to meet every month. I had a great time and was super fit but it was a hard job. It would be short sighted imo

PickUpAPepper · 27/10/2021 08:13

@Magicalwoodlands

I don’t actually understand what you are wanting to riot in the streets about, *@PickUpAPepper*
Really?

Twenty five years ago having a full time job meant that you could afford to buy a house in most parts of the country. In employment you had guaranteed hours. There were 'zero hours contracts' around - I had one - but they were used to cover holidays and sickness, not as a standard work contract to cover regular business hours. You got breaks and lunch breaks. If you wanted more autonomy in employment, and /or more money to cover luxuries you trained up, either worked your way up the management chain or used education to train into more demanding jobs and got it. There were childcare centres being set up so that women could afford to go back to work. It was becoming accepted that men should take responsibility for children too rather than leave women to make all the sacrifices and the promise was that there would be part-time work available at professional levels to allow work-life balance. Then buy-to-let and globalised finance was unleashed.

Now? Minimum wage is nearly all zero-hour contracts. Every job requires you to be fully flexible, not only to cover holidays if you can, but to not have the same hours from one week to the next. I can go to work in a morning expecting a full 9-6 shift, having paid for childcare to cover that, and be told at 3 that numbers have changed so I have to go home, but I can't recover my childcare costs. Breaks and lunch breaks are absolutely minimal and there is an expectation that you will work through them. There are expectations everywhere, expectations that you will go 'above and beyond' for the job to be considered for permanent status, let alone be considered for higher pay positions, what few are left. Going above and beyond however never does result in promotion - the only thing that does is being friendly with higher-ups. There are no jobs that don't come with the responsibility you used to train up to. The attitudes now seem to be that higher paid people have worked up, not to take more responsibility, but to earn the right to do nothing but throw more shit at lower-paid people and force them to do more. Snobbery abounds everywhere. Pay doesn't cover living costs renting and there is no way to buy if you do not come from wealth and do not have a mummy and daddy to help. Part-time working seems to have vanished in many parts of the country, and men are going back to thinking that children are all women's fault, as is the housing crisis - everything is women's fault for not being nicer to men, and they are free to attack us and invent new ways of doing so.

Finally we're constantly told that we've never had it so good, we have more rights on paper than ever, and need to stop moaning and work more while things get worse and worse in actual real life. Anyone want to add anything else?

Badbadbunny · 27/10/2021 08:11

@Ddot

If money needs to be cut it's always the lower end that is shaved never the elite. Too many shareholders filling their pockets. My friend worked in the field (not literally) he then got seconded as a trainer. After several months successfully training he still is on same money but no bonuses so is training people for less than their on. Now apparently its costing too much so he is back and forth, in field and training so bonus messed up, hence no cash again. This country needs a shake up. Minimum wage is bad only because cost of living is ridiculous (rent) how can it be that bloody much for what you get. If you want deluxe then yes you have to hand over the cash but have you seen some of those flats, tiny houses covered in mold falling apart, yet still its unaffordable. Shameful situation
When you say "Too many shareholders filling their pockets" you actually mean normal people with occupational pensions, as it's usually pension funds who are major shareholders in the big companies like Tesco etc. Profits (dividends) are used to pay normal people's pensions!
bruce43mydog · 27/10/2021 08:07

People on the lowest wage need more help.

They work just as hard as any one else. Doesn't matter if your more qualified or think your more stressed. It's not easy on the other side. We all struggle. Of you want to give up your already well paid job. To get a extra 60p a hour your more than welcome.

We work just as much if not more hours and have had a pitiful 1p and 2p rise over the years. Its about time we had our slice of cake.

Let's not forget the cost of living as gone up we won't even notice the rise.

Ddot · 27/10/2021 08:01

In my humble opinion if you work 40hours it shouldn't matter what you do, you should be able to live and pay bills. Not rely on benefit top ups, to pay rent on some scabby moldy pit.

MasterGland · 27/10/2021 07:54

@marchitectmummy I am not a communist. I vote Conservative! However, there has been research that shows that societies that have higher wealth inequality have higher levels of unhappiness. I am not suggesting that everyone has to earn the same, but I do think we should ensure a decent standard of living for those on the minimum wage. It should be much higher.

Magicalwoodlands · 27/10/2021 07:52

I don’t actually understand what you are wanting to riot in the streets about, @PickUpAPepper

ivykaty44 · 27/10/2021 07:49

I love a shiny new 26 year old teacher telling people here relating their stories of life on NMW that they're all wrong.

Then will wonder why they got so many peoples backs up

catfunk · 27/10/2021 07:33

'I have done the long hours. I have worked all the bank holidays. I did back breaking work in the supermarket (I'm tiny and had to carry heavy boxes and use machinery in the warehouse). I know exactly what it is like to have yiur hours changed at the last minute, be spoken to like shit, be utterly run off my feet. I can honestly say that teaching is more stressful and exhausting than any of that.'

So go back to it then?
But you won't will you. Because you'd lose sick pay, holidays, union, and any employment benefits you've accrued, and general stability.
My cleaner at work earns twice my hourly rate technically. But it's just not comparable.

