Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

So if the Minimum Wage increases...

488 replies

missbunnyrabbit · 25/10/2021 20:20

My own wage in a public sector job seems lower than ever. The article I read suggests the public sector pay freezes will end, but I doubt we'll get such a large pay rise!

Aibu to feel like packing my teacher job in to go and work a minimum wage job instead?

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
Feelingoktoday · 01/11/2021 13:41

I worked for a well know high street shop. I worked in the stock room, emptying the boxes from the lorry, scanning, putting on coat hangers, putting security tags on, price labels and hanging up ready to go onto the shop floor. I had a target of 60 items an hour. I was ok as I was full time. But I felt sorry for the students and Saturday kids who also had this target and were told how many hours they owed the shop if they worked slower than than. It was hard work, 100% concentration all the time, no coffee breaks, or chit chat. On my feet for 8 hours with 30 mins unpaid lunch. It was like being in a factory on a conveyor belt and no way can be compared to my role now. If you think it’s easier than teaching then feel free to join up.

Rosebel · 30/10/2021 10:35

Retail work is harder than it used to be. I did it in my 20s while I was at college and I really enjoyed it. There was so little pressure.
Left for several years and went back to a different supermarket 3 years ago. It's like hell on earth. High targets, no support, constant abuse from customers including physical abuse, having teachers look down on you and thinking you deserve a shit wage.
Everyone knows teachers work hard but so do nursery staff, most of whom are on minimum wage. We do 9 to 10 hour days with the children and then around 6o clock (unless we have a staff meeting) we go home to another 3 hours or more of paper work.
So I understand to a certain extent that teachers work hard but they really aren't the only ones.

Pidgylou · 29/10/2021 20:27

Oooooh you have a degree. Well pardon me all over the place!!! You sound either very young or very entitled or both. And a little spoiled. I'd actually rest easier knowing you're not influencing children's minds and instead working in a warehouse stacking shelves or in a shop as a checkout chick. And then you won't have to pay back your student loan its win/win.
I was kind of on your side until I read some of your other posts and answers. You need to grow-up. There is a place for everyone in the world and a job one person couldn't do another will thrive at. Whether a job is 'harder' than another is pure perception.

Pidgylou · 29/10/2021 20:12

Surely working for minimum wage would be a huge decrease from what you earn on a teachers salary.
Also if you have children then the childcare issue would be a huge consideration.
Maybe though it's more that you'd like to find a job that makes you happier. My DH was once a teacher and it stressed him to the point of near breakdown.
I've always worked min wage jobs. It's pants money wise

Also no sick pay and just 4 weeks holiday. I also work weekends and bank holidays
I obviously don't know your financial situation but even with the min wage increase I am shocked if I'd now be making more than a teacher ??

GenderApostatemk2 · 29/10/2021 17:03

I saw a thick as mince woman on the local news last night saying ‘if the minimum wage is going up then it’s not fair on everyone else’ 🙄
Thatcher got her wish , there really is no such thing as society any more.

ivykaty44 · 28/10/2021 19:37

No I haven’t but then as a bar manager are you expected to run trips with no extra pay… just because teachers have a ‘secure’ job does not mean a zero hours job is more stressful. There are different stresses, I have never argued that one was more or less stressful but was challenging the poster who decided that teachers only work 39 hours a week.

you were arguing that one is harder than the other - you started your post that way

the bar 'manager' will be working a 70 hour week and on a salary for 40 I doubt he take punters on trip, but they'll be Vaseline on the cistern just in case. The bar staff will be on zero hours contract

Testingprof · 28/10/2021 17:37

@ivykaty44

Have you ever been a teacher? 39 hours per week 🤣😂 my contracted hours were 40 per week. *Then the marking, planning, events, parents evenings etc… during term time it was probably closer to 60 hours and then during the holidays it was expected that you’d run at least one day of catch up.*

Have you worked split shifts in a hotel on minimum wage? You do late bar to, so may not get home till 2am but have got to be back in for 6:30am breakfast shift, work till 11am and back in for 4pm. Or you’d just start at 3pm and work through till 2 go home get some sleep till young family woke you at 7

Then the next week, no work and no money. The stress of that not easy and trying to work out how to rob Peter to pay Paul.

Minimum wages, terms and conditions need to change for the better and the lack of understanding of that shines through.

No I haven’t but then as a bar manager are you expected to run trips with no extra pay… just because teachers have a ‘secure’ job does not mean a zero hours job is more stressful. There are different stresses, I have never argued that one was more or less stressful but was challenging the poster who decided that teachers only work 39 hours a week.

