Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

So if the Minimum Wage increases...

488 replies

missbunnyrabbit · 25/10/2021 20:20

My own wage in a public sector job seems lower than ever. The article I read suggests the public sector pay freezes will end, but I doubt we'll get such a large pay rise!

Aibu to feel like packing my teacher job in to go and work a minimum wage job instead?

OP posts:
Notashandyta · 25/10/2021 22:34

Ex teacher here.

I'm pretty sure that you don't resent the minimum wage increase, you just want a fair wage yourself. If you worked out how much teachers actually get paid 'per hour', it would be far, far less than the minimum wage.

mayblossominapril · 25/10/2021 22:32

I’ve been a teacher and done a wide range of minimum wage jobs, I’d go back to the mw jobs before the teaching, it’s much easier.
Many businesses are only just viable for a variety of reasons the main one being the customer doesn’t want to pay the full rate due to cheaper imports, we have been in a bit of a race to the bottom.

There’s the old joke about a farmer who was asked when inspected by the agricultural wages board, who is employed by the farm and what their pay is. He replied there’s a lad on £xxx a week, an apprentice on £xx a week, the old boy gets his board and lodging and the dog is on £x. Well said the inspector you can’t just give someone board and lodging for a full weeks work, I need to meet the old boy. The farmer said you already have it’s me.

JurgensCakeBaby · 25/10/2021 22:31

A new probation officer earns £10.50 an hour and has to manage a caseload of dangerous people including sex offenders. I'm all for the NMW going up but public sector practitioner salaries need looking at too. The starting salary hasn't increased in the last 12 years. Nearly all applicants are graduates, or have come from experience in another related field. I work now in a related justice field and we struggle to recruit because we don't pay much more than NMW and the stress, trauma and responsibility we expect people to handle is in no way comparable to a shift in a shop (I've done both).

Jellykat · 25/10/2021 22:29

If minimum wage goes up, all that happens is, those on minimum wage don’t need so much from the government in top up benefits, instead companies pay their staff a wage they can more easily afford to live on

Great for the governments purse, but the employees end up with exactly the same amount per week to live on, not more! While the cost of living rises....
Alternatively, working hours get shaved as in my case last April, still expected to do the same amount of work only less time to do it!

Righty · 25/10/2021 22:27

So a newly qualified teacher gets £25k+, as well as 13 weeks holiday and over 20% pension contributions from their employer.

Someone on NMW gets £18k and 5 weeks holiday, pension contributions from employer probably 5%. They probably have shifts in the evening and weekends.

I know which I'd prefer. An upper payscale teacher is on £40k+ basic salary.

drpaddington · 25/10/2021 22:26

The owner of our nursery drives a jag- she won’t struggle to keep afloat, she may struggle to make the same amount of profit across her 4 nurseries- at some point we need to find a balance. If you don’t pay people enough to live on you pay to subsidise with your taxes - it’s been a race to the bottom for a long time. At some point we (society) have to improve things, but that comes at a cost: income tax, ni, inheritance tax, higher wage bills, council tax.

Our owner seems very well off too but I know her husband is in a very well paid job so that will be part of it. It certainly won't be the case for all nursery owners.

TSSDNCOP · 25/10/2021 22:26

Teachers crack me up. Have any of you ever asked your employer what your on costs are?

HermioneWeasley · 25/10/2021 22:24

Having done a few, I reckon the easiest min wage job is supermarket checkouts - no heavy lifting and usually allowed to sit down (though can get sore shoulders from the scanning).

But most supermarkets don’t offer full time shifts - they want lots of people on part time contracts for the flexibility. For a full time contract you’d have to be in a warehouse, factory or care job.

Do it for a week one summer and see if you still feel you’ve got a raw deal. And remember you’d be doing that hard, physical work with little sick pay, pension and holidays,

DrCoconut · 25/10/2021 22:24

Thing is this will not make much difference to many low paid workers. Between loss of UC top ups due to earning more, higher NI, increased energy bills, increased food costs, probably increased childcare costs to cover higher wages there will be no real change. As ever it will be those with access to more money such as a better paid partner that will benefit.

Rosebel · 25/10/2021 22:22

Round here a newly qualified teacher earns around 28k and a supermarket worker (if they can actually get full time) is on less than £18k.
Yet you begrudge them getting a small increase. If you actually have worked in a supermarket you should know how pressured and target driven it is.
If it's so easy just go back to it. Most supermarkets are screaming out for staff.
OP you obviously see minimum wage workers as beneath you (bet you'd soon notice if no one does the job) and they clearly don't deserve a wage they can live on.
Actually there soon will be fewer supermarket workers and care assistants as it seems most nurseries won't survive meaning a lot of parents giving up work so it'll be even easier to get a minimum wage job.

Ilovegreentomatoes · 25/10/2021 22:21

And I still think NMW should be set at £10ph especially for us in the south east where the cost of living seems higher than many other places.

Ilovegreentomatoes · 25/10/2021 22:19

@Willow231 nursery worker here and I agree with everything you said.
But I think a lot of people do not appreciate what our job entails and the training and paperwork behind the scenes.
Plus the demands from parents and the responsibility we have for basically peanuts.

MasterGland · 25/10/2021 22:18

Such a shame that we can't seem to escape this incessant need to be doing "better" relative to others. That way misery lies.
We would live in much happier, healthier, lower crime communities, if we had much flatter hierarchies. The minimum wage should increase drastically.

DoctorSnortles · 25/10/2021 22:17

Bloody hell. Don't leave teaching. The holidays are brilliant!

BoredZelda · 25/10/2021 22:17

If minimum wage goes up, all that happens is, those on minimum wage don’t need so much from the government in top up benefits, instead companies pay their staff a wage they can more easily afford to live on.

Which is as it should be.

