Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To find DH’s view offensive?

270 replies

Peanutbutterkid08 · 25/10/2021 14:55

I was discussing with my teenage son about how misogyny was systemic in society and how white straight men have always held privilege. Ds doesn’t really agree with this, he thinks girls and women have an ‘easier time.’
I said just because NAMALT (🙄) doesn’t mean it’s enough for men to just sit back and say not my problem. In the same way I don’t believe it is enough to just not be racist - if you don’t speak up even if not racist yourself you are part of the problem.
DH said - in a sort of patronising and angry voice ‘didn’t realise you were such a feminist sweetheart.’
Then he went onto say to ds ‘they’ll miss us when we’re gone, we hold together society.’ DH is in a high level job and is actively encouraged to recruit women into senior positions which I know he doesn’t agree with. It’s because only 3% of the the senior positions in his company are held by women.
It was the way he said it. So scathing. Now he’s stormed off upstairs.

OP posts:
DBI78 · 26/10/2021 02:47

All of your opinions are true and valid but in terms of you and your husband you are both doing the same thing - attacking the opposite sex. Maybe you could speak to him about your views but without the blame? And explain the importance of educating your son correctly. Whilst it feels like we may never achieve it the long term aim is true equality and collaboration between men and women .

Thedogscollar · 25/10/2021 22:04

@Peanutbutterkid08

I’m upset by the view that he doesn’t believe that women are disadvantaged in anyway at all. And alongside that he’s now really angry and hugely defensive. He’s moaned before about having to actively recruit women.
He really doesn't like or respect women. Does he?
TractorAndHeadphones · 25/10/2021 21:30

Also to add I'm not saying that things like female friendly job ads etc don't help.
But many companies focus on recruitment rather than retention because the former is easy. Gets short term gain and gives good figures to slap on reports.

Changing culture is much harder. And as I mentioned starts not with hiring women but with changing the men who are already there.

TractorAndHeadphones · 25/10/2021 21:27

@Kotatsu

One's sex (or race, or sexuality) is not a quality to determine who deserves to be in a senior position. Diversity box ticking does more harm than good.

True for an individual, but for a company, actually you're wrong - companies with a diverse senior management team perform better - although not as a 'box ticking' exercise, but as actually seeking out good candidates who happen to have characteristics the current team is lacking.

Plus of course once you have that diverse team, it's easier to continue to recruit diverse employees - I know that when I walked into one computing lab on an interview, and there wasn't a woman to be seen (until we went to the canteen and they were there serving coffee), it was certainly a factor in choosing a different job where there were other women in the office, doing similar jobs to the one I was applying for.

It's not the 'diversity' of the senior management team that makes a company perform better. Or 'diversity' of staff for that matter. Rather - companies which are better to work for automatically have diverse candidates because they have a company culture that's supporting and accepting of differences!

That's why the push for diversity is the wrong way around.

In my experience - teams full of young, male programmers who all have similar interests. Not always full of straight white males either (plenty of gay men, or South/East Asians) but all with the same interests, break time convos about video games, all went out to the pub after work etc etc. No family responsibilites. All happily working as much OT as possible, all the time.

They weren't being anything -ist (ageist, sexist. what have you) but the team was full of the same kind of person. Age and gender was a proxy for their interests. A woman interested in the same things, or a 50 year old grandfather with the same profile would have fit in perfectly. (not saying that there aren't women interested in these things but you get my gist!)

Companies which have good diversity stats have teams with different sorts of people. Flexible working and team building deliberately to suit chosen the team. One for example had a volunteering day during work hours, in my team we all go for a meal. My last two managers are very careful to ensure that every member of the team is included in the conversation and a fair number of general topics are included (like what music people listened to or what they saw on TV). Basically there is a lot of conscious culture building , an effort to find common points that unite us. I'm the only woman but have never felt left out because everyone doesn't act all MENZ. Of course people can talk about their interests but there isn't a common one that dominates conversation to the extent that others feel left out.

Conversely... the one all woman team I was in... everybody talked about their kids all the time and I felt quite left out.

The problem?

All of this culture building takes TIME and EFFORT. and MONEY. and a long, long time... that companies don't want to invest in. They want those diversity states to look good. Like now.

So they make a big fuss about recruiting senior women, etc etc, being 'female friendly' but don't make the structural changes necessary to retain them.

Once company proudly displayed it's diverse hiring stats but neglected to mention the female retention rate. About 30% left within a year citing a lack of flexible working in practice. I know because I was in the working group.

jamandmarmalade · 25/10/2021 21:15

OP, i was angry on your behalf until i read the last sentence of your post 'he stormed off upstairs'. His behaviour completely undermined his own argument when he flounced stamped his feet? like a recalcitrant child.

