Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To ask that people state age not school year when talking generally about children?

141 replies

clockover · 25/10/2021 19:28

Please?

It would make things much easier for those of us who don't instantly know what Y4 etc is. I know how to convert it but I just think on a thread where it's not school related, but definitely age related, giving the child's age would be more appropriate.

OP posts:
Thatsplentyjack · 25/10/2021 20:36

Yes! I have no idea why people do it. Jt makes no sense. If it's to do with school state their age and year if it makes you feel better, but year 4 means nothing to me, and no I won't look it up because I can't be arsed.

stingofthebutterfly · 25/10/2021 20:35

[quote SheWoreYellow]@stingofthebutterfly
No, what age Grin

Anyway. I googled. You’re thinking yr 11 is age 15, turning 16.

S4 at this time of year could be (rarely) just turned 16, lots of 15s and also could be 14s who don’t turn 15 until next February. So it’s not a massive issue, but there is a difference.

It means that the age of starting senior school can be different, which is relevant too. If you have an 11 yr old yr7 compared to an eleven yr old P7, one is in senior school and one in primary.[/quote]
The 1%... Hmm

liveforsummer · 25/10/2021 20:34

It’s shifted by six months. In England the cut off is 1st sept, rather than 1st March, so they start six months sooner.

Works for the school year equivalent though

It’s not even that simple

England reception is age 4 and they turn five
Scotland they start school in P1 age 4 years 6 months to 5 years six months, unless they have deferred, which is pretty common, and they could be a few months older.
It goes up to yr7 and then senior school starts with S1.

It's that simple to convert primary year groups both systems have 7 years of primary yR - y6 in England and p1 - p7 in Scotland. The stages are similar with a play based p1/yR and dc were being sent work from white rose maths during lockdown and p7 was getting y6 assignments P3 was getting y2. Once it's high school though I get lost. The year group comparison is where it ends though. You can't automatically guess an age from a Scottish year group. There is a couple of weeks short of 2 years between the oldest and youngest dc in DD's primary 4 class. Some will still be 7 for several months then as they turn 8 some will be preparing for their 10th birthday. I guess the age in y3 is far more predictable but everyone definitely can't know that

Medicaltextbook · 25/10/2021 20:34

I’m English but find the school years harder. I went through three tier system and in the middle is switched to R - 11/13. So I went from middle school (1-4) expected to go into Year 3 at high school (so that we would be taking exams in 5th year the same as where schools moved at 11). I actually went into year 9. GCSEs inn10 and 11. Continued into Alevels at the same school which was not 12 and 13, stayed 6th form for some reason.

Also have England centric view to think you can just add simply - how easy would most English users find if Scottish MNetters used school years on all threads rather than age? (I don’t know the NI or Welsh systems but could equally be hard).

daisypond · 25/10/2021 20:34

@SachaStark2

I can’t get excited about people using year groups, instead of ages. It doesn’t take long to work out that Year 1 is 5-6, and Year 13 is 17-18.

Presumably most of us here went through this school system ourselves, if raised in England or Wales, and the Scottish system isn’t massively different, either. Surely we all remember what the school years mean from when we went to school ourselves?!

I am in the U.K., have children who went through the school system, but the school years mean completely different things compared to when I was at school - a normal state comprehensive. Eg, modern Year 8 is Year 2 to me. Year 11 is Year 5. Year 13 is Upper 6th.
Ohsofedupwiththis · 25/10/2021 20:33

I always have to translate for my mum.

I can cope with English primary ages but don't have a clue when it comes to high schools- need to learn soon as my DD is Y5 ha ha.

Y4 is P5 in Scotland.

My DD is y5 but many would automatically assume she was Y6 because of her current age.

She would be P6 in Scotland.

Some of her classmates are 6 + months younger.

They are Y5 but would be P5 in Scotland.

And I think she may actually have an extra year in English schools? Really need to work that one out.

Legoisthebest · 25/10/2021 20:33

It's even more confusing if you grew up reading Enid Blyton and the O'Sullivan twins were in the 1st Form despite being age 14 going on 15 Grin

clockover · 25/10/2021 20:33

So based on that I think that getting them to refer to age instead school year because it's more convenient for you has roughly a snowball's chance in hell.

Oh. Right. Ok then.

OP posts:
Oblomov21 · 25/10/2021 20:33

I often refer to year 7 or year 12 or whatever. It feels less exposing and slightly less outing.

I don't want to type what age my children are all the time. If feels too revealing. Yes I know people will know when I mention school year but if just feels a bit more hidden.

ZingDramaQueenOfSheeba · 25/10/2021 20:32

you can ask
but people will use what is more convenient for them

I always smile when people misuse the shorthand for age and type "DD22" instead of "DD (22)".
I mean unless you have 22 daughters and you are talking about the youngest one...🤣

I've had my fair share of people being confused when I was correctly saying something like "DC6 is about to start nursery" because they thought the 6 meant age.
No, people, the number after DS, DD, DC means which number of child.
so DD4 is 4th daughter, DC3 is 3rd child etc.

