Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

So if the Minimum Wage increases...

488 replies

missbunnyrabbit · 25/10/2021 20:20

My own wage in a public sector job seems lower than ever. The article I read suggests the public sector pay freezes will end, but I doubt we'll get such a large pay rise!

Aibu to feel like packing my teacher job in to go and work a minimum wage job instead?

OP posts:
Tilltheend99 · 26/10/2021 06:31

In a teaching job you presumably have an annual wage and set hours.

If you were in a minimum wage job you could easily be contacted for zero hours.

It is a misnomer that a person on minimum wage is earning 40 hours at that rate.

You would be competing with a large number of people for the hours you want and need to live on.

Even with the rise it is still below the living wage. Presumably as a teacher you are earning the living wage?

Teaching is a unionised job which gives you collective bargaining power to ask for, and possibly get pay rises. You could vote for strike action if you think the upcoming public sector pay rise is not enough.

Most minimum wage jobs have no union.

I agree that the public sector have been shafted by the pay freeze but you really shouldn’t take it out on the poorest in society.

I don’t know what you imagine min-wage work to be like but it is as hard as a ‘normal’ job and often physical. I’m guessing as a teacher you also don’t have to put up with people shouting at you all day. (Although many parents don’t sound very enlightened)

Threads like this are insulting and as an educated person you should think twice about posting this nonsense. Why not simply post about your own role, work load, and lack of remuneration instead of belittling others?

Neurodiversitydoctor · 26/10/2021 06:31

That should read it's not a race to the bottom.

ivykaty44 · 26/10/2021 06:28

If you’re unhappy about your teacher wage, tell the union you want to strike for more pay. Why should you work for less money

haveiahealthyheart · 26/10/2021 06:11

@Notashandyta

This thread is one of the bleakest reads on mn I've ever read Confused
Replying to this^
haveiahealthyheart · 26/10/2021 06:09

Absolutely the pits, isn’t it.

Lazy, greedy, selfish Britain. God I’m ashamed. No wonder the Tories are in power, we deserve them don’t we.

VividGemini · 26/10/2021 06:05

@BrilloPaddy

As a small business owner, I'm all ears as to where this 6.6% is going to come from. And how I then deal with my more skilled staff who are also going to want the same increase.

Angry

If you can't afford to pay your staff a living wage your business isn't viable.
haveiahealthyheart · 26/10/2021 06:03

I think you should definitely go for it OP.
You’re right, life’s too short, so quit teaching at Christmas and go live your best life cleaning McDonalds. You’re ahead of the game here, best do it quick before everyone else is rushing to do the same.

Hmm
Neurodiversitydoctor · 26/10/2021 05:54

*If the jobs that don't need such education or training, and have much less stress and workload, are paid closer and closer to what trained professionals earn, then why would anyone choose to be a trained professional? Unless they genuinely loved the job.

I love a lot of things about my job, but if I am to be paid barely peanuts more than someone in a supermarket, I'd rather do that! Life is not worth the stress (and yes, I have worked in a huge, busy supermarket and it was much much easier than my current job)*

They really have got you where they want you, haven't they ? The nations with less inequity have so much better outcomes all round. I am also a doctor who worked 50 hr weeks for !£200 pm after travel and childcare.It's not a race to the bottom.

whispamint · 26/10/2021 05:45

Sorry, but I think those furloughed SHOULD be the ones to pay most of it back. Not massive amounts, not all of it. But it infuriates me to think of people (cough ex-boyfriend cough) sitting at home, binge watching TV, whilst still getting 80%, while key workers like me are slogging our guts out and putting ourselves at risk of covid.

I don't want to hear 'we're all in this together'. No, I'm sorry, it's been MUCH easier for those sat at home than it has for us still working, still at risk, and doing more than our usual workload.

It's not their fault that they're furloughed. But life's not fair. I have nothing but envy for those sitting at home who work for big chains and are still guaranteed a job when they go back

It actually scares me that people are this stupid.

Waxonwaxoff0 · 26/10/2021 05:30

@Explosivefarts

Sorry, but I think those furloughed SHOULD be the ones to pay most of it back. Not massive amounts, not all of it. But it infuriates me to think of people (cough ex-boyfriend cough) sitting at home, binge watching TV, whilst still getting 80%, while key workers like me are slogging our guts out and putting ourselves at risk of covid.

I don't want to hear 'we're all in this together'. No, I'm sorry, it's been MUCH easier for those sat at home than it has for us still working, still at risk, and doing more than our usual workload.

It's not their fault that they're furloughed. But life's not fair. I have nothing but envy for those sitting at home who work for big chains and are still guaranteed a job when they go back

Oh fuck off with this. Furloughed people had no choice in the matter. If someone was furloughed who didn't need to be, the company should pay it back, not the employee. And by the way, not all of us going out to work were key workers either, I go out to work and I'm not a key worker in any sense.
garlictwist · 26/10/2021 04:46

Minimum wage has increased massively beyond the rate of inflation. Increasing it so quickly drives up the cost of living and threatens the viability of smaller employers. It's not a silver bullet.