@YouJustFoldItIn - as only 6 weeks of the holiday is paid leave but I was still expected to run extra classes during those holidays and also mark controlled assessments. There is a reason why teachers are leaving the profession. Im no longer a teacher for a reason, it’s not as child friendly a job as people think and also the expectations were mounting up with little time to complete the job in the contracted hours.

wertheppl · 28/10/2021 15:41

I've worked in public sector for 6 years and the biggest pay rise I've had was last yr or yr before at 1.5% but mainly it's been 0.5-1%. Absolutely shocking. If it wasn't for the flexibility and part time hrs I do I wld have been away yrs ago! I know they will be bringing in new recruits on a higher salary than me which seriously annoys me there is nothing for loyalty! I cld get thousands more elsewhere but wouldn't get part time 🙁

Maverickess · 28/10/2021 11:39

It's an extra £94 a month for someone on nmw at 40 hours. Before tax and NI and pensions contribution.
It's to try and bridge the gap between the already happening and forecast price rises of survival, not living, survival.
For many it's going to be swapping a few quid in benefits for a few more quid earned, but not actually result in an increase in income for that person. So it's going to reduce the welfare bill a bit. It's going to reduce what's paid out in tax credits and UC to working people and the employers who are running their business are going to have to pay a bit more like the real cost as the government will be bridging less of the gap between wages and the cost of living.
A lot of people aren't actually going to be better off financially with this, and those that are it's going to go straight back out into the economy on increased costs, and still not show a real improvement in income or lifestyle.

Yet people who won't be in danger of going under with the price increases happening aren't happy about it because they don't feel their hard work is valued enough if people earn nearer to what they do. They feel like it's not worth it and they should get paid more.
Well welcome to our world! We're the people who've been told that we just don't try hard enough, are lazy and uninspired and if we want to be paid more we should do something about it, well to those people - here's your advice straight back to you, go work a bit harder, be a bit more inspired and get yourself a better job if you want more money, maybe you're not worth as much as you think you are!

CallMeNutribullet · 28/10/2021 00:17

Your friend who's a manager in Spoons is probably earning comparatively less than his hourly paid staff by the time he puts in his 60 hour week on a shite salary, working every weekend, constantly on his feet, dealing with drunk arseholes.
I know, I've been a Duty Manager in Spoons and nearly had a breakdown.
Yes it can work. My brother manages his own McDonalds branch now after working there since school. Hes on a decent salary and has a company car. It only took him 20 years mind you and you'll STILL probably out earn him in a few years as a teacher.
Like I say op, if you think it's the better choice for you, quit teaching, get yourself a full time bar or supermarket or factory job and enjoy the stress free minimum wage life. Hope you don't want kids though, because people just like you will come along to tell you that you shouldn't have kids if you can't afford them

C8H10N4O2 · 27/10/2021 23:13

A few points to mention ...
I have done a couple of minimum wage jobs, as have people I know, and they are easy compared to a lot of professional jobs

Priceless. Your temporary stints of casual work don't compare with trying to live a life and raise a family on zero hours contract, sod all pension and no security or progression.

You don't know what stress is. Still, at 27 you could turn out just to be a late developer and eventually grow up.

Ddot · 27/10/2021 20:08

Lowest rent here NE is around £500 but that is for a small house or flat but that price is hard to find. Then you have council tax which is around £120 lowest. Food, insurance, travel cost, gas, electric, internet, phone, by the time those have been paid what's left! Not bloody much if any. Depressing

BoredZelda · 27/10/2021 18:46

The issue is that you have a worker earning min wage and a supervisor earning min wage plus 50p. So as soon as min wage goes up by 50p the supervisor says “well I’m not doing the extra work of being a supervisor if I’m on the same wage as the worker underneath me who doesn’t have that responsibility”

No, the issue is, you are paying your supervisor only 50p an hour more than minimum wage.

SofiaMichelle · 27/10/2021 16:25

Whether NMW is 'doable' is surely completely dependent on where you live?

£9.50/hr for 40hrs is £1,425 net per month, without any CB.

Where we are you can rent a 2 bed apartment or cottage for £450-£500 per month.

So perhaps £1,000 per month (including CB) remaining after housing for a single parent and one child.

I'm sure it's nothing like that in many areas, of course - double the housing costs, etc. - but not out of the realms of possibility here.

SayNoToCarrots · 27/10/2021 15:48

Let's estimate that during term if you work 8-6 and then 4 hours each on Saturday and Sunday. That's 58hrs for 39 weeks (2262hrs). If you work for 2hrs each weekday for every holiday week that is another 130hrs.

You should technically also be paid for 28 days holiday. Let's say an average school day is 6hrs (9am to 3pm). That's another 168 hrs.

In total that is 2560hrs. If you were paid £9.50 an hr that would be £24,320.

Some teachers find themselves putting in more hours, and some are lucky enough to work less.

It's not beyond the realms of imagination that a teacher can work so many hours that their hourly rate drops below £9.50. At the top of the payscale though, you would have to be consistently working over 100 hours a week during term time.

drpaddington · 27/10/2021 15:26

Totally agree with this!

