Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Is a teddy a problem - advice from Muslim mumsnetters please!

132 replies

Teddyhelp · 25/10/2021 14:24

I ordered some flowers for a Muslim colleague who has just had a baby. I saw you could add a lovely stuffed bunny so I added that to the order. A bit later, I suddenly had a thought that this might not be okay so I googled it and it might not. I'm on hold trying to cancel the order but can anyone advise me if this will be completely unacceptable if the order gets delivered??? Causing any offence is the last thing I want to do. Thank you

OP posts:
WhiskyXray · 25/10/2021 15:45

I don't think it's othering to try to find out more about other people's cultures.

Your best friend gets offended because others worry she'll get offended? I do get where she's coming from, a little, but I mean, round here, people leave pigs' heads on the mosque doorstep.

Rumplestrumpet · 25/10/2021 15:45

Oh and also I've seen lots of people share photos of their kids praying with teddies and dolls lined up as a congregation around them. Everyone I know thinks this is cute, I've never heard it suggested the child shouldn't even have teddies!

EileenGC · 25/10/2021 15:44

@treesandweeds there are also many branches of Christianity that don’t agree with Halloween celebrations, or choose not to mark Christmas in any special way (I’m not talking Jehovah Witnesses asking the school to refrain from singing about Santa Claus - just people not decorating or doing cards).

Do you go around thinking about the preferences or beliefs of non-Muslims too? Because it we’re being considerate, let’s not make it an exclusive thing for certain groups.

In my religion we don’t do Halloween, Christmas, Easter, and would try to avoid Harry Potter and Stranger Things for example, especially when it comes to the kids. My neighbours and colleagues at work have no idea about some of my beliefs and I wouldn’t think it inconsiderate if they gifted me something related to any of the above. I also don’t drink, but because I’m white no one thinks that it could ever offend me to receive a bottle of wine.

WorraLiberty · 25/10/2021 15:43

@EatSleepRantRepeat

I think it also depends on where you work *@WorraLiberty* - my workplace is extremely multicultural and provides educational materials for staff on each others beliefs. This includes white Christians and it isn't intended to 'other', but for example I knew not to send white flowers to my Chinese colleague who'd just had her baby, which wouldn't occur to me otherwise. My Muslim friends are delighted when we research gifts before sending them as it avoids them having to do the "labour" of educating us about it, and it's part of "the thought that counts".
Yeah I suppose the workplace is different.

It's just annoying being treated to the majority of other parents in the school for example, especially over something as simple as baking a cake.

Rumplestrumpet · 25/10/2021 15:42

Is it "othering" Worra? I'm torn. As a Muslim I'm usually touched when people seek information in order to better understand our faith and practices. But yes, there does seem to be a widespread belief that Muslims (and only Muslims) are offended by pretty much anything.

And as others point out, Muslims come from different cultures and traditions all around the world (including British!) and so there's a huge variety of practices.

On this issue, I have never met anyone who would refuse their kids teddies or dolls, let alone be offended by a teddy as a gift. I mean I've known Muslims to be gifted alcohol and they've just smiled and either accepted it and given it away or gracefully declined the gift with a smile and an apology but without the least bit of offence. The key is the spirit in which it is given.

On the question of images of people and animals - it also dates back to the pre-islamic practice of idol worship, so some Muslims will keep family photos tucked away in an album or avoid having family photos up in a room where they will pray.

EatSleepRantRepeat · 25/10/2021 15:40

I think it also depends on where you work @WorraLiberty - my workplace is extremely multicultural and provides educational materials for staff on each others beliefs. This includes white Christians and it isn't intended to 'other', but for example I knew not to send white flowers to my Chinese colleague who'd just had her baby, which wouldn't occur to me otherwise. My Muslim friends are delighted when we research gifts before sending them as it avoids them having to do the "labour" of educating us about it, and it's part of "the thought that counts".

thepastisanothercountry · 25/10/2021 15:40

Wouldn't worry OP. Our neighbours are Muslim and I rarely see their little girl minus her cuddly lamb which has well chewed ears and tail Grin

WorraLiberty · 25/10/2021 15:39

Sorry OP, wasn't actually aiming my frustration at you Blush

You've done a lovely thing and I'm sure the gift will be received with gratitude.

Elopelo · 25/10/2021 15:39

Yes it’s all a matter of interpretation, as with most things some Muslims take a more traditional and fixed stance and others will see themselves as being more flexible.

Photographs is another interesting area. Most Muslims (myself included) don’t have any problems with digital photos or photo albums etc but some of us wouldn’t feel comfortable having a life size family portrait in the living room for example. Another thing is when it comes to prayer there shouldn’t be any images of beings etc which is why I suppose some Muslim houses are free of these things as lots of prayers are performed at home.

