Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To ask that people state age not school year when talking generally about children?

141 replies

clockover · 25/10/2021 19:28

Please?

It would make things much easier for those of us who don't instantly know what Y4 etc is. I know how to convert it but I just think on a thread where it's not school related, but definitely age related, giving the child's age would be more appropriate.

OP posts:
FrankButchersDickieBow · 25/10/2021 20:02

I agree OP and I have a daughter in year 8 who is nearly 13.

When I was I'm school, it was infants, juniors and seniors.

I found it very confusing when they brought this system in and found it quite american grade 1, grade 2 etc.

I don't think if I had kids or my kids had gone through school when infant, juniors etc., was in place, I wouldn't have a bloody clue about the years.

SheWoreYellow · 25/10/2021 20:02

@liveforsummer

"Year 4" is different in NI and would be called P4 in Scotland

Year 4 in Scotland is P3

It’s not even that simple

England reception is age 4 and they turn five
Scotland they start school in P1 age 4 years 6 months to 5 years six months, unless they have deferred, which is pretty common, and they could be a few months older.
It goes up to yr7 and then senior school starts with S1.

So someone talking about yr 9 isn’t going to be easily convertible for a person used to the Scottish system.

Throwntothewolves · 25/10/2021 20:02

GraceLace that's a bit rude and ignorant. I'm in the UK (Scotland) but year 4 doesn't exist where I am. The equivalent year in Scotland is P5, but the age groups of the children aren't the same, so age really does make a difference.
I'd prefer people to just say the age of the child, everyone understands that no matter where they're from

etulosba · 25/10/2021 20:01

Surely we all remember what the school years mean from when we went to school ourselves?!

When I went to school, they didn’t have school years.

takenforgrantednana · 25/10/2021 19:59

@clockover

Please?

It would make things much easier for those of us who don't instantly know what Y4 etc is. I know how to convert it but I just think on a thread where it's not school related, but definitely age related, giving the child's age would be more appropriate.

totally agree with you, what year they go to secondary school i have no idea, but i know they go when aged 11! what happens if they have to repeat a year? are they still in year 6? 8? 10 whatever?
LittleBearPad · 25/10/2021 19:59

Just add 4 for the youngest age and 5 for the oldest. If you can’t be arsed to do both sums just add 5.

clockover · 25/10/2021 19:58

@CoronaPeroni

School threads - yr1 dd Non-school threads - dd(5)

Well yes, this is what I was asking.

OP posts:
clockover · 25/10/2021 19:58

@NautaOcts

I don’t recall any threads talking about DCs that use ‘year 5’ etc unless it’s to do with school? I think that would be a bit weird. Surely most commonly people say “Dd10 and ds8” or whatever

It definitely happens.

OP posts:
ImUninsultable · 25/10/2021 19:58

@GraceLace

England is not the only country in the UK.

I am in the UK. I dont know what age year 4 is. We dont call them year 4.

DappledThings · 25/10/2021 19:57

Surely we all remember what the school years mean from when we went to school ourselves?!
Not really. I would still have to work it out. If someone says Yr 5 I would have to go through the following mental steps:

  1. Year 7 is first year of secondary
  2. You turn 12 in first year of secondary
  3. So year 5 must be the year you turn 10
  4. Child must be 9 or 10. Or
  5. DS is in Yr 1.
  6. He turns 6 in this year
  7. 5/6 +4 = 9/10.

I don't have any innate sense that makes me instantly go Yr = age 9 or 10. It's just a waste of time making people figure that out.

TheUndeadLovelinessOfDemons · 25/10/2021 19:57

@careerchangeperhaps

It depends. An 11 year old in year 6 is very different to an 11 year old in year 7 in many contexts (being allowed out alone, pocket money, bedtime etc.)
It really isn't. They're still 11 and should be treated the same. I've had an 11yo in year 6 and will have an 11yo in year 7 next year and will treat him the same. Why wouldn't I?
liveforsummer · 25/10/2021 19:57

"Year 4" is different in NI and would be called P4 in Scotland

Year 4 in Scotland is P3

CoronaPeroni · 25/10/2021 19:57

School threads - yr1 dd
Non-school threads - dd(5)

User2638483 · 25/10/2021 19:56

So no, I don’t think it’s an unreasonable request just surprised it’s required as haven’t noticed it as an issue

DietrichandDiMaggio · 25/10/2021 19:56

@SachaStark2

I can’t get excited about people using year groups, instead of ages. It doesn’t take long to work out that Year 1 is 5-6, and Year 13 is 17-18.

