Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Telling my child to be quiet on holiday

214 replies

Ohhappydays123 · 25/10/2021 16:29

Name changed for this as it’s outing. On holiday - all inclusive family resort, nothing too fancy, very popular destination. My DC (4&9) went in the swim up pool around midday but the section by our room was in the shade so they moved round the corner to be in the sun. They were on the side playing with toys. After about 5-10 minutes, some ladies who were on sun loungers near them got up and I saw one say something to DC4 and put her finger to her lips.
They were walking out of the pool area and as they walked past me I said “sorry, are they too loud for you?” She said “yes, I told him. It’s like he has a speaker inside.” I apologised. And then cried.
My DC are loud. I spend half my life asking them to be quiet and reminding them that sometimes we need to be quiet out of respect for other people. I’m a considerate person and try so hard to make my DC behave in the same way. I’m hormonal, the whole holiday experience has been pretty stressful due to Covid and it just pushed me over the edge.
But later on I though that actually, was she right to tell my DC to be quiet? It’s a family resort FFS! It wasn’t very early or very late and they weren’t even being THAT loud. I always make sure I remind them when they are.
I’d never dream of telling a stranger’s children to be quiet in this situation.
AIBU to think she shouldn’t have said anything?

OP posts:
Twentypast · 25/10/2021 17:25

@PamsSpam

They were at a pool at a family resort and kids are loud there. If it was another situation/place then I might have agreed, but I think at a family pool, kids get overexcited and loud? I’m sorry you felt upset about it and cried and the speaker comment was utterly unnecessary. I think providing kids are quiet in the right situations then that’s fair enough. At a family resort by a kids pool I bet lots of children scream and squeak and shout all day long.
But it wasn't a famiy pool or children's pool. It was a swim up pool and they were outside the other women's room.
MrsTerryPratchett · 25/10/2021 17:21

@NotQuiteHere

Is there such a thing as "naturally loud children"? Being loud is usually a learned behaviour, it comes from a few sources. Mostly from school where they try to shout to be heard, but also from families where they do the same thing just because parents do not want to listen to them. And being loud can be unlearned, but an adult dealing with that type of behaviour (a teacher, a parent) should be persistent.
This is nonsense.

Of course some children are naturally loud. Mine was. Just as some are quiet leg-clingers. We've worked with her and she's actually quite quiet now. But children don't come as blank slates.

FlibbertyGiblets · 25/10/2021 17:21

Is the swim up lifeguarded?

Franklin12 · 25/10/2021 17:20

I think the women was correct. They moved because they wanted to be in the sun but didnt want to stop loudly chatting outside someone else's room. What if the women had someone who was sleeping?

How would you feel if outside your room at say midnight someone was talking very loudly and generally be an annoyance?

The fact that you say they are loud means for others they are very loud and probably rather annoying.

My SIL a few years ago insisted that her sleeping baby be allowed into an adults only restaurant. She was refused and promptly went in and asked the people eating (it wasnt a big place) whether they would mind.....

onceandneveragain · 25/10/2021 17:19

@PamsSpam

They were at a pool at a family resort and kids are loud there. If it was another situation/place then I might have agreed, but I think at a family pool, kids get overexcited and loud? I’m sorry you felt upset about it and cried and the speaker comment was utterly unnecessary. I think providing kids are quiet in the right situations then that’s fair enough. At a family resort by a kids pool I bet lots of children scream and squeak and shout all day long.
It wasn't by a kids pool though? OP actually said "There is a kids’ pool but we’ve paid for a swim up room and want to use it!." Google what a 'swim up' pool is. It was a separate semi-private pool, away from the kids or main pool, right outside the woman's own bedroom.
goldfinchfan · 25/10/2021 17:19

OP I dispair eading you justfying how loud your kidsa re and how you have taken it personally.

We all live on this planet WE all have had Covid to deal with.
Most of us have hormones, or difficult issues to deal with.
The lady asked your noisy kids to play quietly without upsetting them.
Nothing wrong there.
Your kids are not perfect being because NO-ONE is.
We all need some tolerance and also some consideration.

Let your kids learn to play happily without so much noise.
Watch other families and observe are all loud?

We need to learn to live together.

CheltenhamLady · 25/10/2021 17:18

[quote ImUninsultable]@CheltenhamLady

Yes. Another poster said that the other women should have moved and sat somewhere else. The poster you quote was replying to them, asking why should someone move from their own room. The children were outside their room, as in the room belonging to the other woman.

OP, you were wrong. With swim up pools, you do not play outside someone else's room. They've paid for that bit. Use your own swim up bit or go to the main, family pools.[/quote]
Ah right sorry, I misunderstood. The OP had stated the children had moved outside the woman's room. I agree the women shouldn't need to move.

ScribblingPixie · 25/10/2021 17:17

I think it's fine. The other woman sounds nice - what she said to you was actually quite humorous, it sounds non-judgemental to me. It's not like she asked you to keep them closer to you or said that the kids were behaving badly.

itsgettingwierd · 25/10/2021 17:17

I hate to sound very MN but can you do a diagram?

I've seen very many set ups with swim up rooms.

I think whether she was being unreasonable to shush them really depends on their position in relation to the ladies expectation of privacy based on the set up.

Swim up rooms I've seen if you are poolside not by your room then your in someone else's space. They all have steps from the balcony/patron into the pool which is shared directly from each room.

