Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

So if the Minimum Wage increases...

488 replies

missbunnyrabbit · 25/10/2021 20:20

My own wage in a public sector job seems lower than ever. The article I read suggests the public sector pay freezes will end, but I doubt we'll get such a large pay rise!

Aibu to feel like packing my teacher job in to go and work a minimum wage job instead?

OP posts:
Salayes · 26/10/2021 07:48

@lomoloko

Wages are not and have never been a reward for hard work. It's a reflection of the added value you can bring to a market and the negotiating position you can take to get your percentage of that added value. That's why union jobs pay better than comparable non union jobs -- your negotiating position is stronger.

It's got nothing to do with effort. It's entirely to do with power.

If loads of teachers leave their jobs and take up shelf stacking at ASDA, the wages of teachers will probably rise, if their job is actually necessary and valuable. So I say go for it.

I am paid approxiimately 76 times what I 'earned' as a family carer. My job is, comparatively, an absolute doddle. Salary really has got nothing to do with effort, or virtue. It's just a measure of social power.

Same here. I earn loads more now than I did as a carer but no way is my job harder. It’s just more valued, that is to say, it’s valued fairly I would say, rather than being so undervalued by society with such bad conditions I had to leave as it was killing me.

Your arrogance to come and say this OP - especially when you’ve never been trapped long term (and no a couple of years around uni doesn’t count Hmm) into a NMW job where you’re treated like crap - and people like you sneer and hate the idea of it actually paying anywhere near like enough ( and this rise still isn’t enough to live on) - is astonishing. I wonder if you also resent people on benefits to top up these ridiculous NMwages too. Because in addition to all the other shit, there’s that stigma too.

I’m sad you’re teaching, I think you should leave if you’re this bitter and resentful. I certainly hope you’re not teaching my child with that attitude.

Whenthedealgoesdown · 26/10/2021 07:45

Not all minimum wage jobs are as described on here, many are wfh call centre type jobs and 9 to 5 office jobs, many office workers only earn minimum wage. They are not all manual labour, zero hour, shift workers

YouJustFoldItIn · 26/10/2021 07:38

My preschool is likely to close, I won’t be able to afford to pay the nursery staff any more money than I already do, unless the government increase the funding rates which I doubt they will. We barely survived last year. We won’t survive this increase.

I also run a preschool and we are in exactly the same position. With this and the staff shortages meaning we can't have enough children on the books to keep us afloat, our preschool is in real trouble.

So you both employ staff who have had to undergo lengthy training in ad vocational qualification to do what they do, and you pay them minimum wage?

stillcrazyafterall · 26/10/2021 07:27

Public sector workers usually understand that their sick pay, holidays and pensions are far better and that their ‘lower’ salaries reflect this.

This is very true, but there are limits! When the minimum wage goes up I will be less than £900 per year better off than someone doing the same hours in Tesco (other supermarkets are available) and I'm not the lowest CS grade! As a CS with 15 years experience that is ridiculous. I can't pay my rent with sick pay, holidays and pension. You know what I mean. In the department I work in they have cut the staff BY HALF over the last 5 years so I am literally doing 2 peoples jobs. Yet people still think we get final salary pensions (I never have). It is galling when people spout crap without a clue!

Badbadbunny · 26/10/2021 07:27

@Fetarabbit why on earth would anyone go to university for 3 years, work in a collapsing health system for hardly anything above minimum wage?

Someone in a NMW job will probably still be on NMW in 10/20 years time and ens up on minimal state pension upon retirement.

Hopefully someone who's been to uni will get a job with prospects and progression, probably earning far nore than NMW after a few years and likely to have a good pension with tax free lump sum on retirement.

You need to look at the long term big picture.

DockOTheBay · 26/10/2021 07:25

@Feelingoktoday

You really cannot compare the salary of a teacher to someone on minimum wage. Have you ever worked in a job with minimum wage? For a start a teacher works 39 weeks while minimum wage works 48 weeks - considerable difference even if teachers work in the holidays. Both are tough jobs but minimum wage jobs are sole destroying.

We need to increase wages so that tax credits can stop. It’s wrong that a couple can work but still need help from the state. All we are doing is funding shareholder dividends and company profits.

I've worked as a teacher and I've worked in a shop on MW. I can tell you working in the shop was FAR easier, FAR less stressful and FAR fewer hours.
BowtieBling · 26/10/2021 07:22

Over the years working in schools I've heard many teachers saying this.
"My job is so hard, I might as well work in ASDA/McDonalds/Amazon where I'd be less stressed" or envying/slating the playground assistants or cleaners.

Funnily enough though they never seem to actually quit and go stack shelves or clean somewhere because the kids love them so much and beg them to stay 🙄

I suspect like them the OP will moan like this for many years to come but will never seriously contemplate leaving.