Presumably most of us here went through this school system ourselves, if raised in England or Wales, and the Scottish system isn’t massively different, either. Surely we all remember what the school years mean from when we went to school ourselves?!

It depends how old you are. When I went to secondary school I went into 1st year, then 2nd, 3rd, 4th, 5th and then stayed on and went into sixth form. Strangely we still use sixth-form, even though it makes no sense now.
clockover · 25/10/2021 19:56

@careerchangeperhaps

It depends. An 11 year old in year 6 is very different to an 11 year old in year 7 in many contexts (being allowed out alone, pocket money, bedtime etc.)

That's an interesting point, although it must work both ways because giving a year would then mean they could be 10 or 11 / 11 or 12 - for me a starting point is age

OP posts:
Plotato · 25/10/2021 19:56

Yes and aside from the cut off, Y4 and P4 are different in that it's a Y4 child's fifth year in school whereas a Scottish P4 is in their fourth year. I find it hard to know instantly what, say, Y10 is because in Scotland you start again counting from one when you go to high school (so the year after P7 is known as either S1 or first year etc). I say this as someone who now teaches primary in England!

liveforsummer · 25/10/2021 19:55

@GraceLace

Well no. This is a parenting site where the majority of posters are in the UK or have a a UK connection for a start.

If you have a gap in your knowledge it's best to try and learn the school years and ages rather than everyone else adjusting the way they post.

It would probably only take about ten minutes and you would only need to learn about four and then you could use that to work our the rest.

Within the uk there are different school set ups Year 1 in England is different to primary 1 in Scotland. They often start at different ages. My daughter didn't start primary school til 5 and a half. Friends ds was 6 yet in England some start at 4 year and a few days. I do agree there are huge differences although if it's a specific schooling question the year will be relevant
NautaOcts · 25/10/2021 19:55

I don’t recall any threads talking about DCs that use ‘year 5’ etc unless it’s to do with school? I think that would be a bit weird. Surely most commonly people say “Dd10 and ds8” or whatever

Lougle · 25/10/2021 19:55

For example, DD2 is year 10, which makes her sound quite mature, but she's an August birthday, so she'll only just be 15 going into year 11.

Dojacatpaws · 25/10/2021 19:54

I agree

clockover · 25/10/2021 19:53

@DietrichandDiMaggio

I think it depends what the post is about, so if it's related to school people often need the year to answer more usefully.

I literally acknowledged that in the OP.

OP posts:
Lougle · 25/10/2021 19:53

It's interesting, though, because a year 5 child (9/10) will likely be treated differently than a year 6 child (10/11), even though they may b both be 10 at the time. There is a perceived maturity difference between 'almost going to secondary school' (young year 6 would still be 10 when they leave) and 'has another year in primary school' (old year 5 would be 10 part way through the year). So year group can make a difference.

clockover · 25/10/2021 19:53

@SachaStark2

I can’t get excited about people using year groups, instead of ages. It doesn’t take long to work out that Year 1 is 5-6, and Year 13 is 17-18.

Presumably most of us here went through this school system ourselves, if raised in England or Wales, and the Scottish system isn’t massively different, either. Surely we all remember what the school years mean from when we went to school ourselves?!

The point I was making is that the school years differ. So I don't instantly know what the English years are in age. I don't know why people would post a thread asking advice for something home related yet give a school year rather then an age. Even more puzzling is that people think this is a strange request!

OP posts:
RobinPenguins · 25/10/2021 19:52

@careerchangeperhaps

It depends. An 11 year old in year 6 is very different to an 11 year old in year 7 in many contexts (being allowed out alone, pocket money, bedtime etc.)
I agree with this, it’s often relevant and valid.
Swipe left for the next trending thread