PinkSyCo · 25/10/2021 17:16

You shouldn’t have apologised to this woman at all if you feel your child wasn’t making that much noise.

onceandneveragain · 25/10/2021 17:16

@Ohhappydays123

Can I just add that they were not out of sight or far away from me. They’d just moved away from being directly outside our room. There is a kids’ pool but we’ve paid for a swim up room and want to use it! Nowhere on the information or rules for use does it say about age limits or being quiet. Just says hours for use (which we were within).
Oh come on, you can't just rely on 'the rules.' Some things aren't written down because they are just normal decent expected behaviour which shouldn't need clarifying. It probably doesn't say 'please don't urinate/defecate/have rampant sex/throw washing up liquid to make a bubblebath in the pool' in 'the rules' but that doesn't mean you can do it!
DGFB · 25/10/2021 17:16

Swim up pools are a little different if near rooms but no yanbu. If they don’t want noise, they shouldn’t book a family resort at half term!!

ArblemarchTFruitbat · 25/10/2021 17:11

Impossible to say without knowing how loud they were.

Talking/laughing = normal and expected. Shrieking/shouting (persistently) = unacceptable unless it's a designated children's pool or area.

People in a "family" resort need to be considerate of all ages - 'family' doesn't just = children.

Thehop · 25/10/2021 17:11

I don’t know about the hotel you’re in but when we’ve had swim you rooms before, you stay in the bit in front of your room. I’d have been a bit cheesed off if someone came and used “our bit” IYSWIM? Realise your set up may be different so apologies if so.

ImUninsultable · 25/10/2021 17:11

@CheltenhamLady

Yes. Another poster said that the other women should have moved and sat somewhere else. The poster you quote was replying to them, asking why should someone move from their own room. The children were outside their room, as in the room belonging to the other woman.

OP, you were wrong. With swim up pools, you do not play outside someone else's room. They've paid for that bit. Use your own swim up bit or go to the main, family pools.

TheFairyCaravan · 25/10/2021 17:10

@CheltenhamLady from the OP’s post at 16:42

they were outside her room

PamsSpam · 25/10/2021 17:08

They were at a pool at a family resort and kids are loud there. If it was another situation/place then I might have agreed, but I think at a family pool, kids get overexcited and loud? I’m sorry you felt upset about it and cried and the speaker comment was utterly unnecessary. I think providing kids are quiet in the right situations then that’s fair enough. At a family resort by a kids pool I bet lots of children scream and squeak and shout all day long.

SeasonFinale · 25/10/2021 17:08

The OP says hers kids are loud. Someone politely asked them to play more quietly. They didn't ask them to go away or worse they merely requested they play a it quieter which I assume they then did. Therefore it is somewhat of an overaction when by your own admission your noisy kids were asked politely to keep the noise down. It doesn't sound as they were aggressive to the kids or to you so I think it was a non issue. I have no problem asking kids to do the same or even telling them to stop doing something either dangerous or naughty. Indeed if they were round the corner she might have assumed there wasn't an adult around

NotQuiteHere · 25/10/2021 17:07

Is there such a thing as "naturally loud children"? Being loud is usually a learned behaviour, it comes from a few sources. Mostly from school where they try to shout to be heard, but also from families where they do the same thing just because parents do not want to listen to them. And being loud can be unlearned, but an adult dealing with that type of behaviour (a teacher, a parent) should be persistent.

onceandneveragain · 25/10/2021 17:07

Yeah I agree with others - if it was the main pool fair enough, but they were outside their room! Just because it's a family friendly holiday doesn't mean everyone wants lots of noise at all times. They could have their own (older or quieter kids) which mean they couldn't go to an adults only place. Or perhaps they just thought 'normal children playing noise, fine, we can always go to our room to get away from it all,' rather than 'incredibly loud noise and when we go to our room they follow us!'

Some kids are just much louder than others (whether naturally or because parents are less strict - or both), and yes, sorry, it's often annoying.

If she'd shouted at your kids and made them cry that might be a different story but it sounded as though she was as nice as she could be. And perhaps it might even help - kids often don't listen to mum but now another adult has told them they are too loud they might take it in a bit more?

TheYearOfSmallThings · 25/10/2021 17:07

I wouldn't worry about it, and I don't think there is any need for your tears. You say they are loud, and you asking them to keep it down has not proven effective...let this lady have a try.

CheltenhamLady · 25/10/2021 17:06

@TheFairyCaravan

They could have moved and sat elsewhere.

Why should they? The children were outside their room.

No, the poster says they were outside the other room where the woman was. They had moved from outside their room to remain in the sun.
DameMaureen · 25/10/2021 17:05

I think people need to google what a swim up room is. If I had kids yelling outside mine I would be pissed off too .

2021namechanger · 25/10/2021 17:04

@Artie30

Ignore. They shouldn't have booked a family resort if they don't like noise. I do get it op, my two are naturally loud too. I am constantly telling them to quieten down. I am sure they have annoyed people before but thankfully no ones told them to be quiet that I know of!

They could have moved and sat elsewhere. They could have spoke to you.

Why should they? At a main pool it’s a bit different, but kids being loud in the swim up outside your room is taking the piss a bit.
SnarkyBag · 25/10/2021 17:03

Rude to let them play outside someone else’s room especially when you already know you have loud kids. They’ve also paid for a swim up pool so reasonable to expect some space from others especially noisy children.

Family friendly resort doesn’t mean kids get priority to be as loud as they like.