Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To ask that people state age not school year when talking generally about children?

141 replies

clockover · 25/10/2021 19:28

Please?

It would make things much easier for those of us who don't instantly know what Y4 etc is. I know how to convert it but I just think on a thread where it's not school related, but definitely age related, giving the child's age would be more appropriate.

OP posts:
TellingTheTimeForTrumpton · 25/10/2021 22:01

Well, I'm still just about young enough to have done (hypothetically) have a youngster and not be completely au fait yet with the numbering system (and that leaves aside foster, adoptive and grandparents etc. who may be older again) and I absolutely did not go through school with the current England & Wales numbering system even though I was educated in the state sector. We had 2 x R, 1, 2, 3 (actually called Class 1 to Class 6) in the Infants (no I don't quite know how it was organised, I was an infant!), and then 2 x Class 1, 2, 3, 4 (with teacher's initials as suffix) in the Middle School. At High School (which we called it, we didn't really say secondary school in usual conversation) it was 2nd year through to 5th year plus Lower 6th and Upper 6th (no 1st year secondary, in order to keep us in line with neighbouring authorities that went up from Middle School a year earlier). So based on that, I wouldn't have the foggiest.

(Actually I am familiar with the R-Y13 system, but I'm disagreeing with the PP who said surely you came through the system yourself or something similar.)

I think it was a reasonable request, the OP wasn't making a demand but just asking and explaining why. We get a lot of great contributions from across the 4 'home nations' and internationally, and I think that adding the age or approx age in brackets would be useful where school year is relevant, or the main topic, or just age when it's not really.

One thing I find a little confusing is when people write, say, DD3 (for their their third daughter - or is that their third child?) but then other posters use DD3 for their daughter aged 3. Usually you can get it from the context eventually but it can make things harder to understand and reply to initially. But maybe that's just me? Confused

BogRollBOGOF · 25/10/2021 21:22

The year system introduced to England in the early 90s is a hell of a lot simpler than the range of regional variations that preceded it. Being born in the early 80s it's easier to convert to y2, y3 that didn't exist at that point rather than attempt to describe how I did two last years of infant school due to moving areas of different systems (then doing 3 years of juniors)

It's not that tricky to work out that some parts of the UK start yR, y1 onwards and some start from P1 with a slight difference of age distribution and greater age range.

If I talk about leaving my 10yo alone, it is relevant that he is y6 (P7 equivilent). He's being gradually prepared for the independence that is expected for secondary transition and is nearly 11. Quite different to a just-turned 10yo in y5. I could avoid all doubt and say he's 130 months old, but I know that really will blow MN's sensibilities Grin

iwishiwasafish · 25/10/2021 21:12

YADDDDDDDDDDDNBU

WeBuiltThisBuffetOnSausageRoll · 25/10/2021 21:10

I'm English, went to school in England and have a child at school in England - and I still have to stop and think. If somebody tells me about their 6yo child, I instantly know how old that child is - anywhere in the world!

I also get confused by the DD3 etc. thing: even if there is a 'correct' way of rendering it in the MN 'rules', enough people use both to mean either age or birth position that you just cannot know. Anything over about 7, you can have a very good guess that it's probably their age, but the lower numbers can be anybody's guess.

The birth order of a child is often completely irrelevant - e.g. "My Son hit me today" - so completely immaterial how many older or younger siblings he might have; but people will still refer to him as 'DS2'. If your 2yo son slapped you during a frustrated toddler tantrum, that's a completely different scenario in terms of seriousness from if your second son, aged 17, physically assaulted you when you refused to let him stay out until the early hours.

Whilst we're at it, can somebody please also start a campaign for shoe sizes in the UK to start at number one for a baby/tiny toddler's first pair and then keep on going right up to the top, beyond what Mark Labett's big brother might wear?! So much pointless checking and uncertainty when you order online from the kids' section and select a child's size 2 shoes - to reassure yourself that they are indeed going to send shoes for a primary school child and not for a tiny one. Who on earth ever decided that we needed to reach an arbitrary size number and then just start again?!

littleburn · 25/10/2021 21:03

@SachaStark2

I can’t get excited about people using year groups, instead of ages. It doesn’t take long to work out that Year 1 is 5-6, and Year 13 is 17-18.

Presumably most of us here went through this school system ourselves, if raised in England or Wales, and the Scottish system isn’t massively different, either. Surely we all remember what the school years mean from when we went to school ourselves?!

Well I'm mid 40s and went through the English school system and the current year system didn't exist until a few years after I left school! Back then it was 1st year juniors, 1st year seniors etc.

My DS is in year 3, which in my head is 1st year juniors. If someone says 'year 8' I have to stop and work out if it's primary or seniors, let alone what year it translates to in 'old money'!

DumplingsAndStew · 25/10/2021 20:56

Didn't get beyond the first reply where @GraceLace showed herself up for the exact type of England-centric bullshit expected on Mumsnet.

OP I completely agree.

NeverDropYourMooncup · 25/10/2021 20:52

@SachaStark2

I can’t get excited about people using year groups, instead of ages. It doesn’t take long to work out that Year 1 is 5-6, and Year 13 is 17-18.

Presumably most of us here went through this school system ourselves, if raised in England or Wales, and the Scottish system isn’t massively different, either. Surely we all remember what the school years mean from when we went to school ourselves?!

You're assuming that everybody here is as young as you and knows the state sector (as not all private schools use it, either)

I know them due to a) having children and b) working in schools where it's used. And even on the computer software, it still lists the post 16 years as 6L and 6U, rather than Y12 and Y13.

ohnana · 25/10/2021 20:52

Oh and in NI some will just have turned 12 starting secondary school if born in July/August, but most will only be 11.