It's laughable. He has an inferiority complex and is projecting.

Ignore and carry on.

SammyScrounge · 25/10/2021 21:13

@smoko

I don’t know, it sounds to me like you were ranting at your son. The way to teach people is with positivity not putting them down

If you dislike men as a group then maybe they didn’t want to be lumped together

Maybe when your son said he thought women had it easier instead of shutting him down ask him why he feel this way?

I can’t stand people preaching to me about issues, they always end up talking at you & wanting to be right instead of having a 2 way conversation

Also the way you frame it that this is fact & how it is with men - maybe use more “I feel” or “I think” or “in my experience”

You come off in this post as being a bit arrogant to lump men together as a collective when you don’t like your husband doing that

Your son needs good strong positive female role models, not to be ranted at about the failings of males that came before him.

This I was taken aback by the lecture.about privilege and the general tone of 'men are horrible'. The boy will not respond to being hectored or being classed as the hateful sex.
Smashingspinster · 25/10/2021 21:05

Sorry OP, it is very disheartening to find even quite sensible and nice men believe shit like this. But if the vast majority did not we would not still be struggling for equality. At least you got a honest look at his beliefs.

SpinsForGin · 25/10/2021 20:47

Get them to read invisible women so they are enlightened to everyday limitations women have as opposed to men.

This should be compulsory reading. Fabulous book

HereForThis · 25/10/2021 20:40

You are misunderstood if you think woke means all those rosy things. It means one thing and one thing alone - virtue signalling.

Woke meant exactly what I said - that's what it started out as but as usual, white people took over and bastardized it and as usual, everybody else is supposed to roll over and accept the new whitewashed meaning. So yeah it now means what you say it means so you can use it to hit others over the head with. Why not call virtue-signalling exactly that: virtue-signalling? Why lump it in with something else?

Sparklybanana · 25/10/2021 20:30

Get them to read invisible women so they are enlightened to everyday limitations women have as opposed to men. The example that stands out is that cars are only tested using a standard man sized dummy - women's body's are different but in a car crash, our bodies aren't tested so women end up being hurt more than men.
www.forbes.com/sites/tanyamohn/2019/10/28/dummies-used-in-motor-vehicle-crash-tests-favor-men-and-put-women-at-risk-new-report-says/
The world is designed around men and not many people notice. It's easy to see that women have jobs and get paid in theory, the same as men, but in truth, women have to fight so much harder than men just to be taken seriously and most of that is hidden because as a man, especially a white man, everything is designed for you. The office is tuned to your body temperature, your phone is designed to fit comfortably in your hand, your car is designed to take a standard man. Its actually quite shocking how much we just accept as normal.

Rosscameasdoody · 25/10/2021 20:25

[quote nanbread]@Rosscameasdoody my point is that there is different underrepresentation in different jobs and industries and this is bound to impact on how those underrepresented people are treated and how they feel. Ergo, the lawyer partner person you've also quoted here not seeing the issue. Which considering she's partner level I'm astonished at, I would have thought a better level of critical thinking was needed.[/quote]
@nanbread. I didn’t take any of that from her post - she was just giving her experience in the context of the discussion.

EmeraldShamrock · 25/10/2021 20:12

You're right OP.
These things are important conversations in every home when raising DC to teach them awareness.

nanbread · 25/10/2021 20:11

@Rosscameasdoody my point is that there is different underrepresentation in different jobs and industries and this is bound to impact on how those underrepresented people are treated and how they feel. Ergo, the lawyer partner person you've also quoted here not seeing the issue. Which considering she's partner level I'm astonished at, I would have thought a better level of critical thinking was needed.

sst1234 · 25/10/2021 20:10

OP, from your few posts, you sound like an insufferable virtue signaller. Someone who likes to go on and on and on and on about their progressive credentials but in reality don’t have much to show for it. Sorry if that’s an unfair takeaway, but your time and language sounds like a Twitter warrior who says all the right things to join in with the work brigade.

Rosscameasdoody · 25/10/2021 20:07

@nanbread

I'm a woman and have been a partner at two different City law firms. Honestly, I have never felt nor have I ever witnessed women being disadvantaged in my industry at all. If anything, it has always been a bonus to be a woman.

Black men are known to be underrepresented in law. Women generally not. Maybe speak to some of the afro-caribbean heritage men in your law firm.

