Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Was I wrong to touch her child?

446 replies

WhatDoYouDo1234 · 25/10/2021 19:08

At a famous London attraction today with my 4 year old. She was playing on one of the interactive exhibits. There was a long queue behind us. Another little girl about 3 kept running up and putting her hands on what my daughter was doing. Think an interactive drawing, so each time she touched it the screen cleared and my daughter’s drawing was lost. There was no parent anywhere near. First time I said gently “No, it’s not your turn, it’s this girl’s turn, you have to wait.” Or something to that effect. By the fifth or sixth time my daughter was getting increasingly cross, no matter how much I told her to be patient and try again, or how I tried to ask the other little girl to stop, and the kids behind us were getting cross too. I’m trying to prevent my daughter from loosing her cool. So I actually removed the girl’s hands and gently lifted her back saying “It’s not your turn. You have to wait.” A mum then came storming up shouting at me “Not to effing touch my child again!” To which I said something like “Well maybe if you were watching her you could have sorted it.” So my question is not if I was unreasonable, I probably was, but what do you do in that situation? With hindsight I’m thinking I should have called out for someone to come and get their child? But it was all quite quick! What would you do?!

OP posts:
Noni123 · 27/10/2021 01:14

@Pinkfluff76

Oh my goodness what the actual fuck is wrong with people in this country?? Firstly a 3 year old should not be running around on her own. Secondly a 3 year old should know by that age to queue and she could see everyone else queuing! Thirdly it’s ok for her to repeatedly touch your daughters hands, but some people think it’s not ok for you to touch this girl?? Fourthly I cannot actually believe the number of people who said they’d leave and come back… so you must q again and you’re teaching your child that the bully wins. And don’t get me started on the fucking rude entitled brat of a parent who is not only rude to you but doesn’t apologise, and funny how she suddenly appears when you touch her brat. What the fuck. I’m fuming for you and your daughter OP! Hope you still enjoyed your day out! Oh and who the hell was the person who said your daughter must stand up for herself? At age 4… really. She wouldn’t have to if 3 year old brats were actually being looked after by their parents!
Oh a person after my own heart! I just cannot believe the number of people suggesting to abandon what op & child were doing & get back in the queue-why oh why are we turning into a nation of wimps & what sort of example is being sent to young children!! We need to demonstrate that you stand up when something is wrong not cower away. The world is big & nasty & if all you ever do is teach them to be victims then that's what they will become.
TirednWorried · 27/10/2021 01:01

you shouldnt have let your dd have 6 goes at drawing a picture when there was a big queue. Don t you teach her to be quick when others are are waiting?

Tigerlilynuj · 27/10/2021 00:41

I think I would have distracted her and asked where her mummy (grown up) was and then brought her back saying that you thought she was a lost child.

SemynonA · 26/10/2021 23:37

Almost the entirety of abuse happens with adults the child (and the parents!) trusts...
The paranoia in this matter is extremely hurtful when we would all benefit from the awareness that the danger is within. And I know it first hand. Sadly, what is very improbable (a pedophile kidnapping a child) gets more media coverage than what happens everyday (the extra nice uncle who is free to abuse the child as the whole family trust him and the child won't say a thing since he loves his uncle).

lazystar · 26/10/2021 23:27

@benzo

The child shouldn't be left left unsupervised at all but she was like 3 or what? I would have gently moved my own child and avoided this battle after telling the child to wait for her turn etc and if it all failed just like your case. She's ruined the drawing many times, doesn't understand to take turns, doesn't know how to queue and doesn't understand what she is ruining and the impact it's doing. My almost 3 year old also wouldn't understand this either but I supervise him like a drone hovering and wouldn't allow him to do this but good for those parents who have commented that your 3 year old is mature and behaves like a civilised human and wouldn't dare to do such a thing. ever.

There's no point trying to reason or teach a 3 year old so I would have moved my own child if it was irritating him so much and told him we can come back when it's quieter. I hate the parents minefield as well and one thing that makes me physically sick is these situations and I try to avoid them and will supervise my son at all times to avoid any conflict. Also I wouldn't want my son to witness me being verbally abused as well that's why I pick my battles no matter how right I am because there's always some crazy person out there.

Op the parents were wrong throughout. You chose to stay to complete your drawing which there's nothing wrong about that either. I'm sure if your daughter had pushed the child, the parents would have still picked a fight with you it's just a case whether it's all worth it to ruin a day when it's meant to be fun.