MissTrip82 · 26/10/2021 03:47

[quote missbunnyrabbit]@LittleBearPad

Actually I'm nearly 27, went to uni late and am three years into teaching.

Im actually sat here reading this with my boyfriend, we can't believe how deluded some of you are.

Are you saying that it would be OK for doctors and amazon workers to earn similar amounts? After all, they both work hard?[/quote]
Actually for quite a long time my cleaner earned more per hour than me (dr). She was working hard too. She deserves to be able to eat too.

I also earned more per hour in med school (working in admin) than I did for the first few years as a dr. I find it hard to feel bitter about that, too.

If my wage dropped to NMW tomorrow I’d still not be choosing to work as a care assistant over my current job.

But of you’re sure your life would be easier and better, may as well make the change now I suppose.

lomoloko · 26/10/2021 01:20

Wages are not and have never been a reward for hard work. It's a reflection of the added value you can bring to a market and the negotiating position you can take to get your percentage of that added value. That's why union jobs pay better than comparable non union jobs -- your negotiating position is stronger.

It's got nothing to do with effort. It's entirely to do with power.

If loads of teachers leave their jobs and take up shelf stacking at ASDA, the wages of teachers will probably rise, if their job is actually necessary and valuable. So I say go for it.

I am paid approxiimately 76 times what I 'earned' as a family carer. My job is, comparatively, an absolute doddle. Salary really has got nothing to do with effort, or virtue. It's just a measure of social power.

CallMeNutribullet · 26/10/2021 01:02

Do it then op. Seriously if you believe life on 9 quid an hour in a supermarket is going to be better, and I presume afford you a good living standard, by all means follow your dreams.

Explosivefarts · 26/10/2021 01:01

I agree begrudging someone on the lowest pay an increase because your not getting one is not a nice attitude

TheFairPrincess · 26/10/2021 00:50

I do think this thread shows a bad nature toward others. Mustering up bitterness when comparing yourself to the bottom line is part of the problem.

Also, I don't understand how you cannot see the glaring difference between salaried and unsalaried work. If you or your DC are ill, you have to consider whether you can afford to be off. How stressful is that?

Notashandyta · 26/10/2021 00:47

This thread is one of the bleakest reads on mn I've ever read Confused

Explosivefarts · 26/10/2021 00:33

@NotMyCat

Some lower paid jobs have immense responsibility Ambulance call handlers? I mean you have someone's life in your hands, it doesn't get much more stressful. Pay? Band 3 in most areas

My job is stressful sometimes, busy most of the time. Not much responsibility (I can't kill anyone) but I handle around 200 calls a day. Min wage, plus commission

If we are paying according to qualifications, responsibility and stress then can we give all the NHS staff a pay rise? Plus ambulance service and police...,

I agree being a carer also isn’t a walk in the park.
BungleandGeorge · 26/10/2021 00:24

I think it’s a fair point that all wages need to rise but what will happen in many companies is that only the minimum wage will rise. Which destabilises everything. So you get supervisors paid 5p extra an hour. The effect of taxation is greater the more you earn due to the tax free amount. It’s not really a good thing for anyone as the middle incomes are the ones spending a high proportion of their wages on cafes, restaurants, shops, hotels, beauty, nurseries etc.

amsadandconfused · 26/10/2021 00:19

@minatrina

I worked pretty hard and got a masters degree in order to get into my career. I'm perfectly happy for minimum wage workers to get this pay rise even though it's not affecting my salary, and I'd be perfectly happy if it meant that I earnt the same as them. What is important is lifting people out of poverty and improving how we all fare as a society - why would you care how you're doing in relation to the lowest paid? Do you get some sort of ego boost from it?

Our wage essentially dictates our quality of life. Why would I think myself entitled to a better quality of life than a care worker or a supermarket worker just because I went to uni?

What we should be doing is focusing our energy on the people at the top who are exploiting workers and not paying taxes.

This ..absolutely everyone deserves a decent pay and to have a decent quality of life. Many people have a really strong work ethic but are not rewarded because they had a poor education….it actually massively upsets me !! I work with care workers and they work 12 hours a day,get up at 530 ,do their LFT ,walk to work because they cannot afford bus/ taxi and then work 12 hours..if they are lucky someone gives them a lift home..otherwise they have another long walk home !
PizzaCrust · 26/10/2021 00:12

@FluffyBooBoo

I do think the op is on to something with her mention of equal pay rises though.

Instead of (keeping this simple for ease) everyone getting 6%, so someone on £10 ph getting £10.60, and someone on £100 ph getting £106, everyone getting 60p per hour means the pay gap doesn't widen.

I'm not sure she actually meant she wanted an equal pay rise, however...

Definitely not. As mentioned numerous times now, having a degree is the only criteria on whether you deserve to be paid a fair wage or not.

