Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

So if the Minimum Wage increases...

488 replies

missbunnyrabbit · 25/10/2021 20:20

My own wage in a public sector job seems lower than ever. The article I read suggests the public sector pay freezes will end, but I doubt we'll get such a large pay rise!

Aibu to feel like packing my teacher job in to go and work a minimum wage job instead?

OP posts:
Danikm151 · 25/10/2021 22:56

I got a 2% pay rise this year. For what should have been an extra £38 per month I am better off around £4 a month due to tax/ni/student finance and the UC taper rate.
It will be interesting to see how much the NMW increase actually benefits anybody but the government

Explosivefarts · 25/10/2021 22:56

@missbunnyrabbit

A few points to mention ... I have done a couple of minimum wage jobs, as have people I know, and they are easy compared to a lot of professional jobs.

Jobs should be paid by how hard they are, how much responsibilty there is, and also how much training and education is needed.

If there were no job hierarchy, I think far fewer people would bother going into professional jobs. Why stress yourself out and be drowning in responsibility if you are not getting paid well (comparatively) for it?

If someone is doing a job that requires significant education and training (eg. A degree) plus responsibility, then they should be paid well for it.

This is not to say that I disagree with a minimum wage rise in itself, but other professionals should receive an equivalent pay rise.

By your logic carers should be getting paid a lot more than you are . I have sat and held hands with people in care homes when they were dying as no family could in . It’s piss easy is it ?But sure get a minimum wage job . Give up your summer off. Your Christmas holidays too.
Kimjonghealthy · 25/10/2021 22:56

Don't get me wrong, I think minimum wage should be increased. I just don't think nursing is worth it. People's lives on the line, chronic understaffing, being assaulted. A higher wage would soften the blow slightly. But even then, it's not worth it

Toomanyradishes · 25/10/2021 22:55

@kimjonghealthy ive been spat at multiple times when i worked in retail, ive been slammed into a wall, had people screaming in my face and been pushed across the room. This was at an opticians too, not somewhere you expect violence. Ive worked in a variety of retail, admin and call center places. Ive been called every name under the sun, had men phoning up to wank down the phone at us etc

I now earn over twice as much and have lower work ouput expectations and lower stress

Also plenty of people in retail have degrees too

LittleBearPad · 25/10/2021 22:55

I think you need to grow up and realise some jobs simply to have less responsibility and require less training than others.

Well you’re just a treat aren’t you OP.

Clocktopus · 25/10/2021 22:53

I think you need to grow up and realise some jobs simply to have less responsibility and require less training than others

So what if they do? They staff doing those jobs should still be paid enough to live on rather the current system of subsistence wages topped up by benefits.

whispamint · 25/10/2021 22:53

It's a pointless idea, but it's done to help make sure the gullible keep voting tory. This increase means nothing, and with the increases in national insurance next plus any further increases in bills, people will still probably be broke or even more broke.

yep

MasterGland · 25/10/2021 22:53

I think people would definitely still do those professional jobs. Especially in this country. The first thing anyone asks when they meet someone new is "what do you do? “
People will always strive for status.

missbunnyrabbit · 25/10/2021 22:52

@PizzaCrust

This is hilarious. Working in retail is just so easy, isn’t it?

Even as a customer advisor, on full time hours a lot more would be expected of you than to simply clock in, do the bare minimum, and clock out. I swear people have completely lost the grasp of how much work it actually takes to run a shop.

It isn’t just serving customers at tills and “shelf stacking”. It’s constantly-

  • date checking every item in store. For the fresh department, this is every single day. Reducing items to clear on a schedule across all ambient, frozen and fresh lines
  • preparing for deliveries, packing out stock, merchandising stock, facing off the shop constantly
  • health and safety protocols and records (temperatures of all fridges/freezers taken multiple times a day, floor checks to list a few)
  • cash handling and ensuring till losses are kept to a minimum
  • handling deliveries of higher value items (cigarettes especially)
  • ensuring stock loss is kept to a minimum
  • numerous KPIs and budget targets set by head office which change all the time and need to be exceeded unless you want upper management in your shop every week giving you a hard time
  • preparing for the future. Christmas stock arrives into stores in August. Easter stock will arrive in January. It doesn’t just magically appear a week before the holidays.

And if you have any sort of management responsibility, then you’ll have paperwork to complete daily, orders to do for the shop, gap checks to complete daily (and yes, you have to investigate every single gap in store), checking cameras for stock loss prevention purposes, invoicing, promotion ordering and preparation, CEO visits to prepare for where everything has to be absolutely perfect, dealings with every single head office department (eg HR, payroll, finance etc), recruiting staff, training staff, ensuring wastage of OOD goods has been recorded properly, stocktake where every single item in store has to be counted and recorded, the list goes on.