Totally agree with this. Most people have accepted that the 4year old may lash out. Hardly anyone has acknowledged that the 3year old is still learning how to behave. Everyone has blamed the 'bad parent' in not parenting the 3year old, and a few have said they have other children also (ie May have taken their eye off a child in some situations), children on the spectrum etc I must congratulate those that have a 3year old that wouldn't be excited, understands the concept of queuing and waiting their turn and then had a strange person telling them something they didn't understand ie wait and then had their hands removed. That child was not at fault. Who knows what the parent was doing, they shouldn't have shouted at the OP. But it was definitely NOT the fault of either child.
Idontknowanymore1 · 26/10/2021 23:15

You done nothing wrong, you parented her when hers didn’t .. you didn’t harm her or were aggressive unlike her mothers reaction. They used to say it takes a village to raise a child we shouldn’t feel we can’t tell someone’s else’s kid off if they’re in the wrong . I just had to tell my neighbours kids to stop throwing water over the balcony and plastic bottles, the looked at me like I was mad but they stopped and I wouldn’t of expected his mum to challenge me only
Say “well you shouldn’t of been doing that should ya” … kids will be kids but they look to us to teach them right from wrong .

benzo · 26/10/2021 23:14

The child shouldn't be left left unsupervised at all but she was like 3 or what? I would have gently moved my own child and avoided this battle after telling the child to wait for her turn etc and if it all failed just like your case. She's ruined the drawing many times, doesn't understand to take turns, doesn't know how to queue and doesn't understand what she is ruining and the impact it's doing. My almost 3 year old also wouldn't understand this either but I supervise him like a drone hovering and wouldn't allow him to do this but good for those parents who have commented that your 3 year old is mature and behaves like a civilised human and wouldn't dare to do such a thing. ever.

There's no point trying to reason or teach a 3 year old so I would have moved my own child if it was irritating him so much and told him we can come back when it's quieter. I hate the parents minefield as well and one thing that makes me physically sick is these situations and I try to avoid them and will supervise my son at all times to avoid any conflict. Also I wouldn't want my son to witness me being verbally abused as well that's why I pick my battles no matter how right I am because there's always some crazy person out there.

Op the parents were wrong throughout. You chose to stay to complete your drawing which there's nothing wrong about that either. I'm sure if your daughter had pushed the child, the parents would have still picked a fight with you it's just a case whether it's all worth it to ruin a day when it's meant to be fun.

gofg · 26/10/2021 23:12

Good on you OP - you did nothing wrong. People who can't be bothered to supervise their children but scream when someone else steps in make me mad.

CateJW · 26/10/2021 23:11

@SemynonA I think the "dont touch other peoples kids" is sadly more to avoid being accused of anything, than to do with the adult interacting with the child.
The majority of parents i know wouldnt have a problem with a sensible grown up stopping their kids from causing harm or being harmed.
Sad sign of the times really (but also to protect children from the possibility of being abused, which society is much more aware of in current times)
Even as costume characters, in a job I did, we had strict rules to keep our hands in view in all pictures

nopuppiesallowed · 26/10/2021 23:03

It takes a village to raise a child...If the parent couldn't parent, you were just 'helping her out'. Well done, OP. Don't feel guilty. I wouldn't.

CateJW · 26/10/2021 22:54

as for @Dhcfisssifjrsnxfjds response...you can but laugh.

I have worked with kids for years (ages 3-18), am also studying psychology with modules in child development and have a four year old myself (who definitely would have decked the other child without intervention in this situation)
Children only start to get impulse control from 3...START to develop, they are around 7 or 8 before it will work consistently, older than than before it is fully developed.
Yes there is some truth to what you say, but certainly not in this scenario at this age, the can only learn it if supervised in the right responses through situations such as this one, when they start "telling tales" at around 7, you can let them work it for themselves a bit more.
Its a rare 4 year old that would have calmly discussed the situation and many would still lash out in frustration at that age!!

CateJW · 26/10/2021 22:42

I think reading it, I would totally say, call out the rubbish parents by drawing attention loudly to what their child is doing...is the best reaction.(easy for people to say what they would never do, when they are not the ones experiencing it in person) Though in the moment I dont think there was anything wrong with what you did!
If mum was watching well enough to see you move her little darling out of the way, then she would have seen her being a brat! (sorry, that should be - typical 3 yr old with crap guidance!)
I wouldn't stress about it OP.
People telling you to move your daughter on, just cos someone else was ruining her turn that she queued for need to give their head a wobble or grow a spine, seriously!
Did the mum say anything further??