I wonder what OPs opinion on apprenticeships are. It’s further training, but still not a coveted degree. It would probably not pass the “deserve to get fair pay” criteria in her book.

This thread is a huge eye opener. I’ve worked with some people who have little qualifications (our company actually pay for you to complete these while you work with us), and I’ve worked with people who were completing PhDs and needed a side income. In terms of their ability in work? Honestly, pretty similar across the board. If anything, at a push, I’d say the more “intelligent” workers were slightly less capable and sometimes lacked the quick “common sense” reaction that is needed in a busy retail environment.

A degree simply means you have an ability in that one sector. It doesn’t mean you’re a better or smarter person across the board. My dad is a farmer, for example. Obviously no degree and barely any qualifications. But is genuinely one of the smartest men I’ve ever met. He can fix anything. In most cases, can diagnose an animal with what is wrong before the vet even comes out (to confirm and prescribe medication/do surgery). Excellent business acumen. Unlimited knowledge on anything you’d ever need to know about the industry.

A teacher would walk onto a farm and unless they grew up on one, they wouldn’t know where to start. How to drive a tractor. How to calf a cow. When do animals get doses for fluke and worms? What types of liability insurance are needed? Doing all your farm paperwork and accounting. Honestly, it’s an endless list.

And we all know how little most farmers (I’m not talking about intensive/large scale operations) earn. Yet their job feeds the country.

The OP has it all wrong. Every profession has positives and minuses, and the negative traits of teaching are well documented. It’s exactly why I never wanted to go into that industry. A degree doesn’t make you any more worthy than anyone else.

mumwon · 26/10/2021 00:06

I have not read all through the read, mea culpa, but what is probably more concerning is the affect, not only to smaller individual private businesses (as mentioned child care) whose income is going to be stretched to breaking point, but also to organisations like the NHS, local councils workers etc etc
But maybe that's the point - another push to privatization
In years gone by the government use to subsidise lower paid which made them more economically viable not only within the UK but Internationally. If companies have to pay more, more will go to the wall. & more companies will leave the UK
UC is a way of decreasing pay to many who are low earners -this is a way of putting financial pressure on companies
What has been discussed here is pay differentials. With respect, with pay freezes there won't be any & someone who has hard won & earned skills, knowledge & responsibility should be recompensed for this?

TableFlowerss · 26/10/2021 00:06

@Wife2b

A lot of people up in arms on this thread. No one is saying that people don’t deserve to earn enough to live on. NMW goes up, prices go up but people working in skilled jobs etc won’t feel any benefit and if anything their money won’t stretch as far.

I have been a supermarket worker on NMW, yes it was tough, the public were awful, the hours were crap and general morale was low. Do I think it’s harder than my job now that I studied years at university for? Nope, not even close. Sure it was stressful, meeting tedious deadlines and being a human machine was stressful, but when the shift ended, it ended. Now in my current role, I get paid 36 hours per week, work with families a typical 7 unpaid hours a week (I can accrue TOIL that I never have time to take), and that’s not taking into account the hours I sit on my laptop at home on an evening or a weekend just to keep my head above water because the industry has gone to the dogs. I don’t begrudge anyone a decent wage, but unless everyone gets an increase it makes it feel like the pounds are worth so much less because the hours actually put in (as opposed to those paid) significantly reduces your hourly rate and it does make me wonder why I bother doing a job that I feel like I’ve sacrificed my soul to when I could take a pay cut for a job that is stressful but not that stressful.

Totally agree
Wife2b · 26/10/2021 00:01

A lot of people up in arms on this thread. No one is saying that people don’t deserve to earn enough to live on. NMW goes up, prices go up but people working in skilled jobs etc won’t feel any benefit and if anything their money won’t stretch as far.

I have been a supermarket worker on NMW, yes it was tough, the public were awful, the hours were crap and general morale was low. Do I think it’s harder than my job now that I studied years at university for? Nope, not even close. Sure it was stressful, meeting tedious deadlines and being a human machine was stressful, but when the shift ended, it ended. Now in my current role, I get paid 36 hours per week, work with families a typical 7 unpaid hours a week (I can accrue TOIL that I never have time to take), and that’s not taking into account the hours I sit on my laptop at home on an evening or a weekend just to keep my head above water because the industry has gone to the dogs. I don’t begrudge anyone a decent wage, but unless everyone gets an increase it makes it feel like the pounds are worth so much less because the hours actually put in (as opposed to those paid) significantly reduces your hourly rate and it does make me wonder why I bother doing a job that I feel like I’ve sacrificed my soul to when I could take a pay cut for a job that is stressful but not that stressful.

FluffyBooBoo · 25/10/2021 23:58

I do think the op is on to something with her mention of equal pay rises though.

Instead of (keeping this simple for ease) everyone getting 6%, so someone on £10 ph getting £10.60, and someone on £100 ph getting £106, everyone getting 60p per hour means the pay gap doesn't widen.

I'm not sure she actually meant she wanted an equal pay rise, however...