People absolutely love to act like working in a shop is a doss. It might be for some who won’t last very long, but for most of us, it’s hard work with just as many pressures and deadlines as other jobs. Oh, and you also have to deal with the general public (remember toilet roll gate) and working unsocialable hours. 6am starts? Working until 12pm? How about an overnight shift?

Grow up.

Sorry, didn't realise you needed a degree to be able to do those things! I worked for 5 years in retail and did plenty of those myself. We had 16-18 year old doing those jobs. Are you for real?

I think you need to grow up and realise some jobs simply to have less responsibility and require less training than others.

OP posts:
whispamint · 25/10/2021 22:52

Aibu to feel like packing my teacher job in to go and work a minimum wage job instead?

Yes as I think in most examples you would still be better off financially.

Clocktopus · 25/10/2021 22:51

- ensuring stock loss is kept to a minimum

Don't forget to add to this that losses can be deducted from staff wages. Your till is wrong? That'll come from your pay. Too much stock is getting binned/written off? That'll come out of your pay too. Been hit by shoplifters and lost a load of stock? Guess what you're paying for from your wages...

Kimjonghealthy · 25/10/2021 22:51

I'm a nurse and I also think like what's the point.

Get spat at for slightly more than minimum wage. Had someone pull my hair the other day.

Minimum wage job in a shop or something might be better. Which is sad because I've worked hard for my crap degree for my crap job 🙃👍

LittleBearPad · 25/10/2021 22:50

@missbunnyrabbit

A few points to mention ... I have done a couple of minimum wage jobs, as have people I know, and they are easy compared to a lot of professional jobs.

Jobs should be paid by how hard they are, how much responsibilty there is, and also how much training and education is needed.

If there were no job hierarchy, I think far fewer people would bother going into professional jobs. Why stress yourself out and be drowning in responsibility if you are not getting paid well (comparatively) for it?

If someone is doing a job that requires significant education and training (eg. A degree) plus responsibility, then they should be paid well for it.

This is not to say that I disagree with a minimum wage rise in itself, but other professionals should receive an equivalent pay rise.

Did you have a Saturday job? One in university holidays?

I’m saying this because you sound very immature. I imagine you’re 2/3 years into teaching?

KateF · 25/10/2021 22:47

The early years sector is in crisis. The government will not invest in early years and funded places are bankrupting providers especially in poorer areas where more 2 year olds are funded Schools are getting financial support for Covid recovery, early years settings are not.
I'm a senior practitioner, a graduate studying for a Masters and with SEND qualifications. I earn £9.31/hour, work 42 hours a week and can't afford to turn the heating on. I am single but have my teenage DD half the week. So no maintenance or UC. My finances are on a knife edge. When I see people complaining about high staff turnover in their nursery this is why. Promising young practitioners can earn more cleaning.

missbunnyrabbit · 25/10/2021 22:47

A few points to mention ...
I have done a couple of minimum wage jobs, as have people I know, and they are easy compared to a lot of professional jobs.

Jobs should be paid by how hard they are, how much responsibilty there is, and also how much training and education is needed.

If there were no job hierarchy, I think far fewer people would bother going into professional jobs. Why stress yourself out and be drowning in responsibility if you are not getting paid well (comparatively) for it?

If someone is doing a job that requires significant education and training (eg. A degree) plus responsibility, then they should be paid well for it.

This is not to say that I disagree with a minimum wage rise in itself, but other professionals should receive an equivalent pay rise.

OP posts:
LittleBearPad · 25/10/2021 22:46

You’ll wave goodbye to the massive employers pension contributions and the 13 weeks holiday. You’ll also be paid less and have sod all job security. Maybe don’t be silly

PizzaCrust · 25/10/2021 22:44

This is hilarious. Working in retail is just so easy, isn’t it?

Even as a customer advisor, on full time hours a lot more would be expected of you than to simply clock in, do the bare minimum, and clock out. I swear people have completely lost the grasp of how much work it actually takes to run a shop.

It isn’t just serving customers at tills and “shelf stacking”. It’s constantly-

  • date checking every item in store. For the fresh department, this is every single day. Reducing items to clear on a schedule across all ambient, frozen and fresh lines
  • preparing for deliveries, packing out stock, merchandising stock, facing off the shop constantly
  • health and safety protocols and records (temperatures of all fridges/freezers taken multiple times a day, floor checks to list a few)
  • cash handling and ensuring till losses are kept to a minimum
  • handling deliveries of higher value items (cigarettes especially)
  • ensuring stock loss is kept to a minimum
  • numerous KPIs and budget targets set by head office which change all the time and need to be exceeded unless you want upper management in your shop every week giving you a hard time
  • preparing for the future. Christmas stock arrives into stores in August. Easter stock will arrive in January. It doesn’t just magically appear a week before the holidays.