StrawberrySquash · 26/10/2021 22:36

YANBU

Porcupineintherough · 26/10/2021 22:17

@SemynonA there is no implicit rule as you can see from this thread.

Bleachmycloths · 26/10/2021 22:10

This is typical behaviour of badly people: shouting and complaining in order to deflect from their own bad behaviour. In this case, poor parenting. You were right to tell her off.
Touching another child isn’t worth the risk, although I totally understand why you did it.

SemynonA · 26/10/2021 22:07

My 7 years old is non verbal autistic, so in term of managing challenging behaviour I'm well trained to many difficult situations.
Firstly, being French I was not aware of the rule to not touch a child. I spontaneously avoid doing so unless needed, but in conflictual situations I would have recourse to it as safeguarding the children and the enjoyment of the place for all of them by helping them interact peacefully and respectfully comes first for me than my discomfort of touching a child.
Even though I know first hand that touching can be triggering. But because of living it I also know how and when it is doable. I can 100% feel with some kids that physical contact would upset them / be unpleasant and then will avoid it at all costs.

If anyone could take the time of explaining to me the implicit rule about not touching children I would be much appreciative.

I would say that in the place of the mom I would find very difficult to try to find the parent / call for them as my focus stays on the children and I'm usually struggling much involving another task (looking for, strategizing...) when something requires already my vigilance and such situation would as it could cause a meltdown to my child.

wentworthinmate · 26/10/2021 21:52

I haven't read all the comments as there is so many but the other parent was negligent and rude and should have apologised not had a go.

MarvellousMonsters · 26/10/2021 21:39

Jeeze how precious are a lot of you? "I wouldn't touch someone's child!"

You asked the child nicely to stop. The child didn't stop. No parent stepped in to stop the child. It's perfectly reasonably of you to take action. You didn't hurt the child, you simply moved the child out the way. The mother can be quiet. Hmm

Pinkfluff76 · 26/10/2021 21:37

And I only read the first page of comments before posting…

Pinkfluff76 · 26/10/2021 21:36

Oh my goodness what the actual fuck is wrong with people in this country??
Firstly a 3 year old should not be running around on her own. Secondly a 3 year old should know by that age to queue and she could see everyone else queuing! Thirdly it’s ok for her to repeatedly touch your daughters hands, but some people think it’s not ok for you to touch this girl?? Fourthly I cannot actually believe the number of people who said they’d leave and come back… so you must q again and you’re teaching your child that the bully wins. And don’t get me started on the fucking rude entitled brat of a parent who is not only rude to you but doesn’t apologise, and funny how she suddenly appears when you touch her brat. What the fuck. I’m fuming for you and your daughter OP! Hope you still enjoyed your day out! Oh and who the hell was the person who said your daughter must stand up for herself? At age 4… really. She wouldn’t have to if 3 year old brats were actually being looked after by their parents!

23minutesfromTulseHill · 26/10/2021 21:36

Course you would, luv. 100%.

telvg · 26/10/2021 21:32

I would have invited the other child over, not pushed her away.

daddypoursthewine · 26/10/2021 21:31

what if you just spent flipping ages a bit of time typing a flipping genius interesting anecdotal answer and then somehow lost the whole thing logging in and you wanted to launch the laptop through the big telly and somehow blame the dog
just asking for a friend

Inastatus · 26/10/2021 21:07

@teatime9999

I wouldn't really mind if you did that with one of my kids tbh. With twins that age and a baby, I'm not always paying close attention to every kid. I'd actually feel worse about one of my kids had behaving that way that if you tried to move her. BUT you were a bit of a bitch when you told her off for not watching her child. Who knows what she was dealing with when it was going on. Anyway, it takes a village.
Nope, no excuse ever for not being able to watch your child. Your child, your responsibility - end of! If you take your eyes off then and someone else stands in then they are not a bitch for calling them out on it!
Liesovertheocean · 26/10/2021 20:23

YANBU

Maybe picking up the kid wasn’t the wisest move but with parents like that you’d have been in for earache no matter how you’d approached it.

When DS1 was 3 we were in a sports hall and he was running around with some little friends whilst we packed up. There was a bigger boy maybe 6 or 7 who was hanging around them and then ran between them and shoved my DS in the back knocking him to the floor. I immediately went over to pick my son up, and as I passed this boy I said firmly ‘that wasn’t very nice now was it?!’ The next thing I knew his Mother flew over, all expletives and fury, demanding to know how I dared speak to her child and I should have spoken to her not him if I had a f’ing problem. You simply can’t argue with stupid.