Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Telling my child to be quiet on holiday

214 replies

Ohhappydays123 · 25/10/2021 16:29

Name changed for this as it’s outing. On holiday - all inclusive family resort, nothing too fancy, very popular destination. My DC (4&9) went in the swim up pool around midday but the section by our room was in the shade so they moved round the corner to be in the sun. They were on the side playing with toys. After about 5-10 minutes, some ladies who were on sun loungers near them got up and I saw one say something to DC4 and put her finger to her lips.
They were walking out of the pool area and as they walked past me I said “sorry, are they too loud for you?” She said “yes, I told him. It’s like he has a speaker inside.” I apologised. And then cried.
My DC are loud. I spend half my life asking them to be quiet and reminding them that sometimes we need to be quiet out of respect for other people. I’m a considerate person and try so hard to make my DC behave in the same way. I’m hormonal, the whole holiday experience has been pretty stressful due to Covid and it just pushed me over the edge.
But later on I though that actually, was she right to tell my DC to be quiet? It’s a family resort FFS! It wasn’t very early or very late and they weren’t even being THAT loud. I always make sure I remind them when they are.
I’d never dream of telling a stranger’s children to be quiet in this situation.
AIBU to think she shouldn’t have said anything?

OP posts:
Rosesareyellow · 25/10/2021 18:14

There's adult only resorts... its a hard one to judge as many people go to family resorts and moan about noise level. Look on tripadvisor there's tons

Adults only is much more expensive. Me and DH only did it for our honeymoon as a treat - if we could have afforded to we would have done it every time before we had DCs.

Alwayswantedasmegf · 25/10/2021 18:12

@LolaSmiles OP broached the woman first and said sorry! Then the woman went on to describe her child like a speaker.

OP apologised what more do you want? OP obviously felt bad after.

Flowersintheattic2021 · 25/10/2021 18:12

Post a pic of said pool

IslaPineappple · 25/10/2021 18:11

Nc fail I think OP.

Tsubasa1 · 25/10/2021 18:11

I don't know who is in the wrong or who is in the right here. To see a positive side to this, it might be a good thing that the lady spoke with your son. Maybe he will be quieter in thr future? Sometimes children listen to a telling off from strangers more so than when their parents tell them off. Sorry you are upset though OPFlowers

LolaSmiles · 25/10/2021 18:09

There's adult only resorts... its a hard one to judge as many people go to family resorts and moan about noise level. Look on tripadvisor there's tons

I don't mind families on holiday, especially given I'm on holiday with mine. I do mind excessive noise, families with no consideration for others, and families who think that life is a free for all to be as loud as they like.

The OP's children were outside someone else's room and were being loud. I would imagine the people who told OP's children to be quiet were quite happy knowing there were children on the resort, just didn't want someone else's kids playing loudly outside their room.

Mojoj · 25/10/2021 18:09

I would not have accepted this. It's a family resort where kids are allowed to have fun. And be loud. If the moaners had wanted peace, they should have chosen an adults only holiday.

babyinthacorner1 · 25/10/2021 18:08

This reply has been deleted

Message withdrawn at poster's request.

TonTonMacoute · 25/10/2021 18:08

*lesson

TonTonMacoute · 25/10/2021 18:07

It is perfectly acceptable to ask other people's children to be a bit quieter if they are just outside your room - family resort or not. It doesn't seem that she was nasty to them at all. How on earth is that rude!?

DCs often ignore parents' pleas, but if a stranger tells them off it often makes more of an impact on them and they might make a bit more effort. Use the experience to ram home the less they need to be bit more considerate sometimes.

OverTheRubicon · 25/10/2021 18:06

My kids are quite loud, one in particular, and I'm actually quite grateful if other people call them out on it - it helps to show them that I'm not lying/mistaken/old-fashioned when I say that it is rude to others around us.

Alwayswantedasmegf · 25/10/2021 18:05

@milkyaqua

She asked him to turn the volume down. That's not rude.
They were walking out of the pool area and as they walked past me I said “sorry, are they too loud for you?” She said “yes, I told him. It’s like he has a speaker inside.” I apologised.

OP maybe has over thought it. She has been courteous and it does sound like she would have spoken to her DC... the woman was rude

Ozanj · 25/10/2021 18:04

@toomuchlaundry

On a separate point should a 4 year old be unsupervised in a pool?
Definitely not.
CharityDingle · 25/10/2021 18:04

@2021namechanger

For those who don’t understand what a swim up pool is…
That's how I pictured it alright. I have never been to one.
toomuchlaundry · 25/10/2021 18:03

On a separate point should a 4 year old be unsupervised in a pool?