And if you have any sort of management responsibility, then you’ll have paperwork to complete daily, orders to do for the shop, gap checks to complete daily (and yes, you have to investigate every single gap in store), checking cameras for stock loss prevention purposes, invoicing, promotion ordering and preparation, CEO visits to prepare for where everything has to be absolutely perfect, dealings with every single head office department (eg HR, payroll, finance etc), recruiting staff, training staff, ensuring wastage of OOD goods has been recorded properly, stocktake where every single item in store has to be counted and recorded, the list goes on.

People absolutely love to act like working in a shop is a doss. It might be for some who won’t last very long, but for most of us, it’s hard work with just as many pressures and deadlines as other jobs. Oh, and you also have to deal with the general public (remember toilet roll gate) and working unsocialable hours. 6am starts? Working until 12pm? How about an overnight shift?

Grow up.

Mateypotatey · 25/10/2021 22:41

Finding this thread very interesting. Have always thought care home workers are massively underpaid for what they do in comparison to what the elderly have to pay to stay there, obviously someone at the top is benefitting and it's not the people doing the exhausting personal care, working long hours, cleaning up bodily fluids etc. To the OP- join the life after teaching Facebook group, there's lots of ideas on there if you want to leave teaching or are wondering about options in the future.

Clocktopus · 25/10/2021 22:41

People on national minimum wage frequently have to claim benefits to get by. Thats fucking outrageous, you shouldnt work 40 plus hours a week and still not earn enough to live

You see threads on here all the time about how people who need benefits to get by shouldn't have children, shouldn't expect to have nice things, shouldn't want holidays or nights out, and should be looking to get a second (or third) job or a 'better' job.

It's bullshit.

We need supermarket workers, carers, cleaners, drivers, hospitality staff, etc and there is nothing shameful about working in these so-called unskilled jobs. Not everyone is a high flyer, not everyone is able to (or indeed wants to) climb the ladder, and for a lot of people the job they have is a case of better the devil you know so why risk jumping to another. And that should all fine because a full time NMW job should pay enough to live on, should be enough to have children on if you want children, should be enough to provide some treats and luxuries, should be enough for them to have time off each week so that they're not working all hours with no rest just to stay above water - an honest wage for an honest day's work that provides an honest standard of living. No one should be working 40hrs a week (or more) and still find themselves in poverty.

Toomanyradishes · 25/10/2021 22:40

For those saying the increase is eaten up in tax and NI increases you are missing the point

If minimum wage goes up this benefits the government two fold, more money coming in from tax and national insurance, less money going out in universal credit

What this means is:

More money to invest in healthcare, education, the civil service etc

Society benefits, rather than amazon or tesco.

Those of you complaining that you are in government paying jobs and you arent being paid enough, you know what will help with that? The government having more money coming in and less money going out. Society benefits from this rather than corporations. So if you are in a public service job why the fuck are you complaining?

MereDintofPandiculation · 25/10/2021 22:38

I regularly daydream of a minimum wage job 9-5! I suspect most on minimum wage dream of this too.

Have you ever wondered how you manage a social life, or even celebrate family events with your wide family, when you don't know till midway through the week beforehand which days you will be working, whetehr you will be asked to start work at 2am or finish work at midnight? And you don't know in advance when you'll get a Saturday off (and a whole weekend is something you can only dream about)? And Public Holidays are just normal working days for you.

2pinkginsplease · 25/10/2021 22:37

As an employee I’m thankful minimum wage is going up. £9.50 an hour gives me £20 extra a week in my pocket equalling an extra grand a year, I work in early years and the private sector is hit hard and can’t compete with council nurseries and their wages. No wonder so many excellent practitioners are leaving private nurseries for council owned ones.

We do the same job but council wages start at £12 an hour!

Pipplekins · 25/10/2021 22:37

Min wage should bloody go up.
Have you forgotten who got this country through the last 2 years! It was the work force, the supermarkets, the nursery staff etc, all the people on shit wages.
I able to comfortably working at home, safe and snug, earning a good wage I won't forget who kept us going.

TirednWorried · 25/10/2021 22:37

The differential between high salaries and low salaries is too great.Long term high earners wages need to reduce to pay for lowearners pay to increase

frumpety · 25/10/2021 22:37

It isn’t. It’s hard, gruelling work, it often involves anti social hours (nights, evenings, weekends) no sick pay, no god forbid death in service benefit, no pension, no enhanced maternity pay

Why is this acceptable ?