I actually agree that public sector workers are underpaid but this thread is a bit nasty and really feels like you're punching down tbh.

PickUpAPepper · 27/10/2021 07:31

@Magicalwoodlands

If you’ve only just been offered a permanent contract and you are the only one from your friends from university to have been offered one then it indicates no shortage in teachers. And yes, before anyone starts, I know there might be an overall shortage - but it is subject and area dependent and always has been.

If there are no shortages of teachers of your subject / age range in your area then it is unlikely that the rising of minimum wage will see everyone flock towards these jobs.

Not necessarily. As you say it is very area dependent. But there are regions where staff were moved wholesale onto temporary year-long contracts to avoid having to pay yearly increments and rises.

TAs are another absolutely shit job. Actually require a lot of skill and education - I have been required to take lessons and, effectively, plan them, on £10 an hour - but are viewed as low down the hierarchy. Too many teachers treat them like shit, and believe they are so superior.

Employment conditions in this country are absolutely crazy now. Far too much of it is about snobbery and maintaining social orders, not getting jobs done. For all of us, minimum wage and qualified staff. We should have all been rioting in the streets long ago, but it has been like a slowly boiling pot, and older people were very very keen to get us all to accept worse conditions steadily. I have been sent on 'change management' courses and told how 'negative' and ticked off or generally made to feel like a little bit of shit on someone's shoe for not being 'change positive' so many, many times. It's become more of a crime to be intelligent and able to see that these changes are negative for those of us not born into wealth than it is to commit actual crimes.

Brefugee · 27/10/2021 07:24

I love a shiny new 26 year old teacher telling people here relating their stories of life on NMW that they're all wrong.

OP, do what you like. Just don't whine about it in 5 years when you're still on the same wage. Or if you're working next to someone with zero qualifications who gets more hours than you because they just get on with it.

CurzonDax · 27/10/2021 07:02

No one can make the d2cision for you - you have to do what's best for you. My story:

Taught in secondary schools for 11 years - was middle management in the end, and earning £48k a year. I got bullied out of the profession by toxic colleagues, and had a mental breakdown. (I did initially try and move schools, and whilst the people there were better, my confidence had been knocked so much, I had to accept that I wasn't being fair on the students if I stayed). My DH supported me through this time, but to be honest, if I had stayed in teaching I probably would have ended up losing my marriage - my behaviour was very difficult during my breakdown, which did put a mental strain on him too.

Left 2 years ago, and am in an admin role and earn £18k a year (at 37 hours a week, this is only just above minimum wage. However, I have worked out that I could potentially be under the minimum wage, if it is increased to £9.50 an hour, maybe?).

I absolutely love my job, and have great colleagues, and a wonderful and supportive manager. I am very fortunate that I was able to take such a pay decrease (a small inheritance a few years back paid off a chunk of our mortgage and DH supplements my wages a lot - it actuallydoes suck to think that I wouldn't be able to do this job/be on this wage if I were single!).

For me it was the best decision- mentally, I am now in a good place. Yes, I have loat my 13 weeks holiday a year, and our disposable income would be absolutely amazing if I were still on my teaching wage, and I'm definitely not using my degree now. But fir me, it was the right decision. I'm also so so fortunate that I was able to make that choice (I appreciate many other on minimum wage jobs aren't able to have the same choices/options that I had).

You need to weigh everything up and do what's best for you and your family.

Ddot · 27/10/2021 06:49

If money needs to be cut it's always the lower end that is shaved never the elite. Too many shareholders filling their pockets. My friend worked in the field (not literally) he then got seconded as a trainer. After several months successfully training he still is on same money but no bonuses so is training people for less than their on. Now apparently its costing too much so he is back and forth, in field and training so bonus messed up, hence no cash again. This country needs a shake up. Minimum wage is bad only because cost of living is ridiculous (rent) how can it be that bloody much for what you get. If you want deluxe then yes you have to hand over the cash but have you seen some of those flats, tiny houses covered in mold falling apart, yet still its unaffordable. Shameful situation

Ddot · 27/10/2021 06:34

missbunnyrabbit
I agree if you spend time and money you should earn more but I dont agree that if you work minimum wage jobs as op said it is easy! because it is not

Marchitectmummy · 27/10/2021 06:13

@MasterGland

Such a shame that we can't seem to escape this incessant need to be doing "better" relative to others. That way misery lies. We would live in much happier, healthier, lower crime communities, if we had much flatter hierarchies. The minimum wage should increase drastically.
Would we? Maybe have a conversation with anyone who has lived through communism as to whether that's true or not.
Whenthedealgoesdown · 27/10/2021 04:17

A lot of call centre and office jobs are minimum wage and you can wfh so they are not all in factories, shops and bars

Magicalwoodlands · 27/10/2021 02:58

If you’ve only just been offered a permanent contract and you are the only one from your friends from university to have been offered one then it indicates no shortage in teachers. And yes, before anyone starts, I know there might be an overall shortage - but it is subject and area dependent and always has been.

If there are no shortages of teachers of your subject / age range in your area then it is unlikely that the rising of minimum wage will see everyone flock towards these jobs.

Swipe left for the next trending thread