So I think we all agree 40 hours should pay enough to live no matter the job you do.

We are really lucky that OH earns enough to keep us going. I can't work full time because childcare for 12 year olds with additional needs is non existent (and childcare for my NT 9 year old isn't sufficient here either!) but even if I did, my £9 per hour job certainly wouldn't be enough to survive on.

Ddot · 27/10/2021 15:20

So I think we all agree 40 hours should pay enough to live no matter the job you do. Good education and training should give you a better standard of living. The problem is their is always someone at the top screwing us all. Share the bloody wealth

Awalkintime · 27/10/2021 14:03

Cyw2018
Those hours are correct, mine sometimes tops 100 hours - this last year it was 100 hours ave each week. So yeah when you divide a teacher's salary by the amount of hours they put in, often it is below minimum wage.

HouseOfFire · 27/10/2021 14:01

@Toomanyradishes

People on national minimum wage frequently have to claim benefits to get by. Thats fucking outrageous, you shouldnt work 40 plus hours a week and still not earn enough to live. You want to be annoyed, be annoyed at the likes of amazon and tesco relying on the tax payers to pick up the bill so they dont have to pay their workers enough to live on, and instead can enjoy their enormous profits

If nurseries cant survive the pay increase they need to lobby the government for higher funding, not expect people to earn less than it costs to live

And if you honestly think you are worth a wage you can live on but someone else should claim benefits because they "just" work in tesco or for amazon then I hope you arent passing that attitude onto the children you teach, the whole country would grind to a halt without minimum wage workers, and none of us is any better than the other. Im quite happy to earn the same as someone in tesco despite my training etc, why the fuck not. Lets all bring each other up together instead of pushing people down just to stand on them to make yourselves feel that much taller

I'm just going to repeat this for the hard of understanding! People on national minimum wage frequently have to claim benefits to get by. Thats fucking outrageous, you shouldnt work 40 plus hours a week and still not earn enough to live.
ChristmasFluff · 27/10/2021 12:41

I do not begrudge the pay rise at all - and OP, hyou wanna jack it in, then do it. I already have.

Physiotherapist for 35 years - and during COVID I just thought -'fuck this for a game of soldiers' and packed it in.

I now work in online support - more hours, but no commute, and I get paid for every minute I work. I've had 3 promotions since May, and now earn more per hour than I did as a physio.That is how little my experience, training and knowledge was valued. [I worked for a charity, my wages were actually slightly higher than NHS, but a poorer pension]

The only person stopping you taking a minimum wage job is you, OP, so I don't get why the angst? At least you have the choice. It's unlikely someone on minimum wage can choose to be a teacher if they fancy it.

Ddot · 27/10/2021 11:35

What went wrong

Tommika · 27/10/2021 11:26

@NoDecentHandlesLeft

BBC is reporting as "living wage" going up? Is this minimum wage, or is it smoke and mirrors?
There are two - minimum wage and living wage

Minimum wage used to be less than the living wage figure, but was revised to be equal

Eg you could earn minimum wage, but wouldn’t be able to ‘live” only on your wage

They were aligned on the basis that minimum should not be less than is required to ‘live’

Gingerandlemont · 27/10/2021 11:10

Everyone is entitled to a living wage. But the more training you need for a job, the more you should earn in comparison.
I have no idea how anyone thinks society would work if everyone was paid the same

I don’t think anyone here is advocating full on communism. But under the current system society ISN’T working. You have people doing vital NMW jobs with no stable home relying on food banks to feed their families (in extreme cases).

I think many are disillusioned with the whole x years of training = x amount of money argument. Why should academic studying be the only way to define how much a job is worth financially? Why should someone who parties for three years at uni with a little bit of studying thrown in and does a years postgraduate degree be paid more than someone who does something vitally important to society, works tough and gruelling hours for a job that doesn’t require an academic qualification? Surely other factors should define financial worth eg how important a job is to society?

I would definitely support a proportion of taxes going to vitally important jobs (teachers included) to ensure the salary reflects the worth of the job to society.

OP I do sympathise because I know a really good teacher (outstanding ofsted reviews) who left because it was just too hard and not worth it. I think the teaching problem will only be rectified when enough teachers leave the profession. There will be a crisis and then higher wages will be offered to attract people back to the profession. Exactly like what is now happening with truck drivers who have been undervalued and badly treated for years.

LittleBearPad · 27/10/2021 10:46

Sooooo many completely ignorant and ill thought out claims on this thread. I honestly don't know where to start with all the points/corrections that need making.

Why don’t you try?

joles12 · 27/10/2021 10:43

I would think very carefully about the pension you would be giving up . As a teacher you have a defined benefit pension scheme which will give you a good income beyond your retirement based on your average wage as a teacher and length of employment. VERY FEW another jobs outside the public sector have this job. A minimum wage job would have no such benefit and you would be much worse off in retirement .

Swipe left for the next trending thread