Lougle · 25/10/2021 20:52

@TheNoodlesIncident

It would be a lot simpler to just include both facts, surely that would cover all bases? Eg my DS (13) is in Year 9, he has an August birthday so will always be 13 throughout the entire school year blah blah.

I would perhaps mention that he is in Y9 because that means he is not expected to be considering what subjects he will do for GCSE, or similar relevant thing, but I wouldn't state what year he was in and not his age at all.

I do agree with OP that clarity is important, although some posters will still ask how old the child is even if you put it in the title as well as the opening post...

That again varies, though. Some schools do a 3 year KS4, so students pick their options in year 8 and start their GCSE course in year 9, with year 11 being a 'consolidation year'.
Legoisthebest · 25/10/2021 20:50

AnyOld yes I always thought it's funny how Americans refer to their children as "my third grader" or whatever.
In the American books by Beverly Clearly there is a scene where the character of Ramona is annoyed that adults keep asking her "what grade are you in now?" when it was the summer holidays. To her she had just finished a grade but yet to start the next one so she wasn't in any grade at all.
(Ramona is my favourite book character ever!!)

ohnana · 25/10/2021 20:50

Yes the cut offs are different too which probably confuses. In NI you start school (P1) in the September of the school year after their fourth birthday up before 1st July. So if they turn 4 on 30th June, they’ll start P1 that September.

You start secondary school as “Year 8” the September after you turn 11.

liveforsummer · 25/10/2021 20:47

@SheWoreYellow yes I know. I've been agreeing with the OP but I simply responded to the pp who said that P4 was year 4 which it isn't in terms of year group, which is the only way you can compare as you cannot compare the two systems by age at all.

AdelindSchade · 25/10/2021 20:46

I was nearly posting this myself tonight so thank you OP. Yes it is irritatingly England centric.

AnyOldPrion · 25/10/2021 20:45

Used to really bug me that people in the US would always refer to their school years in terms that left me utterly clueless about how old they were and now the habit has moved to the UK. Why anyone thinks school year is more important than age is beyond me.

clockover · 25/10/2021 20:44

Either way, one thread isn't going to suddenly change how people post

I was only asking. Tbh if the tables were turned I would absolutely take this on board. It makes no difference to the poster whether they say Y10 or the age of a child but you would think I was asking some people to donate a limb Hmm

OP posts:
Ohsofedupwiththis · 25/10/2021 20:44

“Works for the school year equivalent though”

It works for about 50% of the kids.

The other 50% would be in a different year group in England.

I much prefer the Scottish system.

Sexnotgender · 25/10/2021 20:42

Totally agree. I’m in Scotland and Y3 etc means absolutely nothing to me.

SheWoreYellow · 25/10/2021 20:42

@liveforsummer

*It’s neither. P1 sits between reception and Yr1 So P2 is between Yr1 and yr2*

In what way? Age maybe but even that isn't accurate with the messy in deferral in Scotland. P1 YR are bathe the first year of primary and they both ah e seven years. There isn't really any in betweens

Yes by age. The whole point of the thread is that people need to state the age of the child because you can’t just say the yeargroup name and be able to work it out.

We’re not talking about what maths they can do necessarily, we’re talking about ‘my yr 8 child is in trouble again for forgetting his water bottle’ ‘my yr 5 isn’t getting any play dates’ and for this we need to know their age.

SpookyPumpkinPants · 25/10/2021 20:42

@clockover

Honestly can't get over how rude that first reply was. I didn't think it was an unreasonable request either. There is no need to state what school year a child is in when talking about how much pocket money they get or what time they have to be at each evening.
Well, I disagree with that. Lots of things tend to be decided according to which year they're in. There are 'rights of passage' that come with various year groups snd it does spill over onto bed times and playing out & a bunch of other things.

It's really not complicated to add 4 to a 'Year' to know their age. It's much more useful to know if we're talking about a Y6 or a Y7 child when discussing the things you allow them to do or when they go to bed or even what they might like for christmas.

Either way, one thread isn't going to suddenly change how people post.

liveforsummer · 25/10/2021 20:41

@SheWoreYellow

I don’t really understand what you mean, liveforsummer by

“Works for the school year equivalent though”

My whole point is that if you are talking about, say yr2, you can’t convert the children to a p group as they could be P2 or p3, by age.

Because there are 7 years in both primary systems. The ages vary but they all do 7 years of formal schooling with the first (and sometimes 2nd in Scotland) year being play based and the last being the one before high school
liveforsummer · 25/10/2021 20:39

*leeway not messy. Not sure where that came from

SheWoreYellow · 25/10/2021 20:39

I don’t really understand what you mean, liveforsummer by

“Works for the school year equivalent though”

My whole point is that if you are talking about, say yr2, you can’t convert the children to a p group as they could be P2 or p3, by age.

liveforsummer · 25/10/2021 20:39

It’s neither.
P1 sits between reception and Yr1
So P2 is between Yr1 and yr2

In what way? Age maybe but even that isn't accurate with the messy in deferral in Scotland. P1 YR are bathe the first year of primary and they both ah e seven years. There isn't really any in betweens

ZingDramaQueenOfSheeba · 25/10/2021 20:36

btw I only know age/school year in England, but if you add 4 to Year Whatever then you get the age they are when they start that year in Sept.

so y10 is 14 year old turning 15

listsandbudgets · 25/10/2021 20:36

@sachastark2 I'm old.. when I was at school we didn't have these new fangled numbers. My primary school went 1, 2, 3 and middle school 1, 2, 3, 4 and senior school 3, 4 and 5 ( no years 1 and 2 because years 3 and 4 of middle school did that)

This new.system seems quite simple add 4.or 5 to year number to get approximate age of.child

Swipe left for the next trending thread