It's like those in employment who look at unemployed or people with addictions and comment with what sounds like envy 'why don't I just quit my stressful paid job and sit at home watching daytime TV, they have a better life than me wah wah wah'

Waxonwaxoff0 · 26/10/2021 07:19

@Fetarabbit

Of course it will drive drive prices up, it will also exasperate shortages in some sectors already struggling to retain staff. Someone working full time on £9.50 and hour (plenty do, not everyone is part time) will have take home pay of just over £1.4k. Not far off what a newly qualified nurse makes. All of those jeering it's not a race to the bottom, no, or course not, but why on earth would anyone go to university for 3 years, work in a collapsing health system for hardly anything above minimum wage? If the tories were really arsed they'd cut the levies on energy, perhaps look into council tax rates etc. But no, they put the min wage up for a nice headline, which will force prices up which will then affect the poorest in society. Are benefits rising? I can guess...no.
I guess you'd have to weigh up the pros and cons of each. My mum works in NHS and I work in the private sector for £9.50ph. She only earns about £1 an hour more than I do, but she has benefits that I don't - job security (I was furloughed and my job was in danger in 2020), NHS pension, fully paid sick leave, more annual leave. You have to decide if that's worth it.
DGFB · 26/10/2021 07:08

You’d give up a teacher pension? Feel free but I think that will hit you hard in later life

DockOTheBay · 26/10/2021 07:03

@Freddiefox

My preschool is likely to close, I won’t be able to afford to pay the nursery staff any more money than I already do, unless the government increase the funding rates which I doubt they will. We barely survived last year. We won’t survive this increase.
I also run a preschool and we are in exactly the same position. With this and the staff shortages meaning we can't have enough children on the books to keep us afloat, our preschool is in real trouble.
Roselilly36 · 26/10/2021 07:03

This increase will put pressure on small businesses, and the increase in salary will be passed onto customers, so no real benefit. Inflation is rising. Gov just kicking the can down the road. It won’t affect big businesses, who hardly pay any corp tax in any case.

Teaching is a stressful job, one of my sons teachers left to became an interior designer, I don’t blame her at all, she was a lovely teacher and good at her job, but she wasn’t enjoying it, so what is the point. Life is too short to be unhappy in a job.

Fetarabbit · 26/10/2021 06:58

Of course it will drive drive prices up, it will also exasperate shortages in some sectors already struggling to retain staff. Someone working full time on £9.50 and hour (plenty do, not everyone is part time) will have take home pay of just over £1.4k. Not far off what a newly qualified nurse makes. All of those jeering it's not a race to the bottom, no, or course not, but why on earth would anyone go to university for 3 years, work in a collapsing health system for hardly anything above minimum wage? If the tories were really arsed they'd cut the levies on energy, perhaps look into council tax rates etc. But no, they put the min wage up for a nice headline, which will force prices up which will then affect the poorest in society. Are benefits rising? I can guess...no.

ivykaty44 · 26/10/2021 06:55

Have you ever been a teacher? 39 hours per week 🤣😂 my contracted hours were 40 per week. Then the marking, planning, events, parents evenings etc… during term time it was probably closer to 60 hours and then during the holidays it was expected that you’d run at least one day of catch up.

Have you worked split shifts in a hotel on minimum wage? You do late bar to, so may not get home till 2am but have got to be back in for 6:30am breakfast shift, work till 11am and back in for 4pm. Or you’d just start at 3pm and work through till 2 go home get some sleep till young family woke you at 7

Then the next week, no work and no money. The stress of that not easy and trying to work out how to rob Peter to pay Paul.

Minimum wages, terms and conditions need to change for the better and the lack of understanding of that shines through.

YouJustFoldItIn · 26/10/2021 06:51

Have you ever been a teacher? 39 hours per week 🤣😂 my contracted hours were 40 per week. Then the marking, planning, events, parents evenings etc… during term time it was probably closer to 60 hours and then during the holidays it was expected that you’d run at least one day of catch up.

True. But that is more than compensated for by the sheer amount of holiday you get. The job itself is full on while you are actually in school, but looked at across the whole year teachers don't work harder or longer than everybody else.

MimiDaisy11 · 26/10/2021 06:50

I really don’t want to argue with people who think the healthiest economy is one where we’re all scrapping by barely able to afford anything.

I will say that the most stressful jobs I’ve had were minimum wage jobs.

Testingprof · 26/10/2021 06:47

@Tilltheend99 teaching was unionised. Academisation has removed the ability for unions to create any real change. Some of the schools near me, refuse to acknowledge unions.