Honestly, it's all explained in the abbreviations/acronyms section yet people don't always use it correctly.
So based on that I think that getting them to refer to age instead school year because it's more convenient for you has roughly a snowball's chance in hell.

clockover · 25/10/2021 20:32

@GertrudePerkinsPaperyThing

Yes because Scottish school years are different

However sometimes it’s the school year you need re homework or whatever so it depends

I was asking about when it's not school related.

OP posts:
SheWoreYellow · 25/10/2021 20:31

@stingofthebutterfly
No, what age Grin

Anyway. I googled. You’re thinking yr 11 is age 15, turning 16.

S4 at this time of year could be (rarely) just turned 16, lots of 15s and also could be 14s who don’t turn 15 until next February. So it’s not a massive issue, but there is a difference.

It means that the age of starting senior school can be different, which is relevant too. If you have an 11 yr old yr7 compared to an eleven yr old P7, one is in senior school and one in primary.

GertrudePerkinsPaperyThing · 25/10/2021 20:30

Yes because Scottish school years are different

However sometimes it’s the school year you need re homework or whatever so it depends

TheyWentToSeaInASieve · 25/10/2021 20:30

More and more people home educate. We attend music school, which has its own year system. My friend has asked to hold back her August-born by a year. School years shouldn't define you.

SylvanasWindrunner · 25/10/2021 20:29

[quote stingofthebutterfly]@SylvanasWindrunner which is exactly what people can do if they don't know the equivalent of year 7 is and it is bothering them enough to matter to them. Takes seconds.[/quote]
But it's general good manners when posting somewhere with a diverse user base to make it easy for people to understand.

It doesn't bother me, I won't waste time searching for stuff, I'll just move on to another thread. But if people are posting asking for advice or help then don't make people responding do more work than they have to 🤷‍♀️

giggly · 25/10/2021 20:29

Quite rightly GraceLace got her arse served on a plate for coming over all English on a UK site

AosSi · 25/10/2021 20:28

Yanbu OP. Of course, if they're talking about the y2 curriculum then refer to y2. For anything else though it's just confusing. Or even include both age and year to cover both bases!

Perhaps I will start posting about Senior Infants or Transition Year and expect posters to know what age group that is...

Ohsofedupwiththis · 25/10/2021 20:26

@Legoisthebest

Grace This may be a UK site but the UK consists of England, Wales, Northern Ireland and Scotland. Scotland and Northern Ireland label their school years differently. "Year 4" is different in NI and would be called P4 in Scotland but their cut off ages are different so I don't think the age group is completely the same.
Y4 is P5 in Scotland.
clockover · 25/10/2021 20:26

@DeepaBeesKit

Sometimes its very relevant to the context. Eg say its October time and someone is posting something about school curriculum and they say their child is 7.

7 could be year 2 old in year or year 3, younger. One is key stage 1, the other is key stage 2, so the school year group is more relevant than the age.

I understand it's relevant in the context of school, but I was asking outwith school related content.

OP posts:
stingofthebutterfly · 25/10/2021 20:25

@SylvanasWindrunner which is exactly what people can do if they don't know the equivalent of year 7 is and it is bothering them enough to matter to them. Takes seconds.

HarlanPepper · 25/10/2021 20:25

"Well no. This is a parenting site where the majority of posters are in the UK or have a a UK connection for a start."

England ≠ the UK. Thanks for coming to my TED Talk.

SheWoreYellow · 25/10/2021 20:25

“ satci

liveforsummer
"Year 4" is different in NI and would be called P4 in Scotland

Year 4 in Scotland is P3

Isn't it p5?”

It’s neither.
P1 sits between reception and Yr1
So P2 is between Yr1 and yr2

Yr 4 could be p4 or p5.

DeepaBeesKit · 25/10/2021 20:24

Sometimes its very relevant to the context. Eg say its October time and someone is posting something about school curriculum and they say their child is 7.

7 could be year 2 old in year or year 3, younger. One is key stage 1, the other is key stage 2, so the school year group is more relevant than the age.

TheNoodlesIncident · 25/10/2021 20:23

It would be a lot simpler to just include both facts, surely that would cover all bases? Eg my DS (13) is in Year 9, he has an August birthday so will always be 13 throughout the entire school year blah blah.

I would perhaps mention that he is in Y9 because that means he is not expected to be considering what subjects he will do for GCSE, or similar relevant thing, but I wouldn't state what year he was in and not his age at all.

I do agree with OP that clarity is important, although some posters will still ask how old the child is even if you put it in the title as well as the opening post...

stingofthebutterfly · 25/10/2021 20:23

@SheWoreYellow

Ok *@stingofthebutterfly*

What age is an S4 child? Grin

Roughly year 11.
Swipe left for the next trending thread