WorraLiberty · 25/10/2021 15:37

Isn't it being considerate?

But this is the whole point.

Most of the Muslim parents at the school/neighbours in the street, don't want 'special consideration'. They just want to live like every other parent and be treated the same.

Especially when 9 times out of 10, being considerate normally ends in the person saying "Because I don't want to offend".

It makes my best friend want to bang her head off the wall, because she feels like it makes people think Muslims are so easily offended.

GoFindCoffeeAndSnacks · 25/10/2021 15:35

This is so interesting, thanks. I too wonder about family photos?

RaskolnikovsGarret · 25/10/2021 15:35

Absolutely fine. I am a Muslim and have relatives who are super strict, and they certainly like teddies! Nice of you to check though. Xx

treesandweeds · 25/10/2021 15:33

@WorraLiberty

I do wish people would stop othering Muslims on here, and it is always Muslims.

"I'd like to buy my Muslim neighbour a gift but I don't want to cause offence".

"A Muslim lady is coming to my house with her DC on a playdate. Would she be offended if I baked her a cake?"

"I want to send Christmas cards to my neighbours and don't want to leave out the house across the road, but they're Muslim and I don't want to offend them".

Muslims are generally the same as the rest of the human race - not some sort of strange beings with two heads who take offence to everything.

A nice thought is exactly that and even if it doesn't suit their religion, it will generally be accepted in exactly the kind spirit in which it's given. Because just like people of all religions, they don't expect you to know everything about it.

Honestly, I live in an area that's highly populated by Muslims and this is the one issue that comes up time and again. The majority of Muslims I know are just fed up of people 'tiptoeing' around them, because even with the best of intentions, it is othering.

Isn't it being considerate?
WorraLiberty · 25/10/2021 15:32

I do wish people would stop othering Muslims on here, and it is always Muslims.

"I'd like to buy my Muslim neighbour a gift but I don't want to cause offence".

"A Muslim lady is coming to my house with her DC on a playdate. Would she be offended if I baked her a cake?"

"I want to send Christmas cards to my neighbours and don't want to leave out the house across the road, but they're Muslim and I don't want to offend them".

Muslims are generally the same as the rest of the human race - not some sort of strange beings with two heads who take offence to everything.

A nice thought is exactly that and even if it doesn't suit their religion, it will generally be accepted in exactly the kind spirit in which it's given. Because just like people of all religions, they don't expect you to know everything about it.

Honestly, I live in an area that's highly populated by Muslims and this is the one issue that comes up time and again. The majority of Muslims I know are just fed up of people 'tiptoeing' around them, because even with the best of intentions, it is othering.

Scirocco · 25/10/2021 15:29

@user1471462428

My ex partner is Muslim and his family got my children teddy’s and other toys. I didn’t even know about this till I read the thread. Is it a Sunni belief?
Sunni is a pretty broad term for one of the main branches of Islam, but if it helps I'm a Sunni Muslim and I'm buying toys for my little one as we speak. It's not a mainstream view, and as Sunni Islam is one of the main branches of mainstream Islam , it's reasonable to consider that most Sunni Muslims aren't going to hold that view. In fact, I don't think any of my friends who are Sunni Muslims would have a problem with soft toys.
romdowa · 25/10/2021 15:27

I didn't even know this was a thing. My neighbour who is a Muslim bought me a Teddy of a pig for my baby shower.

BunnytheFriendlyDragon · 25/10/2021 15:27

I didn't know this either

Donotgogentle · 25/10/2021 15:25

This is really interesting. But what about Persian rugs as a pp mentioned? We have one made in Pakistan and based on a 17th century Safavid design. It’s got hunting scenes all over it.

SVRT19674 · 25/10/2021 15:24

The little muslim girls in the park have dolls just like my daughter´s. Their mums seem to be okay with it.

Scirocco · 25/10/2021 15:24

@andyoldlabour Yes, there are different schools of thought, different practices, different cultures, all of which contribute to making our faith diverse and rich in history. That's why I said a lot of Islamic art and not all.

user1471462428 · 25/10/2021 15:24

My ex partner is Muslim and his family got my children teddy’s and other toys. I didn’t even know about this till I read the thread. Is it a Sunni belief?

Kindertonguehappierlife · 25/10/2021 15:23

Interesting!!

SoupDragon · 25/10/2021 15:22

I had no idea!

I knew about the flaw in carpet patterns but thought this might just be an urban myth.

I love Mumsnet!

TaraR2020 · 25/10/2021 15:19

This is so interesting, I never knew this!

@Elopelo are photographs of family & friends also not acceptable then?