Lucyloo49 · 25/10/2021 22:15

Let's not turn against each other on this.

Absolutely minimum wage should rise as should other wages for non minimum wage roles if Boris wants to retain a skilled workforce.

We should all be coming together to fight for fairer wages for everyone in line with inflation/price rises. Public or private sector, minimum wage or non minimum wage shouldn't be the focus.

I am a nurse and have considered leaving for the past 3 years. I stay in the job because of many reasons & I won't be leaving the profession but I have reduced my hours significantly. I have a second minimum wage job for 12 hours a week and it's the best thing I've ever done. Many others are also planning to do the same & there's already a big staffing crisis. There becomes a point where it's just not worth the benefits anymore.

But we also can't be naive to think a better paid or less paid job is going to be the answer/easier.

Willow231 · 25/10/2021 22:12

I work in a nursery. I am responsible for making sure a room full of toddlers are happy, cared for, have stimulating activities, have nutritious food to eat, have clean nappies, sleeps etc. Have been to college to earn my childcare qualifications, first aid, food hygiene and child protection trained. I do observations and write up reports for the parents on how their child is progressing. This just a small list of what is expected if me, and doesn't include all the demands and stress from those higher up.

I earn £8.91an hour. I feel thoroughly depressed that there are people who think I don't deserve any more than this because I am 'unskilled'.

MsJinks · 25/10/2021 22:11

I don’t think the issue is wages going up for the least well paid at all. I think it’s more that teaching - like many jobs - is now depressing and very stressful in its requirements with extensive hours and difficult conditions at times, plus endless paperwork. Many teachers leave the profession, often suffer burnout, and some teachers only stay teaching due to financial considerations. If there’s less financial impact in job change then why wouldn’t you leave if your job drains the life out of you to one that has less overspill into your entire life. I’m not saying all jobs are like this but my relative loves Amazon as when she’s done, she doesn’t have to think about it again till clocking on unlike some jobs.
Ideally we would all earn a good wage, in a role we enjoyed, and jobs wouldn’t be ridiculously stressful due to low resource or employee/authority regulations- unfortunately we don’t live in that utopia and we have to weigh up what’s best for each one of us.

MilkTwoSugarsThanks · 25/10/2021 22:04

But to not be able to increase my fees but have my out going increase, the reality will mean we will close and 9 people will lose their jobs.

And those 9 people will be able to get one of those lovely 10 a penny easy minimum wage jobs like at a supermarket checkout or Amazon fulfilment centre and bask in the glorious stress free high life.

Hmm
Ilovegreentomatoes · 25/10/2021 22:04

Nurseries should never of accepted the funded hours in the first place tbh they were much to low.
Cost of living has increased so what would be the option? Leave people unable to pay their Bills or feed their families.

OnlyFoolsnMothers · 25/10/2021 22:03

@drpaddington

As a nursery nurse earning a few pence over minimum wage, I have to say this announcement doesn't make me feel any better. Prices will go up in line with the increase so I won't see any benefit. Then there's the worry of how many nurseries will have to close because owners can't afford the increased wage bill along with increased prices for everything else.
The owner of our nursery drives a jag- she won’t struggle to keep afloat, she may struggle to make the same amount of profit across her 4 nurseries- at some point we need to find a balance. If you don’t pay people enough to live on you pay to subsidise with your taxes - it’s been a race to the bottom for a long time. At some point we (society) have to improve things, but that comes at a cost: income tax, ni, inheritance tax, higher wage bills, council tax.
BritWifeInUSA · 25/10/2021 22:03

@Magicalwoodlands

effort doesn’t seem worth it

But you have already made the effort.

Do you seriously think that working as a care assistant, stacking shelves in Tesco, working in an Amazon warehouse, is somehow stress free and ‘easy’?

It isn’t. It’s hard, gruelling work, it often involves anti social hours (nights, evenings, weekends) no sick pay, no god forbid death in service benefit, no pension, no enhanced maternity pay, often dealing with very difficult situations and people.

I know there is a lot wrong with teaching and that it’s hard work, but as a minimum you’re on nearly 26,000. Minimum wage on a 40hour week isn’t that.

Perfectly put! I’m wondering how a teacher thinks that a min wage job would be better? I guess they are taking their annual salary, dividing by 52 and then dividing by 40. Completely forgetting that 13 weeks of that they are not due in work. I’m not going to get into the argument if Joe much teachers work it don’t work during the school holidays - my sister abd her husband both teach at secondary schools and I know how much time off they get. Even if you are marking it preparing for the be t term, it’s at your pace, on your terms, for your benefit. It’s not even close to stacking shelves or doing bed pans at 6 am.

Also, many public sector workers forget the job security that they have over the private sector. In the time That my sister has been a teacher she has been made redundant zero times. She’s even had promotions. I’ve been made redundant 5 times in the same period. And every private sector worker lives with the reality that the company could go bust tomorrow.

drpaddington · 25/10/2021 22:01

If nurseries cant survive the pay increase they need to lobby the government for higher funding, not expect people to earn less than it costs to live

Childcare providers have been trying this for years and haven't got far.

OnlyFoolsnMothers · 25/10/2021 21:59

@HalfwomanHalfcookie

Oh it's happening again isn't it. This time it's hardworking people having a little dig at other hardworking people who might be getting a little extra in their wages next year. The little bit extra in their wages next year is necessary as otherwise they may not be able to afford to live.
Yep!!!!!
Freddiefox · 25/10/2021 21:58

@Animood

If you can’t afford to pay your staff enough money for them to live on then your business isn’t viable. Sorry. Not the job of people on minimum wage to live in poverty to prop up businesses that can’t afford to keep going.

Yes. Amazing post!

That only works if you don’t have a cap on what you can charge. If they removed the cap then great no probs.