Ozanj · 25/10/2021 18:02

Tresspassing into your neighbours pool I mean.

CharityDingle · 25/10/2021 18:02

Some people, and I include adults in that appear to have no volume control. I was sitting in a lovely coffee shop recently, enjoying my coffee in the normal hustle and bustle of a busy coffee shop. Until two guys sat at the next table and one proceeded to yell at the other. Except this was obviously normal volume to him. Very very annoying. It wasn't as if they were conversing across a huge outdoor area, they were sitting at a small table, indoors.

There used to be a kid in my estate and when he was out playing, he could be heard all over the place. He could wake the dead, he was so darn loud. Thankfully they moved out.

OP, I have never been in a resort with a swim up pool, but I presume the idea is that you use yours, not the one outside someone else's room. The lady said it nicely, she wasn't mean about it. A lot of us are overwrought after the past eighteen months, and relieved to be getting our lives back at last, so that's probably why you took it to heart a little more than normal.
Keep them to your own area, they are old enough to understand that, and relax and enjoy your holiday.

Ozanj · 25/10/2021 18:02

@Ohhappydays123

Name changed for this as it’s outing. On holiday - all inclusive family resort, nothing too fancy, very popular destination. My DC (4&9) went in the swim up pool around midday but the section by our room was in the shade so they moved round the corner to be in the sun. They were on the side playing with toys. After about 5-10 minutes, some ladies who were on sun loungers near them got up and I saw one say something to DC4 and put her finger to her lips. They were walking out of the pool area and as they walked past me I said “sorry, are they too loud for you?” She said “yes, I told him. It’s like he has a speaker inside.” I apologised. And then cried. My DC are loud. I spend half my life asking them to be quiet and reminding them that sometimes we need to be quiet out of respect for other people. I’m a considerate person and try so hard to make my DC behave in the same way. I’m hormonal, the whole holiday experience has been pretty stressful due to Covid and it just pushed me over the edge. But later on I though that actually, was she right to tell my DC to be quiet? It’s a family resort FFS! It wasn’t very early or very late and they weren’t even being THAT loud. I always make sure I remind them when they are. I’d never dream of telling a stranger’s children to be quiet in this situation. AIBU to think she shouldn’t have said anything?
They were being loud in your neighbour’s bit of the pool. You’re lucky all they said was for them to be quieter - some resorts will kick you out for doing that.
5128gap · 25/10/2021 18:00

I don't think the woman was being unreasonable. Your children were encroaching into her space. Just because its a family resort doesn't mean people should expect no respite from noisy children. Even people with their own children want this at times, for children's naps and so on, and it's not unreasonable to want the swim up pool directly outside your room to be a bit quieter. Your children had options after all, play quietly where they were, or play noisily elsewhere. Unfortunately they couldn't have everything they wanted on that occasion without annoying someone else.

milkyaqua · 25/10/2021 17:59

She asked him to turn the volume down. That's not rude.

toomuchlaundry · 25/10/2021 17:59

If the pool is like that picture is it not then treated a bit like an extension to your patio, so you wouldn't be too impressed if a couple of children came up and played right outside your patio, when they had their own space to play. Also I would assume that is an area to relax/cool down. The main pool and the kids' pool is where children can go and be as noisy as they want

JumperandJacket · 25/10/2021 17:58

In a swim up pool your children should be by your room, not unsupervised by someone else's room. If they are exceptionally noisy on top of that, I'm not surprised the woman spoke to them- in fact, she sounds to have been very restrained!

Thethreecs · 25/10/2021 17:56

They were in the swim up part to HER room?

Then that's a big no, you don't go in that area of someone's room , it's an unwritten rule that you use your own and your own garden/deck. You can swim in the whole pool.

It's unfortunate that yours was shady, people request certain rooms when booking as they know where the sun will be. A bit like booking a room with pool view etc

If kids were loud outside my room like that, I'd shush them too. I know kids make noise but not right outside someone's room. This is why many choose rooms away from pools, walk ways etc.

2021namechanger · 25/10/2021 17:54

For those who don’t understand what a swim up pool is…

Telling my child to be quiet on holiday
LittleGwyneth · 25/10/2021 17:49

Is it advertised as a family resort or is it just a resort which permits children?

Generally speaking I think if your DC were making an enormous noise it was perfectly fine for her to ask, as long as she was polite about it.