YouJustFoldItIn · 26/10/2021 06:45

I do think teachers really earn their money by the way, but there are plenty in the public sector who are just on an absolute gravy train and wouldn't last 2 minutes in the private sector.

yoyo1234 · 26/10/2021 06:44

YABU to begrudge a move to help those who maybe on zero hour contracts some increase in wage that may help with rising inflation. I am worried about eg childcare businesses if funding is not appropriately increased. It is not a race to the bottom. Those in public sector roles often have very good pensions, job security, sick leave etc as benefits.

Testingprof · 26/10/2021 06:44

@Feelingoktoday

You really cannot compare the salary of a teacher to someone on minimum wage. Have you ever worked in a job with minimum wage? For a start a teacher works 39 weeks while minimum wage works 48 weeks - considerable difference even if teachers work in the holidays. Both are tough jobs but minimum wage jobs are sole destroying.

We need to increase wages so that tax credits can stop. It’s wrong that a couple can work but still need help from the state. All we are doing is funding shareholder dividends and company profits.

Have you ever been a teacher? 39 hours per week 🤣😂 my contracted hours were 40 per week. Then the marking, planning, events, parents evenings etc… during term time it was probably closer to 60 hours and then during the holidays it was expected that you’d run at least one day of catch up.
nanabow · 26/10/2021 06:43

@Willow231

I work in a nursery. I am responsible for making sure a room full of toddlers are happy, cared for, have stimulating activities, have nutritious food to eat, have clean nappies, sleeps etc. Have been to college to earn my childcare qualifications, first aid, food hygiene and child protection trained. I do observations and write up reports for the parents on how their child is progressing. This just a small list of what is expected if me, and doesn't include all the demands and stress from those higher up.

I earn £8.91an hour. I feel thoroughly depressed that there are people who think I don't deserve any more than this because I am 'unskilled'.

You deserve so much more.

If anything you deserve to be on a package close to, if not the same, as teachers. Looking after and helping pre schoolers develop is REALLY important, tough and very skilled work.

Problem is funding. I already pay £65 a day, I can't afford more. If prices went up I'd have to pull my children out as fees would be higher than my salary. But despite all the noise we make the government won't give more funding.

YouJustFoldItIn · 26/10/2021 06:42

My own wage in a public sector job seems lower than ever.

What is it exactly? And how long have you been teaching?

Tilltheend99 · 26/10/2021 06:40

@garlictwist

Minimum wage has increased massively beyond the rate of inflation. Increasing it so quickly drives up the cost of living and threatens the viability of smaller employers. It's not a silver bullet.
If it has gone up massively above inflation then it would be the same as the living wage wouldn’t it? i.e. enough to live on!

The minimum wage is not some benefit that you are kindly bestowing upon your workers. They are earning it through work.

Employers like you disgust me. And with such a low grasp of basic economic concepts I’m surprised you are able to run a business at all.

motherrunner · 26/10/2021 06:38

OP, if you’re going to stick it out in teaching you need to forget about the money.

I’ve been teaching 22 years. My first salary was just under 15k and I will have suffered much longer than you under pay freezes. I’m now at the top of pay scale but my salary won’t increase as I don’t want TLR (before children I did but dropped it after my second child). This isn’t a ‘woe is me’ post, my point is there is OPPORTUNITY to increase your salary in teaching. I could apply for TLRs now but I don’t want the added responsibility. Those on NMW haven’t the opportunity to increase their salary, unless they want more hours and often the hours aren’t there.

Teaching is tough and at tired times (like end of half term!) I think ‘why?’ but doesn’t everyone feel this way about their jobs when they’re tired and over worked?

Tbh, as a teacher I’m more depressed about Covid working conditions rather than a NMW worker getting a few pence more (which will no doubt be eaten up by higher taxes etc elsewhere).

YouJustFoldItIn · 26/10/2021 06:38

Aibu to feel like packing my teacher job in to go and work a minimum wage job instead?

Yes. Go ahead and try it, with it's lack of security, often backbreaking physically exhausting work and unpleasant sometimes dangerous conditions, nowhere near as much time off as you get, no pension, only statutory sick pay, often no union protection, very little chance for career progression and no government schemes recognising your key worker status to subsidise you to get onto the housing ladder.

Then you'll soon realise how lucky you people with in the public sector really are, even if you think you should be worth more in terms of actual salary.

ivykaty44 · 26/10/2021 06:33

Lazy, greedy, selfish Britain. God I’m ashamed. No wonder the Tories are in power, we deserve them don’t we

We do get the government we deserve

If we’re not happy with wages, don’t stop those at the bottom having an increase. Concentrate efforts to achieve your own increase

Prices for goods are increasing as inflation is rising now

Interest rates also set to rise. This is going to add £200 to the monthly bill for an average home and without wage increases people will get into debt