But this was about women wasn’t it ?
sst1234 · 25/10/2021 20:05

@HereForThis

Side note - why do men think feminist is an insult. It’s like calling someone stunningly amazing and beautiful and expecting them to be insulted. Grin

Probably the same reason white women/feminists think 'woke' is an insult and use it as one. It's like calling someone smart, aware of racial prejudice, speaking out against it and not remaining a doormat, and expecting them to be insulted.Grin

You are misunderstood if you think woke means all those rosy things. It means one thing and one thing alone - virtue signalling. Those who do good, don’t go around banging on about their good intentions and progressive views all day long. They just do.
Speckledhem · 25/10/2021 20:02

Not blaming anyone and not angry, just have no interest in society or what men think. Not everyone shares the same opinion- I’m ok with that.

Iheartbaby · 25/10/2021 20:02

Sorry, but I think your husband has a point

Kotatsu · 25/10/2021 20:00

One's sex (or race, or sexuality) is not a quality to determine who deserves to be in a senior position. Diversity box ticking does more harm than good.

True for an individual, but for a company, actually you're wrong - companies with a diverse senior management team perform better - although not as a 'box ticking' exercise, but as actually seeking out good candidates who happen to have characteristics the current team is lacking.

Plus of course once you have that diverse team, it's easier to continue to recruit diverse employees - I know that when I walked into one computing lab on an interview, and there wasn't a woman to be seen (until we went to the canteen and they were there serving coffee), it was certainly a factor in choosing a different job where there were other women in the office, doing similar jobs to the one I was applying for.

TedMullins · 25/10/2021 19:58

@FurierTransform

Him storming off is a bit amateur, but you shouldn't be teaching your son about how mysogyny is so systemic society is (it isn't) - it's very wrong to project your bias on him at a very impressionable age.
Misogyny is still systemic in society though. Why are women questioned and victim blamed if they disclose an assault or harassment? Why are rape convictions so low? Why is it only ever women’s careers that suffer after having kids? Why are women still expected to take their husband’s name? I could go on.
TractorAndHeadphones · 25/10/2021 19:55

Also to add I'm not condoning your DH or your son's attitude.
But we are influenced by what we see. If your son doesn't realise it the way to enlighten him is to understand (as pp have said) why he feels the way he does. Not make blanket statements like 'white male privilege'.
As he is your son and not some hardened old misogynist you're trying to educate (i.e. your DH maybe) you must take a didactic approach.

TractorAndHeadphones · 25/10/2021 19:53

Your husband's tone sounds like he was angered by your low opinion of men rather than being anti-women in general. Without knowing him more I can't tell.
Girls outperform boys at school, outnumber them at university, and at lower levels earn equal salaries. Casual dating is easier for women than it is for men, and many still expect him to impress her. The majority of suicides and homicides are men.

Can you not see why an immature teenage boy who's never had to lift a finger thinks this way? Bonus points if you were a SAHM/part-time who arranged family life around your DH's 'big job'.

And as a woman in a male-dominated field the drive to recruit senior woman is bollocks. All they do is find the women lucky enough to have risen to that level in the first place, and who fit the 'male' patterns of working. Without changing the company culture that leads to women leaving in the first place.

Where I currently work there are many senior women of different backgrounds. The common denominator is that they all have managers who are supportive and skilled in managing teams working flexibly. People scheduling meetings around the school run , WFH pre-pandemic etc are all very common. Including my own boss who is not a feminist or any sort of 'ally' in the participation of diversity programs but who put me on track for promotion and is also going to promote another woman who just - !gasp! came back from mat leave!

Change the company/management culture - talented women will stay. Recruiting from outside while ignoring internal talent is like patching a leaky ship with tape. Yes you may get a few but you lose a lot, so it's not the most efficient.

P.s the majority of HUMANS are lazy, don't consider it their job to 'stand up'. Humans are social creatures heavily influenced by group tendencies. It's not a man, it's a human thing. That's why the tone at the top - and of the dominant group need to change. Not recruit more senior women. But male execs openly endorsing flexibility, and more importantly ALL the managers lower down the chain doing it.

SpinsForGin · 25/10/2021 19:48

@Speckledhem

Why do women like you get so wound up about stuff. Truly strong women don’t give a stuff about what think
If you aren't angry then you aren't paying attention.

Doing nothing means a nothing happens.

liz750 · 25/10/2021 19:46

@Speckledhem

Why do women like you get so wound up about stuff. Truly strong women don’t give a stuff about what think
Truly strong women don’t blame other women for getting distressed about sexist remarks (from a partner)
Speckledhem · 25/10/2021 19:40

*what men think